SettleADebt.

FIND THE EXPLANATION

Which place’s debt rules apply—and who can help?

Use the notice, agreement, and places connected to the debt to find the right court, regulator, or legal-help service.

Explore Montana information →

This address preserves a dated source document behind the guide. The complete explanation covers the questions, comparisons and next steps for this subject.

If you came here to check a specific citation, open the original archive below. It includes its source dates and recorded qualifications.

Original source archive (optional)Original working documents, complete tables and revision history
About this archive

The explanation above is written for readers. These original working documents preserve the evidence trail, including technical language, dated passages and known corrections. They have not all received independent professional review. Use the marked limits before relying on a particular rule or figure.

DETAILED RESEARCH · EVIDENCE & LIMITS INCLUDED

SMT Bounded precision and source corrections to

S_MT · pass-27Captured 2026-10-269 tables · 22 claim records · 15 source recordsScoped coordinator review completed

Read the evidence with its boundaries. These are saved research components, including revisions. A scoped coordinator review checks selected evidence; it does not certify every claim, a complete jurisdiction, current law or individual applicability. Dates and access limits remain attached to the records.

How to read the research →

S_MT PASS-27 — Bounded precision and source corrections to PASS-22

Fresh PASS-27 access date: October 26, 2026, Pacific / October 26, 2026, UTC Scope: Only the three requested correction groups affecting PASS-22. PASS-22 remains unreviewed. This patch does not accept PASS-22, PASS-23, PASS-24, or any other pending component as a legal premise.

All sixteen PASS-22 examples and their checked numerical results remain unchanged except for:

  • The express qualification added to Example 14 concerning HSA contribution timing; and
  • The labeling of Example 6’s one-third and two-thirds percentages as approximate decimal displays.

I. Effect on the original PASS-22

Group and subissue Affected PASS-22 location Correction or qualification Effect on original
1(a) Debtor-notice contents Core finding 5; notice matrix; debtor-notice coverage Add the statutorily required date of judgment, together with case name and creditor. Timing and service rules remain unchanged.
1(b) Excess proceeds Workflow row 17 and distribution language Add §25-13-402(2)’s exception: return excess unless the judgment or a court order directs otherwise. No universal debtor-return rule is created.
1(c) Converted exempt-property proceeds Core finding 13; P22-C028; proceeds matrix; coverage Restore §25-13-610(1)’s two disjunctive branches: sale; or loss/damage/destruction plus indemnification. Indemnification is not imposed on every voluntary sale.
2(a) HSA statutory interaction Core finding 11; exemption matrix; P22-C025; Example 14; coverage Read §25-13-603 together with §25-13-608(1)(l). Section 608 expressly identifies pre-suit contributions and earnings; §603 contains broader account language and its medical-expense-recovery exception. Exact treatment of post-suit contributions remains held.
2(b) HSA controlling opinion Same HSA locations Add In re Giacometto, 2017 MT 162. Its holding concerned the pre-amendment statute, and the Court expressly said the 2017 amendment would supersede that route. The old “used or will be used for care” route is not silently imported as the current contribution-timing rule.
3(a) P22 S007 URLs Source register S007 Restore separate full literal URLs for §§25-13-603, 608, 609, and 610. Locator correction.
3(b) P22 S011 URLs Source register S011 Restore separate full literal URLs for §§212.2 through 212.11 and Appendix C. Locator and clause-precision correction.
3(c) Part 212 timing and predicates P22-C037, C039, C046–C048, C052 Distinguish receipt-only initial Notice-of-Right check from account review after receipt plus sufficient identifying information; preserve §212.6’s covered-benefit predicate. No new federal framework is added.
3(d) Official forms P22 S021 and Part XI Restore two landing pages and six direct form URLs. Five Word bodies remain unread; the generic District Praecipe PDF is a 2010 summons-service form, not a bank packet. No form content or revision date is inferred.
3(e) Dorwart source omission Part X decision table; no matching source-register row Add Dorwart as a historical due-process source and add the narrow Buxbaum later-treatment annotation. Current §§25-13-211 and 212 remain the operative procedure.
3(f) Dean provenance P22 S019; P22-C058 Confirm one-based PDF pp.7–10 / zero-based indices 6–9 and the historical joint-account/FIFO holding. Printed/PDF locator precision only.
3(g) Salminen provenance P22 S020; P22-C061 Treat the filed December 2, 2014 caption as controlling; preserve pleading-stage posture and partial reversal/remand. No automatic bank liability or damages conclusion.
3(h) Philpott and Porter P22 C054–C055 and source rows Correct majority read bounds and keep separate the statutory VA taxation clause, Porter’s creditor-process reasoning, and Justice Douglas’s separate opinion. Substantive bounded holdings preserved.
3(i) Coverage crosslinks Rows using shortened C10/C12/C14 or bare S005 Replace with full existing claim IDs and add only the missing limited-court route claims. No municipal or deposit-specific form rule is invented.
3(j) Example 6 percentages Joint-account worked example State exact fractions as 1/3 and 2/3; label 33.333% and 66.667% as approximate. $2,000 and $4,000 results remain unchanged.

