SettleADebt.

FIND THE EXPLANATION

Which place’s debt rules apply—and who can help?

Use the notice, agreement, and places connected to the debt to find the right court, regulator, or legal-help service.

Explore Idaho information →

This address preserves a dated source document behind the guide. The complete explanation covers the questions, comparisons and next steps for this subject.

If you came here to check a specific citation, open the original archive below. It includes its source dates and recorded qualifications.

Original source archive (optional)Original working documents, complete tables and revision history
About this archive

The explanation above is written for readers. These original working documents preserve the evidence trail, including technical language, dated passages and known corrections. They have not all received independent professional review. Use the marked limits before relying on a particular rule or figure.

DETAILED RESEARCH · EVIDENCE & LIMITS INCLUDED

SID Idaho provider market access and consumer fees

S_ID · pass-01Captured 2026-10-259 tables · 35 claim records · 31 source recordsScoped coordinator review completed

Read the evidence with its boundaries. These are saved research components, including revisions. A scoped coordinator review checks selected evidence; it does not certify every claim, a complete jurisdiction, current law or individual applicability. Dates and access limits remain attached to the records.

How to read the research →

S_ID PASS-01 — Idaho provider market access and consumer fees

Research/access date: October 24, 2026, Pacific time. Component status: Substantively completed for provider classification, public market access, consumer-fee ceilings, and applicable fee timing. This does not accept Idaho overall, does not accept A066, and does not close later agreement, funds-handling, bond-remedies, collection, litigation, limitations, exemptions, secured-debt, sector, local, tribal, contract, or comprehensive case-law passes.

Currentness qualification: The Idaho Department of Finance’s current statute index identifies Title 26, chapter 22 and the operative sections discussed below. The Legislature’s direct section pages returned internal/robots-access errors through the available public route, so the statutory language was read from the 2025 codification reproduced by Justia, then checked against the Department’s 2026 materials and the Idaho Supreme Court’s August 21, 2025 decision. A final search for 2026 session legislation touching these sections could not be completed through the blocked Legislature route. Core conclusions are high-confidence; exact official-code-page currentness remains a documented hold rather than being overstated. Department of Finance+1

Controlling result

Idaho has an activity-based licensing regime, not a special voluntary “debt-settlement registration” and not a blanket prohibition on all debt relief. A person engaging or offering to engage in Idaho in any of three debtor-side activities—receiving debtor funds for creditors, providing debt-management counseling or services, or contracting to adjust, compromise, or discharge indebtedness—must obtain an Idaho Department of Finance license unless an exact statutory exemption applies. The provider’s marketing label does not decide coverage. Justia Law+1

The principal consumer-fee pathways are:

Model Idaho classification and access Idaho consumer-fee rule Timing result
Provider receives debtor money and pays or prorates it to creditors Debt/credit counselor; license required absent exemption Maximum 15% of each amount received at one time for payment or proration; no other charges for that service The state text says the fee is for “services performed” but gives no settlement-by-settlement milestone. It is not affirmative advance-fee authorization. Justia Law
Provider does not receive, hold, or disburse debtor funds; manages or settles unsecured debt Debt/credit counselor; license required absent exemption Maximum 20% of the principal amount of unsecured debt at contracting; this is an aggregate ceiling, not 20% of a monthly payment No specific Idaho settlement-and-first-payment trigger was found. Federal TSR timing independently controls when its coverage conditions are met. Justia Law+1
Noncustodial secured-debt or tax-lien work May still be covered and licensed; Idaho Supreme Court held tax-debt settlement covered The 20% unsecured-debt ceiling is not applicable to secured debt. No substitute Idaho fee ceiling was established in this pass; exact lawful amount is held No amount or timing permission should be invented from the absence of § 26-2229(3)(b) coverage. Justia Law+1
Credit-repair services Separate credit-repair classification may overlap with debt settlement If the provider receives money for payment/proration, the 15% rule applies. No general Idaho percentage cap for a standalone, noncustodial credit-repair service was established Idaho expressly prohibits charging or receiving consideration before the agreed service is fully performed. Federal CROA and the TSR credit-repair rule may separately apply. Justia Law+2

A. Substantive findings

1. How Idaho defines and classifies the relevant conduct

1.1 The statutory classification is functional

Idaho Code § 26-2223(7) contains three independent debtor-side branches:

  1. Receiving money from debtors for application, payment, or proration to creditors.
  2. Providing counseling or other services to debtors in managing their debts.
  3. Contracting with a debtor to adjust, compromise, or discharge an account, note, or other indebtedness.

A provider can therefore be covered without ever taking custody of settlement funds. Negotiating a principal reduction falls naturally within the adjustment/compromise branch; a DMP that seeks interest, fee, or payment concessions may fall within the management-services branch; and a DMP that also receives and distributes debtor money falls within the first branch. [C001–C003; S_ID-P1-S003 §26-2223(7); S_ID-P1-S014 pp. 3–5] Justia Law+1

The custody distinction primarily determines which fee rule applies:

  • Custodial payment/proration: § 26-2229(3)(a), 15% of each amount received at one time.
  • Noncustodial unsecured-debt management: § 26-2229(3)(b), 20% of principal unsecured debt at contracting.

Custody is not itself a prerequisite to licensing. [C002, C015–C017; S_ID-P1-S003; S_ID-P1-S008] Justia Law+1

1.2 Credit repair is a separate classification and may overlap

Section 26-2223(8) separately covers selling, providing, performing, advising on, or assisting with services intended to improve a consumer’s credit record, history, or rating. A company can therefore be both a debt counselor and credit-repair organization when its representations and actual services satisfy both branches. A generic “financial wellness,” “debt resolution,” or “credit advocacy” name does not avoid either classification. [C003–C004; S_ID-P1-S002 §26-2222(5); S_ID-P1-S003 §26-2223(8)] Justia Law+1

1.3 Tax-debt settlement is covered

In Wall & Associates, Inc. v. Idaho Department of Finance, the Idaho Supreme Court held that a tax-debt settlement business was a debt counselor under the plain statutory language. The court explained that Idaho regulates debtor-side intermediaries and rejected the argument that tax liabilities fall outside the Act merely because the government does not fit every use of the statute’s “creditor” definition. [C008; S_ID-P1-S014 pp. 3–10] Justia Law+1

Federal enrolled-agent status did not displace Idaho licensing. The court held that an enrolled agent could comply with both IRS rules and Idaho’s requirement to obtain a debt-counselor license. [C008; S_ID-P1-S014 pp. 11–13] Justia Law

1.4 Secured debt remains within potential licensing coverage, but the unsecured fee ceiling does not carry over

The Idaho Supreme Court rejected the proposition that § 26-2229(3)(b)’s reference to unsecured debt limits the entire ICAA. Instead, the unsecured qualifier limits that particular fee ceiling. Thus:

  • A provider may still be a licensed debt counselor for secured-debt or tax-lien work.
  • The 20% ceiling cannot simply be applied to secured debt.
  • The absence of that ceiling does not itself establish a lawful unlimited-fee pathway.

[C009; S_ID-P1-S008 §26-2229(3)(b); S_ID-P1-S014 pp. 9–10] Justia Law+1

1.5 Consumer versus business purpose

Section 26-2223(7), unlike the credit-repair branch in subsection (8), does not use the word “consumer” or expressly limit covered indebtedness to personal, family, or household purposes. The Wall record also included representations about helping individuals or businesses, but the court did not separately adjudicate a pure business-only debt-management program. The best current reading is:

  • Idaho’s debt-counselor text is broader than a consumer-purpose-only statute.
  • A pure commercial-debt program should not be presumed outside the Act.
  • A categorical conclusion on a provider serving only business entities remains held pending a controlling commercial-debt decision or official interpretation.

[C007; S_ID-P1-S003 §26-2223(7)–(8); S_ID-P1-S014 pp. 3–7] Justia Law+1

Federal TSR and CROA purpose limitations are separate questions; they do not narrow Idaho’s state definition.

1.6 Idaho nexus and remote providers

The statute covers engaging or offering to engage “in this state.” Its definition of an agent expressly reaches compensated persons who contact people in Idaho in connection with a licensee or required-to-be-licensed business. The Idaho Supreme Court applied the Act to an out-of-state provider serving Idaho clients. Accordingly, a remote provider does not avoid Idaho coverage merely because its offices, employees, or settlement operations are elsewhere. [C005; S_ID-P1-S002 §26-2222(1); S_ID-P1-S003 §26-2223(7); S_ID-P1-S014] Justia Law+2

The sources read do not resolve whether a passive website, with no Idaho solicitation, customer, contract, agent contact, or service, is by itself enough. That edge remains held. [C006]

2. Whether each model is prohibited, licensed, or exempt

2.1 Covered conduct is conditionally authorized through licensing

Section 26-2223 prohibits covered operation without compliance and a license. Section 26-2225 directs the Department’s director to issue a license when the statutory requirements and fees are satisfied and the applicant is not otherwise unqualified. Idaho therefore has a mandatory-license regime, not a categorical ban on licensed debt counseling or settlement. [C010; S_ID-P1-S003 §26-2223; S_ID-P1-S005 §26-2225] Justia Law+1

Operating without a required license is a felony under § 26-2238(2), subject to the statutory exemption provision. Administrative denial, suspension, revocation, civil penalties, restitution, and other remedies may also apply. [C011, C034; S_ID-P1-S007; S_ID-P1-S012; S_ID-P1-S014 pp. 14–17] Justia Law+3

2.2 Model-by-model access result

Business model Idaho result Important boundary
Custodial DMP/payment distribution License required unless exact § 26-2239 exemption Custody invokes the 15%-per-receipt ceiling and no-other-charge rule.
Noncustodial credit counseling or DMP License required unless exact exemption 20% unsecured-principal ceiling if the service is unsecured-debt management and the provider does not handle debtor funds.
Noncustodial debt settlement/negotiation License required unless exact exemption Contracting to compromise or discharge indebtedness is independently covered.
Tax-debt settlement License required IRS enrolled-agent status is not enough to avoid the state license.
Secured-debt negotiation Potentially licensed; § 26-2229(3)(b) fee rule inapplicable Exact state fee ceiling remains unresolved.
Standalone credit repair Credit-repair license required unless exact exemption Idaho full-performance fee timing applies; federal CROA/TSR may overlap.
Pure lead generation or advertising Fact-dependent “Offering to engage,” soliciting, contracts, compensation, representations, and actual Idaho contacts must be analyzed; no blanket conclusion was established.

2.3 Exemptions are specific, not label-based

Section 26-2239 exempts:

  • Idaho-licensed lawyers only to the extent they are retained by clients and the covered work is incidental to legal practice; the exemption expressly excludes an attorney operating a separate covered business.
  • A regulated lender, subsidiary, affiliate, or agent only to the extent it collects for the lender or performs covered acts incidental to the regulated-lender business.
  • Banks, trust companies, credit unions, insurance companies, and industrial loan companies authorized in Idaho.
  • Government agencies or instrumentalities.
  • Certain Idaho real-estate licensees acting within their licensed activity.
  • Authorized escrow businesses acting within that business.
  • Mortgage lenders acting in their regular mortgage business, but not a separate covered business.
  • Court-appointed trustees, receivers, or conservators.
  • The specified pre-delinquency telephone-company billing activity.
  • A commonly owned or controlled affiliate collecting only for affiliates where debt collection is not its principal business.

[C012–C014; S_ID-P1-S013 §26-2239(1)–(10)] Justia Law+2

Consequences:

  • Nonprofit status is not a general Idaho exemption.
  • Accreditation is not a license.
  • An attorney’s name, ownership interest, referral relationship, or limited involvement does not satisfy the incidental-practice exemption.
  • Federal nonprofit or creditor exclusions under CROA do not create an Idaho exemption.
  • Enrolled-agent status does not create an Idaho tax-settlement exemption.

The Department expressly warned in September 2026 that accreditation is not a license and directed consumers to NMLS Consumer Access. [C004, C011–C014; S_ID-P1-S014; S_ID-P1-S020] Department of Finance+1

2.4 Original creditor and self-creditor boundary

Idaho separately covers a person collecting its own account when the debt was acquired from another person while delinquent or in default—the debt-buyer branch in § 26-2223(6). Section 26-2239 contains no general “self-creditor” exemption. An original creditor restructuring its own directly originated debt may nevertheless fall outside some third-party collection language, but that does not automatically resolve whether a separate counseling, credit-repair, or debtor-representation business is covered. This boundary remains fact-specific and later collection-side work remains open. [C014; S_ID-P1-S003 §26-2223(2)–(7); S_ID-P1-S013] Justia Law+2

2.5 Administrative-rule status

The official Idaho administrative-rule cumulative index marks IDAPA 12.01.11, “Rules Pursuant to the Idaho Collection Agency Act,” as expired March 31, 2022. The archived chapter is historical evidence only and cannot be silently treated as a current operative rule. No replacement ICAA-specific rule chapter was verified in the official index reviewed. [C032; S_ID-P1-S022–S023] ProdDFMMainSA+1

3. Current fee structures, limits, refunds, and dated guidance

3.1 Controlling Idaho fee matrix

Structure Covered provider/model Fee base Maximum Other subcaps/conditions
Custodial payment or proration Debt counselor, credit counselor, or credit-repair organization receiving money from or for one person to pay/prorate creditors Amount received at any one time for that person 15% of that receipt No other charges may be made or received for that service. [C015]
Noncustodial unsecured-debt management Debt or credit counselor that does not receive, hold, or disburse debtor funds for creditors Principal amount of the debtor’s unsecured debt at contracting 20% aggregate No separate statutory setup, monthly, per-debt, or savings subcap was found. Any labeled provider fees must remain within the aggregate maximum. [C016]
Cancellation of noncustodial program Same § 26-2229(3)(b) model; debtor cancels before successful completion Collected fees associated with debt remaining unsettled at termination 50% refund of those associated collected fees The text does not state a specific number of days for the refund. [C017]
Noncustodial secured debt Debt counselor may still be covered Not supplied by § 26-2229(3)(b) Held—no amount established The 20% unsecured ceiling cannot be imported. [C009]
Standalone noncustodial credit repair Credit-repair organization No percentage/dollar base established in the provisions read No general amount cap established in this pass Fee cannot be charged or received until the agreed service is fully performed. [C021]

3.2 The 20% rule is not “20% of the monthly payment”

The operative text bases the noncustodial ceiling on the principal amount of unsecured debt at the time of contracting. An April 2025 Department consumer release instead says debt-settlement companies may charge 20% of the consumer’s “monthly payment.” That language does not match the statute. The same release describes the custodial 15% rule as a percentage of a “monthly payment,” although the statute instead uses each amount received “at any one time.” [C019; S_ID-P1-S008 §26-2229(3); S_ID-P1-S021 p. 1] Justia Law+1

The Department’s own legal page warns that agency policy statements and guidance do not have the force and effect of law. The statutory text therefore controls over the release’s simplified wording. Department of Finance

3.3 No indexing or adjusted-dollar schedule was found

Neither § 26-2229(3) nor the official operational materials reviewed establish:

  • A CPI adjustment.
  • An annually adjusted dollar amount.
  • A separate setup-fee allowance.
  • A monthly-maintenance allowance outside the controlling ceiling.
  • A separate per-debt fee cap.
  • A separate savings-percentage cap under Idaho law.
  • A minimum consumer fee.

