SettleADebt.

FIND THE EXPLANATION

Which place’s debt rules apply—and who can help?

Use the notice, agreement, and places connected to the debt to find the right court, regulator, or legal-help service.

Explore Minnesota information →

This address preserves a dated source document behind the guide. The complete explanation covers the questions, comparisons and next steps for this subject.

If you came here to check a specific citation, open the original archive below. It includes its source dates and recorded qualifications.

Original source archive (optional)Original working documents, complete tables and revision history
About this archive

The explanation above is written for readers. These original working documents preserve the evidence trail, including technical language, dated passages and known corrections. They have not all received independent professional review. Use the marked limits before relying on a particular rule or figure.

DETAILED RESEARCH · EVIDENCE & LIMITS INCLUDED

SMN Minnesota DMP fees, initial-payment allocation, and necessary funds ledger

S_MN · pass-06Captured 2026-10-2717 tables · 45 claim records · 17 source recordsScoped coordinator review completed

Read the evidence with its boundaries. These are saved research components, including revisions. A scoped coordinator review checks selected evidence; it does not certify every claim, a complete jurisdiction, current law or individual applicability. Dates and access limits remain attached to the records.

How to read the research →

Read the related correction supplements

These components repair their stated scope. They do not replace every other finding in this research series.

SMN Credit-repair representations, Minnesota CSOs, CROA, and the TSR →

S_MN PASS-06 — Minnesota DMP fees, initial-payment allocation, and necessary funds ledger

Research/access date: October 27, 2026, America/Los_Angeles. Scope: Debt-management-plan origination and maintenance fees; initial and periodic-payment allocation; advance-payment restrictions; necessary custody, distribution, cancellation, and refund accounting; and the directly relevant federal Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR).

Disposition: The statutory limits can be reconciled for several conditional models, including one that permits both origination and maintenance fees. No authority was established for deducting $50 plus $45 from the same ordinary $300 periodic payment. The genuinely separate, fee-only initial-payment theory remains unresolved rather than approved.

P01’s original examples and access history remain preserved. P02 and P04 are separate reviewed components. P05’s unreviewed settlement-performance findings are not premises for this report.

Throughout, S001 means S_MN-P06-S001. Claim identifiers C001–C045 belong exclusively to this pass.

A. Answers to the central questions

A1. Can origination and maintenance both be taken from an initial payment?

Yes, conditionally—but each fee’s individual ceiling is not the entire test.

Section 332A.13 separately provides an origination allowance, a maintenance ceiling and reasonableness condition, and a restriction on all authorized fees retained from any periodic payment. The initial-payment provision contains no express statement exempting an initial payment that is also a periodic plan payment from that retention restriction. [C009–C011; S001, subdivisions 1–4.] MN Revisor

That produces these distinct results:

Proposed first-payment treatment Calculation Result within this pass
$300 periodic payment; $50 origination plus $45 maintenance $95 retained; 31.6667% of receipt; $205 left for creditors No supported route. It exceeds the $45 aggregate retention limit by $50.
$300 periodic payment; contract instead specifies $30 origination plus $15 maintenance $45 retained; 15%; $255 for creditors Conditionally compatible with the numerical limits. Contract, services, timing, consent and distribution conditions remain necessary.
$1,000 periodic payment; $50 origination plus $75 maintenance $125 retained; 12.5%; $875 for creditors Conditionally compatible with both individual ceilings and the aggregate retention limit.
$50 genuinely separate fee-only payment plus a $300 periodic payment Depends on whether the $50 is legally distinct from the periodic payment Unresolved classification—not a permitted workaround.
One $300 periodic obligation divided into a $50 “enrollment” debit and a $250 “plan” debit Same underlying periodic obligation, merely split operationally Splitting the transfer does not establish a statutory exception.

These are applications of the text, not holdings from a Minnesota appellate decision. No responsive published majority opinion or binding administrative interpretation was located and read that supplies an initial-periodic-payment exception. The practical conclusion is therefore narrower than a universal pronouncement about every conceivable initial payment: the stated $95-from-$300 transaction has not been justified. [C011–C012, C036.]

A2. What remains unresolved about a separately paid origination fee?

The statute distinguishes an “initial amount” from a “periodic payment,” but the relevant definitions do not expressly define those terms or establish how to classify a separate fee-only transfer. Two constructions remain materially different:

Construction Supporting textual consideration Missing authority
A genuinely separate initial origination payment is not a periodic payment Subdivision 1 expressly permits an origination fee from the initial amount; subdivision 4 addresses periodic payments A responsive construction explaining when a separate payment is genuinely outside subdivision 4, and how the agreement and payment schedule must reflect it
An initial transfer associated with the first scheduled plan payment remains subject to the periodic-payment limit Subdivision 4 applies to fees authorized by the section and to any periodic payment A responsive application to separately invoiced or separately debited amounts connected to the same scheduled obligation

Neither construction permits treating labels as decisive. A “nominal enrollment charge,” separate invoice, second debit, or different accounting code does not itself establish an exception. The written agreement, actual obligation, purpose, timing and funds flow matter. [C012; S001–S003.] MN Revisor+2

Federal timing is an additional issue. For the covered DMP model discussed below, moving the origination charge into a separate payment before the qualifying DMP enrollment and first payment does not solve the federal advance-fee problem. Moving it afterward may resolve that federal timing issue, but does not resolve Minnesota’s payment-classification question. [C030–C032.] Federal Register

A3. Does Minnesota impose the settlement chapter’s “fully performed” test on every DMP fee?

This pass does not import that test. Chapter 332A supplies its own fee, service-reasonableness, agreement, advance-payment, consent and funds rules. The relevant cancellation language also distinguishes origination fees from fees earned before cancellation or default. It does not provide a universal definition of when every maintenance fee is earned. [C010, C015–C017, C025; S001.] MN Revisor

For a particular DMP fee, the questions are instead:

  • Is the charge authorized by the signed agreement and the applicable statutory fee category?
  • Is the maintenance amount reasonable for services actually provided?
  • Do the monthly and per-payment limits both permit it?
  • Does the advance-payment restriction prohibit receipt or retention at that time?
  • Have any independently applicable federal predicates been satisfied?
  • Is the proposed transfer authorized, correctly recorded, and compatible with timely creditor distribution?

A provider’s receipt of money, a numerical ceiling, a bank debit, and a lawful fee transfer are four different events.

B. Version, enactment, and adjustment findings

B1. Current statutory version and material historical changes

The retrieved Revisor section pages are labeled 2025 Minnesota Statutes. The targeted 2026 regular-session statutes-changed entries for Chapter 332A identify the previously reviewed accreditation-definition repeal and application amendment. They do not list an amendment to the fee or funds provisions examined here. That is a targeted regular-session index finding, not a fully consolidated October 2026 or all-later-session certificate. [C001; S011.] MN Revisor

The fee provision’s material enacted history was checked directly:

Authority Material point Effective/applicability finding
Laws 2007, chapter 57, article 3, §56 Enacted the relevant §332A.13 origination, maintenance, periodic-retention, advance-payment, consent and funds structure The section expressly became effective January 1, 2008.
Laws 2008, chapter 210, §8 Changed the trust-deposit language to funds being available, and added the limited separate disbursement-account route Section 10 makes §§1–9 effective the day following final enactment. The act was signed April 21, 2008; this change therefore took effect April 22, 2008.
Laws 2009, chapter 37, article 4 Relevant DMP definition, agreement and cancellation amendments were inspected as historical context The precise historical effective-date chain for these selected 2009 changes was not fully reconstructed. No particular 2009 date is asserted here.
Displayed current section bodies Supply the present wording used for the 2026 fictional models Subject to the stated compilation and later-amendment limits.

The 2009 limitation does not conceal an assumed date: the models use the retrieved current bodies, not a claim that a historical version governed a particular 2009 transaction. [C002–C003; S008–S010.] MN Revisor+3

B2. No DMP inflation adjustment established

The complete §332A.13 body contains no indexing formula for its $50 and $75 amounts. Commerce’s current July 1, 2026 Consumer Credit Code adjustment notice expressly concerns Chapter 56 and §47.59—not these DMP fee caps. It cannot be imported into Chapter 332A. No applicable DMP adjustment notice was located in the bounded search. [C004; S001, S017.] mn.gov // Minnesota's State Portal

Accordingly, the calculations below use the displayed $50 origination and $75 maintenance figures. No inflation calculation was invented.

Provider registration charges, renewal charges and bond costs are not additional consumer-fee categories established by this analysis. Their separate existence does not authorize passing them through as an extra debtor charge. [C013; S001, subdivision 3.]

C. State fee and funds rules applied together

C1. Classification and agreement prerequisites

Minnesota’s DMP definition focuses on receiving debtor funds and distributing periodic payments to creditors for full repayment of personal, family or household debt. Provider and delegated-service provisions, and holding oneself out as providing the service, also matter. A business cannot establish a noncustodial exclusion merely by having an associated processor receive the money. [C005–C006; S002, subdivisions 8–10, 12.] MN Revisor

A genuinely direct-creditor arrangement—where the consumer pays creditors without provider receipt or distribution—requires its own classification. It does not automatically inherit §332A.13’s fee permissions, and a concession-negotiation service may still meet the federal debt-relief definition even without provider custody.

Section 332A.10 requires the executed written agreement before DMP services or plan funds, together with the required pre-agreement assessment and disclosures. Fee amounts, services, anticipated charges, refund policy, cancellation terms and creditor participation are material to this ledger. [C007–C008; S003, subdivisions 1–3.] MN Revisor+1

C2. Joint fee calculation

For a periodic receipt PjP_jPj​, define:

  • OjO_jOj​: origination amount retained from that receipt;
  • MjM_jMj​: maintenance amount retained from that receipt;
  • MmonthM_{\text{month}}Mmonth​: total maintenance attributed to the month;
  • PmonthP_{\text{month}}Pmonth​: the relevant monthly payment amount under the agreement.

The combined textual constraints are:

Plain text

Total origination fee ≤ $50.

Monthly maintenance must be reasonable for the services provided, and:
M_month ≤ lesser of (15% × monthly payment amount) or $75.

For each periodic payment:
O_j + M_j + any other purported fee retention ≤ 15% × P_j.

Creditor allocation from that periodic payment:
P_j − lawful fee retention ≥ 85% × P_j.

This is a combined reading of subdivisions 1–4, not a statutory formula expressly printed in this notation. A lower contractual fee remains lower; unused statutory capacity is not automatically earned. [C009–C011; S001, S008.] MN Revisor+1

For weekly or biweekly schedules, the monthly maintenance ceiling is not a fresh $75 allowance for every installment. The provider must reconcile both the month and every individual receipt. The precise treatment of irregular months, unspecified monthly amounts, and a missed month’s possible contractual fee receivable requires the actual agreement and potentially additional interpretation. [C041–C042.]

C3. Charges that cannot be supplied by changing the label

The reviewed provisions do not establish separate provider charges for handling a late payment, returned payment, cancellation, statement, modification, or “enrollment donation.” Section 332A.14 also prohibits demanding or collecting a purported voluntary contribution from the debtor. A bank’s independently imposed charge is a different issue and is not converted into a provider surcharge by this report. [C013; S001, subdivision 3; S006, clauses (5), (7), (8), (16).] MN Revisor

The “recurring payments” no-fee rule has a specific listed subject matter: current living and support obligations such as rent, mortgage, utilities, telephone, child support and insurance. It should not be misread to mean that every recurring monthly DMP installment is fee-free. Conversely, handling current rent does not enlarge the fee-bearing DMP base merely because the same transfer also includes plan money. [C014; S001, subdivision 4.]

Additional or separate agreements do not authorize another origination charge. Modifications have their own signed-writing rule and limited exceptions; they do not create an unrestricted new fee. [C027; S003, subdivision 5.] MN Revisor

C4. Advance-payment restriction and exceptions

Agreement cadence or circumstance Operative treatment What it does not establish
Monthly payment Fee receipt/retention restricted when the debtor pays more than 42 days early That a payment 42 days early is automatically fee-earned
Biweekly payment Corresponding threshold: more than 15 days early A new monthly maintenance allowance for every receipt
Weekly payment Corresponding threshold: more than seven days early Permission to disregard creditor distribution deadlines
Agreement has no specified payment amounts Portion exceeding twice the average prior regular payment is deemed advance payment A defined average where no prior regular payments exist
Debtor intends the advance to satisfy contractual obligations due within 30 days Subdivision 5 does not apply to that circumstance Waiver of fee ceilings, reasonableness, other state duties or federal predicates

Subdivision 5 expressly overrides inconsistent provisions of the chapter. The restriction concerns fees for advance payments; it is not itself a complete rule about whether funds may be accepted, how long they may be held, or when creditors must receive them. [C015–C017; S001, subdivision 5; S008, article 3, §56.] MN Revisor+1

For an unspecified-amount agreement with previous regular payments of $100, $150 and $200:

Plain text

Average prior payment = ($100 + $150 + $200) ÷ 3 = $150.
Twice that average = $300.
New $400 payment: $100 is deemed advance payment.

That classification still needs the applicable date and 30-day-intent analysis. It is not a self-executing permission to charge on the entire $400.

C5. Custody, availability and creditor distribution use different clocks

The necessary trust rules require available payments to enter the separate trust account. Disbursements to the debtor, creditors and provider originate there, subject to the limited debtor/creditor disbursement-account route. The narrow minimum-bank-balance commingling allowance does not turn debtor funds into operating revenue. [C020; S001, subdivision 8; S009, §8.] MN Revisor+1

The distribution deadline is measured from receipt, not automatically restarted when funds become available: creditors must be paid within 42 days, or earlier where their agreement requires it. The statute contains specified longer-holding circumstances, including reasonable accumulation of a sum certain and a returned payment or another reason making withholding in the debtor’s net interest. These are factual exceptions, not a general 42-day float or permission to accumulate provider fees. [C021; S001, subdivision 9.]

A returned check may require both a provisional-credit reversal in the bank reconciliation and a separate debtor-ledger notation. It does not become a creditor payment. If no cash ever became available, the available-cash model below records zero receipt and separately records the failed attempt.

C6. Consent, insufficient payments and withdrawal

The provider must actively seek all creditor consent. Minnesota permits evidence of consent through acceptance of a plan payment as well as express writing. Failure to obtain consent has a ten-day notice requirement; withdrawal or refusal has a prompt-notice requirement with a fifteen-day outside limit. The notices include the specified cancellation information. Where both provisions potentially apply, a provider should not use the longer outside limit to disregard the shorter applicable requirement. [C018–C019; S001, subdivisions 6–7.] MN Revisor

A short payment does not make its full scheduled amount available. For example, if $100 is received against a $400 scheduled payment, the receipt-level retention ceiling is $15. Whether a maintenance receivable otherwise exists depends on the agreement, service and monthly-base interpretation; it is not established simply because the contract originally contemplated $400. [C011, C042.]