GROUP 1 — Operative statutory corrections

A. Exact replacement for PASS-22 core finding 5 and debtor-notice content

Montana officer notice after execution

Within five days after executing upon the debtor’s property, the sheriff or levying officer must serve a notice that:

  1. Describes the property or money seized;
  2. States the case name, date of judgment, and judgment creditor’s name;
  3. Advises that state or federal exemptions may apply; and
  4. Explains how the debtor may claim an exemption and request a hearing.

The statute requires the date of judgment. A form may also identify the seizure or levy date for operational clarity, but that does not replace the required judgment date. Personal service and first-class mail remain authorized, and mailed notice is complete when the officer places it in the mail. Montana Code Annotated

The related §25-13-212 conclusions remain unchanged:

  • Personal service: ten days, excluding weekends and holidays, from actual receipt;
  • Mail: ten days, excluding weekends and holidays, from the officer’s mailing date;
  • Same-day copies to the creditor or counsel and the sheriff or levying officer;
  • Hearing within ten days, excluding weekends and holidays, after the court receives the request; and
  • An untimely state claim is barred in the seized property.

No actual calendar is calculated, and filing the request is not converted into an indefinite automatic stay.

Claim effect

  • P22-C013 remains correct: officer notice is due within five days.
  • P22-C014 remains correct: mailed notice is complete upon mailing.
  • P27-C001 supplies the missing required-content proposition.

B. Exact replacement for PASS-22 workflow row 17

Distribution after the statutory hold

After the statutory hold expires and no contrary exemption, ownership, federal-protection, or court order remains pending, the officer may distribute lawful nonexempt proceeds toward the judgment. Any amount exceeding the judgment and accruing costs must be returned to the judgment debtor unless otherwise directed by the judgment or an order of the court. Montana Code Annotated

This qualification preserves:

  • A judgment’s express distribution terms;
  • A court’s priority or interpleader order;
  • A pending exemption or third-party ownership ruling;
  • Legally established superior interests;
  • The officer’s applicable hold; and
  • The difference between partial and full judgment satisfaction.

Corrected workflow row

Stage Actor Trigger Required action Consequence
17. Distribution Sheriff or levying officer Hold expires and no contrary order remains Apply lawful nonexempt proceeds as directed by statute, judgment, and court order Return true excess to the debtor unless the judgment or court order directs otherwise

No bank-default, damages, fee, or universal-return theory is added.

C. Exact replacement for PASS-22 core finding 13 and P22-C028

Six-month converted-property proceeds: two statutory branches

MCA §25-13-610(1) supplies a six-month traceable-proceeds exemption through two distinct branches:

Branch 1 — exempt property was sold

If property exempt under §§25-13-608 or 25-13-609 has been sold, the debtor is entitled for six months to an exemption in proceeds that remain traceable.

The sale branch does not textually require that the debtor also have been “indemnified.”