The operative limits are the static 15% and 20% percentages. No adjusted-dollar amount was calculated or invented. [C018; S_ID-P1-S008] Justia Law

A savings-based fee may be numerically compatible with Idaho’s 20% aggregate ceiling, but Idaho’s statute does not affirmatively approve every savings-based contract. When the federal TSR applies, a savings fee must use the same percentage across individualized debts and remains subject to Idaho’s lower aggregate result if Idaho is more restrictive. [C016, C025] Justia Law+1

3.4 Refund interpretation

The cancellation sentence is attached to the noncustodial § 26-2229(3)(b) model. It does not expressly create the same 50% refund for:

  • A custodial § 26-2229(3)(a) program.
  • A standalone credit-repair program.
  • A secured-debt program outside the unsecured fee ceiling.

The formula is not 50% of all fees automatically. It is 50% of the collected fees associated with the amount of debt remaining unsettled at cancellation. A defensible example must therefore maintain the same debt balances and allocation method used for previous earnings. [C017] Justia Law

3.5 Provider charges versus other amounts

The consumer-fee ceilings regulate compensation for the provider’s covered service. They should not be confused with:

  • Creditor settlement payments.
  • Taxes or government filing charges.
  • The provider’s $150 state application fee.
  • The provider’s $100 annual renewal fee.
  • A compliant independent dedicated-account provider’s charge.

However, labeling an affiliated or retained amount as a “technology,” “legal,” “account,” or “processing” fee does not automatically place it outside the provider ceiling. Section 26-2229(3)(a) expressly bars other charges for the custodial service; treatment of pass-through, affiliate, and third-party charges in other models requires the later agreement/funds pass. [C015–C018, C028–C030] Justia Law+3

4. When fees may be requested or received

4.1 Idaho’s state rules

For ordinary debt management or settlement, Idaho’s fee provisions primarily establish amount ceilings. The custodial provision refers to compensation for services performed, but the sections reviewed do not prescribe an Idaho settlement-by-settlement trigger equivalent to the federal TSR. The noncustodial provision likewise supplies a ceiling and cancellation refund without affirmatively authorizing advance collection. [C020; S_ID-P1-S008 §26-2229(3)] Justia Law

Accordingly:

  • A state maximum is not an advance-fee safe harbor.
  • A provider cannot argue that a fee was timely merely because it was below 15% or 20%.
  • Other Idaho provisions requiring fair, open, honest conduct and prohibiting misleading fee representations continue to apply.
  • Federal timing rules must be applied independently.

Idaho expressly prohibits a covered credit-repair organization from charging or receiving money or other consideration before the agreed service is fully performed. [C021–C022; S_ID-P1-S006; S_ID-P1-S009 §26-2229A(8)–(9)] Justia Law+1

4.2 Federal TSR timing—conditional common context

The TSR defines a debt-relief service as a represented program or service to renegotiate, settle, or alter debt terms involving one or more unsecured creditors or debt collectors. TSR coverage also requires the rule’s telemarketing nexus; it should not be assumed for every website, face-to-face transaction, business-purpose service, or nontelephone channel. [C023; S_ID-P1-S025 §310.2(o); S_ID-P1-S027] eCFR+1

Where the TSR applies, no debt-relief fee may be requested or received until:

  1. The provider has renegotiated, settled, reduced, or otherwise altered at least one debt under a valid settlement agreement, DMP, or comparable agreement executed by the customer.
  2. The customer has made at least one payment under that agreement.
  3. For debts resolved individually, the charged fee uses one of the permitted allocation methods.

[C024; S_ID-P1-S026 §310.4(a)(5)(i)(A)–(C)] eCFR

The two federal individualized-debt allocation methods are:

  • Proportional total-fee method: individual enrolled debt ÷ total enrolled debt × total contracted fee.
  • Savings method: the same percentage of actual savings for every individualized debt.

A provider may not switch methods between debts merely to accelerate earnings or increase the fee. [C025] eCFR

A dedicated account does not make the provider’s fee earned. The TSR requires, among other things, an insured institution, customer ownership, an unaffiliated administrator, no referral compensation, and return of all funds other than lawfully earned fees within seven business days after withdrawal. [C026] eCFR

Inbound calls responding to debt-relief advertisements are excluded from the ordinary inbound-call exemption, so “the consumer called us” is not a universal TSR escape. [C023; S_ID-P1-S027 §310.6(b)(5)–(6)] eCFR

4.3 Federal credit-repair overlap

CROA applies only when its definition is met. It covers paid interstate services represented as improving an individual consumer’s credit record, history, or rating, or providing related advice or assistance. Its exclusions include qualifying § 501(c)(3) organizations and a creditor helping restructure debt owed to itself. These federal exclusions do not become Idaho exemptions. [C027; S_ID-P1-S028 §1679a] U.S. Code

For a covered credit-repair organization, CROA bars charging or receiving consideration before the agreed service is fully performed. The TSR has an additional credit-repair timing/results-documentation rule when its telemarketing coverage exists. [C021, C027; S_ID-P1-S026 §310.4(a)(2); S_ID-P1-S029 §1679b(b)] eCFR+1

The April 2025 Idaho release incorrectly attributes the debt-settlement “settled debt plus first payment” trigger to CROA. That precise trigger is found in the TSR’s debt-relief provision, not CROA’s credit-repair advance-payment provision. [C019, C024, C027] Department of Finance+2

5. Regulator, application route, lookup, and public market access

The issuing regulator is the Idaho Department of Finance, acting through the director under the Idaho Collection Agency Act. [C028; S_ID-P1-S001, S_ID-P1-S003–S005] Department of Finance+1

Verified operational path

Stage Verified requirement or public route Boundary
Classification Determine whether the applicant will collect, receive/pay funds, counsel/manage debt, settle debt, buy delinquent debt, or provide credit repair Marketing name is not the test.
Application File through the electronic licensing system prescribed by the director; current IDOF forms page routes applications to NMLS The exact current Idaho NMLS checklist was not recoverable in parsed form. Justia Law+1
Application contents Identity and ownership information, principal address, trade names, affiliates, Idaho plan of operation, contracts/forms/ads, entity documents, Idaho-contact agents, Idaho service agent, financial-account examination consent, and other requested information Application information must be kept current. An incomplete application may become void after failure to cure within 60 days. Justia Law+1
Government application fee $150 nonrefundable This is paid by the applicant to the state; it is not a consumer service fee. Justia Law
Approval Director issues the license when statutory requirements and fees are met and the applicant is not otherwise unqualified Filing an application is not permission to operate before issuance. Justia Law
Bond/CD before issuance Debt counselors, credit counselors, and credit-repair organizations file a qualifying bond or CD after application approval and before license issuance Initial amount is $15,000; renewal amount is $15,000 or twice average monthly third-party money, rounded up to the next $1,000, whichever is greater, capped at $100,000. Full bond/remedies analysis remains later. Justia Law+1
Renewal Electronic renewal and $100 nonrefundable fee by December 31; automatic expiration on failure; possible 60-day reinstatement with $50 fee The older IDOF collection page’s March 15/paper-renewal language conflicts with the 2022-amended statute. Justia Law+1
Annual activity/bond filing Current 2026 package required all licensees to report 2025 activity by March 15, 2026 This March 15 operational filing is distinct from the December 31 statutory license renewal. Department of Finance
Public lookup NMLS Consumer Access and IDOF’s Licensee & Financial Institution Search These verify an actual named company only after a search result is obtained. Department of Finance+2

The 2026 annual package operationally distinguishes activity categories including credit repair, debt/credit counseling, debt settlement, and delinquent-debt purchasing. Those reporting categories help identify the Department’s administration but do not replace the statutory definitions or create separate substantive exemptions. Department of Finance

No provider-specific authorization established

No company name or NMLS identifier was supplied or searched. This pass verifies the public route and legal availability of licensure, not that any unnamed or marketed provider is currently licensed. A website statement, accreditation badge, attorney relationship, nonprofit description, or NMLS application in progress is not proof of an active Idaho license.

6. Worked fee and boundary examples

The examples are in Section D below. They use one stated allocation method throughout each scenario, distinguish numerical compliance from legal timing, and do not assume a fee became earned merely because money moved.

7. Component boundary

This pass resolves the principal provider-access and consumer-fee questions but deliberately leaves the following for later passes except where needed above:

  • Full contracts and disclosures.
  • Trust/dedicated-account treatment under Idaho law.
  • Complete bond, claims, and discontinuance obligations.
  • Private and public remedies.
  • Creditor-side collection licensing.
  • Litigation conduct and unauthorized-practice issues.
  • Limitations periods and debt revival.
  • Detailed secured-debt, mortgage, student-loan, tax, medical, and other sector rules.
  • Tribal and local jurisdiction.
  • Full Idaho and federal case survey.
  • Named-provider license status.

No acceptance of those categories is implied.

B. Source table

Idaho legal authorities

Source ID Title / issuer Direct literal URL Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
S_ID-P1-S001 Statutes and Rules — Idaho Department of Finance https://www.finance.idaho.gov/legal/statutes-and-rules/ Current official index; lines 156–160 and 228–258. Freshly read 2026-10-24 PT. It identifies the ICAA sections and states that agency guidance lacks force and effect of law. Department of Finance
S_ID-P1-S002 Idaho Code § 26-2222, Definitions — 2025 Idaho Code reproduced by Justia https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2222/ §(1), (5), (9), (14); lines 58 onward. Freshly read 2026-10-24 PT. Secondary code reproduction; official section HTML inaccessible. Justia Law
S_ID-P1-S003 Idaho Code § 26-2223, License Required — 2025 Idaho Code reproduced by Justia https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2223/ Opening clause and subsections (1)–(8), especially (7)–(8), lines 57–73. Freshly read. Last displayed amendment 2008; official current section inaccessible. Justia Law+1
S_ID-P1-S004 Idaho Code § 26-2224, License Application https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2224/ §(1)(a)–(l), §(2), lines 57–86. Freshly read. 2022 amendment displayed. Justia Law+1
S_ID-P1-S005 Idaho Code § 26-2225, Approval of License Application https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2225/ §(1)–(2), lines 57–62. Freshly read. Justia Law
S_ID-P1-S006 Idaho Code § 26-2226, False or Fraudulent Debt Reduction and Elimination Practices https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2226/ §(1)–(2), lines 57–64. Freshly read. Prohibits obtaining or attempting to obtain compensation through misleading reduction/elimination claims. Justia Law
S_ID-P1-S007 Idaho Code § 26-2227, Denial, Suspension, or Revocation https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2227/ §(1) and grounds beginning lines 57–63. Freshly read; full remedies pass remains open. Justia Law
S_ID-P1-S008 Idaho Code § 26-2229, Contracts https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2229/ §(3)(a)–(b), lines 67–70. Freshly read. Controlling 15%, 20%, and cancellation-refund text. Justia Law
S_ID-P1-S009 Idaho Code § 26-2229A, Fair, Open, and Honest Dealing https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2229a/ §(1), (4), (8), (9), especially lines 57–75. Freshly read. Justia Law+1
S_ID-P1-S010 Idaho Code § 26-2231, Renewal and Reinstatement https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2231/ §(1)–(3), lines 57–69. Freshly read; amended 2022. Justia Law
S_ID-P1-S011 Idaho Code § 26-2232A, Debt/Credit Counselor and Credit-Repair Bonds https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2232a/ §(1)–(3), lines 57–64. Freshly read. Access condition only; full bond pass remains open. Justia Law+1
S_ID-P1-S012 Idaho Code § 26-2238, Violations and Penalties https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2238/ §(1)–(3), lines 57–61. Freshly read. Justia Law
S_ID-P1-S013 Idaho Code § 26-2239, Exemptions https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2239/ §(1)–(10), lines 58–75. Freshly read; last displayed amendment 2020. Justia Law+2
S_ID-P1-S014 Wall & Associates, Inc. v. State of Idaho, Department of Finance, Consumer Finance Bureau, Idaho Supreme Court, Docket 51310 https://cases.justia.com/idaho/supreme-court-civil/2025-51310.pdf?ts=1755796372 Opinion filed 2025-08-21; pp. 3–17 materially read, with PDF pages visually inspected. Freshly checked 2026-10-24. Controlling Idaho Supreme Court opinion; PDF copy accessed through Justia. Justia Law+3
S_ID-P1-S015 Idaho Supreme Court Opinions — Idaho Judicial Branch https://isc.idaho.gov/cases-opinions/isc-opinions Lines 22–24 state cited opinions are posted on release. Freshly read. The searchable official page did not expose a stable direct PDF link for Docket 51310 through this route. Idaho Supreme Court