The statute does not supply a general instruction to stop paying creditors while a fee balance accumulates. The related prohibitions against encouraging or condoning stopped creditor payments and plans involving negative amortization remain relevant. [S006, clauses (3), (4), (9), (13).] MN Revisor+1

C7. Cancellation, termination and fee refunds

These events require different ledgers:

Event Custody treatment Treatment of prior fees
Debtor cancels without cause on ten days’ written notice Notify creditors and return unexpended funds within ten days of cancellation Ordinary cancellation does not itself establish return of every previously lawful fee
Provider cancels for good cause Thirty days’ written notice; creditor notice and unexpended-funds return within ten days after cancellation No immediate-forfeiture rule inferred from a missed installment
All listed debts and fees are paid Automatic termination; immediate return of unexpended funds No continued maintenance merely because a surplus remains
Material Chapter 332A violation followed by rescission Separate from ordinary cancellation Section 332A.17 requires return within ten days of fees paid to the provider or other noncreditors

The protection in §332A.13(6) for origination and previously earned fees is not treated as validating an originally unlawful charge or overriding the distinct material-violation rescission provision. Nor does this report invent a universal DMP “immediate excess-fee refund” rule borrowed from the settlement chapter. [C023–C026; S001, S004, S007.] MN Revisor+2

Monthly and cancellation/termination statements must distinguish receipts, creditor disbursements and deducted fees. The provider must maintain the relevant records for the statutory period. [C022; S005.] MN Revisor

D. Essential federal interaction—DMP-specific, not settlement-derived

D1. Coverage assumptions

The positive models below assume a nonexempt for-profit provider selling an unsecured consumer-debt concession DMP through a covered telephone campaign involving interstate calls. That fits the relevant federal debt-relief and telemarketing definitions on the stipulated facts, not merely because the service is called a DMP. [C028; S012.] eCFR

The following distinctions remain necessary:

Actual facts Consequence for this pass
Service represents that it will reduce interest, waive fees, or otherwise alter unsecured-debt terms Potential debt-relief service even where principal will be repaid in full
Pure payment processing with no represented alteration of debt terms Debt-relief coverage cannot be presumed from payment custody alone
Consumer responds to debt-relief advertising or direct mail The ordinary inbound advertising/direct-mail exemptions contain debt-relief carve-outs
Truly unsolicited call without prior solicitation The separate exemption and its conditions require examination
Qualifying face-to-face sales presentation Specific sequencing and residual-coverage rules apply; not a universal exemption
Provider claims nonprofit status Actual jurisdictional/entity facts must be established; neither universal TSR coverage nor exemption is assumed
No covered telephone campaign This pass does not apply the telemarketing rule solely because a website or DMP exists

These distinctions come from the freshly read definitions and exemptions. No actual provider’s nonprofit, institutional or other jurisdictional status was adjudicated. [C028–C029; S012, S014.] eCFR+1

D2. What the Commission specifically says about DMPs

The operative rule requires a qualifying alteration under a customer-executed agreement and a payment under that agreement. Its individual-debt allocation provision applies to the extent debts are altered individually. [C030; S013, §310.4(a)(5)(i).] eCFR

The Commission’s final-rule explanation addresses DMPs directly. At 75 FR 48489, section III.C.5(a), and footnote 431, it describes:

  • a customer-executed plan with altered terms binding the applicable creditors;
  • evidence of the consumer’s first payment to the credit-counseling agency for distribution to creditors;
  • a DMP model in which eligible debts are renegotiated together, rather than individually; and
  • subsequent periodic servicing fees after the qualifying enrollment and first payment.

Thus, that described DMP does not need to wait until all principal is repaid before any fee may be collected. [C031–C032; S015.] Federal Register+1

This is the Commission’s published explanation of its rule—not a Minnesota fee interpretation and not a blanket exception for any business using a DMP label. If creditors join at different times, terms are not binding, or debts are individually altered, the factual premise for the footnote’s treatment must be re-examined.

D3. Separate state and federal predicates

Proposed event Minnesota question Federal question for a covered DMP
Agree on a fee schedule Is it disclosed and within authorized categories and limits? Disclosure of a conditional fee is not a substitute for the payment predicates
Receive first plan funds Executed agreement, proper custody and advance-payment analysis Is there the qualifying executed, binding DMP described by the rule and Commission?
Transfer origination fee Initial-payment classification and collective retention limit Has the qualifying enrollment and first payment occurred?
Transfer monthly servicing fee Contract, reasonable services, monthly ceiling and receipt-level limit Is it a subsequent servicing charge within the described DMP structure?
Treat only one creditor as participating Consent, notification, feasibility and contract issues Do individual-debt allocation and timing requirements now matter?
Debit a bank account Entitlement and custody must still be lawful Applicable express informed consent to the charge and identified account is separately required

No federal predicate increases Minnesota’s dollar ceiling, creates a state fee category, or supplies an exception to the periodic-retention restriction. [C030–C034.] eCFR+1

D4. Account accumulation is not the same as ordinary DMP distribution

The dedicated-account provision has insurance, consumer ownership, administrator independence, referral-compensation and withdrawal/return conditions. A provider-controlled Minnesota trust account is not automatically the independent account contemplated by that federal provision. [C033; S013, §310.4(a)(5)(ii).] eCFR

The models do not use a pre-trigger savings account to pay an advance fee. They assume a binding DMP before the first scheduled plan payment and postpone fee transfers until after the qualifying event. The specific federal treatment of an alternative pre-trigger custody arrangement remains held.

The models also use consumer-initiated payments, not a claim that an automatic debit arrangement has been approved. Other payment-rail or bank-account rules remain outside this limited review. CROA and TSR credit-repair applicability remain separate boundaries if actual representations make them relevant.

E. Actor-and-event decision table

Actor/event Required factual record Proper ledger treatment What cannot be inferred
Provider conducts pre-agreement assessment Counseling, financial analysis, proposed plan, affordability and creditor information Pre-agreement work is separately identified An independent “consultation” or “enrollment” fee is authorized
Debtor and provider execute agreement Signed terms, cadence, gross payment, fee schedule, creditor allocations, refund provisions Establish contractual obligations—not cash receipt Every disclosed fee is immediately collectible
Debtor authorizes a bank payment Amount, purpose and applicable consent Authorization record separate from entitlement Authorization cures an excessive or premature fee
Bank receives a check or transfer instruction Pending/cleared/available status and any reversal Pending instruments separately reconciled A pending or returned item funded creditors
Provider receives available plan money Trust receipt with debtor-specific allocation Custody asset and corresponding debtor-funds responsibility Entire receipt is provider revenue
Provider proposes origination deduction Initial-payment classification, lawful amount, joint retention calculation, federal trigger where applicable Fee transfer only when predicates are met “Nonrefundable” defeats every cancellation or violation remedy
Provider proposes maintenance deduction Services, contract, monthly total, each receipt’s retention capacity Separate monthly and per-receipt checks $75 is available for each weekly payment
Creditor accepts a payment Creditor credit date, amount and allocation Reduce the creditor balance by the amount actually credited Provider receipt itself reduced the debt
Creditor refuses or withdraws Date learned, affected payment, required notices Revise projections and preserve funds accurately Immediate additional fees or automatic cancellation
Debtor misses or underpays Actual available cash, contract treatment and creditor consequences No fictitious receipt; no fictitious creditor credit A scheduled amount is cash, or late charges are authorized
Debtor cancels Notice, effective date, unexpended funds, prior lawful fees Separate custody return from fee-refund analysis All old fees are refundable—or all are protected
Provider cancels Good cause and thirty-day notice Required creditor notice and return following cancellation One failed payment permits immediate forfeiture
Plan completes All listed debts and lawful fees paid Immediate surplus return Surplus may be retained for future maintenance
Material violation is rescinded Violation and rescission facts Separate return of qualifying prior fees Ordinary cancellation and statutory rescission are identical

These are evidence and accounting tests derived from the cited provisions, not a complete account-control or compliance manual. [C007–C035.] MN Revisor+4

F. Fourteen fresh fictional postures

All are hypothetical. None concerns an actual provider or debtor.

Posture Facts Result or exact hold
P01 — Nominal pre-agreement payment Provider requests $10 to “open the plan” before an executed agreement No established authority to accept it as plan money or a third fee category.
P02 — First $300 periodic payment Proposed $50 origination and $45 maintenance Aggregate $95 retention is unsupported; see M01.
P03 — First $1,000 periodic payment $50 origination and $75 reasonable maintenance; all other predicates met Both fit the individual and collective numerical constraints; see M02.
P04 — Separate $50 payment Described as fee-only, in addition to $300 monthly plan money Classification remains held. A pre-trigger fee also fails the modeled federal timing condition; see M03.
P05 — Four weekly receipts Four $200 payments in one month; provider takes $25 each Each $25 is below $30, but $100 monthly maintenance exceeds $75. A different $18.75-per-receipt schedule totals $75, subject to services and contract.
P06 — Monthly receipt 43 days early No obligation within 30 days is identified Subdivision 5 bars the related fee receipt/retention. Custody and distribution still require separate analysis.
P07 — Biweekly receipt 16 days early No applicable 30-day exception Same restriction; the threshold is more than fifteen days. Exactly fifteen days does not itself establish earning.
P08 — Weekly receipt eight days early Debtor documents intent to satisfy a contractual obligation due within thirty days The subdivision 5 exception may apply; other caps and predicates remain.
P09 — Variable payments Prior regular payments $100/$150/$200; new payment $400 $100 is deemed advance. Missing due-date or intent facts remain material. No prior-payment history would leave the average unresolved.
P10 — Rent plus DMP money Transfer includes $500 current rent and $300 DMP payment Do not charge a handling fee on rent or use it merely to enlarge the fee-bearing DMP base.
P11 — Direct-creditor payments Consumer pays creditors directly; provider only advises Provider-custody ledger is zero for those payments. Minnesota classification and possible federal debt-relief coverage require the actual service/representation facts.
P12 — Partial scheduled payment $100 received against a $400 schedule; provider wants $30 $30 exceeds the $15 receipt-retention limit even before resolving monthly-base and earning questions.
P13 — Returned payment $400 payment fails before cash becomes available Record the failed transaction; do not record $400 of available funds or creditor reduction. No separate provider NSF fee was established.
P14 — Cancel or finish Debtor cancels, provider cancels for cause, or all debts and fees are paid Apply the appropriate notice and return rule; these events do not share one universal deadline or fee-refund outcome.

Authorities: C007, C009–C027, C028–C034, C041–C042. The numerical comparisons are original calculations; their legal conditions remain those stated above.

G. Fully worked joint funds models

Common assumptions and accounting convention

These are conditional demonstrations, not approvals.

For positive branches, assume a legally eligible registrant; a valid written agreement; required assessment and disclosures; reasonable actual services; unsecured consumer debts; customer-executed concessions binding both creditors before the first receipt; a covered for-profit interstate telephone-sales campaign; and no applicable exemption.

For transparent debt arithmetic, creditors agree to 0% interest and no additional charges during the illustrated period. This is a fictional contract fact, not a prediction. Real creditor balances must incorporate actual interest, charges and application of payments.

All positive cash receipts are consumer-initiated and available on the stated date. No automatic-debit compliance is assumed. Fee transfers occur after the federal DMP trigger; maintenance is transferred after the modeled services.

Plain text

Opening custody
+ available receipts
− lawful provider-fee transfers
− creditor payments
− returns to debtor
= closing custody.

Creditor debt balances are calculated separately. A provider fee or debtor refund is never also counted as a creditor payment.

All selected amounts calculate exactly to cents. No statutory cent-rounding method was located. These examples do not round a fee upward beyond a computed ceiling.

M01 — The $300 adversarial test and a different, conditionally compliant contract

Inputs

  • Debts: A $2,000; B $4,000; total $6,000.
  • Agreement executed September 7, 2026.
  • Gross plan payment: $300 monthly, due on the tenth.
  • Creditor payments due on the fifteenth.
  • Creditor allocation: one-third to A, two-thirds to B.
  • Opening custody: $0.

Rejected proposal: $50 plus $45

Plain text

Maintenance ceiling:
min(15% × $300, $75) = min($45, $75) = $45.

All-fee retention ceiling for this periodic payment:
15% × $300 = $45.

Proposed fees:
$50 + $45 = $95.

Retention percentage:
$95 ÷ $300 × 100 = 31.6667%.

Proposed creditor remainder:
$300 − $95 = $205.

Minimum creditor allocation under the 15% restriction:
$300 − $45 = $255.

Difference:
$255 − $205 = $50.

Even taking only the full $50 origination from this ordinary $300 periodic payment exceeds the $45 collective retention ceiling. The independent $50 allowance has not been shown to override that ceiling. [C037.]

Alternative branch—not a retroactive cure

A separately stipulated agreement instead sets origination at $30 and monthly maintenance at $15. There is no additional $20 origination receivable.

Date/event Receipts Fee transfer Creditor payment Debtor return Closing custody
September 10: available plan payment $300.00 — — — $300.00
September 12: A receives $85; B receives $170 — — $255.00 — $45.00
September 13: lawful origination transfer assumed — $30.00 — — $15.00
September 30: reasonable maintenance services completed — $15.00 — — $0.00

Plain text

Cash:
$0 + $300 − $45 − $255 − $0 = $0.

Monthly maintenance:
$15 ≤ $45.

Combined fee retention:
($30 + $15) ÷ $300 = 15%.

Creditor balances:
A: $2,000 − $85 = $1,915.
B: $4,000 − $170 = $3,830.
Total: $5,745.

Before September 30, the remaining $15 is still custody money awaiting the modeled lawful fee transfer—not already spent revenue. After completion, closing custody and presently unearned held fees are zero.

Result: The original $95 proposal is not supported. The different $45-total contract is numerically and conditionally reconcilable; reasonableness and the other assumed predicates are not established for any actual provider.

M02 — Both maximum component fees fit a larger initial periodic payment

Inputs

  • Debts: A $4,000; B $6,000.
  • Agreement executed September 1, 2026.
  • Gross monthly payment: $1,000, due on the fifth.
  • Creditor payments due on the fifteenth.
  • Origination $50; reasonable monthly maintenance $75.
  • Creditor allocation: 40% to A, 60% to B.

Plain text

Maintenance ceiling:
min(15% × $1,000, $75) = $75.

All-fee retention ceiling:
15% × $1,000 = $150.

Actual first-cycle fee total:
$50 + $75 = $125.

Retention percentage:
$125 ÷ $1,000 = 12.5%.

Creditor remainder:
$1,000 − $125 = $875.

Minimum creditor amount:
85% × $1,000 = $850.

Actual creditor amount exceeds that minimum by $25.
Date/event Receipts Fee transfer Creditor payment Debtor return Closing custody
September 5: plan payment $1,000.00 — — — $1,000.00
September 8: A $350; B $525 — — $875.00 — $125.00
September 9: origination — $50.00 — — $75.00
September 30: maintenance — $75.00 — — $0.00

Plain text

Cash:
$0 + $1,000 − $125 − $875 − $0 = $0.

Creditor balances:
A: $4,000 − $350 = $3,650.
B: $6,000 − $525 = $5,475.
Total: $9,125.

The unused $25 of retention capacity is not another fee allowance. It remains part of the creditor allocation. No second origination fee is assumed for a later payment.

Result: This provides an initial-payment fact pattern permitting both component fees without needing an exception to the periodic-retention rule. It does not establish that $75 is reasonable for every provider’s services. [C038.]

M03 — Separate fee-only candidate: accounting balance does not establish legality

Inputs and disputed alternatives

  • Debts: A $2,000; B $4,000.
  • Scheduled monthly plan payment: $300.
  • Reasonable maintenance: $45.
  • Proposed additional origination payment: $50.

Candidate A: Collect $50 before the qualifying DMP enrollment/first-payment event. The modeled federal rule does not permit this merely because it is called origination.

Candidate B: Collect $50 separately after the qualifying event. Federal timing may no longer be the obstacle, but Minnesota classification remains unresolved.

If the two amounts are one $350 periodic payment in substance:

Plain text

15% × $350 = $52.50 maximum collective retention.
Proposed $50 + $45 = $95.
Difference = $42.50.

If the $50 is genuinely nonperiodic, the statute’s separate-initial-payment interpretation must be established rather than assumed.

The following equation can balance physically while remaining legally unsupported:

Plain text

$0 + $350 − $95 − $255 = $0.