Branch 2 — exempt property was lost, damaged, or destroyed and the debtor was indemnified

If exempt property has been lost, damaged, or destroyed and the debtor has been indemnified, the debtor is entitled for six months to the traceable indemnity proceeds.

Thus, the statute should not be compressed into a cumulative formula requiring that every exempt-property proceeds claim involve sale, loss, damage, destruction, and indemnification. Montana Code Annotated

Unchanged neighboring rules

  • Exempt wages retain their exemption for 45 days after receipt while traceable.
  • The debtor may select FIFO, LIFO, or another reasonable tracing method.
  • Section 25-13-610 does not establish a universal six-month exemption for all money deposited into a bank account.
  • The underlying property must itself have been exempt under §25-13-608 or §25-13-609.

Corrected P22-C028

MCA §25-13-610(1) creates a six-month traceable-proceeds exemption when qualifying exempt property either (a) has been sold, or (b) has been lost, damaged, or destroyed and the debtor has been indemnified. Indemnification is not an additional predicate for the sale branch.

Corrected proceeds matrix row

Source event Additional statutory predicate Duration Tracing
Exempt property sold Sale proceeds remain identifiable as proceeds of the exempt property 6 months FIFO, LIFO, or another reasonable method
Exempt property lost, damaged, or destroyed Debtor has been indemnified and the indemnity remains traceable 6 months FIFO, LIFO, or another reasonable method
Exempt wages deposited Portion was exempt under the wage statute and remains traceable 45 days FIFO, LIFO, or another reasonable method

GROUP 2 — HSA statutory interaction and controlling authority

A. Exact replacement for PASS-22 core finding 11 and exemption-matrix HSA row

Current HSA/MCSA/MSA exemption requires both current provisions to be read

Section 25-13-603 broadly provides that a qualifying Montana medical care savings account, federal HSA, or medical savings account:

  • Is exempt from creditor processes;
  • Is not liable to attachment, garnishment, or similar process;
  • May not be seized or applied to an account holder’s or beneficiary’s debt;
  • Includes rights to hold or receive the account’s assets, income, and funds paid into or out of the account; and
  • Is subject to an exception when the process seeks recovery of eligible medical expenses incurred from that account. Montana Code Annotated

Section 25-13-608(1)(l), however, places these accounts in the general execution-exemption list “as provided in 25-13-603” and expressly refers to:

  • Contributions made before the suit resulting in judgment was filed; and
  • Earnings on those contributions. Montana Code Annotated

These two current provisions must be read together. Calling an account a “qualifying HSA” does not by itself resolve:

  • When each contribution was made;
  • Which earnings derive from pre-suit contributions;
  • Whether the creditor’s claim is for eligible medical expenses incurred from the account; or
  • How the broad language in §603 interacts with §608(1)(l) for post-suit contributions.

Current application held

A bounded search located no post-amendment Montana appellate holding squarely deciding whether:

  1. Section 603 independently protects post-suit contributions despite §608(1)(l);
  2. Section 608(1)(l) limits the ordinary-execution exemption to pre-suit contributions and their earnings; or
  3. The provisions operate through another harmonized construction.

Therefore:

  • Pre-suit contributions and earnings on them are expressly within §608(1)(l), subject to §603’s account qualification and medical-expense-recovery exception.
  • Post-suit contributions are neither categorically declared protected nor categorically declared nonexempt in this correction.
  • Actual contribution dates and earnings records remain necessary.

B. Controlling opinion qualification — In re Giacometto

In In re John Charles Giacometto, 2017 MT 162, the Montana Supreme Court held under the pre-amendment version of §25-13-608(1)(f) that an HSA could be exempt to the extent it was used or would be used for qualifying medical care. The Court then expressly observed that the 2017 legislation added a more specific savings-account exemption and would supersede the applicability of the former §608(1)(f) route to such accounts. The relevant amendment discussion is at ¶14, printed opinion page 7 / zero-based PDF index 6; the pre-amendment holding is at ¶15, printed page 8 / PDF index 7. Justia Law+2

Accordingly:

  • Giacometto remains controlling for its pre-amendment facts and Montana’s liberal-construction background.
  • It does not decide the current interaction between §§25-13-603 and 25-13-608(1)(l).
  • Its old “used or will be used to pay for care” holding should not be substituted for the current contribution-timing text.
  • The current §603(3) eligible-medical-expense recovery exception remains independently relevant.