Operational, interpretive, and rule-status materials

Source ID Title / issuer Direct literal URL Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
S_ID-P1-S016 Collection Agency Forms — IDOF https://www.finance.idaho.gov/consumer-finance-bureau/collection-agencies/collection-agency-forms/ Lines 156–170. Freshly read. Routes applications to NMLS and states March 2026 agent reporting moved to Tyler Idaho. Procedure, not independent legal permission. Department of Finance
S_ID-P1-S017 Collection Agencies — IDOF https://www.finance.idaho.gov/consumer-finance-bureau/collection-agencies/ Lines 156–168; page last updated 2025-07-09. Freshly read. The March 15/paper renewal wording conflicts with the amended statute; used only as an operational lead. Department of Finance
S_ID-P1-S018 Idaho Collection Agency Annual Report and 2026 Bond Calculation Package — IDOF https://www.finance.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Idaho-Collection-Agency-Act-Annual-Reporting-and-Bond-Calculation-Package-3.pdf Pages 1–2, including activity categories, March 15 filing, and license prefixes. Freshly read and visually inspected. Operational form, not a source of new substantive fee permission. Department of Finance
S_ID-P1-S019 April 22, 2026 Financial Literacy Release — IDOF https://www.finance.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/2026-DOF-PR-FLM-Debt-Settlement.pdf Pages 1–2. Freshly read and visually inspected. Confirms licensing treatment of debt and tax-debt settlement and NMLS lookup route. Nonbinding guidance; its CROA discussion is not relied on for federal timing. Department of Finance
S_ID-P1-S020 September 14, 2026 Credit Repair / “Finfluencer” Alert — IDOF https://www.finance.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/2026-DOF-PR-Debt-Finfluencer-.pdf Pages 1–2, especially p. 2. Freshly read and visually inspected. Says accreditation is not a license and directs users to NMLS. Nonbinding consumer guidance. Department of Finance
S_ID-P1-S021 2025 Debt Settlement and Credit Repair Consumer Tip — IDOF https://www.finance.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/about/press-releases/documents/2025/2025-DOF-PR-Debt-Settlement-Credit-Repair-Cos-Tip.pdf Page 1, lines 45–67. Freshly read and visually inspected. Its “monthly payment” fee descriptions conflict with § 26-2229; retained as a documented guidance conflict, not controlling law. Department of Finance
S_ID-P1-S022 IDAPA 12 Cumulative Index — Idaho Office of Administrative Rules/DFM https://proddfmmainsa.blob.core.windows.net/dfm-admin-website/cindex/12.pdf Page 4/parsed p. 3, line 184. Freshly read and visually inspected. Marks IDAPA 12.01.11 expired 2022-03-31. ProdDFMMainSA
S_ID-P1-S023 Archived IDAPA 12.01.11, Rules Pursuant to the ICAA https://proddfmmainsa.blob.core.windows.net/dfm-admin-website/rules/2021%20Archive/12/120111.pdf Archived chapter; read only to identify historical scope and incorporated-law version. Expired/historical, not current authority. ProdDFMMainSA
S_ID-P1-S024 NMLS Checklist Compiler — NMLS https://mortgage.nationwidelicensingsystem.org/knowledge/Products/nmls/stateresourcecenter/SitePages/Checklist-Compiler.aspx Public locator opened but produced no usable Idaho checklist text through the parsed route. Discovery-only; not relied on for checklist contents.
S_ID-P1-S025 Licensee & Financial Institution Search — IDOF https://www.finance.idaho.gov/finance-license-charter-search/ Current official search landing page freshly opened. Embedded results were not queried for any named provider. Department of Finance
S_ID-P1-S030 Direct Idaho Legislature section routes — access-failure record https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title26/T26CH22/SECT26-2222 https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title26/T26CH22/SECT26-2223 https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title26/T26CH22/SECT26-2229 https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title26/T26CH22/SECT26-2229A https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title26/T26CH22/SECT26-2239 Actual attempts on 2026-10-24 returned internal/access errors. These were not treated as read passages. (Website Name Missing)

Federal common-context authorities

Source ID Title / issuer Direct literal URL Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
S_ID-P1-S026 16 C.F.R. § 310.2, Definitions — eCFR https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.2 §310.2(o), debt-relief service. Current eCFR read 2026-10-24; page indicated continuously updated status. eCFR+1
S_ID-P1-S027 16 C.F.R. § 310.4, Abusive Telemarketing Acts — eCFR https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.4 §310.4(a)(2) and (a)(5)(i)–(ii), lines 101–131. Freshly read. eCFR+3
S_ID-P1-S028 16 C.F.R. § 310.6, Exemptions — eCFR https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.6 §310.6(b)(5)–(6), particularly debt-relief-advertisement carveouts. Freshly read. eCFR+1
S_ID-P1-S029 15 U.S.C. § 1679a, CROA Definitions — U.S. House OLRC https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/119-118/t15/s1679a/ §1679a(1)–(3), through Public Law 119-120, 2026-10-07. Freshly read. U.S. Code
S_ID-P1-S031 15 U.S.C. § 1679b, CROA Prohibited Practices — U.S. House OLRC https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/119-118/t15/s1679b/ §1679b(b), lines 47–48; through Public Law 119-120, 2026-10-07. Freshly read. U.S. Code

C. Claim table

Claim ID Precise assertion Sources and pinpoints Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
S_ID-P1-C001 Idaho’s debt-counselor category has three independent branches: payment/proration, debt-management services, and contracting to adjust/compromise/discharge debt. S003 §26-2223(7); S014 pp. 3–5. Justia Law+1 High substantive confidence; official section-page access held under C035.
C002 Custody is unnecessary for licensing; it primarily changes the applicable fee branch. S003 §(7); S008 §(3)(a)–(b). Justia Law+1 High.
C003 Principal reduction/settlement, nonprincipal concessions, DMP counseling, and distribution can be covered under different or overlapping clauses. S003 §(7). Justia Law High for clause mapping; application remains fact-specific.
C004 Credit repair is separately classified and may overlap with debt settlement; labels, accreditation, or nonprofit descriptions do not decide coverage. S002 §(5); S003 §(8); S020 p. 2. Justia Law+2 High.
C005 An out-of-state provider serving and contracting with Idaho debtors can be subject to Idaho licensure. S002 §(1); S003; S014. Justia Law+2 High for actual Idaho customer/contact facts.
C006 A passive website with no Idaho customer, solicitation, contract, agent contact, or service was not resolved. S002–S003; no controlling passive-site holding found. Held; territorial edge requires later authority.
C007 The debt-counselor clause lacks an express consumer-purpose limitation, but pure business-only program coverage was not separately adjudicated. S003 §(7)–(8); S014. Justia Law+1 Moderate-high textual confidence; pure B2B conclusion held.
C008 Tax-debt settlement is covered; enrolled-agent status does not replace Idaho licensure. S014 pp. 3–13. Justia Law+2 High; controlling state decision.
C009 Secured debt may remain within licensing coverage, but the 20% unsecured-debt fee ceiling is inapplicable; no substitute amount was established. S008 §(3)(b); S014 pp. 9–10. Justia Law+1 High on inapplicability; fee amount unresolved.
C010 Covered conduct is conditionally authorized through licensure, not categorically prohibited in all circumstances. S003 opening clause; S005 §(1). Justia Law+1 High.
C011 Nonexempt operation without the required license is a felony and may support regulatory sanctions. S012 §(2); S007; S014. Justia Law+2 High; criminal application requires actual statutory elements and prosecution.
C012 Attorney exemption is limited to Idaho-licensed lawyers retained by clients where the covered activity is incidental to practice; no separate covered business. S013 §(1). Justia Law High.
C013 Idaho has enumerated institutional and activity-specific exclusions but no general nonprofit exemption. S013 §(1)–(10). Justia Law+2 High based on complete listed exemptions.
C014 A purchaser collecting delinquent/defaulted debt for itself is expressly covered; original-creditor boundaries are fact-specific and no blanket self-creditor exemption appears in §26-2239. S003 §(6); S013. Justia Law+1 High for debt buyer; original-creditor counseling edge partial.
C015 Custodial payment/proration compensation is capped at 15% of each amount received at one time, with no other charges for that service. S008 §(3)(a). Justia Law High.
C016 Noncustodial unsecured-debt management fees are capped in aggregate at 20% of principal unsecured debt at contracting. S008 §(3)(b). Justia Law High.
C017 Upon debtor cancellation before successful completion, 50% of collected fees associated with debt remaining unsettled must be refunded. S008 §(3)(b), final sentence. Justia Law High text; association/allocation and payment deadline require facts/later contract analysis.
C018 No CPI indexing, adjusted dollar schedule, setup subcap, monthly subcap, or separate Idaho savings/per-debt cap was found. S008; S001; S016–S021. Justia Law+2 Moderate-high; subject to official-code currentness hold.
C019 IDOF’s 2025 “monthly payment” description conflicts with the statutory fee bases and is nonbinding. S001 lines 156–160; S008; S021. Department of Finance+2 High.
C020 Idaho’s fee ceilings do not themselves affirmatively authorize collection in advance of performance. S008; S009. Justia Law+1 High as a negative/no-safe-harbor conclusion; no general Idaho debt-settlement milestone found.
C021 Idaho credit-repair fees cannot be charged or received before the agreed service is fully performed. S009 §(8). Justia Law High.
C022 False, fraudulent, or materially misleading debt-reduction and service representations are independently prohibited. S006; S009 §(1), (9). Justia Law+2 High.
C023 Federal TSR fee timing applies only when the TSR’s debt-relief and telemarketing coverage requirements are met; inbound response to a debt-relief advertisement is not generically exempt. S026 §310.2(o); S028 §310.6. eCFR+1 High; individual channel/facts still required.
C024 Covered TSR debt-relief fees require a qualifying agreement altering at least one debt and at least one customer payment under that agreement. S027 §310.4(a)(5)(i)(A)–(B). eCFR High.
C025 Individually resolved TSR debts require proportional total-fee allocation or the same percentage of actual savings across debts. S027 §310.4(a)(5)(i)(C). eCFR High.
C026 A dedicated account does not earn the fee; it must satisfy insured-account, ownership, independence, no-referral-payment, withdrawal, and return conditions. S027 §310.4(a)(5)(ii). eCFR High.
C027 CROA is conditional, has its own definition and exclusions, and prohibits payment before full performance; it is not a universal debt-settlement statute. S029 §1679a; S031 §1679b(b). U.S. Code+1 High.
C028 Idaho applications use the director-prescribed electronic system; IDOF currently routes applicants to NMLS. S004 §(1); S016. Justia Law+1 High.
C029 Debt/credit counselor and credit-repair applicants must provide a qualifying bond or CD after approval and before issuance. S011 §(1)–(3). Justia Law+1 High; full bond obligations remain outside this pass.
C030 License renewal is due electronically by December 31 with a $100 fee; the 60-day statutory reinstatement requires an additional $50. S010 §(1)–(3). Justia Law High.
C031 Public status routes are NMLS Consumer Access and IDOF’s license search; no named provider status was established. S019 p. 2; S020 p. 2; S025. Department of Finance+2 High for route; no company authorization claim.
C032 IDAPA 12.01.11 expired March 31, 2022 and is historical only. S022 line 184; S023. ProdDFMMainSA+1 High.
C033 The exact current Idaho NMLS application/renewal checklist was not obtained through the public parsed route. S016; S024. Department of Finance Explicit unresolved evidence gap.
C034 Administrative fee restoration or disgorgement in Wall is an enforcement remedy, not an alternative lawful fee schedule. S014 pp. 14–17. Justia Law+1 High.
C035 Core current-law conclusions are corroborated by current IDOF materials and a 2025 controlling decision, but official 2026 section text/session-law comparison was inaccessible. S001, S014, S019–S020, S030. Department of Finance+2 Moderate-high overall currentness; exact official text held.

D. Worked examples

No Idaho rounding rule for these consumer-fee ceilings was located. These examples use exact arithmetic. Where a computation produced fractional cents, a provider should not round upward beyond a statutory ceiling without authority.

Example 1 — Custodial DMP remittance

Facts and assumptions

  • Provider is licensed and receives one debtor remittance of $500.00.
  • The money is received for payment or proration to creditors.
  • No exemption applies.
  • No separate government or independent third-party charge is included.

Operator

  • Idaho maximum = 15% × amount received at that one time.

Calculation

  • $500.00 × 0.15 = $75.00.

Result

  • Maximum provider compensation for that remittance: $75.00.
  • At least $425.00 remains for creditor payment if the fee is deducted from the receipt.
  • A proposed $75 service fee plus a $25 setup fee would total $100 and fail both the $75 numerical ceiling and the “no other charges” clause.

This establishes only the Idaho amount ceiling. It does not independently establish that the fee was timely under any applicable federal rule. [C015, C020] Justia Law

Example 2 — Noncustodial unsecured program with proportional TSR allocation

Inputs

  • Total principal unsecured debt at contracting: $20,000.00.
  • Debt A: $12,000.00.
  • Debt B: $8,000.00.
  • Contracted total provider fee: 18% of enrolled principal.
  • Provider does not receive, hold, or disburse debtor funds.
  • TSR applies.
  • Provider uses the proportional-total-fee method consistently.

Idaho aggregate ceiling

  • $20,000 × 20% = $4,000 maximum.

Contracted fee

  • $20,000 × 18% = $3,600.
  • $3,600 is numerically below the Idaho ceiling.

Debt A allocation

  • Debt A ratio = $12,000 ÷ $20,000 = 0.60.
  • Allocated fee = 0.60 × $3,600 = $2,160.

The $2,160 may be requested or received only after Debt A has been altered under a qualifying agreement and the customer has made the required first payment under that agreement.

Debt B allocation

  • Debt B ratio = $8,000 ÷ $20,000 = 0.40.
  • Allocated fee = 0.40 × $3,600 = $1,440.

Debt B’s $1,440 is not earned merely because Debt A performed. Debt B needs its own qualifying trigger if debts are resolved individually.

Consistency check

  • $2,160 + $1,440 = $3,600.
  • The same enrolled balances and allocation method were used throughout.
  • No previous fee was assumed earned solely because one consumer payment occurred.

[C016, C024–C025] Justia Law+2

Example 3 — Lower-debt case exceeding the Idaho ceiling

Inputs

  • Noncustodial unsecured principal at contracting: $3,000.
  • Proposed total provider fee: $750.

Calculation

  • Idaho maximum = $3,000 × 20% = $600.
  • Excess = $750 − $600 = $150.