That is why bank reconciliation alone cannot validate the fee.

Demonstrated no-origination path

For this actual hypothetical ledger, the agreement waives origination. The consumer mistakenly sends an additional $50, which is never treated as earned and is returned.

Date/event Receipts Fee transfer Creditor payment Debtor return Closing custody
September 10: scheduled payment $300.00 — — — $300.00
September 11: mistaken extra payment $50.00 — — — $350.00
September 12: A $85; B $170 — — $255.00 — $95.00
September 13: extra $50 returned — — — $50.00 $45.00
September 30: maintenance — $45.00 — — $0.00

Plain text

Cash:
$0 + $350 − $45 − $255 − $50 = $0.

Creditor balances:
A = $1,915.
B = $3,830.
Total = $5,745.

The $50 return does not reduce creditor debt and is not counted as a provider-fee refund because the model never treats it as a fee. Its return follows the stipulated waiver and mistaken-payment facts; it is not a holding that every separately paid origination fee must be refunded.

Result: A lawful-looking cash balance does not resolve the separate-fee theory. The demonstrated branch avoids that unresolved theory rather than approving it. [C039.]

M04 — Missed payment, partial receipt and cancellation

Inputs

  • Debts: A $3,000; B $5,000.
  • Agreement executed July 1, 2026.
  • Gross payment $400 monthly, due on the fifth.
  • Creditor payment due on the fifteenth.
  • Origination waived.
  • Maintenance $30 for a funded cycle, expressly waived by the contract for a missed or underfunded cycle.
  • Creditors allocate payments 37.5% to A and 62.5% to B.
  • For this illustration only, creditors preserve the zero-interest/no-extra-charge terms during the missed-payment interval.

The maintenance waiver is a contractual fact—not a universal statutory requirement.

July: funded cycle

Plain text

Maintenance ceiling = min(15% × $400, $75) = $60.
Contractual maintenance = $30.
Receipt retention = $30 ÷ $400 = 7.5%.
Creditor distribution = $370.

A receives $138.75; B receives $231.25.

August: failed payment

The attempted $400 payment is returned before funds become available. It is recorded as a failed transaction, not a $400 available-cash receipt. If a bank statement had shown provisional credit, the bank reconciliation would also show its reversal.

September: partial receipt and cancellation

The debtor gives written notice August 31. September 10 is stipulated as the effective cancellation date; this is not a legal notice-service computation.

A $100 partial payment becomes available September 5. The contractual underfunded-cycle fee waiver applies. The next creditor due date is September 15. The $100 is returned September 12, with creditor notification and a closing statement.

Period/event Receipts Fee transfers Creditor payments Debtor returns Closing custody
July 5 receipt $400.00 — — — $400.00
July 8 creditor distributions — — $370.00 — $30.00
July 31 maintenance — $30.00 — — $0.00
August failed payment $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
September 5 partial receipt $100.00 — — — $100.00
September 12 cancellation return — $0.00 $0.00 $100.00 $0.00

Plain text

Combined cash:
$0 + $500 − $30 − $370 − $100 = $0.

Creditor balances:
A: $3,000 − $138.75 = $2,861.25.
B: $5,000 − $231.25 = $4,768.75.
Total = $7,630.

The attempted August payment does not reduce debt. The September return does not reduce debt. Missed installments are not added a second time as new principal.

Ordinary cancellation does not automatically require repayment of the assumed-lawful July $30 fee. If a material violation and statutory rescission were separately established, the fee-return analysis would change; the $30 would be a provider-fee return, not another creditor payment. The main model does not assume such a violation.

Result: Closing custody is zero; creditor debt remains $7,630; no unearned funds remain held; no missed-cycle fee receivable exists because the stipulated contract waived it. [C040.]

H. Concise effect crosswalk to P01

Original example Preserved arithmetic PASS-06 legal effect
E05: $300 monthly payment $45 maintenance ceiling and $255 remainder Preserved. It did not authorize adding a full $50 origination deduction to the same ordinary periodic receipt. M01 supplies the joint test; the separate-fee theory remains held.
E06: $800 monthly payment Maintenance ceiling $75; remainder $725; retention 9.375% Preserved. Adding $50 would create $125 total retention against a $120 receipt-level ceiling. That addition is not approved merely because each component separately fits its own maximum.

No original example, source-access date or reviewed record is rewritten. [C043–C044.]

I. Source register

Access convention: All “fresh” entries below were accessed during this October 27, 2026 research session. Individual fetch timestamps were not exposed and are not invented. Statutory sections within one chapter are separate retrieved bodies, not independent corroborating legal systems.

Source ID Issuer, complete literal HTTPS URL Actual read scope and operative pinpoint Version/effect and limitations
S_MN-P06-S001 Minnesota Revisor, §332A.13. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.13 Fresh complete read: subdivisions 1–9 and history. Displayed 2025 text. Core fee, advance, consent and funds authority. MN Revisor+1
S_MN-P06-S002 Minnesota Revisor, §332A.02. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.02 Fresh targeted read: subdivisions 5a–10 and 12; relevant provider/delegation/holding-out language and warning. 2025 display with accreditation warning. Exemption categories not rerun. MN Revisor+1
S_MN-P06-S003 Minnesota Revisor, §332A.10. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.10 Fresh complete operative read: subdivisions 1–5; relied on agreement prerequisites, assessment, fee/refund disclosures and modification rules. 2025 display. No full contract-compliance approval. MN Revisor+1
S_MN-P06-S004 Minnesota Revisor, §332A.11. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.11 Fresh complete read: subdivisions 1–4 and history. Debtor/provider cancellation and automatic termination. MN Revisor
S_MN-P06-S005 Minnesota Revisor, §332A.12. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.12 Fresh operative read: subdivisions 1, 1a and 2; relied on records, monthly/final statements and access. Annual regulatory reporting not developed beyond the read. MN Revisor
S_MN-P06-S006 Minnesota Revisor, §332A.14. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.14 Fresh operative body read: relied particularly on clauses (3)–(5), (7)–(10), (12), (13), (16). Necessary fee/payment prohibitions only; not a complete conduct dossier. MN Revisor+1
S_MN-P06-S007 Minnesota Revisor, §332A.17. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.17 Fresh complete operative read: material-violation rescission paragraph and history. Distinguishes rescission from ordinary cancellation. MN Revisor
S_MN-P06-S008 Minnesota Legislature/Revisor, Laws 2007, chapter 57. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/laws/2007/0/57/ Fresh targeted enacted read: article 3, §56, including its effective-date clause; relevant surrounding agreement/cancellation/records/rescission provisions inspected. §56 expressly effective January 1, 2008. An initial history-link route failed; the direct act route succeeded. Not a full-act sequential read. MN Revisor
S_MN-P06-S009 Minnesota Legislature/Revisor, Laws 2008, chapter 210. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/laws/2008/0/210/ Fresh targeted enacted read: §§6, 8, 10 and signature. §8 custody change effective April 22, 2008 under §10 and April 21 signature. MN Revisor+1
S_MN-P06-S010 Minnesota Legislature/Revisor, Laws 2009, chapter 37. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/laws/2009/0/37/ Fresh targeted historical read: article 4, relevant definition changes and §§15–16; end signature inspected. Signed May 7, 2009. Exact effective-date chain for the selected historical amendments not completed; signature not substituted for effectiveness. MN Revisor+1
S_MN-P06-S011 Minnesota Revisor, 2026 statutes-changed Table 2. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/2026/table2?full=&page=5&per_page=500&year=2026 Fresh index read: relevant Chapter 332A entries, parsed lines 305–306 and surrounding entries. Regular-session index; not a complete later/special-session certification. MN Revisor
S_MN-P06-S012 OFR/eCFR, 16 CFR §310.2. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.2 Fresh relevant operative definitions: customer, debt relief, person, seller, telemarketer and telemarketing; paragraphs (n), (o), (y), (ee), (hh), (ii). Retrieved eCFR display current through October 23, 2026. Title-level amendment metadata is not attributed to this particular provision. eCFR
S_MN-P06-S013 OFR/eCFR, 16 CFR §310.4. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.4 Fresh complete relevant passages: (a)(5)(i)(A)–(C), (ii)(A)–(E), and applicable (a)(7) consent provisions. Same eCFR version limit. Credit-repair requirements not analyzed as applicable. eCFR
S_MN-P06-S014 OFR/eCFR, 16 CFR §310.6. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.6 Fresh operative exemptions read, particularly (b)(3)–(7) and their exceptions. Coverage depends on actual actor/campaign facts. eCFR
S_MN-P06-S015 FTC, final TSR amendments, 75 FR 48458. HTML: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2010/08/10/2010-19412/telemarketing-sales-rule Official PDF: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2010-08-10/pdf/2010-19412.pdf Fresh targeted Commission explanation: III.C.5(a), printed page 48489, especially footnote 431; related timing/account discussion. Official PDF pages 31–32, printed pages 48489–48490, visually inspected. One underlying final-rule document, not two independent authorities. Published August 10, 2010; (a)(5) effective October 27, 2010. Preamble interpretation is distinguished from current regulatory text. Federal Register+3
S_MN-P06-S016 FTC, business compliance guide. https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/debt-relief-services-telemarketing-sales-rule-guide-business Fresh limited read: DMP coverage, initial-fee evidence and entity qualifications. Staff guidance, not binding Commission interpretation. Historical record-retention advice was not imported as current law. Federal Trade Commission
S_MN-P06-S017 Minnesota Commerce, Consumer Credit Code Adjustments. https://mn.gov/commerce/money/industry/interest-rates/consumer-credit-code/ Fresh body read: 2026 adjustment authority and covered statutes, lines 19–44. Effective July 1, 2026 notice concerns Chapter 56 and §47.59, not §332A.13. mn.gov // Minnesota's State Portal

Interpretation search and unsuccessful/discovery routes

The bounded search used the exact statute and combinations including:

"332A.13" "origination" "periodic" court "332A.13" "initial" "fee" interpretation "332A.13" site:mncourts.gov "332A.13" site:mn.gov/commerce "332A.13" site:revisor.mn.gov/rules "332A.13" "opinion" "332A" "fee" "inflation" site:mn.gov

No responsive published judicial-majority opinion or binding agency interpretation was located and opened resolving the separate-initial-fee classification or supplying an exception to the periodic-retention limit. Some searches returned irrelevant material; those results are not evidence of nonexistence.

No unpublished opinion, party argument, headnote or search snippet is used as law. No operative administrative rule was relied upon without its body being read. The missing interpretation is a research gap, not an identified inaccessible decision whose contents are presumed.

P01 E05/E06 and the coordinator’s review history are supplied historical context, not fresh public-source readings. P02/P04 operational and registration conclusions were not used to establish fee earning.

J. Atomic claim register

“High—text” means the retrieved wording directly supports the claim, within the source-version limits. “Conditional” means application depends on stipulated or missing facts. “Held” identifies an unresolved interpretation.

Claim Precise actor/predicate/effect Authority and pinpoint Confidence, exceptions and limits
C001 Retrieved Minnesota bodies are 2025 displays; targeted 2026 index entries do not identify a fee-section change S001–S007; S011 Chapter 332A entries High as version/index finding; no all-later-law certificate
C002 The relevant original §332A.13 enactment became effective January 1, 2008 S008, article 3, §56 effective-date clause High—enacted text
C003 The 2008 funds-availability/disbursement-account amendment became effective April 22, 2008 S009, §§8, 10 and signature High—express chain
C004 No indexing authority appears in §332A.13; the retrieved 2026 adjustment notice covers different statutes S001 complete body; S017 lines 19–44 High for these bodies; not proof that every possible notice was searched
C005 DMP classification principally involves provider receipt/distribution for full repayment of consumer-purpose debt S002, subdivision 9 High—text; actual service facts necessary
C006 Delegation and holding out matter; a direct-payment label does not conclusively resolve classification S002, subdivisions 8–10, 12 Conditional application
C007 Executed agreement and prescribed pre-agreement steps precede covered services/plan money S003, subdivisions 1–2 High—text
C008 Agreement must disclose fees, services, anticipated charges, refund and cancellation terms S003, subdivision 3 High—text; actual agreement not supplied
C009 Registrant may charge an origination fee not exceeding $50 from the initial amount S001, subdivision 1 High—text; other restrictions still apply
C010 Maintenance must be reasonable and no greater than the lesser of 15% monthly payment or $75 S001, subdivision 2 High—text; monthly-base and service facts matter
C011 Combined fee retention from any periodic payment is limited to 15%; creditor allocation must respect the remainder S001, subdivision 4; S008, §56 High—text; initial-periodic application is the stated combined reading, not a located holding
C012 A genuinely separate fee-only initial payment is not resolved by the retrieved definitions or an opened controlling interpretation S001–S003; bounded search Held; no approval by invoice/debit label
C013 Other provider charges and debtor “voluntary contributions” lack authority under the relied-on provisions S001, subdivision 3; S006, clause (16) High—text; bank-imposed charges and broader remedies not decided
C014 Handling the listed recurring living/support payments cannot generate provider handling fees S001, subdivision 4 High—text; additional rule-prescribed categories not exhaustively investigated
C015 Fee receipt/retention is restricted for payments more than 42/15/7 days early under monthly/biweekly/weekly schedules S001, subdivision 5 High—text; 30-day exception remains
C016 For unspecified amounts, excess over twice the prior regular-payment average is deemed advance S001, subdivision 5 High—text; no-history computation unresolved
C017 Debtor intent to satisfy contractual obligations due within thirty days removes subdivision 5’s restriction S001, subdivision 5 High—text; not a waiver of all other restrictions
C018 Provider must seek creditor consent; failure invokes the specified ten-day notice/cancellation-right requirement S001, subdivision 6 High—text; acceptance of payment may evidence consent
C019 Creditor withdrawal/refusal invokes prompt notice, no later than fifteen days after learning of it S001, subdivision 7 High—text; does not displace a separately applicable shorter requirement
C020 Available payments belong in the separate trust process; statutory routing and narrow commingling exception apply S001, subdivision 8; S009, §8 High—text; full trust-control compliance deferred
C021 Creditor disbursement runs from receipt, within42 days or earlier creditor due date, subject to stated exceptions S001, subdivision 9 High—text; factual exception required
C022 Provider must maintain records and provide monthly and cancellation/termination accounting of receipts, payments and fees S005, subdivisions 1–2 High—text
C023 Debtor cancellation uses ten days’ written notice and a ten-day post-cancellation unexpended-funds/creditor-notice duty S004, subdivision 1 High—text; effective notice date fact-dependent
C024 Provider good-cause cancellation requires thirty days’ notice; completed plans automatically terminate with immediate surplus return S004, subdivisions 3–4 High—text
C025 Ordinary cancellation/default does not by itself require return of lawful origination and prior earned fees S001, subdivision 6; S004 High as limited rule; does not validate unlawful fees or decide all earning facts
C026 Material-violation rescission requires qualifying noncreditor fee returns within ten days S007, operative paragraph High—text; actual violation and rescission required
C027 Additional agreements do not authorize another origination fee; modifications follow specified writing/exception rules S003, subdivision 5 High—text; no fee-reset workaround
C028 TSR coverage requires the defined actor, service and telephone-campaign predicates S012, (n), (o), (y), (ee), (hh), (ii) High—text; modeled facts assumed
C029 Inbound, unsolicited and face-to-face exemptions have distinct conditions; nonprofit status is not resolved by a label S014, (b)(3)–(7); S015–S016 limited explanation Conditional; actual entity jurisdiction deferred
C030 Covered debt-relief fee collection requires the operative result/agreement/payment predicates and applicable individual-debt allocation S013, (a)(5)(i) High—text
C031 Commission DMP explanation recognizes a binding customer-executed DMP and first payment to the counseling agency for creditors S015, III.C.5(a), 75 FR48489 Strong federal interpretive evidence; not Minnesota construction
C032 Under the described jointly renegotiated DMP, individual-debt allocation does not apply and later servicing fees may be collected S015, footnote431 Conditional on that factual model; not every DMP label
C033 Federal dedicated-account conditions are not established merely by a provider-controlled Minnesota trust account S013, (a)(5)(ii) High text plus conditional application
C034 Billing authorization is separately required; it does not cure fee entitlement defects S013, (a)(7) High—text; other payment-rail law deferred
C035 Receipt, fee transfer, creditor credit and debtor return must be separately accounted for S001, subdivisions 8–9; S005, subdivision 2 Analytical consequence; actual creditor posting needed
C036 No responsive opened majority opinion or binding agency construction resolved the initial-fee exception issue Search record Bounded search finding, not nonexistence
C037 M01’s proposed $95 retention exceeds the $45 limit; the different $30+$15 contract reconciles conditionally M01; C009–C011 Verified arithmetic; hypothetical legal assumptions
C038 M02’s $125 from $1,000 satisfies the joint numerical constraints M02; C009–C011 Verified arithmetic; reasonableness/timing assumed
C039 M03 demonstrates that a zero cash balance can coexist with an unsupported separate-fee theory M03; C012, C030–C034 Conditional; demonstrated branch waives origination
C040 M04 separates failed receipts, lawful fees, creditor payments and cancellation returns M04; C020–C026 Verified ledger; contract waivers and creditor concessions stipulated
C041 Weekly/biweekly receipts must satisfy both per-receipt retention and the monthly maintenance ceiling C010–C011; P05 Combined reading; irregular-month details held
C042 Underpayment limits current retention by the actual periodic receipt; missed-cycle fee earning is not automatic C010–C011, C015–C017; P12–P13 Conditional; actual contract/service/base required
C043 P01 E05 arithmetic survives, but does not establish $95 retention from $300 Supplied P01 E05; C037 Historical reuse plus fresh application
C044 P01 E06 arithmetic survives; adding $50 would exceed the $800 payment’s $120 retention limit Supplied P01 E06; C011 Historical reuse plus arithmetic
C045 No actual provider, account, claimant, contract, broader-state or A066 approval follows Scope and evidence limits Express limitation

K. Granular coverage and remaining evidence

Subissue Status Claims/models Exact missing evidence or next action
Complete §332A.13 operative body Answered C009–C021 All subdivisions read; interpretation gaps separately retained
Relevant DMP/debtor/provider/creditor definitions Answered textually C005–C006 Actual service and delegation facts
Initial/periodic/monthly/earned definitions Partial C012, C025, C042 Responsive authority or actual contract where statutory terms are not expressly defined
$50 origination ceiling Answered C009 Actual agreement and lawful timing
Maintenance ceiling and reasonableness Answered textually C010 Evidence of actual services and reasonableness
Combined first-periodic-payment retention Answered as combined textual reading C011, M01–M02 No located controlling contrary/confirming construction
Genuine separate fee-only payment Unresolved C012, M03 Published majority opinion or binding agency interpretation addressing classification
Split debit/relabeling theory No authority established C012 Actual legal basis; operational labels alone insufficient
Nominal enrollment/application charge Answered narrowly C007, C013, P01 No third consumer-fee category established
Registration/bond costs versus consumer fees Answered boundary C013 Registration/bond compliance itself deferred
Inflation/indexing Answered for read authorities C004 No applicable DMP notice found; broader notice sweep not certified
2007 fee enactment/effective date Answered C002 None within the stated provision
2008 funds amendment/effective date Answered C003 None within the stated provision
Selected 2009 historical effective-date chain Partial S010 Complete applicable general/specific date analysis; no guessed date used
Current 2026 regular-session check Answered narrowly C001 Complete later/special-session consolidation remains separate
Written agreement and disclosures Answered for ledger purposes C007–C008 Actual executed agreement and assessment records
Extra origination/modification fees Answered C027 Actual modification facts and applicable limited exception
Monthly advance threshold Answered C015, P06 Actual agreement due date
Biweekly advance threshold Answered C015, P07 Same
Weekly advance threshold Answered C015, P08 Same
Variable-payment calculation Answered with boundary C016, P09 Date/intent facts; no-history average unresolved
Thirty-day obligation exception Answered conditionally C017 Evidence of debtor intent and contractual obligation
Weekly/biweekly monthly aggregation Answered in principle C041, P05 Actual monthly base and irregular-month treatment
Recurring living-expense handling Answered for statutory list C014, P10 Any additional commissioner-rule categories not exhaustively reviewed
Custody receipt versus fee earning Answered analytically C020, C035 Actual transaction and subledger records
Availability versus receipt clocks Answered C020–C021 Actual receipt/availability dates and any return
Trust-to-provider/creditor/debtor routing Answered narrowly C020 Full trust controls and bank documentation deferred
Creditor distribution deadline Answered C021 Creditor due dates and actual credits
Accumulation/returned-payment exceptions Answered textually C021 Fact-specific reasonable/net-interest evidence
Creditor consent Answered C018 Actual binding concessions and consent evidence
Withdrawal/refusal notice Answered C019 Date learned and notices
Direct-creditor/noncustodial branch Partial C006, P11 Actual service, representations, delegation and control
Insufficient payment Partial application C042, P12 Contractual monthly-base and earning facts
Late/missed/NSF payment Answered for modeled facts P13, M04 Real creditor consequences and bank reconciliation
Monthly/final accounting Answered C022 Actual statements not supplied
Ordinary debtor cancellation Answered C023, C025 Actual notice/effective date and lawful prior fees
Provider cancellation Answered C024 Good cause and thirty-day notice
Automatic termination Answered C024 Proof all listed debts and lawful fees paid
Material-violation rescission Answered narrowly C026 Actual material violation and exercise of rescission
Federal actor/service/telephone coverage Answered conditionally C028–C029 Actual entity and campaign facts
Federal DMP first-fee trigger Answered for described DMP C030–C032 Executed binding plan and qualifying first payment
DMP subsequent servicing fees Answered federally, state limits separate C032 Actual service/contract/state compliance
Staggered creditor participation Unresolved application C030–C032 Whether individual-debt treatment applies and corresponding records
Pre-trigger dedicated account Partial C033 Actual ownership, administration, independence and account terms
Bank-debit authorization Answered narrowly C034 Actual consent; other payment-rail requirements deferred
P01 nominal enrollment posture Completed P01 Hypothetical only
P02–P04 initial-payment postures Completed with separate-fee hold P02–P04 M01–M03 specify assumptions
P05 cadence posture Completed P05 Irregular-month interpretation remains open
P06–P09 advance-payment postures Completed conditionally P06–P09 Date/intent/history facts stated or held
P10–P11 living-expense/direct-pay postures Completed with classification limits P10–P11 Actual service/account facts
P12–P14 shortage/failure/exit postures Completed P12–P14 Real contract and creditor facts
M01 $300 adversarial joint ledger Completed C037 Not actual fee approval
M02 larger initial joint ledger Completed conditionally C038 Reasonableness and other assumptions essential
M03 separate-fee candidate Completed; authority held C039 Responsive classification authority
M04 missed-payment/cancellation ledger Completed conditionally C040 Waivers/concessions are stipulated, not universal
P01 E05 crosswalk Completed C043 Original preserved
P01 E06 crosswalk Completed C044 Original preserved
Responsive judicial/administrative interpretation Not located in bounded search C036 Further official published-opinion/Commerce-order research on exact issue
P05 settlement-performance component Excluded; not a premise C045 Separate review remains separate
NMLS/current provider status/2026 transition Deferred/preserved C045 P02/P04 holds unchanged
Full trust/bond compliance Deferred C045 Account-control, bond and broader supervision component
Nonprofit/attorney registration and exemptions Deferred C045 Actual entity/activity qualification
CROA and broader federal credit repair Deferred boundary C045 Actual representations and separate operative review
Collection/litigation/wage/bank/other property Deferred C045 Separate parent-state components
Sector/local/tribal and remaining state dimensions Deferred C045 No completion or acceptance by implication

L. Researcher self-check and final disposition

Actually read: The complete §332A.13 body; necessary Chapter 332A definitions, agreement, cancellation, records, prohibitions and rescission provisions; the material 2007 and 2008 fee/funds enactments; selected 2009 historical amendments; targeted 2026 index entries; the current Commerce adjustment notice; fresh operative federal definitions, debt-relief fee/account conditions and exemptions; and the Commission’s DMP-specific final-rule explanation. The relevant official Federal Register PDF pages were visually inspected.

Not established: A controlling Minnesota interpretation approving a genuinely separate fee-only initial payment, an exception allowing $95 from a $300 ordinary periodic payment, a universal definition of maintenance earning in missed or irregular months, a complete historical 2009 date chain, or exhaustive later-law/rule/case coverage. No actual contract, account or provider record was supplied or examined.

The ledgers distinguish available custody cash, fee transfers, creditor credits and debtor returns. Their calculations were checked; their legal assumptions remain explicit. No local artifact or publication is claimed.

Bottom line: Both origination and maintenance can fit within one initial periodic payment when the combined retention limit is respected. The $1,000 model demonstrates that without inventing an exception. The $300/$95 proposal does not. A separate fee-only transfer remains an unresolved legal classification, not an accounting workaround. Federal DMP timing must be tested on the DMP’s actual structure, while Minnesota’s fee, custody, distribution and cancellation requirements continue independently.

No component, state, parent, operational, publication or A066 acceptance is implied.

END S_MN PASS-06

Every captured table

Captured cells with original header handling and explicitly labeled bounded correction overlays. Downloaded JSON retains original cells. Tables may contain source limitations, historical examples and identified corrections; the complete reading supplies context.

Read the evidence with its boundaries. These are saved research components, including revisions. A scoped coordinator review checks selected evidence; it does not certify every claim, a complete jurisdiction, current law or individual applicability. Dates and access limits remain attached to the records.

How to read the research →

Read the related correction supplements

These components repair their stated scope. They do not replace every other finding in this research series.

SMN Credit-repair representations, Minnesota CSOs, CROA, and the TSR →

Captured table 01

Proposed first-payment treatment · Calculation · Result within this pass · 5 data rows

Proposed first-payment treatmentCalculationResult within this pass
$300 periodic payment; $50 origination plus $45 maintenance$95 retained; 31.6667% of receipt; $205 left for creditorsNo supported route. It exceeds the $45 aggregate retention limit by $50.
$300 periodic payment; contract instead specifies $30 origination plus $15 maintenance$45 retained; 15%; $255 for creditorsConditionally compatible with the numerical limits. Contract, services, timing, consent and distribution conditions remain necessary.
$1,000 periodic payment; $50 origination plus $75 maintenance$125 retained; 12.5%; $875 for creditorsConditionally compatible with both individual ceilings and the aggregate retention limit.
$50 genuinely separate fee-only payment plus a $300 periodic paymentDepends on whether the $50 is legally distinct from the periodic paymentUnresolved classification—not a permitted workaround.
One $300 periodic obligation divided into a $50 “enrollment” debit and a $250 “plan” debitSame underlying periodic obligation, merely split operationallySplitting the transfer does not establish a statutory exception.

Captured table 02

Construction · Supporting textual consideration · Missing authority · 2 data rows

ConstructionSupporting textual considerationMissing authority
A genuinely separate initial origination payment is not a periodic paymentSubdivision 1 expressly permits an origination fee from the initial amount; subdivision 4 addresses periodic paymentsA responsive construction explaining when a separate payment is genuinely outside subdivision 4, and how the agreement and payment schedule must reflect it
An initial transfer associated with the first scheduled plan payment remains subject to the periodic-payment limitSubdivision 4 applies to fees authorized by the section and to any periodic paymentA responsive application to separately invoiced or separately debited amounts connected to the same scheduled obligation

Captured table 03

Authority · Material point · Effective/applicability finding · 4 data rows

AuthorityMaterial pointEffective/applicability finding
Laws 2007, chapter 57, article 3, §56Enacted the relevant §332A.13 origination, maintenance, periodic-retention, advance-payment, consent and funds structureThe section expressly became effective January 1, 2008.
Laws 2008, chapter 210, §8Changed the trust-deposit language to funds being available, and added the limited separate disbursement-account routeSection 10 makes §§1–9 effective the day following final enactment. The act was signed April 21, 2008; this change therefore took effect April 22, 2008.
Laws 2009, chapter 37, article 4Relevant DMP definition, agreement and cancellation amendments were inspected as historical contextThe precise historical effective-date chain for these selected 2009 changes was not fully reconstructed. No particular 2009 date is asserted here.
Displayed current section bodiesSupply the present wording used for the 2026 fictional modelsSubject to the stated compilation and later-amendment limits.

Captured table 04

Agreement cadence or circumstance · Operative treatment · What it does not establish · 5 data rows

Agreement cadence or circumstanceOperative treatmentWhat it does not establish
Monthly paymentFee receipt/retention restricted when the debtor pays more than 42 days earlyThat a payment 42 days early is automatically fee-earned
Biweekly paymentCorresponding threshold: more than 15 days earlyA new monthly maintenance allowance for every receipt
Weekly paymentCorresponding threshold: more than seven days earlyPermission to disregard creditor distribution deadlines
Agreement has no specified payment amountsPortion exceeding twice the average prior regular payment is deemed advance paymentA defined average where no prior regular payments exist
Debtor intends the advance to satisfy contractual obligations due within 30 daysSubdivision 5 does not apply to that circumstanceWaiver of fee ceilings, reasonableness, other state duties or federal predicates

Captured table 05

Event · Custody treatment · Treatment of prior fees · 4 data rows

EventCustody treatmentTreatment of prior fees
Debtor cancels without cause on ten days’ written noticeNotify creditors and return unexpended funds within ten days of cancellationOrdinary cancellation does not itself establish return of every previously lawful fee
Provider cancels for good causeThirty days’ written notice; creditor notice and unexpended-funds return within ten days after cancellationNo immediate-forfeiture rule inferred from a missed installment
All listed debts and fees are paidAutomatic termination; immediate return of unexpended fundsNo continued maintenance merely because a surplus remains
Material Chapter 332A violation followed by rescissionSeparate from ordinary cancellationSection 332A.17 requires return within ten days of fees paid to the provider or other noncreditors

Captured table 06

Actual facts · Consequence for this pass · 7 data rows

Actual factsConsequence for this pass
Service represents that it will reduce interest, waive fees, or otherwise alter unsecured-debt termsPotential debt-relief service even where principal will be repaid in full
Pure payment processing with no represented alteration of debt termsDebt-relief coverage cannot be presumed from payment custody alone
Consumer responds to debt-relief advertising or direct mailThe ordinary inbound advertising/direct-mail exemptions contain debt-relief carve-outs
Truly unsolicited call without prior solicitationThe separate exemption and its conditions require examination
Qualifying face-to-face sales presentationSpecific sequencing and residual-coverage rules apply; not a universal exemption
Provider claims nonprofit statusActual jurisdictional/entity facts must be established; neither universal TSR coverage nor exemption is assumed
No covered telephone campaignThis pass does not apply the telemarketing rule solely because a website or DMP exists

Captured table 07

Proposed event · Minnesota question · Federal question for a covered DMP · 6 data rows