Result

The proposed fee exceeds Idaho’s ceiling by $150. Later performance under the TSR cannot legalize the state-law excess; timing compliance and amount compliance are separate. [C016, C020, C024] Justia Law+1

Example 4 — Savings-based method across two debts

Inputs

  • Debt A at enrollment: $10,000.
  • Debt B at enrollment: $10,000.
  • Total principal at contracting: $20,000.
  • Fee: the same 30% of actual savings for every debt.
  • TSR and Idaho both apply.
  • Provider is noncustodial.

Idaho ceiling

  • $20,000 × 20% = $4,000 aggregate maximum.

Debt A

  • Settlement payment: $6,000.
  • Savings: $10,000 − $6,000 = $4,000.
  • Fee: 30% × $4,000 = $1,200, after Debt A’s qualifying trigger.

Debt B

  • Settlement payment: $4,000.
  • Savings: $10,000 − $4,000 = $6,000.
  • Fee: 30% × $6,000 = $1,800, after Debt B’s qualifying trigger.

Result

  • Total fee = $1,200 + $1,800 = $3,000.
  • $3,000 is below Idaho’s $4,000 aggregate ceiling.
  • The same 30% savings rate was used on both debts.

If the same-percentage calculation had produced $4,500, Idaho would limit the aggregate provider fee to $4,000 even though the federal allocation formula was applied correctly. [C016, C025] Justia Law+1

Example 5 — Cancellation and prior-fee reconciliation

5A. State-formula illustration

Inputs

  • Original enrolled balances: Debt A $12,000; Debt B $8,000.
  • Total previously collected fees: $2,000.
  • Those fees were consistently allocated in the same 60%/40% proportion:Debt A association: $1,200.Debt B association: $800.
  • Debt A was settled.
  • Debt B remained unsettled when the debtor cancelled.

Refund calculation

  • Refund = 50% × collected fees associated with unresolved Debt B.
  • 50% × $800 = $400.

Important legal limitation

The $400 arithmetic does not prove that collecting the $800 associated with Debt B was timely or lawful. If the TSR applied and Debt B had not satisfied its individual trigger, taking that $800 earlier could violate federal timing even though the later Idaho refund computation is mathematically correct.

5B. TSR-compliant variant

  • Debt A fee of $2,160 was collected only after Debt A’s qualifying trigger.
  • Debt B fee collected: $0.
  • Debt B remains unsettled at cancellation.

Under the stated allocation, fees collected and associated with unsettled Debt B equal $0, so 50% × $0 = $0 under this particular Idaho cancellation formula. Contractual refund rights, deceptive-practice remedies, dedicated-account return rules, and other claims remain separate.

[C017, C024–C026] Justia Law+2

Example 6 — Secured-debt hold

Inputs

  • Provider negotiates a $15,000 debt secured by property.
  • Provider does not handle debtor funds.
  • No exact exemption applies.

Result

  • Licensing may still be required.
  • The § 26-2229(3)(b) calculation of 20% × $15,000 is not a valid Idaho fee-ceiling calculation because subsection (3)(b) is limited to unsecured debt.
  • Exact lawful Idaho provider fee: HOLD—no amount established.
  • No licensed or unlimited-fee scenario is invented.

[C009] Justia Law

Example 7 — Credit-repair startup fee

Inputs

  • Covered credit-repair organization promises a defined service.
  • It proposes to take a $99 startup fee before that service is fully performed.

Result

  • Idaho § 26-2229A(8) prohibits the advance charge or receipt.
  • If federal CROA also applies, § 1679b(b) independently reaches the same timing problem.
  • No generic Idaho percentage ceiling is invented for the standalone credit-repair model.

[C021, C027] Justia Law+1

Pass coverage and gap table

Component Status Supporting claims Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Debt counselor statutory definition Answered C001–C003 Official Legislature section HTML remains inaccessible; preserve C035.
Principal reduction versus DMP/concession services Answered C002–C003 Fact-specific overlap still requires actual service documents in a provider review.
Custodial versus noncustodial classification Answered C002, C015–C017 Third-party/affiliate account arrangements need later funds-and-contract analysis.
Credit-repair overlap Answered C003–C004, C021, C027 Apply to actual representations and services; no universal overlap.
Consumer versus business-purpose debt Partial C007, C023, C027 Locate controlling Idaho commercial-debt case or official interpretation; separately analyze TSR B2B scope.
Remote-provider Idaho nexus Partial but operationally strong C005–C006 Passive-site/no-customer edge requires territorial authority; Idaho-client contracting is covered.
Tax-debt settlement Answered C008 Sector-specific contracts, IRS practice, and tax-lien fees remain later.
Secured-debt licensing Answered at classification level C009 Full secured-sector pass remains open.
Secured-debt provider fee Unresolved C009 Find controlling fee statute, order, opinion, or approved contract treatment; do not use 20%.
Licensing versus prohibition Answered C010–C011 Provider-specific eligibility still requires application and license result.
Attorney exemption Answered C012 UPL, fee sharing, separate-entity facts, and litigation services remain later.
Nonprofit/accreditation treatment Answered C004, C013 Federal tax status may affect CROA but not Idaho’s enumerated exemption list.
Institutional exclusions Answered for text C013 Entity-by-entity charter and incidental-activity facts still required.
Original-creditor/self-creditor boundary Partial C014 Later creditor-side and debt-buyer pass must resolve each model.
Custodial 15% cap Answered C015 Affiliate/pass-through and what constitutes the same service need later contract/funds work.
Noncustodial 20% cap Answered C016 Actual contract must identify contracting-date principal and all provider compensation.
Cancellation refund formula Answered, timing partial C017 No payment deadline found; association methodology, contract language, and remedies need later work.
Indexing/adjustment Answered from accessible sources C018 Recheck official section/session laws when accessible; no CPI calculation.
Historical/current guidance conflict Answered C019 Statute controls; do not operationalize the “monthly payment” wording.
Idaho fee timing Answered as no general affirmative trigger located C020–C022 Full contract and enforcement pass may reveal additional timing consequences.
Federal TSR common context Answered conditionally C023–C026 Apply actual marketing channel, call flow, creditor type, debt type, and customer purpose.
Federal CROA common context Answered conditionally C027 Apply actual credit-improvement representations and exclusions.
Application and issuance Answered C028–C029 Exact NMLS checklist unresolved under C033.
Renewal Answered C030 Reconcile future IDOF webpage corrections if made.
Public lookup route Answered C031 Named-provider status requires exact company name/NMLS ID and an actual registry result.
Current administrative rule Answered C032 Monitor for any future replacement rule; archived chapter is not operative.
Exact NMLS checklist Unresolved C033 Retrieve a public Idaho company-license new-application and renewal checklist through an accessible NMLS route.
Administrative restitution Answered only as relevant to fee characterization C034 Full remedies/disgorgement standards remain later.
Official-code currentness Partial/held C035 Reopen official Idaho section text and compare 2026 session laws when the public route is accessible.
Agreements/disclosures Excluded for later pass — Read statutory contract clauses, cancellation provisions, required notices, and actual forms.
Funds/trust/dedicated accounts Excluded except federal context — Analyze Idaho §§ 26-2233 and 26-2234, affiliations, indirect receipt, and account charges.
Full bonds/remedies/closure Excluded except access conditions — Complete §§ 26-2232A, 26-2244–2247 and discontinuance rules.
Creditor-side collection/debt buyers Excluded for later pass C014 only Separate collection-licensing and activity analysis.
Litigation, limitations, exemptions from execution Excluded — Separate state investigations.
Local/tribal law Excluded — Identify tribal jurisdiction, state reach, and any local rules.
Comprehensive case law Excluded except controlling Wall issue C008–C009, C034 Search reported and administrative cases for fee, contract, exemption, nexus, and remedies issues.

E. Researcher self-check

Actually read and used

  • Idaho Department of Finance’s current statute index and the listed ICAA section structure.
  • The accessible 2025 text of §§ 26-2222, 26-2223, 26-2224, 26-2225, 26-2226, 26-2227, 26-2229, 26-2229A, 26-2231, 26-2232A, 26-2238, and 26-2239.
  • Material portions of the Idaho Supreme Court’s Wall & Associates opinion, including classification, tax debt, secured-debt fee language, federal-preemption argument, and restitution.
  • The official administrative-rule cumulative index and the archived ICAA rule chapter.
  • IDOF’s current application/forms page, collection-agency page, 2026 annual report/bond package, April 2026 licensing release, September 2026 credit-repair alert, and the conflicting 2025 fee release.
  • Current eCFR text for 16 C.F.R. §§ 310.2, 310.4, and 310.6.
  • Current House U.S. Code text for 15 U.S.C. §§ 1679a and 1679b.
  • PDF pages used for substantive findings were also visually inspected rather than relying only on extracted text.

Not read or not established

  • The official Idaho Legislature’s actual section HTML, because the direct routes returned access/internal errors.
  • A complete official 2026 session-law comparison for every relevant section.
  • A usable, current Idaho-specific NMLS application or renewal checklist.
  • Any named company’s NMLS or Idaho license record.
  • Any private provider contracts, fee schedules, call scripts, account arrangements, or borrower records.
  • The entire Idaho administrative-action inventory.
  • A comprehensive Idaho case-law, local-law, tribal-law, secured-debt, sector, remedies, or collection-side investigation.
  • Any model act or model-act comments as a substitute for enacted Idaho wording.

No inaccessible passage was represented as read. No search snippet, company chart, association summary, marketing statement, or archived rule was used as controlling current law. No provider application was filed, no regulator or company was contacted, and no local file or publication-ready legal opinion is claimed.

END S_ID PASS-01.

Every captured table

Captured cells with original header handling and explicitly labeled bounded correction overlays. Downloaded JSON retains original cells. Tables may contain source limitations, historical examples and identified corrections; the complete reading supplies context.

Read the evidence with its boundaries. These are saved research components, including revisions. A scoped coordinator review checks selected evidence; it does not certify every claim, a complete jurisdiction, current law or individual applicability. Dates and access limits remain attached to the records.

How to read the research →

Captured table 01

Model · Idaho classification and access · Idaho consumer-fee rule · 4 data rows

ModelIdaho classification and accessIdaho consumer-fee ruleTiming result
Provider receives debtor money and pays or prorates it to creditorsDebt/credit counselor; license required absent exemptionMaximum 15% of each amount received at one time for payment or proration; no other charges for that serviceThe state text says the fee is for “services performed” but gives no settlement-by-settlement milestone. It is not affirmative advance-fee authorization. Justia Law
Provider does not receive, hold, or disburse debtor funds; manages or settles unsecured debtDebt/credit counselor; license required absent exemptionMaximum 20% of the principal amount of unsecured debt at contracting; this is an aggregate ceiling, not 20% of a monthly paymentNo specific Idaho settlement-and-first-payment trigger was found. Federal TSR timing independently controls when its coverage conditions are met. Justia Law +1
Noncustodial secured-debt or tax-lien workMay still be covered and licensed; Idaho Supreme Court held tax-debt settlement coveredThe 20% unsecured-debt ceiling is not applicable to secured debt. No substitute Idaho fee ceiling was established in this pass; exact lawful amount is heldNo amount or timing permission should be invented from the absence of § 26-2229(3)(b) coverage. Justia Law +1
Credit-repair servicesSeparate credit-repair classification may overlap with debt settlementIf the provider receives money for payment/proration, the 15% rule applies. No general Idaho percentage cap for a standalone, noncustodial credit-repair service was establishedIdaho expressly prohibits charging or receiving consideration before the agreed service is fully performed. Federal CROA and the TSR credit-repair rule may separately apply. Justia Law +2
Source links captured in this table

Captured table 02

Business model · Idaho result · Important boundary · 7 data rows

Business modelIdaho resultImportant boundary
Custodial DMP/payment distributionLicense required unless exact § 26-2239 exemptionCustody invokes the 15%-per-receipt ceiling and no-other-charge rule.
Noncustodial credit counseling or DMPLicense required unless exact exemption20% unsecured-principal ceiling if the service is unsecured-debt management and the provider does not handle debtor funds.
Noncustodial debt settlement/negotiationLicense required unless exact exemptionContracting to compromise or discharge indebtedness is independently covered.
Tax-debt settlementLicense requiredIRS enrolled-agent status is not enough to avoid the state license.
Secured-debt negotiationPotentially licensed; § 26-2229(3)(b) fee rule inapplicableExact state fee ceiling remains unresolved.
Standalone credit repairCredit-repair license required unless exact exemptionIdaho full-performance fee timing applies; federal CROA/TSR may overlap.
Pure lead generation or advertisingFact-dependent“Offering to engage,” soliciting, contracts, compensation, representations, and actual Idaho contacts must be analyzed; no blanket conclusion was established.

Captured table 03

Structure · Covered provider/model · Fee base · 5 data rows

StructureCovered provider/modelFee baseMaximumOther subcaps/conditions
Custodial payment or prorationDebt counselor, credit counselor, or credit-repair organization receiving money from or for one person to pay/prorate creditorsAmount received at any one time for that person15% of that receiptNo other charges may be made or received for that service. [C015]
Noncustodial unsecured-debt managementDebt or credit counselor that does not receive, hold, or disburse debtor funds for creditorsPrincipal amount of the debtor’s unsecured debt at contracting20% aggregateNo separate statutory setup, monthly, per-debt, or savings subcap was found. Any labeled provider fees must remain within the aggregate maximum. [C016]
Cancellation of noncustodial programSame § 26-2229(3)(b) model; debtor cancels before successful completionCollected fees associated with debt remaining unsettled at termination50% refund of those associated collected feesThe text does not state a specific number of days for the refund. [C017]
Noncustodial secured debtDebt counselor may still be coveredNot supplied by § 26-2229(3)(b)Held—no amount establishedThe 20% unsecured ceiling cannot be imported. [C009]
Standalone noncustodial credit repairCredit-repair organizationNo percentage/dollar base established in the provisions readNo general amount cap established in this passFee cannot be charged or received until the agreed service is fully performed. [C021]

Captured table 04

Stage · Verified requirement or public route · Boundary · 9 data rows

StageVerified requirement or public routeBoundary
ClassificationDetermine whether the applicant will collect, receive/pay funds, counsel/manage debt, settle debt, buy delinquent debt, or provide credit repairMarketing name is not the test.
ApplicationFile through the electronic licensing system prescribed by the director; current IDOF forms page routes applications to NMLSThe exact current Idaho NMLS checklist was not recoverable in parsed form. Justia Law +1
Application contentsIdentity and ownership information, principal address, trade names, affiliates, Idaho plan of operation, contracts/forms/ads, entity documents, Idaho-contact agents, Idaho service agent, financial-account examination consent, and other requested informationApplication information must be kept current. An incomplete application may become void after failure to cure within 60 days. Justia Law +1
Government application fee$150 nonrefundableThis is paid by the applicant to the state; it is not a consumer service fee. Justia Law
ApprovalDirector issues the license when statutory requirements and fees are met and the applicant is not otherwise unqualifiedFiling an application is not permission to operate before issuance. Justia Law
Bond/CD before issuanceDebt counselors, credit counselors, and credit-repair organizations file a qualifying bond or CD after application approval and before license issuanceInitial amount is $15,000; renewal amount is $15,000 or twice average monthly third-party money, rounded up to the next $1,000, whichever is greater, capped at $100,000. Full bond/remedies analysis remains later. Justia Law +1
RenewalElectronic renewal and $100 nonrefundable fee by December 31; automatic expiration on failure; possible 60-day reinstatement with $50 feeThe older IDOF collection page’s March 15/paper-renewal language conflicts with the 2022-amended statute. Justia Law +1
Annual activity/bond filingCurrent 2026 package required all licensees to report 2025 activity by March 15, 2026This March 15 operational filing is distinct from the December 31 statutory license renewal. Department of Finance
Public lookupNMLS Consumer Access and IDOF’s Licensee & Financial Institution SearchThese verify an actual named company only after a search result is obtained. Department of Finance +2
Source links captured in this table

Captured table 05

Source ID · Title / issuer · Direct literal URL · 15 data rows

Source IDTitle / issuerDirect literal URLPinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
S_ID-P1-S001Statutes and Rules — Idaho Department of Financehttps://www.finance.idaho.gov/legal/statutes-and-rules/Current official index; lines 156–160 and 228–258. Freshly read 2026-10-24 PT. It identifies the ICAA sections and states that agency guidance lacks force and effect of law. Department of Finance
S_ID-P1-S002Idaho Code § 26-2222, Definitions — 2025 Idaho Code reproduced by Justiahttps://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2222/§(1), (5), (9), (14); lines 58 onward. Freshly read 2026-10-24 PT. Secondary code reproduction; official section HTML inaccessible. Justia Law
S_ID-P1-S003Idaho Code § 26-2223, License Required — 2025 Idaho Code reproduced by Justiahttps://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2223/Opening clause and subsections (1)–(8), especially (7)–(8), lines 57–73. Freshly read. Last displayed amendment 2008; official current section inaccessible. Justia Law +1
S_ID-P1-S004Idaho Code § 26-2224, License Applicationhttps://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2224/§(1)(a)–(l), §(2), lines 57–86. Freshly read. 2022 amendment displayed. Justia Law +1
S_ID-P1-S005Idaho Code § 26-2225, Approval of License Applicationhttps://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2225/§(1)–(2), lines 57–62. Freshly read. Justia Law
S_ID-P1-S006Idaho Code § 26-2226, False or Fraudulent Debt Reduction and Elimination Practiceshttps://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2226/§(1)–(2), lines 57–64. Freshly read. Prohibits obtaining or attempting to obtain compensation through misleading reduction/elimination claims. Justia Law
S_ID-P1-S007Idaho Code § 26-2227, Denial, Suspension, or Revocationhttps://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2227/§(1) and grounds beginning lines 57–63. Freshly read; full remedies pass remains open. Justia Law
S_ID-P1-S008Idaho Code § 26-2229, Contractshttps://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2229/§(3)(a)–(b), lines 67–70. Freshly read. Controlling 15%, 20%, and cancellation-refund text. Justia Law
S_ID-P1-S009Idaho Code § 26-2229A, Fair, Open, and Honest Dealinghttps://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2229a/§(1), (4), (8), (9), especially lines 57–75. Freshly read. Justia Law +1
S_ID-P1-S010Idaho Code § 26-2231, Renewal and Reinstatementhttps://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2231/§(1)–(3), lines 57–69. Freshly read; amended 2022. Justia Law
S_ID-P1-S011Idaho Code § 26-2232A, Debt/Credit Counselor and Credit-Repair Bondshttps://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2232a/§(1)–(3), lines 57–64. Freshly read. Access condition only; full bond pass remains open. Justia Law +1
S_ID-P1-S012Idaho Code § 26-2238, Violations and Penaltieshttps://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2238/§(1)–(3), lines 57–61. Freshly read. Justia Law
S_ID-P1-S013Idaho Code § 26-2239, Exemptionshttps://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2239/§(1)–(10), lines 58–75. Freshly read; last displayed amendment 2020. Justia Law +2
S_ID-P1-S014Wall & Associates, Inc. v. State of Idaho, Department of Finance, Consumer Finance Bureau, Idaho Supreme Court, Docket 51310https://cases.justia.com/idaho/supreme-court-civil/2025-51310.pdf?ts=1755796372Opinion filed 2025-08-21; pp. 3–17 materially read, with PDF pages visually inspected. Freshly checked 2026-10-24. Controlling Idaho Supreme Court opinion; PDF copy accessed through Justia. Justia Law +3
S_ID-P1-S015Idaho Supreme Court Opinions — Idaho Judicial Branchhttps://isc.idaho.gov/cases-opinions/isc-opinionsLines 22–24 state cited opinions are posted on release. Freshly read. The searchable official page did not expose a stable direct PDF link for Docket 51310 through this route. Idaho Supreme Court
Source links captured in this table

Captured table 06

Source ID · Title / issuer · Direct literal URL · 11 data rows

Source IDTitle / issuerDirect literal URLPinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
S_ID-P1-S016Collection Agency Forms — IDOFhttps://www.finance.idaho.gov/consumer-finance-bureau/collection-agencies/collection-agency-forms/Lines 156–170. Freshly read. Routes applications to NMLS and states March 2026 agent reporting moved to Tyler Idaho. Procedure, not independent legal permission. Department of Finance
S_ID-P1-S017Collection Agencies — IDOFhttps://www.finance.idaho.gov/consumer-finance-bureau/collection-agencies/Lines 156–168; page last updated 2025-07-09. Freshly read. The March 15/paper renewal wording conflicts with the amended statute; used only as an operational lead. Department of Finance
S_ID-P1-S018Idaho Collection Agency Annual Report and 2026 Bond Calculation Package — IDOFhttps://www.finance.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Idaho-Collection-Agency-Act-Annual-Reporting-and-Bond-Calculation-Package-3.pdfPages 1–2, including activity categories, March 15 filing, and license prefixes. Freshly read and visually inspected. Operational form, not a source of new substantive fee permission. Department of Finance
S_ID-P1-S019April 22, 2026 Financial Literacy Release — IDOFhttps://www.finance.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/2026-DOF-PR-FLM-Debt-Settlement.pdfPages 1–2. Freshly read and visually inspected. Confirms licensing treatment of debt and tax-debt settlement and NMLS lookup route. Nonbinding guidance; its CROA discussion is not relied on for federal timing. Department of Finance
S_ID-P1-S020September 14, 2026 Credit Repair / “Finfluencer” Alert — IDOFhttps://www.finance.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/2026-DOF-PR-Debt-Finfluencer-.pdfPages 1–2, especially p. 2. Freshly read and visually inspected. Says accreditation is not a license and directs users to NMLS. Nonbinding consumer guidance. Department of Finance
S_ID-P1-S0212025 Debt Settlement and Credit Repair Consumer Tip — IDOFhttps://www.finance.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/about/press-releases/documents/2025/2025-DOF-PR-Debt-Settlement-Credit-Repair-Cos-Tip.pdfPage 1, lines 45–67. Freshly read and visually inspected. Its “monthly payment” fee descriptions conflict with § 26-2229; retained as a documented guidance conflict, not controlling law. Department of Finance
S_ID-P1-S022IDAPA 12 Cumulative Index — Idaho Office of Administrative Rules/DFMhttps://proddfmmainsa.blob.core.windows.net/dfm-admin-website/cindex/12.pdfPage 4/parsed p. 3, line 184. Freshly read and visually inspected. Marks IDAPA 12.01.11 expired 2022-03-31. ProdDFMMainSA
S_ID-P1-S023Archived IDAPA 12.01.11, Rules Pursuant to the ICAAhttps://proddfmmainsa.blob.core.windows.net/dfm-admin-website/rules/2021%20Archive/12/120111.pdfArchived chapter; read only to identify historical scope and incorporated-law version. Expired/historical, not current authority. ProdDFMMainSA
S_ID-P1-S024NMLS Checklist Compiler — NMLShttps://mortgage.nationwidelicensingsystem.org/knowledge/Products/nmls/stateresourcecenter/SitePages/Checklist-Compiler.aspxPublic locator opened but produced no usable Idaho checklist text through the parsed route. Discovery-only; not relied on for checklist contents.
S_ID-P1-S025Licensee & Financial Institution Search — IDOFhttps://www.finance.idaho.gov/finance-license-charter-search/Current official search landing page freshly opened. Embedded results were not queried for any named provider. Department of Finance
S_ID-P1-S030Direct Idaho Legislature section routes — access-failure recordhttps://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title26/T26CH22/SECT26-2222 https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title26/T26CH22/SECT26-2223 https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title26/T26CH22/SECT26-2229 https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title26/T26CH22/SECT26-2229A https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title26/T26CH22/SECT26-2239Actual attempts on 2026-10-24 returned internal/access errors. These were not treated as read passages. (Website Name Missing)
Source links captured in this table

Captured table 07

Source ID · Title / issuer · Direct literal URL · 5 data rows

Source IDTitle / issuerDirect literal URLPinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
S_ID-P1-S02616 C.F.R. § 310.2, Definitions — eCFRhttps://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.2§310.2(o), debt-relief service. Current eCFR read 2026-10-24; page indicated continuously updated status. eCFR +1
S_ID-P1-S02716 C.F.R. § 310.4, Abusive Telemarketing Acts — eCFRhttps://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.4§310.4(a)(2) and (a)(5)(i)–(ii), lines 101–131. Freshly read. eCFR +3
S_ID-P1-S02816 C.F.R. § 310.6, Exemptions — eCFRhttps://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.6§310.6(b)(5)–(6), particularly debt-relief-advertisement carveouts. Freshly read. eCFR +1
S_ID-P1-S02915 U.S.C. § 1679a, CROA Definitions — U.S. House OLRChttps://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/119-118/t15/s1679a/§1679a(1)–(3), through Public Law 119-120, 2026-10-07. Freshly read. U.S. Code
S_ID-P1-S03115 U.S.C. § 1679b, CROA Prohibited Practices — U.S. House OLRChttps://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/119-118/t15/s1679b/§1679b(b), lines 47–48; through Public Law 119-120, 2026-10-07. Freshly read. U.S. Code
Source links captured in this table