Proposed eventMinnesota questionFederal question for a covered DMP
Agree on a fee scheduleIs it disclosed and within authorized categories and limits?Disclosure of a conditional fee is not a substitute for the payment predicates
Receive first plan fundsExecuted agreement, proper custody and advance-payment analysisIs there the qualifying executed, binding DMP described by the rule and Commission?
Transfer origination feeInitial-payment classification and collective retention limitHas the qualifying enrollment and first payment occurred?
Transfer monthly servicing feeContract, reasonable services, monthly ceiling and receipt-level limitIs it a subsequent servicing charge within the described DMP structure?
Treat only one creditor as participatingConsent, notification, feasibility and contract issuesDo individual-debt allocation and timing requirements now matter?
Debit a bank accountEntitlement and custody must still be lawfulApplicable express informed consent to the charge and identified account is separately required

Captured table 08

Actor/event · Required factual record · Proper ledger treatment · 14 data rows

Actor/eventRequired factual recordProper ledger treatmentWhat cannot be inferred
Provider conducts pre-agreement assessmentCounseling, financial analysis, proposed plan, affordability and creditor informationPre-agreement work is separately identifiedAn independent “consultation” or “enrollment” fee is authorized
Debtor and provider execute agreementSigned terms, cadence, gross payment, fee schedule, creditor allocations, refund provisionsEstablish contractual obligations—not cash receiptEvery disclosed fee is immediately collectible
Debtor authorizes a bank paymentAmount, purpose and applicable consentAuthorization record separate from entitlementAuthorization cures an excessive or premature fee
Bank receives a check or transfer instructionPending/cleared/available status and any reversalPending instruments separately reconciledA pending or returned item funded creditors
Provider receives available plan moneyTrust receipt with debtor-specific allocationCustody asset and corresponding debtor-funds responsibilityEntire receipt is provider revenue
Provider proposes origination deductionInitial-payment classification, lawful amount, joint retention calculation, federal trigger where applicableFee transfer only when predicates are met“Nonrefundable” defeats every cancellation or violation remedy
Provider proposes maintenance deductionServices, contract, monthly total, each receipt’s retention capacitySeparate monthly and per-receipt checks$75 is available for each weekly payment
Creditor accepts a paymentCreditor credit date, amount and allocationReduce the creditor balance by the amount actually creditedProvider receipt itself reduced the debt
Creditor refuses or withdrawsDate learned, affected payment, required noticesRevise projections and preserve funds accuratelyImmediate additional fees or automatic cancellation
Debtor misses or underpaysActual available cash, contract treatment and creditor consequencesNo fictitious receipt; no fictitious creditor creditA scheduled amount is cash, or late charges are authorized
Debtor cancelsNotice, effective date, unexpended funds, prior lawful feesSeparate custody return from fee-refund analysisAll old fees are refundable—or all are protected
Provider cancelsGood cause and thirty-day noticeRequired creditor notice and return following cancellationOne failed payment permits immediate forfeiture
Plan completesAll listed debts and lawful fees paidImmediate surplus returnSurplus may be retained for future maintenance
Material violation is rescindedViolation and rescission factsSeparate return of qualifying prior feesOrdinary cancellation and statutory rescission are identical

Captured table 09

Posture · Facts · Result or exact hold · 14 data rows

PostureFactsResult or exact hold
P01 — Nominal pre-agreement paymentProvider requests $10 to “open the plan” before an executed agreementNo established authority to accept it as plan money or a third fee category.
P02 — First $300 periodic paymentProposed $50 origination and $45 maintenanceAggregate $95 retention is unsupported; see M01.
P03 — First $1,000 periodic payment$50 origination and $75 reasonable maintenance; all other predicates metBoth fit the individual and collective numerical constraints; see M02.
P04 — Separate $50 paymentDescribed as fee-only, in addition to $300 monthly plan moneyClassification remains held. A pre-trigger fee also fails the modeled federal timing condition; see M03.
P05 — Four weekly receiptsFour $200 payments in one month; provider takes $25 eachEach $25 is below $30, but $100 monthly maintenance exceeds $75. A different $18.75-per-receipt schedule totals $75, subject to services and contract.
P06 — Monthly receipt 43 days earlyNo obligation within 30 days is identifiedSubdivision 5 bars the related fee receipt/retention. Custody and distribution still require separate analysis.
P07 — Biweekly receipt 16 days earlyNo applicable 30-day exceptionSame restriction; the threshold is more than fifteen days. Exactly fifteen days does not itself establish earning.
P08 — Weekly receipt eight days earlyDebtor documents intent to satisfy a contractual obligation due within thirty daysThe subdivision 5 exception may apply; other caps and predicates remain.
P09 — Variable paymentsPrior regular payments $100/$150/$200; new payment $400$100 is deemed advance. Missing due-date or intent facts remain material. No prior-payment history would leave the average unresolved.
P10 — Rent plus DMP moneyTransfer includes $500 current rent and $300 DMP paymentDo not charge a handling fee on rent or use it merely to enlarge the fee-bearing DMP base.
P11 — Direct-creditor paymentsConsumer pays creditors directly; provider only advisesProvider-custody ledger is zero for those payments. Minnesota classification and possible federal debt-relief coverage require the actual service/representation facts.
P12 — Partial scheduled payment$100 received against a $400 schedule; provider wants $30$30 exceeds the $15 receipt-retention limit even before resolving monthly-base and earning questions.
P13 — Returned payment$400 payment fails before cash becomes availableRecord the failed transaction; do not record $400 of available funds or creditor reduction. No separate provider NSF fee was established.
P14 — Cancel or finishDebtor cancels, provider cancels for cause, or all debts and fees are paidApply the appropriate notice and return rule; these events do not share one universal deadline or fee-refund outcome.

Captured table 10

Date/event · Receipts · Fee transfer · 4 data rows

Date/eventReceiptsFee transferCreditor paymentDebtor returnClosing custody
September 10: available plan payment$300.00———$300.00
September 12: A receives $85; B receives $170——$255.00—$45.00
September 13: lawful origination transfer assumed—$30.00——$15.00
September 30: reasonable maintenance services completed—$15.00——$0.00

Captured table 11

Date/event · Receipts · Fee transfer · 4 data rows

Date/eventReceiptsFee transferCreditor paymentDebtor returnClosing custody
September 5: plan payment$1,000.00———$1,000.00
September 8: A $350; B $525——$875.00—$125.00
September 9: origination—$50.00——$75.00
September 30: maintenance—$75.00——$0.00

Captured table 12

Date/event · Receipts · Fee transfer · 5 data rows

Date/eventReceiptsFee transferCreditor paymentDebtor returnClosing custody
September 10: scheduled payment$300.00———$300.00
September 11: mistaken extra payment$50.00———$350.00
September 12: A $85; B $170——$255.00—$95.00
September 13: extra $50 returned———$50.00$45.00
September 30: maintenance—$45.00——$0.00

Captured table 13

Period/event · Receipts · Fee transfers · 6 data rows

Period/eventReceiptsFee transfersCreditor paymentsDebtor returnsClosing custody
July 5 receipt$400.00———$400.00
July 8 creditor distributions——$370.00—$30.00
July 31 maintenance—$30.00——$0.00
August failed payment$0.00$0.00$0.00$0.00$0.00
September 5 partial receipt$100.00———$100.00
September 12 cancellation return—$0.00$0.00$100.00$0.00

Captured table 14

Original example · Preserved arithmetic · PASS-06 legal effect · 2 data rows

Original examplePreserved arithmeticPASS-06 legal effect
E05: $300 monthly payment$45 maintenance ceiling and $255 remainderPreserved. It did not authorize adding a full $50 origination deduction to the same ordinary periodic receipt. M01 supplies the joint test; the separate-fee theory remains held.
E06: $800 monthly paymentMaintenance ceiling $75; remainder $725; retention 9.375%Preserved. Adding $50 would create $125 total retention against a $120 receipt-level ceiling. That addition is not approved merely because each component separately fits its own maximum.

Captured table 15

Source ID · Issuer, complete literal HTTPS URL · Actual read scope and operative pinpoint · 17 data rows

Source IDIssuer, complete literal HTTPS URLActual read scope and operative pinpointVersion/effect and limitations
S_MN-P06-S001Minnesota Revisor, §332A.13. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.13Fresh complete read: subdivisions 1–9 and history.Displayed 2025 text. Core fee, advance, consent and funds authority. MN Revisor +1
S_MN-P06-S002Minnesota Revisor, §332A.02. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.02Fresh targeted read: subdivisions 5a–10 and 12; relevant provider/delegation/holding-out language and warning.2025 display with accreditation warning. Exemption categories not rerun. MN Revisor +1
S_MN-P06-S003Minnesota Revisor, §332A.10. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.10Fresh complete operative read: subdivisions 1–5; relied on agreement prerequisites, assessment, fee/refund disclosures and modification rules.2025 display. No full contract-compliance approval. MN Revisor +1
S_MN-P06-S004Minnesota Revisor, §332A.11. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.11Fresh complete read: subdivisions 1–4 and history.Debtor/provider cancellation and automatic termination. MN Revisor
S_MN-P06-S005Minnesota Revisor, §332A.12. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.12Fresh operative read: subdivisions 1, 1a and 2; relied on records, monthly/final statements and access.Annual regulatory reporting not developed beyond the read. MN Revisor
S_MN-P06-S006Minnesota Revisor, §332A.14. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.14Fresh operative body read: relied particularly on clauses (3)–(5), (7)–(10), (12), (13), (16).Necessary fee/payment prohibitions only; not a complete conduct dossier. MN Revisor +1
S_MN-P06-S007Minnesota Revisor, §332A.17. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.17Fresh complete operative read: material-violation rescission paragraph and history.Distinguishes rescission from ordinary cancellation. MN Revisor
S_MN-P06-S008Minnesota Legislature/Revisor, Laws 2007, chapter 57. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/laws/2007/0/57/Fresh targeted enacted read: article 3, §56, including its effective-date clause; relevant surrounding agreement/cancellation/records/rescission provisions inspected.§56 expressly effective January 1, 2008. An initial history-link route failed; the direct act route succeeded. Not a full-act sequential read. MN Revisor
S_MN-P06-S009Minnesota Legislature/Revisor, Laws 2008, chapter 210. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/laws/2008/0/210/Fresh targeted enacted read: §§6, 8, 10 and signature.§8 custody change effective April 22, 2008 under §10 and April 21 signature. MN Revisor +1
S_MN-P06-S010Minnesota Legislature/Revisor, Laws 2009, chapter 37. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/laws/2009/0/37/Fresh targeted historical read: article 4, relevant definition changes and §§15–16; end signature inspected.Signed May 7, 2009. Exact effective-date chain for the selected historical amendments not completed; signature not substituted for effectiveness. MN Revisor +1
S_MN-P06-S011Minnesota Revisor, 2026 statutes-changed Table 2. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/2026/table2?full=&page=5&per_page=500&year=2026Fresh index read: relevant Chapter 332A entries, parsed lines 305–306 and surrounding entries.Regular-session index; not a complete later/special-session certification. MN Revisor
S_MN-P06-S012OFR/eCFR, 16 CFR §310.2. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.2Fresh relevant operative definitions: customer, debt relief, person, seller, telemarketer and telemarketing; paragraphs (n), (o), (y), (ee), (hh), (ii).Retrieved eCFR display current through October 23, 2026. Title-level amendment metadata is not attributed to this particular provision. eCFR
S_MN-P06-S013OFR/eCFR, 16 CFR §310.4. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.4Fresh complete relevant passages: (a)(5)(i)(A)–(C), (ii)(A)–(E), and applicable (a)(7) consent provisions.Same eCFR version limit. Credit-repair requirements not analyzed as applicable. eCFR
S_MN-P06-S014OFR/eCFR, 16 CFR §310.6. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.6Fresh operative exemptions read, particularly (b)(3)–(7) and their exceptions.Coverage depends on actual actor/campaign facts. eCFR
S_MN-P06-S015FTC, final TSR amendments, 75 FR 48458. HTML: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2010/08/10/2010-19412/telemarketing-sales-rule Official PDF: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2010-08-10/pdf/2010-19412.pdfFresh targeted Commission explanation: III.C.5(a), printed page 48489, especially footnote 431; related timing/account discussion. Official PDF pages 31–32, printed pages 48489–48490, visually inspected.One underlying final-rule document, not two independent authorities. Published August 10, 2010; (a)(5) effective October 27, 2010. Preamble interpretation is distinguished from current regulatory text. Federal Register +3
S_MN-P06-S016FTC, business compliance guide. https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/debt-relief-services-telemarketing-sales-rule-guide-businessFresh limited read: DMP coverage, initial-fee evidence and entity qualifications.Staff guidance, not binding Commission interpretation. Historical record-retention advice was not imported as current law. Federal Trade Commission
S_MN-P06-S017Minnesota Commerce, Consumer Credit Code Adjustments. https://mn.gov/commerce/money/industry/interest-rates/consumer-credit-code/Fresh body read: 2026 adjustment authority and covered statutes, lines 19–44.Effective July 1, 2026 notice concerns Chapter 56 and §47.59, not §332A.13. mn.gov // Minnesota's State Portal
Source links captured in this table