Captured table 08

Claim ID · Precise assertion · Sources and pinpoints · 35 data rows

Claim IDPrecise assertionSources and pinpointsConditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
S_ID-P1-C001Idaho’s debt-counselor category has three independent branches: payment/proration, debt-management services, and contracting to adjust/compromise/discharge debt.S003 §26-2223(7); S014 pp. 3–5. Justia Law +1High substantive confidence; official section-page access held under C035.
C002Custody is unnecessary for licensing; it primarily changes the applicable fee branch.S003 §(7); S008 §(3)(a)–(b). Justia Law +1High.
C003Principal reduction/settlement, nonprincipal concessions, DMP counseling, and distribution can be covered under different or overlapping clauses.S003 §(7). Justia LawHigh for clause mapping; application remains fact-specific.
C004Credit repair is separately classified and may overlap with debt settlement; labels, accreditation, or nonprofit descriptions do not decide coverage.S002 §(5); S003 §(8); S020 p. 2. Justia Law +2High.
C005An out-of-state provider serving and contracting with Idaho debtors can be subject to Idaho licensure.S002 §(1); S003; S014. Justia Law +2High for actual Idaho customer/contact facts.
C006A passive website with no Idaho customer, solicitation, contract, agent contact, or service was not resolved.S002–S003; no controlling passive-site holding found.Held; territorial edge requires later authority.
C007The debt-counselor clause lacks an express consumer-purpose limitation, but pure business-only program coverage was not separately adjudicated.S003 §(7)–(8); S014. Justia Law +1Moderate-high textual confidence; pure B2B conclusion held.
C008Tax-debt settlement is covered; enrolled-agent status does not replace Idaho licensure.S014 pp. 3–13. Justia Law +2High; controlling state decision.
C009Secured debt may remain within licensing coverage, but the 20% unsecured-debt fee ceiling is inapplicable; no substitute amount was established.S008 §(3)(b); S014 pp. 9–10. Justia Law +1High on inapplicability; fee amount unresolved.
C010Covered conduct is conditionally authorized through licensure, not categorically prohibited in all circumstances.S003 opening clause; S005 §(1). Justia Law +1High.
C011Nonexempt operation without the required license is a felony and may support regulatory sanctions.S012 §(2); S007; S014. Justia Law +2High; criminal application requires actual statutory elements and prosecution.
C012Attorney exemption is limited to Idaho-licensed lawyers retained by clients where the covered activity is incidental to practice; no separate covered business.S013 §(1). Justia LawHigh.
C013Idaho has enumerated institutional and activity-specific exclusions but no general nonprofit exemption.S013 §(1)–(10). Justia Law +2High based on complete listed exemptions.
C014A purchaser collecting delinquent/defaulted debt for itself is expressly covered; original-creditor boundaries are fact-specific and no blanket self-creditor exemption appears in §26-2239.S003 §(6); S013. Justia Law +1High for debt buyer; original-creditor counseling edge partial.
C015Custodial payment/proration compensation is capped at 15% of each amount received at one time, with no other charges for that service.S008 §(3)(a). Justia LawHigh.
C016Noncustodial unsecured-debt management fees are capped in aggregate at 20% of principal unsecured debt at contracting.S008 §(3)(b). Justia LawHigh.
C017Upon debtor cancellation before successful completion, 50% of collected fees associated with debt remaining unsettled must be refunded.S008 §(3)(b), final sentence. Justia LawHigh text; association/allocation and payment deadline require facts/later contract analysis.
C018No CPI indexing, adjusted dollar schedule, setup subcap, monthly subcap, or separate Idaho savings/per-debt cap was found.S008; S001; S016–S021. Justia Law +2Moderate-high; subject to official-code currentness hold.
C019IDOF’s 2025 “monthly payment” description conflicts with the statutory fee bases and is nonbinding.S001 lines 156–160; S008; S021. Department of Finance +2High.
C020Idaho’s fee ceilings do not themselves affirmatively authorize collection in advance of performance.S008; S009. Justia Law +1High as a negative/no-safe-harbor conclusion; no general Idaho debt-settlement milestone found.
C021Idaho credit-repair fees cannot be charged or received before the agreed service is fully performed.S009 §(8). Justia LawHigh.
C022False, fraudulent, or materially misleading debt-reduction and service representations are independently prohibited.S006; S009 §(1), (9). Justia Law +2High.
C023Federal TSR fee timing applies only when the TSR’s debt-relief and telemarketing coverage requirements are met; inbound response to a debt-relief advertisement is not generically exempt.S026 §310.2(o); S028 §310.6. eCFR +1High; individual channel/facts still required.
C024Covered TSR debt-relief fees require a qualifying agreement altering at least one debt and at least one customer payment under that agreement.S027 §310.4(a)(5)(i)(A)–(B). eCFRHigh.
C025Individually resolved TSR debts require proportional total-fee allocation or the same percentage of actual savings across debts.S027 §310.4(a)(5)(i)(C). eCFRHigh.
C026A dedicated account does not earn the fee; it must satisfy insured-account, ownership, independence, no-referral-payment, withdrawal, and return conditions.S027 §310.4(a)(5)(ii). eCFRHigh.
C027CROA is conditional, has its own definition and exclusions, and prohibits payment before full performance; it is not a universal debt-settlement statute.S029 §1679a; S031 §1679b(b). U.S. Code +1High.
C028Idaho applications use the director-prescribed electronic system; IDOF currently routes applicants to NMLS.S004 §(1); S016. Justia Law +1High.
C029Debt/credit counselor and credit-repair applicants must provide a qualifying bond or CD after approval and before issuance.S011 §(1)–(3). Justia Law +1High; full bond obligations remain outside this pass.
C030License renewal is due electronically by December 31 with a $100 fee; the 60-day statutory reinstatement requires an additional $50.S010 §(1)–(3). Justia LawHigh.
C031Public status routes are NMLS Consumer Access and IDOF’s license search; no named provider status was established.S019 p. 2; S020 p. 2; S025. Department of Finance +2High for route; no company authorization claim.
C032IDAPA 12.01.11 expired March 31, 2022 and is historical only.S022 line 184; S023. ProdDFMMainSA +1High.
C033The exact current Idaho NMLS application/renewal checklist was not obtained through the public parsed route.S016; S024. Department of FinanceExplicit unresolved evidence gap.
C034Administrative fee restoration or disgorgement in Wall is an enforcement remedy, not an alternative lawful fee schedule.S014 pp. 14–17. Justia Law +1High.
C035Core current-law conclusions are corroborated by current IDOF materials and a 2025 controlling decision, but official 2026 section text/session-law comparison was inaccessible.S001, S014, S019–S020, S030. Department of Finance +2Moderate-high overall currentness; exact official text held.
Source links captured in this table

Captured table 09

Component · Status · Supporting claims · 36 data rows

ComponentStatusSupporting claimsExact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Debt counselor statutory definitionAnsweredC001–C003Official Legislature section HTML remains inaccessible; preserve C035.
Principal reduction versus DMP/concession servicesAnsweredC002–C003Fact-specific overlap still requires actual service documents in a provider review.
Custodial versus noncustodial classificationAnsweredC002, C015–C017Third-party/affiliate account arrangements need later funds-and-contract analysis.
Credit-repair overlapAnsweredC003–C004, C021, C027Apply to actual representations and services; no universal overlap.
Consumer versus business-purpose debtPartialC007, C023, C027Locate controlling Idaho commercial-debt case or official interpretation; separately analyze TSR B2B scope.
Remote-provider Idaho nexusPartial but operationally strongC005–C006Passive-site/no-customer edge requires territorial authority; Idaho-client contracting is covered.
Tax-debt settlementAnsweredC008Sector-specific contracts, IRS practice, and tax-lien fees remain later.
Secured-debt licensingAnswered at classification levelC009Full secured-sector pass remains open.
Secured-debt provider feeUnresolvedC009Find controlling fee statute, order, opinion, or approved contract treatment; do not use 20%.
Licensing versus prohibitionAnsweredC010–C011Provider-specific eligibility still requires application and license result.
Attorney exemptionAnsweredC012UPL, fee sharing, separate-entity facts, and litigation services remain later.
Nonprofit/accreditation treatmentAnsweredC004, C013Federal tax status may affect CROA but not Idaho’s enumerated exemption list.
Institutional exclusionsAnswered for textC013Entity-by-entity charter and incidental-activity facts still required.
Original-creditor/self-creditor boundaryPartialC014Later creditor-side and debt-buyer pass must resolve each model.
Custodial 15% capAnsweredC015Affiliate/pass-through and what constitutes the same service need later contract/funds work.
Noncustodial 20% capAnsweredC016Actual contract must identify contracting-date principal and all provider compensation.
Cancellation refund formulaAnswered, timing partialC017No payment deadline found; association methodology, contract language, and remedies need later work.
Indexing/adjustmentAnswered from accessible sourcesC018Recheck official section/session laws when accessible; no CPI calculation.
Historical/current guidance conflictAnsweredC019Statute controls; do not operationalize the “monthly payment” wording.
Idaho fee timingAnswered as no general affirmative trigger locatedC020–C022Full contract and enforcement pass may reveal additional timing consequences.
Federal TSR common contextAnswered conditionallyC023–C026Apply actual marketing channel, call flow, creditor type, debt type, and customer purpose.
Federal CROA common contextAnswered conditionallyC027Apply actual credit-improvement representations and exclusions.
Application and issuanceAnsweredC028–C029Exact NMLS checklist unresolved under C033.
RenewalAnsweredC030Reconcile future IDOF webpage corrections if made.
Public lookup routeAnsweredC031Named-provider status requires exact company name/NMLS ID and an actual registry result.
Current administrative ruleAnsweredC032Monitor for any future replacement rule; archived chapter is not operative.
Exact NMLS checklistUnresolvedC033Retrieve a public Idaho company-license new-application and renewal checklist through an accessible NMLS route.
Administrative restitutionAnswered only as relevant to fee characterizationC034Full remedies/disgorgement standards remain later.
Official-code currentnessPartial/heldC035Reopen official Idaho section text and compare 2026 session laws when the public route is accessible.
Agreements/disclosuresExcluded for later pass—Read statutory contract clauses, cancellation provisions, required notices, and actual forms.
Funds/trust/dedicated accountsExcluded except federal context—Analyze Idaho §§ 26-2233 and 26-2234, affiliations, indirect receipt, and account charges.
Full bonds/remedies/closureExcluded except access conditions—Complete §§ 26-2232A, 26-2244–2247 and discontinuance rules.
Creditor-side collection/debt buyersExcluded for later passC014 onlySeparate collection-licensing and activity analysis.
Litigation, limitations, exemptions from executionExcluded—Separate state investigations.
Local/tribal lawExcluded—Identify tribal jurisdiction, state reach, and any local rules.
Comprehensive case lawExcluded except controlling Wall issueC008–C009, C034Search reported and administrative cases for fee, contract, exemption, nexus, and remedies issues.

Find the assertion and its boundaries

Read the evidence with its boundaries. These are saved research components, including revisions. A scoped coordinator review checks selected evidence; it does not certify every claim, a complete jurisdiction, current law or individual applicability. Dates and access limits remain attached to the records.

How to read the research →

S_ID-P1-C001 Saved research record

Idaho’s debt-counselor category has three independent branches: payment/proration, debt-management services, and contracting to adjust/compromise/discharge debt.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S003 §26-2223(7); S014 pp. 3–5. Justia Law +1
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High substantive confidence; official section-page access held under C035.
S_ID-C002 Saved research record

Custody is unnecessary for licensing; it primarily changes the applicable fee branch.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S003 §(7); S008 §(3)(a)–(b). Justia Law +1
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High.
S_ID-C003 Saved research record

Principal reduction/settlement, nonprincipal concessions, DMP counseling, and distribution can be covered under different or overlapping clauses.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S003 §(7). Justia Law
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High for clause mapping; application remains fact-specific.
S_ID-C004 Saved research record

Credit repair is separately classified and may overlap with debt settlement; labels, accreditation, or nonprofit descriptions do not decide coverage.

Recorded check status: qualified by reviewed pass02 official current and provider holds remain

Sources and pinpoints
S002 §(5); S003 §(8); S020 p. 2. Justia Law +2
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High.
S_ID-C005 Saved research record

An out-of-state provider serving and contracting with Idaho debtors can be subject to Idaho licensure.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S002 §(1); S003; S014. Justia Law +2
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High for actual Idaho customer/contact facts.
S_ID-C006 Saved research record

A passive website with no Idaho customer, solicitation, contract, agent contact, or service was not resolved.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S002–S003; no controlling passive-site holding found.
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
Held; territorial edge requires later authority.
S_ID-C007 Saved research record

The debt-counselor clause lacks an express consumer-purpose limitation, but pure business-only program coverage was not separately adjudicated.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S003 §(7)–(8); S014. Justia Law +1
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
Moderate-high textual confidence; pure B2B conclusion held.
S_ID-C008 Saved research record

Tax-debt settlement is covered; enrolled-agent status does not replace Idaho licensure.

Recorded check status: qualified by reviewed pass02 official current and provider holds remain

Sources and pinpoints
S014 pp. 3–13. Justia Law +2
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High; controlling state decision.
S_ID-C009 Saved research record

Secured debt may remain within licensing coverage, but the 20% unsecured-debt fee ceiling is inapplicable; no substitute amount was established.

Recorded check status: qualified by reviewed pass02 official current and provider holds remain

Sources and pinpoints
S008 §(3)(b); S014 pp. 9–10. Justia Law +1
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High on inapplicability; fee amount unresolved.
S_ID-C010 Saved research record

Covered conduct is conditionally authorized through licensure, not categorically prohibited in all circumstances.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S003 opening clause; S005 §(1). Justia Law +1
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High.
S_ID-C011 Saved research record

Nonexempt operation without the required license is a felony and may support regulatory sanctions.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S012 §(2); S007; S014. Justia Law +2
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High; criminal application requires actual statutory elements and prosecution.
S_ID-C012 Saved research record

Attorney exemption is limited to Idaho-licensed lawyers retained by clients where the covered activity is incidental to practice; no separate covered business.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S013 §(1). Justia Law
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High.
S_ID-C013 Saved research record

Idaho has enumerated institutional and activity-specific exclusions but no general nonprofit exemption.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S013 §(1)–(10). Justia Law +2
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High based on complete listed exemptions.
S_ID-C014 Saved research record

A purchaser collecting delinquent/defaulted debt for itself is expressly covered; original-creditor boundaries are fact-specific and no blanket self-creditor exemption appears in §26-2239.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S003 §(6); S013. Justia Law +1
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High for debt buyer; original-creditor counseling edge partial.
S_ID-C015 Saved research record

Custodial payment/proration compensation is capped at 15% of each amount received at one time, with no other charges for that service.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S008 §(3)(a). Justia Law
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High.
S_ID-C016 Saved research record

Noncustodial unsecured-debt management fees are capped in aggregate at 20% of principal unsecured debt at contracting.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S008 §(3)(b). Justia Law
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High.
S_ID-C017 Saved research record

Upon debtor cancellation before successful completion, 50% of collected fees associated with debt remaining unsettled must be refunded.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S008 §(3)(b), final sentence. Justia Law
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High text; association/allocation and payment deadline require facts/later contract analysis.
S_ID-C018 Saved research record

No CPI indexing, adjusted dollar schedule, setup subcap, monthly subcap, or separate Idaho savings/per-debt cap was found.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S008; S001; S016–S021. Justia Law +2
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
Moderate-high; subject to official-code currentness hold.
S_ID-C019 Saved research record

IDOF’s 2025 “monthly payment” description conflicts with the statutory fee bases and is nonbinding.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S001 lines 156–160; S008; S021. Department of Finance +2
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High.
S_ID-C020 Saved research record

Idaho’s fee ceilings do not themselves affirmatively authorize collection in advance of performance.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S008; S009. Justia Law +1
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High as a negative/no-safe-harbor conclusion; no general Idaho debt-settlement milestone found.
S_ID-C021 Saved research record

Idaho credit-repair fees cannot be charged or received before the agreed service is fully performed.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S009 §(8). Justia Law
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High.
S_ID-C022 Saved research record

False, fraudulent, or materially misleading debt-reduction and service representations are independently prohibited.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S006; S009 §(1), (9). Justia Law +2
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High.
S_ID-C023 Saved research record

Federal TSR fee timing applies only when the TSR’s debt-relief and telemarketing coverage requirements are met; inbound response to a debt-relief advertisement is not generically exempt.

Recorded check status: bounded reference or qualification patch required originalcells preserved

Sources and pinpoints
S026 §310.2(o); S028 §310.6. eCFR +1
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High; individual channel/facts still required.
S_ID-C024 Saved research record

Covered TSR debt-relief fees require a qualifying agreement altering at least one debt and at least one customer payment under that agreement.

Recorded check status: bounded reference or qualification patch required originalcells preserved

Sources and pinpoints
S027 §310.4(a)(5)(i)(A)–(B). eCFR
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High.
S_ID-C025 Saved research record

Individually resolved TSR debts require proportional total-fee allocation or the same percentage of actual savings across debts.

Recorded check status: bounded reference or qualification patch required originalcells preserved

Sources and pinpoints
S027 §310.4(a)(5)(i)(C). eCFR
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High.
S_ID-C026 Saved research record

A dedicated account does not earn the fee; it must satisfy insured-account, ownership, independence, no-referral-payment, withdrawal, and return conditions.