Captured table 16

Claim · Precise actor/predicate/effect · Authority and pinpoint · 45 data rows

ClaimPrecise actor/predicate/effectAuthority and pinpointConfidence, exceptions and limits
C001Retrieved Minnesota bodies are 2025 displays; targeted 2026 index entries do not identify a fee-section changeS001–S007; S011 Chapter 332A entriesHigh as version/index finding; no all-later-law certificate
C002The relevant original §332A.13 enactment became effective January 1, 2008S008, article 3, §56 effective-date clauseHigh—enacted text
C003The 2008 funds-availability/disbursement-account amendment became effective April 22, 2008S009, §§8, 10 and signatureHigh—express chain
C004No indexing authority appears in §332A.13; the retrieved 2026 adjustment notice covers different statutesS001 complete body; S017 lines 19–44High for these bodies; not proof that every possible notice was searched
C005DMP classification principally involves provider receipt/distribution for full repayment of consumer-purpose debtS002, subdivision 9High—text; actual service facts necessary
C006Delegation and holding out matter; a direct-payment label does not conclusively resolve classificationS002, subdivisions 8–10, 12Conditional application
C007Executed agreement and prescribed pre-agreement steps precede covered services/plan moneyS003, subdivisions 1–2High—text
C008Agreement must disclose fees, services, anticipated charges, refund and cancellation termsS003, subdivision 3High—text; actual agreement not supplied
C009Registrant may charge an origination fee not exceeding $50 from the initial amountS001, subdivision 1High—text; other restrictions still apply
C010Maintenance must be reasonable and no greater than the lesser of 15% monthly payment or $75S001, subdivision 2High—text; monthly-base and service facts matter
C011Combined fee retention from any periodic payment is limited to 15%; creditor allocation must respect the remainderS001, subdivision 4; S008, §56High—text; initial-periodic application is the stated combined reading, not a located holding
C012A genuinely separate fee-only initial payment is not resolved by the retrieved definitions or an opened controlling interpretationS001–S003; bounded searchHeld; no approval by invoice/debit label
C013Other provider charges and debtor “voluntary contributions” lack authority under the relied-on provisionsS001, subdivision 3; S006, clause (16)High—text; bank-imposed charges and broader remedies not decided
C014Handling the listed recurring living/support payments cannot generate provider handling feesS001, subdivision 4High—text; additional rule-prescribed categories not exhaustively investigated
C015Fee receipt/retention is restricted for payments more than 42/15/7 days early under monthly/biweekly/weekly schedulesS001, subdivision 5High—text; 30-day exception remains
C016For unspecified amounts, excess over twice the prior regular-payment average is deemed advanceS001, subdivision 5High—text; no-history computation unresolved
C017Debtor intent to satisfy contractual obligations due within thirty days removes subdivision 5’s restrictionS001, subdivision 5High—text; not a waiver of all other restrictions
C018Provider must seek creditor consent; failure invokes the specified ten-day notice/cancellation-right requirementS001, subdivision 6High—text; acceptance of payment may evidence consent
C019Creditor withdrawal/refusal invokes prompt notice, no later than fifteen days after learning of itS001, subdivision 7High—text; does not displace a separately applicable shorter requirement
C020Available payments belong in the separate trust process; statutory routing and narrow commingling exception applyS001, subdivision 8; S009, §8High—text; full trust-control compliance deferred
C021Creditor disbursement runs from receipt, within42 days or earlier creditor due date, subject to stated exceptionsS001, subdivision 9High—text; factual exception required
C022Provider must maintain records and provide monthly and cancellation/termination accounting of receipts, payments and feesS005, subdivisions 1–2High—text
C023Debtor cancellation uses ten days’ written notice and a ten-day post-cancellation unexpended-funds/creditor-notice dutyS004, subdivision 1High—text; effective notice date fact-dependent
C024Provider good-cause cancellation requires thirty days’ notice; completed plans automatically terminate with immediate surplus returnS004, subdivisions 3–4High—text
C025Ordinary cancellation/default does not by itself require return of lawful origination and prior earned feesS001, subdivision 6; S004High as limited rule; does not validate unlawful fees or decide all earning facts
C026Material-violation rescission requires qualifying noncreditor fee returns within ten daysS007, operative paragraphHigh—text; actual violation and rescission required
C027Additional agreements do not authorize another origination fee; modifications follow specified writing/exception rulesS003, subdivision 5High—text; no fee-reset workaround
C028TSR coverage requires the defined actor, service and telephone-campaign predicatesS012, (n), (o), (y), (ee), (hh), (ii)High—text; modeled facts assumed
C029Inbound, unsolicited and face-to-face exemptions have distinct conditions; nonprofit status is not resolved by a labelS014, (b)(3)–(7); S015–S016 limited explanationConditional; actual entity jurisdiction deferred
C030Covered debt-relief fee collection requires the operative result/agreement/payment predicates and applicable individual-debt allocationS013, (a)(5)(i)High—text
C031Commission DMP explanation recognizes a binding customer-executed DMP and first payment to the counseling agency for creditorsS015, III.C.5(a), 75 FR48489Strong federal interpretive evidence; not Minnesota construction
C032Under the described jointly renegotiated DMP, individual-debt allocation does not apply and later servicing fees may be collectedS015, footnote431Conditional on that factual model; not every DMP label
C033Federal dedicated-account conditions are not established merely by a provider-controlled Minnesota trust accountS013, (a)(5)(ii)High text plus conditional application
C034Billing authorization is separately required; it does not cure fee entitlement defectsS013, (a)(7)High—text; other payment-rail law deferred
C035Receipt, fee transfer, creditor credit and debtor return must be separately accounted forS001, subdivisions 8–9; S005, subdivision 2Analytical consequence; actual creditor posting needed
C036No responsive opened majority opinion or binding agency construction resolved the initial-fee exception issueSearch recordBounded search finding, not nonexistence
C037M01’s proposed $95 retention exceeds the $45 limit; the different $30+$15 contract reconciles conditionallyM01; C009–C011Verified arithmetic; hypothetical legal assumptions
C038M02’s $125 from $1,000 satisfies the joint numerical constraintsM02; C009–C011Verified arithmetic; reasonableness/timing assumed
C039M03 demonstrates that a zero cash balance can coexist with an unsupported separate-fee theoryM03; C012, C030–C034Conditional; demonstrated branch waives origination
C040M04 separates failed receipts, lawful fees, creditor payments and cancellation returnsM04; C020–C026Verified ledger; contract waivers and creditor concessions stipulated
C041Weekly/biweekly receipts must satisfy both per-receipt retention and the monthly maintenance ceilingC010–C011; P05Combined reading; irregular-month details held
C042Underpayment limits current retention by the actual periodic receipt; missed-cycle fee earning is not automaticC010–C011, C015–C017; P12–P13Conditional; actual contract/service/base required
C043P01 E05 arithmetic survives, but does not establish $95 retention from $300Supplied P01 E05; C037Historical reuse plus fresh application
C044P01 E06 arithmetic survives; adding $50 would exceed the $800 payment’s $120 retention limitSupplied P01 E06; C011Historical reuse plus arithmetic
C045No actual provider, account, claimant, contract, broader-state or A066 approval followsScope and evidence limitsExpress limitation

Captured table 17

Subissue · Status · Claims/models · 65 data rows

SubissueStatusClaims/modelsExact missing evidence or next action
Complete §332A.13 operative bodyAnsweredC009–C021All subdivisions read; interpretation gaps separately retained
Relevant DMP/debtor/provider/creditor definitionsAnswered textuallyC005–C006Actual service and delegation facts
Initial/periodic/monthly/earned definitionsPartialC012, C025, C042Responsive authority or actual contract where statutory terms are not expressly defined
$50 origination ceilingAnsweredC009Actual agreement and lawful timing
Maintenance ceiling and reasonablenessAnswered textuallyC010Evidence of actual services and reasonableness
Combined first-periodic-payment retentionAnswered as combined textual readingC011, M01–M02No located controlling contrary/confirming construction
Genuine separate fee-only paymentUnresolvedC012, M03Published majority opinion or binding agency interpretation addressing classification
Split debit/relabeling theoryNo authority establishedC012Actual legal basis; operational labels alone insufficient
Nominal enrollment/application chargeAnswered narrowlyC007, C013, P01No third consumer-fee category established
Registration/bond costs versus consumer feesAnswered boundaryC013Registration/bond compliance itself deferred
Inflation/indexingAnswered for read authoritiesC004No applicable DMP notice found; broader notice sweep not certified
2007 fee enactment/effective dateAnsweredC002None within the stated provision
2008 funds amendment/effective dateAnsweredC003None within the stated provision
Selected 2009 historical effective-date chainPartialS010Complete applicable general/specific date analysis; no guessed date used
Current 2026 regular-session checkAnswered narrowlyC001Complete later/special-session consolidation remains separate
Written agreement and disclosuresAnswered for ledger purposesC007–C008Actual executed agreement and assessment records
Extra origination/modification feesAnsweredC027Actual modification facts and applicable limited exception
Monthly advance thresholdAnsweredC015, P06Actual agreement due date
Biweekly advance thresholdAnsweredC015, P07Same
Weekly advance thresholdAnsweredC015, P08Same
Variable-payment calculationAnswered with boundaryC016, P09Date/intent facts; no-history average unresolved
Thirty-day obligation exceptionAnswered conditionallyC017Evidence of debtor intent and contractual obligation
Weekly/biweekly monthly aggregationAnswered in principleC041, P05Actual monthly base and irregular-month treatment
Recurring living-expense handlingAnswered for statutory listC014, P10Any additional commissioner-rule categories not exhaustively reviewed
Custody receipt versus fee earningAnswered analyticallyC020, C035Actual transaction and subledger records
Availability versus receipt clocksAnsweredC020–C021Actual receipt/availability dates and any return
Trust-to-provider/creditor/debtor routingAnswered narrowlyC020Full trust controls and bank documentation deferred
Creditor distribution deadlineAnsweredC021Creditor due dates and actual credits
Accumulation/returned-payment exceptionsAnswered textuallyC021Fact-specific reasonable/net-interest evidence
Creditor consentAnsweredC018Actual binding concessions and consent evidence
Withdrawal/refusal noticeAnsweredC019Date learned and notices
Direct-creditor/noncustodial branchPartialC006, P11Actual service, representations, delegation and control
Insufficient paymentPartial applicationC042, P12Contractual monthly-base and earning facts
Late/missed/NSF paymentAnswered for modeled factsP13, M04Real creditor consequences and bank reconciliation
Monthly/final accountingAnsweredC022Actual statements not supplied
Ordinary debtor cancellationAnsweredC023, C025Actual notice/effective date and lawful prior fees
Provider cancellationAnsweredC024Good cause and thirty-day notice
Automatic terminationAnsweredC024Proof all listed debts and lawful fees paid
Material-violation rescissionAnswered narrowlyC026Actual material violation and exercise of rescission
Federal actor/service/telephone coverageAnswered conditionallyC028–C029Actual entity and campaign facts
Federal DMP first-fee triggerAnswered for described DMPC030–C032Executed binding plan and qualifying first payment
DMP subsequent servicing feesAnswered federally, state limits separateC032Actual service/contract/state compliance
Staggered creditor participationUnresolved applicationC030–C032Whether individual-debt treatment applies and corresponding records
Pre-trigger dedicated accountPartialC033Actual ownership, administration, independence and account terms
Bank-debit authorizationAnswered narrowlyC034Actual consent; other payment-rail requirements deferred
P01 nominal enrollment postureCompletedP01Hypothetical only
P02–P04 initial-payment posturesCompleted with separate-fee holdP02–P04M01–M03 specify assumptions
P05 cadence postureCompletedP05Irregular-month interpretation remains open
P06–P09 advance-payment posturesCompleted conditionallyP06–P09Date/intent/history facts stated or held
P10–P11 living-expense/direct-pay posturesCompleted with classification limitsP10–P11Actual service/account facts
P12–P14 shortage/failure/exit posturesCompletedP12–P14Real contract and creditor facts
M01 $300 adversarial joint ledgerCompletedC037Not actual fee approval
M02 larger initial joint ledgerCompleted conditionallyC038Reasonableness and other assumptions essential
M03 separate-fee candidateCompleted; authority heldC039Responsive classification authority
M04 missed-payment/cancellation ledgerCompleted conditionallyC040Waivers/concessions are stipulated, not universal
P01 E05 crosswalkCompletedC043Original preserved
P01 E06 crosswalkCompletedC044Original preserved
Responsive judicial/administrative interpretationNot located in bounded searchC036Further official published-opinion/Commerce-order research on exact issue
P05 settlement-performance componentExcluded; not a premiseC045Separate review remains separate
NMLS/current provider status/2026 transitionDeferred/preservedC045P02/P04 holds unchanged
Full trust/bond complianceDeferredC045Account-control, bond and broader supervision component
Nonprofit/attorney registration and exemptionsDeferredC045Actual entity/activity qualification
CROA and broader federal credit repairDeferred boundaryC045Actual representations and separate operative review
Collection/litigation/wage/bank/other propertyDeferredC045Separate parent-state components
Sector/local/tribal and remaining state dimensionsDeferredC045No completion or acceptance by implication

Find the assertion and its boundaries

Read the evidence with its boundaries. These are saved research components, including revisions. A scoped coordinator review checks selected evidence; it does not certify every claim, a complete jurisdiction, current law or individual applicability. Dates and access limits remain attached to the records.

How to read the research →

Read the related correction supplements

These components repair their stated scope. They do not replace every other finding in this research series.

SMN Credit-repair representations, Minnesota CSOs, CROA, and the TSR →
S_MN-P06-C001 Saved research record

Retrieved Minnesota bodies are 2025 displays; targeted 2026 index entries do not identify a fee-section change

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C001
Authority and pinpoint
S001–S007; S011 Chapter 332A entries
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High as version/index finding; no all-later-law certificate
S_MN-P06-C002 Saved research record

The relevant original §332A.13 enactment became effective January 1, 2008

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C002
Authority and pinpoint
S008, article 3, §56 effective-date clause
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—enacted text
S_MN-P06-C003 Saved research record

The 2008 funds-availability/disbursement-account amendment became effective April 22, 2008

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C003
Authority and pinpoint
S009, §§8, 10 and signature
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—express chain
S_MN-P06-C004 Saved research record

No indexing authority appears in §332A.13; the retrieved 2026 adjustment notice covers different statutes

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C004
Authority and pinpoint
S001 complete body; S017 lines 19–44
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High for these bodies; not proof that every possible notice was searched
S_MN-P06-C005 Saved research record

DMP classification principally involves provider receipt/distribution for full repayment of consumer-purpose debt

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C005
Authority and pinpoint
S002, subdivision 9
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text; actual service facts necessary
S_MN-P06-C006 Saved research record

Delegation and holding out matter; a direct-payment label does not conclusively resolve classification

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C006
Authority and pinpoint
S002, subdivisions 8–10, 12
Confidence, exceptions and limits
Conditional application
S_MN-P06-C007 Saved research record

Executed agreement and prescribed pre-agreement steps precede covered services/plan money

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C007
Authority and pinpoint
S003, subdivisions 1–2
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text
S_MN-P06-C008 Saved research record

Agreement must disclose fees, services, anticipated charges, refund and cancellation terms

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C008
Authority and pinpoint
S003, subdivision 3
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text; actual agreement not supplied
S_MN-P06-C009 Saved research record

Registrant may charge an origination fee not exceeding $50 from the initial amount

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C009
Authority and pinpoint
S001, subdivision 1
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text; other restrictions still apply
S_MN-P06-C010 Saved research record

Maintenance must be reasonable and no greater than the lesser of 15% monthly payment or $75

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C010
Authority and pinpoint
S001, subdivision 2
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text; monthly-base and service facts matter
S_MN-P06-C011 Saved research record

Combined fee retention from any periodic payment is limited to 15%; creditor allocation must respect the remainder

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C011
Authority and pinpoint
S001, subdivision 4; S008, §56
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text; initial-periodic application is the stated combined reading, not a located holding
S_MN-P06-C012 Saved research record

A genuinely separate fee-only initial payment is not resolved by the retrieved definitions or an opened controlling interpretation

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C012
Authority and pinpoint
S001–S003; bounded search
Confidence, exceptions and limits
Held; no approval by invoice/debit label
S_MN-P06-C013 Saved research record

Other provider charges and debtor “voluntary contributions” lack authority under the relied-on provisions

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C013
Authority and pinpoint
S001, subdivision 3; S006, clause (16)
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text; bank-imposed charges and broader remedies not decided
S_MN-P06-C014 Saved research record

Handling the listed recurring living/support payments cannot generate provider handling fees

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C014
Authority and pinpoint
S001, subdivision 4
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text; additional rule-prescribed categories not exhaustively investigated
S_MN-P06-C015 Saved research record

Fee receipt/retention is restricted for payments more than 42/15/7 days early under monthly/biweekly/weekly schedules

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C015
Authority and pinpoint
S001, subdivision 5
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text; 30-day exception remains
S_MN-P06-C016 Saved research record

For unspecified amounts, excess over twice the prior regular-payment average is deemed advance

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C016
Authority and pinpoint
S001, subdivision 5
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text; no-history computation unresolved
S_MN-P06-C017 Saved research record

Debtor intent to satisfy contractual obligations due within thirty days removes subdivision 5’s restriction

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C017
Authority and pinpoint
S001, subdivision 5
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text; not a waiver of all other restrictions
S_MN-P06-C018 Saved research record

Provider must seek creditor consent; failure invokes the specified ten-day notice/cancellation-right requirement

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C018
Authority and pinpoint
S001, subdivision 6
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text; acceptance of payment may evidence consent
S_MN-P06-C019 Saved research record

Creditor withdrawal/refusal invokes prompt notice, no later than fifteen days after learning of it

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C019
Authority and pinpoint
S001, subdivision 7
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text; does not displace a separately applicable shorter requirement
S_MN-P06-C020 Saved research record

Available payments belong in the separate trust process; statutory routing and narrow commingling exception apply

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C020
Authority and pinpoint
S001, subdivision 8; S009, §8
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text; full trust-control compliance deferred
S_MN-P06-C021 Saved research record

Creditor disbursement runs from receipt, within42 days or earlier creditor due date, subject to stated exceptions