Recorded check status: bounded reference or qualification patch required originalcells preserved

Sources and pinpoints
S027 §310.4(a)(5)(ii). eCFR
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High.
S_ID-C027 Saved research record

CROA is conditional, has its own definition and exclusions, and prohibits payment before full performance; it is not a universal debt-settlement statute.

Recorded check status: bounded reference or qualification patch required originalcells preserved

Sources and pinpoints
S029 §1679a; S031 §1679b(b). U.S. Code +1
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High.
S_ID-C028 Saved research record

Idaho applications use the director-prescribed electronic system; IDOF currently routes applicants to NMLS.

Recorded check status: qualified by reviewed pass02 official current and provider holds remain

Sources and pinpoints
S004 §(1); S016. Justia Law +1
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High.
S_ID-C029 Saved research record

Debt/credit counselor and credit-repair applicants must provide a qualifying bond or CD after approval and before issuance.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S011 §(1)–(3). Justia Law +1
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High; full bond obligations remain outside this pass.
S_ID-C030 Saved research record

License renewal is due electronically by December 31 with a $100 fee; the 60-day statutory reinstatement requires an additional $50.

Recorded check status: qualified by reviewed pass02 official current and provider holds remain

Sources and pinpoints
S010 §(1)–(3). Justia Law
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High.
S_ID-C031 Saved research record

Public status routes are NMLS Consumer Access and IDOF’s license search; no named provider status was established.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S019 p. 2; S020 p. 2; S025. Department of Finance +2
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High for route; no company authorization claim.
S_ID-C032 Saved research record

IDAPA 12.01.11 expired March 31, 2022 and is historical only.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S022 line 184; S023. ProdDFMMainSA +1
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High.
S_ID-C033 Saved research record

The exact current Idaho NMLS application/renewal checklist was not obtained through the public parsed route.

Recorded check status: selectedevidence reviewed with currentness applicabilityholds notfullclearance

Sources and pinpoints
S016; S024. Department of Finance
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
Explicit unresolved evidence gap.
S_ID-C034 Saved research record

Administrative fee restoration or disgorgement in Wall is an enforcement remedy, not an alternative lawful fee schedule.

Recorded check status: qualified by reviewed pass02 official current and provider holds remain

Sources and pinpoints
S014 pp. 14–17. Justia Law +1
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
High.
S_ID-C035 Saved research record

Core current-law conclusions are corroborated by current IDOF materials and a 2025 controlling decision, but official 2026 section text/session-law comparison was inaccessible.

Recorded check status: bounded reference or qualification patch required originalcells preserved

Sources and pinpoints
S001, S014, S019–S020, S030. Department of Finance +2
Conditions, exceptions, currentness, confidence
Moderate-high overall currentness; exact official text held.

Sources, pinpoints and access limits

Keep the source version, actual read extent and jurisdiction with the proposition. A link or researcher access claim is not a substitute for an operative primary passage.

S_ID-P1-S001 Saved research record

Statutes and Rules — Idaho Department of Finance

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://www.finance.idaho.gov/legal/statutes-and-rules/
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
Current official index; lines 156–160 and 228–258. Freshly read 2026-10-24 PT. It identifies the ICAA sections and states that agency guidance lacks force and effect of law. Department of Finance
Direct source URLs
https://www.finance.idaho.gov/legal/statutes-and-rules/
S_ID-P1-S002 Saved research record

Idaho Code § 26-2222, Definitions — 2025 Idaho Code reproduced by Justia

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2222/
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
§(1), (5), (9), (14); lines 58 onward. Freshly read 2026-10-24 PT. Secondary code reproduction; official section HTML inaccessible. Justia Law
Direct source URLs
https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2222/
S_ID-P1-S003 Saved research record

Idaho Code § 26-2223, License Required — 2025 Idaho Code reproduced by Justia

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2223/
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
Opening clause and subsections (1)–(8), especially (7)–(8), lines 57–73. Freshly read. Last displayed amendment 2008; official current section inaccessible. Justia Law +1
Direct source URLs
https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2223/
S_ID-P1-S004 Saved research record

Idaho Code § 26-2224, License Application

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2224/
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
§(1)(a)–(l), §(2), lines 57–86. Freshly read. 2022 amendment displayed. Justia Law +1
Direct source URLs
https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2224/
S_ID-P1-S006 Saved research record

Idaho Code § 26-2226, False or Fraudulent Debt Reduction and Elimination Practices

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2226/
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
§(1)–(2), lines 57–64. Freshly read. Prohibits obtaining or attempting to obtain compensation through misleading reduction/elimination claims. Justia Law
Direct source URLs
https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2226/
S_ID-P1-S007 Saved research record

Idaho Code § 26-2227, Denial, Suspension, or Revocation

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2227/
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
§(1) and grounds beginning lines 57–63. Freshly read; full remedies pass remains open. Justia Law
Direct source URLs
https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2227/
S_ID-P1-S008 Saved research record

Idaho Code § 26-2229, Contracts

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2229/
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
§(3)(a)–(b), lines 67–70. Freshly read. Controlling 15%, 20%, and cancellation-refund text. Justia Law
Direct source URLs
https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2229/
S_ID-P1-S009 Saved research record

Idaho Code § 26-2229A, Fair, Open, and Honest Dealing

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2229a/
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
§(1), (4), (8), (9), especially lines 57–75. Freshly read. Justia Law +1
Direct source URLs
https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2229a/
S_ID-P1-S010 Saved research record

Idaho Code § 26-2231, Renewal and Reinstatement

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2231/
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
§(1)–(3), lines 57–69. Freshly read; amended 2022. Justia Law
Direct source URLs
https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2231/
S_ID-P1-S011 Saved research record

Idaho Code § 26-2232A, Debt/Credit Counselor and Credit-Repair Bonds

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2232a/
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
§(1)–(3), lines 57–64. Freshly read. Access condition only; full bond pass remains open. Justia Law +1
Direct source URLs
https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2232a/
S_ID-P1-S013 Saved research record

Idaho Code § 26-2239, Exemptions

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2239/
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
§(1)–(10), lines 58–75. Freshly read; last displayed amendment 2020. Justia Law +2
Direct source URLs
https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-26/chapter-22/section-26-2239/
S_ID-P1-S014 Saved research record

Wall & Associates, Inc. v. State of Idaho, Department of Finance, Consumer Finance Bureau, Idaho Supreme Court, Docket 51310

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://cases.justia.com/idaho/supreme-court-civil/2025-51310.pdf?ts=1755796372
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
Opinion filed 2025-08-21; pp. 3–17 materially read, with PDF pages visually inspected. Freshly checked 2026-10-24. Controlling Idaho Supreme Court opinion; PDF copy accessed through Justia. Justia Law +3
Direct source URLs
https://cases.justia.com/idaho/supreme-court-civil/2025-51310.pdf?ts=1755796372
S_ID-P1-S015 Saved research record

Idaho Supreme Court Opinions — Idaho Judicial Branch

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://isc.idaho.gov/cases-opinions/isc-opinions
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
Lines 22–24 state cited opinions are posted on release. Freshly read. The searchable official page did not expose a stable direct PDF link for Docket 51310 through this route. Idaho Supreme Court
Direct source URLs
https://isc.idaho.gov/cases-opinions/isc-opinions
S_ID-P1-S016 Saved research record

Collection Agency Forms — IDOF

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://www.finance.idaho.gov/consumer-finance-bureau/collection-agencies/collection-agency-forms/
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
Lines 156–170. Freshly read. Routes applications to NMLS and states March 2026 agent reporting moved to Tyler Idaho. Procedure, not independent legal permission. Department of Finance
Direct source URLs
https://www.finance.idaho.gov/consumer-finance-bureau/collection-agencies/collection-agency-forms/
S_ID-P1-S017 Saved research record

Collection Agencies — IDOF

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://www.finance.idaho.gov/consumer-finance-bureau/collection-agencies/
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
Lines 156–168; page last updated 2025-07-09. Freshly read. The March 15/paper renewal wording conflicts with the amended statute; used only as an operational lead. Department of Finance
Direct source URLs
https://www.finance.idaho.gov/consumer-finance-bureau/collection-agencies/
S_ID-P1-S018 Saved research record

Idaho Collection Agency Annual Report and 2026 Bond Calculation Package — IDOF

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://www.finance.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Idaho-Collection-Agency-Act-Annual-Reporting-and-Bond-Calculation-Package-3.pdf
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
Pages 1–2, including activity categories, March 15 filing, and license prefixes. Freshly read and visually inspected. Operational form, not a source of new substantive fee permission. Department of Finance
Direct source URLs
https://www.finance.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Idaho-Collection-Agency-Act-Annual-Reporting-and-Bond-Calculation-Package-3.pdf
S_ID-P1-S019 Saved research record

April 22, 2026 Financial Literacy Release — IDOF

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://www.finance.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/2026-DOF-PR-FLM-Debt-Settlement.pdf
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
Pages 1–2. Freshly read and visually inspected. Confirms licensing treatment of debt and tax-debt settlement and NMLS lookup route. Nonbinding guidance; its CROA discussion is not relied on for federal timing. Department of Finance
Direct source URLs
https://www.finance.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/2026-DOF-PR-FLM-Debt-Settlement.pdf
S_ID-P1-S020 Saved research record

September 14, 2026 Credit Repair / “Finfluencer” Alert — IDOF

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://www.finance.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/2026-DOF-PR-Debt-Finfluencer-.pdf
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
Pages 1–2, especially p. 2. Freshly read and visually inspected. Says accreditation is not a license and directs users to NMLS. Nonbinding consumer guidance. Department of Finance
Direct source URLs
https://www.finance.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/2026-DOF-PR-Debt-Finfluencer-.pdf
S_ID-P1-S021 Saved research record

2025 Debt Settlement and Credit Repair Consumer Tip — IDOF

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://www.finance.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/about/press-releases/documents/2025/2025-DOF-PR-Debt-Settlement-Credit-Repair-Cos-Tip.pdf
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
Page 1, lines 45–67. Freshly read and visually inspected. Its “monthly payment” fee descriptions conflict with § 26-2229; retained as a documented guidance conflict, not controlling law. Department of Finance
Direct source URLs
https://www.finance.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/about/press-releases/documents/2025/2025-DOF-PR-Debt-Settlement-Credit-Repair-Cos-Tip.pdf
S_ID-P1-S022 Saved research record

IDAPA 12 Cumulative Index — Idaho Office of Administrative Rules/DFM

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://proddfmmainsa.blob.core.windows.net/dfm-admin-website/cindex/12.pdf
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
Page 4/parsed p. 3, line 184. Freshly read and visually inspected. Marks IDAPA 12.01.11 expired 2022-03-31. ProdDFMMainSA
Direct source URLs
https://proddfmmainsa.blob.core.windows.net/dfm-admin-website/cindex/12.pdf
S_ID-P1-S023 Saved research record

Archived IDAPA 12.01.11, Rules Pursuant to the ICAA

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://proddfmmainsa.blob.core.windows.net/dfm-admin-website/rules/2021%20Archive/12/120111.pdf
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
Archived chapter; read only to identify historical scope and incorporated-law version. Expired/historical, not current authority. ProdDFMMainSA
Direct source URLs
https://proddfmmainsa.blob.core.windows.net/dfm-admin-website/rules/2021%20Archive/12/120111.pdf
https://proddfmmainsa.blob.core.windows.net/dfm-admin-website/rules/2021%20Archive/12/120111.pdf?utm_source=chatgpt.com
S_ID-P1-S024 Saved research record

NMLS Checklist Compiler — NMLS

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://mortgage.nationwidelicensingsystem.org/knowledge/Products/nmls/stateresourcecenter/SitePages/Checklist-Compiler.aspx
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
Public locator opened but produced no usable Idaho checklist text through the parsed route. Discovery-only; not relied on for checklist contents.
Direct source URLs
https://mortgage.nationwidelicensingsystem.org/knowledge/Products/nmls/stateresourcecenter/SitePages/Checklist-Compiler.aspx
S_ID-P1-S025 Saved research record

Licensee & Financial Institution Search — IDOF

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://www.finance.idaho.gov/finance-license-charter-search/
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
Current official search landing page freshly opened. Embedded results were not queried for any named provider. Department of Finance
Direct source URLs
https://www.finance.idaho.gov/finance-license-charter-search/
S_ID-P1-S030 Saved research record

Direct Idaho Legislature section routes — access-failure record

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title26/T26CH22/SECT26-2222 https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title26/T26CH22/SECT26-2223 https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title26/T26CH22/SECT26-2229 https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title26/T26CH22/SECT26-2229A https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title26/T26CH22/SECT26-2239
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
Actual attempts on 2026-10-24 returned internal/access errors. These were not treated as read passages. (Website Name Missing)
Direct source URLs
https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title26/T26CH22/SECT26-2222
https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title26/T26CH22/SECT26-2223
https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title26/T26CH22/SECT26-2229
https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title26/T26CH22/SECT26-2229A
https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title26/T26CH22/SECT26-2239
S_ID-P1-S026 Saved research record

16 C.F.R. § 310.2, Definitions — eCFR

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.2
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
§310.2(o), debt-relief service. Current eCFR read 2026-10-24; page indicated continuously updated status. eCFR +1
Direct source URLs
https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.2
S_ID-P1-S027 Saved research record

16 C.F.R. § 310.4, Abusive Telemarketing Acts — eCFR

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.4
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
§310.4(a)(2) and (a)(5)(i)–(ii), lines 101–131. Freshly read. eCFR +3
Direct source URLs
https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.4
S_ID-P1-S028 Saved research record

16 C.F.R. § 310.6, Exemptions — eCFR

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.6
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
§310.6(b)(5)–(6), particularly debt-relief-advertisement carveouts. Freshly read. eCFR +1
Direct source URLs
https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.6
S_ID-P1-S031 Saved research record

15 U.S.C. § 1679b, CROA Prohibited Practices — U.S. House OLRC

Recorded check status: see actual primary secondary reuse failure or uncheckedscope in reviews/S ID-pass-01-source-checks.json

Direct literal URL
https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/119-118/t15/s1679b/
Pinpoint, version, status, actual check, limitation
§1679b(b), lines 47–48; through Public Law 119-120, 2026-10-07. Freshly read. U.S. Code
Direct source URLs
https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/119-118/t15/s1679b/

What was examined—and what is still missing

The saved component-level coverage record keeps answered, partial, blank and unresolved branches distinct. A coverage label is not acceptance of a whole subject or jurisdiction.

coverage-1 Saved research record

Debt counselor statutory definition

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Supporting claims
C001–C003
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Official Legislature section HTML remains inaccessible; preserve C035.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-2 Saved research record

Principal reduction versus DMP/concession services

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Supporting claims
C002–C003
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Fact-specific overlap still requires actual service documents in a provider review.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-3 Saved research record

Custodial versus noncustodial classification

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Supporting claims
C002, C015–C017
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Third-party/affiliate account arrangements need later funds-and-contract analysis.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-4 Saved research record

Credit-repair overlap

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Supporting claims
C003–C004, C021, C027
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Apply to actual representations and services; no universal overlap.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-5 Saved research record

Consumer versus business-purpose debt

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Partial
Supporting claims
C007, C023, C027
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Locate controlling Idaho commercial-debt case or official interpretation; separately analyze TSR B2B scope.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-6 Saved research record

Remote-provider Idaho nexus

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Partial but operationally strong
Supporting claims
C005–C006
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Passive-site/no-customer edge requires territorial authority; Idaho-client contracting is covered.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-7 Saved research record

Tax-debt settlement

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Supporting claims
C008
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Sector-specific contracts, IRS practice, and tax-lien fees remain later.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-8 Saved research record

Secured-debt licensing

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered at classification level
Supporting claims
C009
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Full secured-sector pass remains open.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-9 Saved research record

Secured-debt provider fee

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Unresolved
Supporting claims
C009
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Find controlling fee statute, order, opinion, or approved contract treatment; do not use 20%.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-10 Saved research record

Licensing versus prohibition

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Supporting claims
C010–C011
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Provider-specific eligibility still requires application and license result.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-11 Saved research record

Attorney exemption

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Supporting claims
C012
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
UPL, fee sharing, separate-entity facts, and litigation services remain later.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-12 Saved research record

Nonprofit/accreditation treatment

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Supporting claims
C004, C013
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Federal tax status may affect CROA but not Idaho’s enumerated exemption list.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-13 Saved research record

Institutional exclusions

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered for text
Supporting claims
C013
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Entity-by-entity charter and incidental-activity facts still required.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-14 Saved research record

Original-creditor/self-creditor boundary

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Partial
Supporting claims
C014
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Later creditor-side and debt-buyer pass must resolve each model.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-15 Saved research record

Custodial 15% cap

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Supporting claims
C015
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Affiliate/pass-through and what constitutes the same service need later contract/funds work.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-16 Saved research record

Noncustodial 20% cap

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Supporting claims
C016
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Actual contract must identify contracting-date principal and all provider compensation.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-17 Saved research record

Cancellation refund formula

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered, timing partial
Supporting claims
C017
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
No payment deadline found; association methodology, contract language, and remedies need later work.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-18 Saved research record

Indexing/adjustment

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered from accessible sources
Supporting claims
C018
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Recheck official section/session laws when accessible; no CPI calculation.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-19 Saved research record

Historical/current guidance conflict

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Supporting claims
C019
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Statute controls; do not operationalize the “monthly payment” wording.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-20 Saved research record

Idaho fee timing

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered as no general affirmative trigger located
Supporting claims
C020–C022
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Full contract and enforcement pass may reveal additional timing consequences.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-21 Saved research record

Federal TSR common context

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered conditionally
Supporting claims
C023–C026
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Apply actual marketing channel, call flow, creditor type, debt type, and customer purpose.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-22 Saved research record

Federal CROA common context

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered conditionally
Supporting claims
C027
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Apply actual credit-improvement representations and exclusions.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-23 Saved research record

Application and issuance

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Supporting claims
C028–C029
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Exact NMLS checklist unresolved under C033.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-24 Saved research record

Renewal

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Supporting claims
C030
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Reconcile future IDOF webpage corrections if made.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-25 Saved research record

Public lookup route

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Supporting claims
C031
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Named-provider status requires exact company name/NMLS ID and an actual registry result.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-26 Saved research record

Current administrative rule

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Supporting claims
C032
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Monitor for any future replacement rule; archived chapter is not operative.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-27 Saved research record

Exact NMLS checklist

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Unresolved
Supporting claims
C033
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Retrieve a public Idaho company-license new-application and renewal checklist through an accessible NMLS route.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-28 Saved research record

Administrative restitution

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered only as relevant to fee characterization
Supporting claims
C034
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Full remedies/disgorgement standards remain later.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-29 Saved research record

Official-code currentness

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Partial/held
Supporting claims
C035
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Reopen official Idaho section text and compare 2026 session laws when the public route is accessible.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-30 Saved research record

Agreements/disclosures

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Excluded for later pass
Supporting claims
—
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Read statutory contract clauses, cancellation provisions, required notices, and actual forms.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-31 Saved research record

Funds/trust/dedicated accounts

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Excluded except federal context
Supporting claims
—
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Analyze Idaho §§ 26-2233 and 26-2234, affiliations, indirect receipt, and account charges.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-32 Saved research record

Full bonds/remedies/closure

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Excluded except access conditions
Supporting claims
—
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Complete §§ 26-2232A, 26-2244–2247 and discontinuance rules.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-33 Saved research record

Creditor-side collection/debt buyers

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Excluded for later pass
Supporting claims
C014 only
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Separate collection-licensing and activity analysis.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-34 Saved research record

Litigation, limitations, exemptions from execution

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Excluded
Supporting claims
—
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Separate state investigations.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-35 Saved research record

Local/tribal law

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Excluded
Supporting claims
—
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Identify tribal jurisdiction, state reach, and any local rules.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance
coverage-36 Saved research record

Comprehensive case law

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Excluded except controlling Wall issue
Supporting claims
C008–C009, C034
Exact unresolved evidence / next investigation
Search reported and administrative cases for fee, contract, exemption, nexus, and remedies issues.

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
reviewed_partial_with_officialcurrency_and_applicability_holds_no_component_or_parent_acceptance

Corrections, review and scope

Read the evidence with its boundaries. These are saved research components, including revisions. A scoped coordinator review checks selected evidence; it does not certify every claim, a complete jurisdiction, current law or individual applicability. Dates and access limits remain attached to the records.

How to read the research →

No currently queued material correction is mapped to this component. This does not remove its currentness, access, jurisdiction or application limits.

Recorded review disposition

revise

Other components in this research series

S_IDpass-15-citation-01

SID bounded rule-pinpoint clarification

Inside: 1. Corrected sentence · 2. Source and read-status register · Document identity

7 tables7 claim records1 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-22-quantity-01

SID Rule 40 quantity and exception completion

Inside: Displayed history—not an original-order audit · Original claim retained · 3.1 Without-cause branches

12 tables15 claim records1 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-27-limited-01

Idaho: appellate history and quantity-row corrections

Inside: 1. Replacement history rows · 2. Replacement quantity row · 3. Source and usage register

6 tables4 claim records2 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-30-limited-01

Idaho: completion of appellate costs inquiry cells B07–B27

Inside:

5 tables5 claim records8 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-29
S_IDpass-31-limited-01

Idaho: appellate rehearing quantity-row correction

Inside: Replacement quantity row · Source and traceability patch · Read log and preserved gaps

4 tables2 claim records1 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-29
S_IDpass-02

SID bounded corrections and qualifications to P1

Inside: 1. Stable reference aliases · 1.1 Immutable P1 source identities · 1.2 Exact inline-reference replacements

14 tables7 claim records16 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_IDpass-03

SID official-source currency and NMLS-checklist evidence patch

Inside: Bottom-line disposition · A1. C004 — credit-repair definition and exclusions · Substantive disposition

8 tables12 claim records22 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_IDpass-04

SID Idaho customer funds and trust accounts

Inside: Current-source limitation · 1. Which models Idaho’s account and funds provisions reach · 1.1 Section 26-2233 uses an actual-custody trigger

7 tables30 claim records21 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_IDpass-05

SID Idaho generic provider agreements, disclosures, cancellation, and termination

Inside: Principal findings · 3.1 Necessary actor and relationship boundaries · 3.2 Collection agency–creditor-client contracts

14 tables40 claim records26 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-06

SID Idaho limitation periods, accrual, acknowledgment, and part-payment

Inside: 1. Principal findings · Status key · 2.1 General contracts and accounts

23 tables59 claim records21 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-07

SID Idaho wage and earnings garnishment, exemptions, and claiming procedure

Inside: Evidence status · 1.1 Earnings, disposable earnings, and the proceeding being regulated · Earnings versus other property

25 tables51 claim records17 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-08

SID Idaho bank-account garnishment, protected benefit deposits, and exemption-claim boundaries

Inside: Principal findings · 1.1 Different proceedings and legal objects · 1.2 Prejudgment attachment is not ordinary postjudgment collection

25 tables55 claim records12 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-09

SID Idaho personal-property secured-debt possession, disposition, redemption, surplus, and deficiency

Inside: Principal findings · 1.1 Different legal questions must remain separate · 1.2 Roles and consumer categories

27 tables60 claim records15 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-10

SID Idaho trust-deed nonjudicial power of sale

Inside: Principal findings · 1.1 Trust deed, mortgage, title, and obligation · 1.2 Property and acreage predicates

24 tables50 claim records13 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-11

SID Idaho medical billing, collection conditions, financial assistance, and federal boundaries

Inside: Principal findings · 1.1 Actor and authority comparison · 1.2 Idaho extraordinary collection action is a defined category

27 tables56 claim records23 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-12

SID Idaho payday/deferred-deposit credit, charges, and borrower protections

Inside: Principal findings · 1.1 Product and actor matrix · 1.2 Territorial and exemption qualifications

24 tables48 claim records15 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-13

SID bounded P9 noncash-proceeds correction and symbolic-register additions

Inside: 1.1 Replacement for P9 § 4.5 · 1.2 Disposition and collection are separate clauses · Effective/application status

12 tables8 claim records8 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-14

SID Idaho judicial real-property mortgage foreclosure, judicial sale, redemption, and deficiency

Inside: Principal findings · 1.1 Instrument, debt, property, and possession · 1.2 Judicially foreclosed trust deeds

24 tables55 claim records11 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-15

SID Idaho residential rent arrears, nonpayment termination, summary possession, and deposit boundaries

Inside: Principal findings · 1.1 Distinct legal objects · 1.2 Actor and property categories

27 tables49 claim records14 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-16

SID Idaho regulated residential electric and natural-gas arrears, deposits, termination, restoration, and complaints

Inside: Evidence disposition · Principal findings · 1.1 Actor and service distinctions

29 tables54 claim records10 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-17

SID Idaho consumer credit sales, retail-installment obligations, and motor-vehicle sale distinctions

Inside: Principal findings · 1.1 Product and actor distinctions · 1.2 Territorial and exemption conditions

33 tables56 claim records17 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-18

SID Idaho consumer personal-property leases and lease-purchase arrangements

Inside: Principal findings · 1.1 Legal-category comparison · 1.2 Chapter 36 exclusions

24 tables54 claim records11 source recordsCorrections to readCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-19

SID Idaho ordinary personal-property exemptions and homestead protection

Inside: Principal findings · 1.1 Execution, exemption, ownership, and debt are different questions · 1.2 Individual, dependent, and residence predicates

27 tables57 claim records13 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-20

SID Idaho ordinary unsecured closed-end consumer cash and personal loans

Inside: Principal findings · 1.1 Product and actor comparison · 1.2 Idaho nexus and exclusions

33 tables54 claim records15 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-21

SID Idaho ordinary civil debt actions: jurisdiction, commencement, service, response, default, and set-aside boundaries

Inside: Evidence disposition · Principal findings · 1.1 Distinct court questions

29 tables56 claim records11 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-22

SID Idaho small-claims debt route

Inside: Evidence disposition · Principal findings · 1.1 Small claims is a distinct procedural route

28 tables48 claim records19 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-23

SID Idaho contested debt proof, documentary evidence, and summary judgment

Inside: Evidence disposition · Principal findings · 1.1 Applicable rule systems

23 tables50 claim records8 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-24

SID Idaho ordinary civil discovery, disclosures, depositions, subpoenas, and protective/enforcement boundaries

Inside: Evidence disposition · Principal findings · 1.1 Ordinary discovery versus other proceedings

25 tables56 claim records5 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-25

SID Idaho ordinary civil trial, jury, verdict, findings, and post-trial motions

Inside: Evidence disposition · Principal findings · 1.1 Procedural posture matters

39 tables56 claim records9 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-26

SID Idaho judgment interest, remaining renewal history, recording, and satisfaction interfaces

Inside: Evidence disposition · Principal findings · 2.1 Interest categories and controlling events

23 tables35 claim records13 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-27

SID Idaho ordinary civil appellate gateways, timing, motion interactions, and stays

Inside: Evidence disposition · Principal findings · 2.1 Constitutional and statutory framework

31 tables55 claim records8 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-28

SID Idaho ordinary civil appellate records and transcripts

Inside: Evidence disposition · Principal findings · 1.1 Reuse versus new evidence

37 tables52 claim records8 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-29

SID Idaho ordinary civil appellate briefing, format, appendices, and oral argument

Inside: Evidence disposition · Principal findings · 1.1 Reuse versus new evidence

37 tables52 claim records8 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-28
S_IDpass-30

SID Idaho ordinary civil appellate costs, attorney fees, and sanction awards

Inside: Evidence disposition · Principal findings · 1.1 Reuse versus new work

34 tables51 claim records8 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-29
S_IDpass-31

SID Idaho appellate rehearing, discretionary review, and narrow remittitur/remand operation

Inside: Evidence disposition · Principal findings · 1.1 Reuse versus new work

30 tables45 claim records8 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-29
S_IDpass-32

SID Idaho residential property-tax arrears, payment relief, reductions, and deferral

Inside: Evidence disposition · 1.1 Assessment, levy, bill, delinquency, and lien are different · 1.2 Property categories

39 tables62 claim records24 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-29
Record integrity

Original saved Markdown SHA-256: df9dbacda00784bdf550765aaf35b0b9a013ce60dd23e6431a05196936000c53. Public formatting, private-reference removal and correction annotations are separate from that immutable original.

Get debt settlement help