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C021
Authority and pinpoint
S001, subdivision 9
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text; factual exception required
S_MN-P06-C022 Saved research record

Provider must maintain records and provide monthly and cancellation/termination accounting of receipts, payments and fees

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C022
Authority and pinpoint
S005, subdivisions 1–2
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text
S_MN-P06-C023 Saved research record

Debtor cancellation uses ten days’ written notice and a ten-day post-cancellation unexpended-funds/creditor-notice duty

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C023
Authority and pinpoint
S004, subdivision 1
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text; effective notice date fact-dependent
S_MN-P06-C024 Saved research record

Provider good-cause cancellation requires thirty days’ notice; completed plans automatically terminate with immediate surplus return

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C024
Authority and pinpoint
S004, subdivisions 3–4
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text
S_MN-P06-C025 Saved research record

Ordinary cancellation/default does not by itself require return of lawful origination and prior earned fees

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C025
Authority and pinpoint
S001, subdivision 6; S004
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High as limited rule; does not validate unlawful fees or decide all earning facts
S_MN-P06-C026 Saved research record

Material-violation rescission requires qualifying noncreditor fee returns within ten days

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C026
Authority and pinpoint
S007, operative paragraph
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text; actual violation and rescission required
S_MN-P06-C027 Saved research record

Additional agreements do not authorize another origination fee; modifications follow specified writing/exception rules

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C027
Authority and pinpoint
S003, subdivision 5
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text; no fee-reset workaround
S_MN-P06-C028 Saved research record

TSR coverage requires the defined actor, service and telephone-campaign predicates

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C028
Authority and pinpoint
S012, (n), (o), (y), (ee), (hh), (ii)
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text; modeled facts assumed
S_MN-P06-C029 Saved research record

Inbound, unsolicited and face-to-face exemptions have distinct conditions; nonprofit status is not resolved by a label

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C029
Authority and pinpoint
S014, (b)(3)–(7); S015–S016 limited explanation
Confidence, exceptions and limits
Conditional; actual entity jurisdiction deferred
S_MN-P06-C030 Saved research record

Covered debt-relief fee collection requires the operative result/agreement/payment predicates and applicable individual-debt allocation

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C030
Authority and pinpoint
S013, (a)(5)(i)
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text
S_MN-P06-C031 Saved research record

Commission DMP explanation recognizes a binding customer-executed DMP and first payment to the counseling agency for creditors

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C031
Authority and pinpoint
S015, III.C.5(a), 75 FR48489
Confidence, exceptions and limits
Strong federal interpretive evidence; not Minnesota construction
S_MN-P06-C032 Saved research record

Under the described jointly renegotiated DMP, individual-debt allocation does not apply and later servicing fees may be collected

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C032
Authority and pinpoint
S015, footnote431
Confidence, exceptions and limits
Conditional on that factual model; not every DMP label
S_MN-P06-C033 Saved research record

Federal dedicated-account conditions are not established merely by a provider-controlled Minnesota trust account

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C033
Authority and pinpoint
S013, (a)(5)(ii)
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High text plus conditional application
S_MN-P06-C034 Saved research record

Billing authorization is separately required; it does not cure fee entitlement defects

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C034
Authority and pinpoint
S013, (a)(7)
Confidence, exceptions and limits
High—text; other payment-rail law deferred
S_MN-P06-C035 Saved research record

Receipt, fee transfer, creditor credit and debtor return must be separately accounted for

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C035
Authority and pinpoint
S001, subdivisions 8–9; S005, subdivision 2
Confidence, exceptions and limits
Analytical consequence; actual creditor posting needed
S_MN-P06-C036 Saved research record

No responsive opened majority opinion or binding agency construction resolved the initial-fee exception issue

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C036
Authority and pinpoint
Search record
Confidence, exceptions and limits
Bounded search finding, not nonexistence
S_MN-P06-C037 Saved research record

M01’s proposed $95 retention exceeds the $45 limit; the different $30+$15 contract reconciles conditionally

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C037
Authority and pinpoint
M01; C009–C011
Confidence, exceptions and limits
Verified arithmetic; hypothetical legal assumptions
S_MN-P06-C038 Saved research record

M02’s $125 from $1,000 satisfies the joint numerical constraints

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C038
Authority and pinpoint
M02; C009–C011
Confidence, exceptions and limits
Verified arithmetic; reasonableness/timing assumed
S_MN-P06-C039 Saved research record

M03 demonstrates that a zero cash balance can coexist with an unsupported separate-fee theory

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C039
Authority and pinpoint
M03; C012, C030–C034
Confidence, exceptions and limits
Conditional; demonstrated branch waives origination
S_MN-P06-C040 Saved research record

M04 separates failed receipts, lawful fees, creditor payments and cancellation returns

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C040
Authority and pinpoint
M04; C020–C026
Confidence, exceptions and limits
Verified ledger; contract waivers and creditor concessions stipulated
S_MN-P06-C041 Saved research record

Weekly/biweekly receipts must satisfy both per-receipt retention and the monthly maintenance ceiling

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C041
Authority and pinpoint
C010–C011; P05
Confidence, exceptions and limits
Combined reading; irregular-month details held
S_MN-P06-C042 Saved research record

Underpayment limits current retention by the actual periodic receipt; missed-cycle fee earning is not automatic

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C042
Authority and pinpoint
C010–C011, C015–C017; P12–P13
Confidence, exceptions and limits
Conditional; actual contract/service/base required
S_MN-P06-C043 Saved research record

P01 E05 arithmetic survives, but does not establish $95 retention from $300

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C043
Authority and pinpoint
Supplied P01 E05; C037
Confidence, exceptions and limits
Historical reuse plus fresh application
S_MN-P06-C044 Saved research record

P01 E06 arithmetic survives; adding $50 would exceed the $800 payment’s $120 retention limit

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C044
Authority and pinpoint
Supplied P01 E06; C011
Confidence, exceptions and limits
Historical reuse plus arithmetic
S_MN-P06-C045 Saved research record

No actual provider, account, claimant, contract, broader-state or A066 approval follows

Recorded check status: same coordinator scoped selected primary and arithmetic checks;not all source or current law verification;see review

Claim
C045
Authority and pinpoint
Scope and evidence limits
Confidence, exceptions and limits
Express limitation

Sources, pinpoints and access limits

Keep the source version, actual read extent and jurisdiction with the proposition. A link or researcher access claim is not a substitute for an operative primary passage.

S_MN-P06-S001 Saved research record

Minnesota Revisor, §332A.13. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.13

Recorded check status: not yet checked

Actual read scope and operative pinpoint
Fresh complete read: subdivisions 1–9 and history.
Version/effect and limitations
Displayed 2025 text. Core fee, advance, consent and funds authority. MN Revisor +1
Direct source URLs
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.13
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.13?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator review scope
Selected fresh primary checks and exact historical access limits retained; no blanket verification.
S_MN-P06-S002 Saved research record

Minnesota Revisor, §332A.02. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.02

Recorded check status: not yet checked

Actual read scope and operative pinpoint
Fresh targeted read: subdivisions 5a–10 and 12; relevant provider/delegation/holding-out language and warning.
Version/effect and limitations
2025 display with accreditation warning. Exemption categories not rerun. MN Revisor +1
Direct source URLs
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.02
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.02?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator review scope
Selected fresh primary checks and exact historical access limits retained; no blanket verification.
S_MN-P06-S003 Saved research record

Minnesota Revisor, §332A.10. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.10

Recorded check status: not yet checked

Actual read scope and operative pinpoint
Fresh complete operative read: subdivisions 1–5; relied on agreement prerequisites, assessment, fee/refund disclosures and modification rules.
Version/effect and limitations
2025 display. No full contract-compliance approval. MN Revisor +1
Direct source URLs
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.10
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.10?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator review scope
Selected fresh primary checks and exact historical access limits retained; no blanket verification.
S_MN-P06-S004 Saved research record

Minnesota Revisor, §332A.11. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.11

Recorded check status: not yet checked

Actual read scope and operative pinpoint
Fresh complete read: subdivisions 1–4 and history.
Version/effect and limitations
Debtor/provider cancellation and automatic termination. MN Revisor
Direct source URLs
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.11
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.11?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator review scope
Selected fresh primary checks and exact historical access limits retained; no blanket verification.
S_MN-P06-S005 Saved research record

Minnesota Revisor, §332A.12. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.12

Recorded check status: not yet checked

Actual read scope and operative pinpoint
Fresh operative read: subdivisions 1, 1a and 2; relied on records, monthly/final statements and access.
Version/effect and limitations
Annual regulatory reporting not developed beyond the read. MN Revisor
Direct source URLs
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.12
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.12?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator review scope
Selected fresh primary checks and exact historical access limits retained; no blanket verification.
S_MN-P06-S006 Saved research record

Minnesota Revisor, §332A.14. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.14

Recorded check status: not yet checked

Actual read scope and operative pinpoint
Fresh operative body read: relied particularly on clauses (3)–(5), (7)–(10), (12), (13), (16).
Version/effect and limitations
Necessary fee/payment prohibitions only; not a complete conduct dossier. MN Revisor +1
Direct source URLs
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.14
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.14?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator review scope
Selected fresh primary checks and exact historical access limits retained; no blanket verification.
S_MN-P06-S007 Saved research record

Minnesota Revisor, §332A.17. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.17

Recorded check status: not yet checked

Actual read scope and operative pinpoint
Fresh complete operative read: material-violation rescission paragraph and history.
Version/effect and limitations
Distinguishes rescission from ordinary cancellation. MN Revisor
Direct source URLs
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.17
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/cite/332A.17?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator review scope
Selected fresh primary checks and exact historical access limits retained; no blanket verification.
S_MN-P06-S008 Saved research record

Minnesota Legislature/Revisor, Laws 2007, chapter 57. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/laws/2007/0/57/

Recorded check status: not yet checked

Actual read scope and operative pinpoint
Fresh targeted enacted read: article 3, §56, including its effective-date clause; relevant surrounding agreement/cancellation/records/rescission provisions inspected.
Version/effect and limitations
§56 expressly effective January 1, 2008. An initial history-link route failed; the direct act route succeeded. Not a full-act sequential read. MN Revisor
Direct source URLs
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/laws/2007/0/57/
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/laws/2007/0/57/?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator review scope
Selected fresh primary checks and exact historical access limits retained; no blanket verification.
S_MN-P06-S009 Saved research record

Minnesota Legislature/Revisor, Laws 2008, chapter 210. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/laws/2008/0/210/

Recorded check status: not yet checked

Actual read scope and operative pinpoint
Fresh targeted enacted read: §§6, 8, 10 and signature.
Version/effect and limitations
§8 custody change effective April 22, 2008 under §10 and April 21 signature. MN Revisor +1
Direct source URLs
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/laws/2008/0/210/
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/laws/2008/0/210/?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator review scope
Selected fresh primary checks and exact historical access limits retained; no blanket verification.
S_MN-P06-S010 Saved research record

Minnesota Legislature/Revisor, Laws 2009, chapter 37. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/laws/2009/0/37/

Recorded check status: not yet checked

Actual read scope and operative pinpoint
Fresh targeted historical read: article 4, relevant definition changes and §§15–16; end signature inspected.
Version/effect and limitations
Signed May 7, 2009. Exact effective-date chain for the selected historical amendments not completed; signature not substituted for effectiveness. MN Revisor +1
Direct source URLs
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/laws/2009/0/37/
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/laws/2009/0/37/?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator review scope
Selected fresh primary checks and exact historical access limits retained; no blanket verification.
S_MN-P06-S011 Saved research record

Minnesota Revisor, 2026 statutes-changed Table 2. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/2026/table2?full=&page=5&per_page=500&year=2026

Recorded check status: not yet checked

Actual read scope and operative pinpoint
Fresh index read: relevant Chapter 332A entries, parsed lines 305–306 and surrounding entries.
Version/effect and limitations
Regular-session index; not a complete later/special-session certification. MN Revisor
Direct source URLs
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/2026/table2?full=&page=5&per_page=500&year=2026
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/2026/table2?full&page=5&per_page=500&year=2026&utm_source=chatgpt.com

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator review scope
Selected fresh primary checks and exact historical access limits retained; no blanket verification.
S_MN-P06-S012 Saved research record

OFR/eCFR, 16 CFR §310.2. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.2

Recorded check status: not yet checked

Actual read scope and operative pinpoint
Fresh relevant operative definitions: customer, debt relief, person, seller, telemarketer and telemarketing; paragraphs (n), (o), (y), (ee), (hh), (ii).
Version/effect and limitations
Retrieved eCFR display current through October 23, 2026. Title-level amendment metadata is not attributed to this particular provision. eCFR
Direct source URLs
https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.2
https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.2?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator review scope
Selected fresh primary checks and exact historical access limits retained; no blanket verification.
S_MN-P06-S013 Saved research record

OFR/eCFR, 16 CFR §310.4. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.4

Recorded check status: not yet checked

Actual read scope and operative pinpoint
Fresh complete relevant passages: (a)(5)(i)(A)–(C), (ii)(A)–(E), and applicable (a)(7) consent provisions.
Version/effect and limitations
Same eCFR version limit. Credit-repair requirements not analyzed as applicable. eCFR
Direct source URLs
https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.4
https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.4?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator review scope
Selected fresh primary checks and exact historical access limits retained; no blanket verification.
S_MN-P06-S014 Saved research record

OFR/eCFR, 16 CFR §310.6. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.6

Recorded check status: not yet checked

Actual read scope and operative pinpoint
Fresh operative exemptions read, particularly (b)(3)–(7) and their exceptions.
Version/effect and limitations
Coverage depends on actual actor/campaign facts. eCFR
Direct source URLs
https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.6
https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-310/section-310.6?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator review scope
Selected fresh primary checks and exact historical access limits retained; no blanket verification.
S_MN-P06-S015 Saved research record

FTC, final TSR amendments, 75 FR 48458. HTML: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2010/08/10/2010-19412/telemarketing-sales-rule Official PDF: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2010-08-10/pdf/2010-19412.pdf

Recorded check status: not yet checked

Actual read scope and operative pinpoint
Fresh targeted Commission explanation: III.C.5(a), printed page 48489, especially footnote 431; related timing/account discussion. Official PDF pages 31–32, printed pages 48489–48490, visually inspected.
Version/effect and limitations
One underlying final-rule document, not two independent authorities. Published August 10, 2010; (a)(5) effective October 27, 2010. Preamble interpretation is distinguished from current regulatory text. Federal Register +3
Direct source URLs
https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2010/08/10/2010-19412/telemarketing-sales-rule
https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2010-08-10/pdf/2010-19412.pdf
https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2010/08/10/2010-19412/telemarketing-sales-rule?utm_source=chatgpt.com
https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2010-08-10/pdf/2010-19412.pdf?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator review scope
Selected fresh primary checks and exact historical access limits retained; no blanket verification.
S_MN-P06-S016 Saved research record

FTC, business compliance guide. https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/debt-relief-services-telemarketing-sales-rule-guide-business

Recorded check status: not yet checked

Actual read scope and operative pinpoint
Fresh limited read: DMP coverage, initial-fee evidence and entity qualifications.
Version/effect and limitations
Staff guidance, not binding Commission interpretation. Historical record-retention advice was not imported as current law. Federal Trade Commission
Direct source URLs
https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/debt-relief-services-telemarketing-sales-rule-guide-business
https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/debt-relief-services-telemarketing-sales-rule-guide-business?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator review scope
Selected fresh primary checks and exact historical access limits retained; no blanket verification.
S_MN-P06-S017 Saved research record

Minnesota Commerce, Consumer Credit Code Adjustments. https://mn.gov/commerce/money/industry/interest-rates/consumer-credit-code/

Recorded check status: not yet checked

Actual read scope and operative pinpoint
Fresh body read: 2026 adjustment authority and covered statutes, lines 19–44.
Version/effect and limitations
Effective July 1, 2026 notice concerns Chapter 56 and §47.59, not §332A.13. mn.gov // Minnesota's State Portal
Direct source URLs
https://mn.gov/commerce/money/industry/interest-rates/consumer-credit-code/
https://mn.gov/commerce/money/industry/interest-rates/consumer-credit-code/index.jsp

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator review scope
Selected fresh primary checks and exact historical access limits retained; no blanket verification.

What was examined—and what is still missing

The saved component-level coverage record keeps answered, partial, blank and unresolved branches distinct. A coverage label is not acceptance of a whole subject or jurisdiction.

coverage-1 Saved research record

Complete §332A.13 operative body

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Claims/models
C009–C021
Exact missing evidence or next action
All subdivisions read; interpretation gaps separately retained

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-2 Saved research record

Relevant DMP/debtor/provider/creditor definitions

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered textually
Claims/models
C005–C006
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual service and delegation facts

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-3 Saved research record

Initial/periodic/monthly/earned definitions

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Partial
Claims/models
C012, C025, C042
Exact missing evidence or next action
Responsive authority or actual contract where statutory terms are not expressly defined

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-4 Saved research record

$50 origination ceiling

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Claims/models
C009
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual agreement and lawful timing

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-5 Saved research record

Maintenance ceiling and reasonableness

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered textually
Claims/models
C010
Exact missing evidence or next action
Evidence of actual services and reasonableness

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-6 Saved research record

Combined first-periodic-payment retention

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered as combined textual reading
Claims/models
C011, M01–M02
Exact missing evidence or next action
No located controlling contrary/confirming construction

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-7 Saved research record

Genuine separate fee-only payment

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Unresolved
Claims/models
C012, M03
Exact missing evidence or next action
Published majority opinion or binding agency interpretation addressing classification

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-8 Saved research record

Split debit/relabeling theory

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
No authority established
Claims/models
C012
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual legal basis; operational labels alone insufficient

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-9 Saved research record

Nominal enrollment/application charge

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered narrowly
Claims/models
C007, C013, P01
Exact missing evidence or next action
No third consumer-fee category established

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-10 Saved research record

Registration/bond costs versus consumer fees

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered boundary
Claims/models
C013
Exact missing evidence or next action
Registration/bond compliance itself deferred

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-11 Saved research record

Inflation/indexing

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered for read authorities
Claims/models
C004
Exact missing evidence or next action
No applicable DMP notice found; broader notice sweep not certified

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-12 Saved research record

2007 fee enactment/effective date

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Claims/models
C002
Exact missing evidence or next action
None within the stated provision

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-13 Saved research record

2008 funds amendment/effective date

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Claims/models
C003
Exact missing evidence or next action
None within the stated provision

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-14 Saved research record

Selected 2009 historical effective-date chain

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Partial
Claims/models
S010
Exact missing evidence or next action
Complete applicable general/specific date analysis; no guessed date used

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-15 Saved research record

Current 2026 regular-session check

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered narrowly
Claims/models
C001
Exact missing evidence or next action
Complete later/special-session consolidation remains separate

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-16 Saved research record

Written agreement and disclosures

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered for ledger purposes
Claims/models
C007–C008
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual executed agreement and assessment records

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-17 Saved research record

Extra origination/modification fees

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Claims/models
C027
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual modification facts and applicable limited exception

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-18 Saved research record

Monthly advance threshold

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Claims/models
C015, P06
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual agreement due date

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-19 Saved research record

Biweekly advance threshold

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Claims/models
C015, P07
Exact missing evidence or next action
Same

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-20 Saved research record

Weekly advance threshold

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Claims/models
C015, P08
Exact missing evidence or next action
Same

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-21 Saved research record

Variable-payment calculation

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered with boundary
Claims/models
C016, P09
Exact missing evidence or next action
Date/intent facts; no-history average unresolved

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-22 Saved research record

Thirty-day obligation exception

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered conditionally
Claims/models
C017
Exact missing evidence or next action
Evidence of debtor intent and contractual obligation

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-23 Saved research record

Weekly/biweekly monthly aggregation

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered in principle
Claims/models
C041, P05
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual monthly base and irregular-month treatment

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-24 Saved research record

Recurring living-expense handling

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered for statutory list
Claims/models
C014, P10
Exact missing evidence or next action
Any additional commissioner-rule categories not exhaustively reviewed

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-25 Saved research record

Custody receipt versus fee earning

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered analytically
Claims/models
C020, C035
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual transaction and subledger records

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-26 Saved research record

Availability versus receipt clocks

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Claims/models
C020–C021
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual receipt/availability dates and any return

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-27 Saved research record

Trust-to-provider/creditor/debtor routing

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered narrowly
Claims/models
C020
Exact missing evidence or next action
Full trust controls and bank documentation deferred

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-28 Saved research record

Creditor distribution deadline

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Claims/models
C021
Exact missing evidence or next action
Creditor due dates and actual credits

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-29 Saved research record

Accumulation/returned-payment exceptions

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered textually
Claims/models
C021
Exact missing evidence or next action
Fact-specific reasonable/net-interest evidence

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-30 Saved research record

Creditor consent

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Claims/models
C018
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual binding concessions and consent evidence

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-31 Saved research record

Withdrawal/refusal notice

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Claims/models
C019
Exact missing evidence or next action
Date learned and notices

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-32 Saved research record

Direct-creditor/noncustodial branch

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Partial
Claims/models
C006, P11
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual service, representations, delegation and control

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-33 Saved research record

Insufficient payment

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Partial application
Claims/models
C042, P12
Exact missing evidence or next action
Contractual monthly-base and earning facts

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-34 Saved research record

Late/missed/NSF payment

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered for modeled facts
Claims/models
P13, M04
Exact missing evidence or next action
Real creditor consequences and bank reconciliation

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-35 Saved research record

Monthly/final accounting

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Claims/models
C022
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual statements not supplied

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-36 Saved research record

Ordinary debtor cancellation

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Claims/models
C023, C025
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual notice/effective date and lawful prior fees

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-37 Saved research record

Provider cancellation

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Claims/models
C024
Exact missing evidence or next action
Good cause and thirty-day notice

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-38 Saved research record

Automatic termination

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Claims/models
C024
Exact missing evidence or next action
Proof all listed debts and lawful fees paid

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-39 Saved research record

Material-violation rescission

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered narrowly
Claims/models
C026
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual material violation and exercise of rescission

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-40 Saved research record

Federal actor/service/telephone coverage

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered conditionally
Claims/models
C028–C029
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual entity and campaign facts

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-41 Saved research record

Federal DMP first-fee trigger

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered for described DMP
Claims/models
C030–C032
Exact missing evidence or next action
Executed binding plan and qualifying first payment

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-42 Saved research record

DMP subsequent servicing fees

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered federally, state limits separate
Claims/models
C032
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual service/contract/state compliance

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-43 Saved research record

Staggered creditor participation

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Unresolved application
Claims/models
C030–C032
Exact missing evidence or next action
Whether individual-debt treatment applies and corresponding records

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-44 Saved research record

Pre-trigger dedicated account

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Partial
Claims/models
C033
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual ownership, administration, independence and account terms

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-45 Saved research record

Bank-debit authorization

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered narrowly
Claims/models
C034
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual consent; other payment-rail requirements deferred

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-46 Saved research record

P01 nominal enrollment posture

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Completed
Claims/models
P01
Exact missing evidence or next action
Hypothetical only

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-47 Saved research record

P02–P04 initial-payment postures

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Completed with separate-fee hold
Claims/models
P02–P04
Exact missing evidence or next action
M01–M03 specify assumptions

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-48 Saved research record

P05 cadence posture

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Completed
Claims/models
P05
Exact missing evidence or next action
Irregular-month interpretation remains open

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-49 Saved research record

P06–P09 advance-payment postures

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Completed conditionally
Claims/models
P06–P09
Exact missing evidence or next action
Date/intent/history facts stated or held

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-50 Saved research record

P10–P11 living-expense/direct-pay postures

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Completed with classification limits
Claims/models
P10–P11
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual service/account facts

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-51 Saved research record

P12–P14 shortage/failure/exit postures

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Completed
Claims/models
P12–P14
Exact missing evidence or next action
Real contract and creditor facts

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-52 Saved research record

M01 $300 adversarial joint ledger

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Completed
Claims/models
C037
Exact missing evidence or next action
Not actual fee approval

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-53 Saved research record

M02 larger initial joint ledger

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Completed conditionally
Claims/models
C038
Exact missing evidence or next action
Reasonableness and other assumptions essential

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-54 Saved research record

M03 separate-fee candidate

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Completed; authority held
Claims/models
C039
Exact missing evidence or next action
Responsive classification authority

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-55 Saved research record

M04 missed-payment/cancellation ledger

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Completed conditionally
Claims/models
C040
Exact missing evidence or next action
Waivers/concessions are stipulated, not universal

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-56 Saved research record

P01 E05 crosswalk

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Completed
Claims/models
C043
Exact missing evidence or next action
Original preserved

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-57 Saved research record

P01 E06 crosswalk

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Completed
Claims/models
C044
Exact missing evidence or next action
Original preserved

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-58 Saved research record

Responsive judicial/administrative interpretation

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Not located in bounded search
Claims/models
C036
Exact missing evidence or next action
Further official published-opinion/Commerce-order research on exact issue

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-59 Saved research record

P05 settlement-performance component

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Excluded; not a premise
Claims/models
C045
Exact missing evidence or next action
Separate review remains separate

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-60 Saved research record

NMLS/current provider status/2026 transition

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Deferred/preserved
Claims/models
C045
Exact missing evidence or next action
P02/P04 holds unchanged

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-61 Saved research record

Full trust/bond compliance

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Deferred
Claims/models
C045
Exact missing evidence or next action
Account-control, bond and broader supervision component

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-62 Saved research record

Nonprofit/attorney registration and exemptions

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Deferred
Claims/models
C045
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual entity/activity qualification

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-63 Saved research record

CROA and broader federal credit repair

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Deferred boundary
Claims/models
C045
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual representations and separate operative review

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-64 Saved research record

Collection/litigation/wage/bank/other property

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Deferred
Claims/models
C045
Exact missing evidence or next action
Separate parent-state components

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted
coverage-65 Saved research record

Sector/local/tribal and remaining state dimensions

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Deferred
Claims/models
C045
Exact missing evidence or next action
No completion or acceptance by implication

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
scoped_review_complete_with_material_evidence_holds;not_accepted

Corrections, review and scope

Read the evidence with its boundaries. These are saved research components, including revisions. A scoped coordinator review checks selected evidence; it does not certify every claim, a complete jurisdiction, current law or individual applicability. Dates and access limits remain attached to the records.

How to read the research →

No currently queued material correction is mapped to this component. This does not remove its currentness, access, jurisdiction or application limits.

Recorded review disposition

scoped review complete separate initial fee earning currentness notice holds

Other components in this research series

S_MNpass-01

SMN — Minnesota Debt Settlement and Debt Management

Inside: A. Substantive findings · 1. Minnesota regulates settlement and debt management separately · 2. Minnesota is a registration state for covered debt settlement services

6 tables20 claim records11 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-25
S_MNpass-02

SMN — Minnesota

Inside: 2026 registration amendments, effective date, and incorporated exemptions · Focused disposition · 1. Replacement for PASS-01 section 4 currentness discussion

8 tables18 claim records13 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MNpass-03

Minnesota: correction of PASS-02 research and access dates

Inside:

1 tables0 claim records0 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MNpass-04

SMN — Minnesota

Inside: Current public registration materials, transition evidence, and status-verification procedure · Focused disposition · 1. Current public application, checklist, and registration instructions

11 tables22 claim records14 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MNpass-05

SMN Minnesota settlement-fee performance and partial-plan savings

Inside: 1. Principal findings · A1. Currentness and material effective dates · A2. Minnesota’s performance question

15 tables44 claim records18 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-27
S_MNpass-07

SMN Minnesota lead generation, referrals, compensation, and provider boundaries

Inside: A1. Four questions must be answered separately · A2. Lead generation is distinct from providing the service—but not necessarily unregulated · Actor/activity/required-step matrix

12 tables44 claim records25 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-27
S_MNpass-08

SMN Credit-repair representations, Minnesota CSOs, CROA, and the TSR

Inside: A. Principal conclusions · A1. Three regimes—not one interchangeable “debt relief” rule · A2. A material Minnesota amendment must be applied

20 tables58 claim records31 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-27
S_MNpass-09

SMN Custody, account controls, records, reconciliation, and security

Inside: B2. Ownership and account control: what is established · Bank-documentation gap · C1. DMP and settlement controls are not interchangeable

18 tables60 claim records36 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-27
S_MNpass-10

SMN Collection-agency, debt-buyer, and individual-collector credentials

Inside: A. Findings that control this gateway · 1. Minnesota’s collection definition is not the FDCPA definition · 2. Entity approval and individual registration have different starting rules

17 tables64 claim records47 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-27
S_MNpass-11

SMN Ordinary consumer collection communications, validation, and disputes

Inside: A. Conclusions that must remain separate · Necessary 2026 exclusion overlay · Principal-purpose buyers and knowledge

25 tables65 claim records48 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-27
S_MNpass-12

SMN Earnings garnishment, wage exemptions, and the claim–objection–hearing process

Inside: A1. Minnesota no longer has a universally applicable flat 25% ordinary-wage formula · A2. Percentage protection is automatic; a benefit-based claim is a different question · A3. Garnishment, sheriff’s levy, and attorney’s execution are different procedures

21 tables65 claim records47 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-27
S_MNpass-13

SMN Bank-account and non-earnings garnishment, exemptions, tracing, and release

Inside: A1. There are three materially different routes · A2. Automatic federal protection is not the entire exemption determination · A3. Minnesota expressly requires FIFO for specified deposited exemptions

25 tables68 claim records53 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-27
S_MNpass-14

SMN Earnings remittance, retention, exemption claims, and form harmonization

Inside: A. Focused findings · A1. The 90-day remittance instruction is enacted law, not merely informal guidance · A2. The six-business-day creditor rule is not a six-business-day employer-release rule

16 tables64 claim records44 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-27
S_MNpass-15

SMN Consumer contract and account-debt limitations, accrual, choice of law, and revival

Inside: A1. The consumer rule is broader than a debt-buyer restriction · A2. Six years is not a universal classification rule for every transaction · A3. A missed installment is not automatically acceleration of every future installment

18 tables64 claim records50 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-27
S_MNpass-16

SMN Bounded correction supplement to

Inside: A. Verified statutory correction · A1. What §571.79(h) requires · A2. Necessary surrounding discharge provisions

9 tables18 claim records9 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-27
S_MNpass-17

SMN Minnesota consumer money-debt court gateway

Inside: A1. District and conciliation court are not interchangeable · The $4,000 category is narrower than “consumer debt” · A2. Venue and jurisdiction are separate

22 tables80 claim records54 source recordsCorrections to readCaptured 2026-10-27
Record integrity

Original saved Markdown SHA-256: 6508394f656c193b74aa5b8690e4088fa4f9fba7cde06640855fbe726520aa2b. Public formatting, private-reference removal and correction annotations are separate from that immutable original.

Get debt settlement help