C. Corrected P22-C025

A qualifying MCSA, HSA, or MSA receives broad account protection under §25-13-603, subject to its eligible-medical-expense recovery exception. Section 25-13-608(1)(l), while incorporating §603, expressly identifies contributions made before the suit resulting in judgment and earnings on those contributions. Pre-suit contributions and earnings are textually covered; the exact treatment of post-suit contributions under the two current provisions remains unresolved absent controlling post-amendment authority.

Confidence: High for both current statutory texts and Giacometto’s pre-amendment/supersession statement; unresolved for the current post-suit-contribution application.

D. Exact replacement for PASS-22 Example 14

Example 14 — HSA with contribution timing and debt type held

Assumptions

  • Account balance: $2,500.00.
  • The account otherwise satisfies the applicable MCSA/HSA/MSA definition.
  • The judgment arises from an ordinary credit-card claim.
  • The creditor is not seeking recovery of eligible medical expenses incurred from that account.
  • Contribution dates and the allocation of earnings are initially unknown.
Branch A — the full $2,500.00 consists of pre-suit contributions and earnings on those contributions

Section 25-13-608(1)(l) expressly identifies those contributions and earnings, as provided in §25-13-603.

Conditional protected amount:

$2,500.00\boxed{$2,500.00}$2,500.00​This result still assumes account qualification and that §25-13-603(3)’s medical-expense-recovery exception does not apply.

Branch B — the $2,500.00 includes one or more post-suit contributions

The exact protected amount is held because the current interaction between §603’s broad account language and §608(1)(l)’s pre-suit-contribution language has not been resolved by controlling post-amendment authority located here.

No portion is automatically classified merely from the current balance.

Branch C — the process seeks eligible medical expenses incurred from the account

Section 25-13-603(3) supplies an express exception. No $2,500.00 exemption conclusion follows without the actual expense, account, and recovery facts.

The arithmetic and original $2,500.00 balance remain unchanged. “Qualifying account” does not resolve contribution timing or debt type.

E. Corrected HSA coverage row

Component Status after PASS-27 Claim IDs Exact remaining evidence or next action
Qualifying MCSA/HSA/MSA account protection Answered textually P27-C005, C006 Actual account type and governing documents
Pre-suit contributions and earnings Answered textually P27-C006 Contribution and earnings ledger
Post-suit contributions Unresolved P27-C008 Controlling post-2017 construction or claim-specific court ruling
Eligible-medical-expense recovery exception Answered textually P27-C007 Actual debt type and expense source
Pre-amendment Giacometto route Historical/currentness-qualified P27-C009 Do not use as current contribution-timing rule

GROUP 3 — Source, provenance, and mapping corrections

A. Replacement for PASS-22 S007

S_MT-P22-S007 — Montana exemptions and tracing

Full literal URLs:

  1. MCA §25-13-603 — Medical care, health, or medical savings accounts https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0130/part_0060/section_0030/0250-0130-0060-0030.html
  2. MCA §25-13-608 — Property exempt without limitation https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0130/part_0060/section_0080/0250-0130-0060-0080.html
  3. MCA §25-13-609 — Property exempt to specified value https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0130/part_0060/section_0090/0250-0130-0060-0090.html
  4. MCA §25-13-610 — Tracing of proceeds exempt from execution https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0130/part_0060/section_0100/0250-0130-0060-0100.html

PASS-27 status: Fresh current MCA 2025 HTML reads. Printed page and PDF index are not applicable to these HTML code pages. Material HSA and tracing clauses were read completely. Montana Code Annotated+3

B. Replacement for PASS-22 S011

S_MT-P22-S011 — 31 CFR Part 212

Full literal section URLs:

  1. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-31/subtitle-B/chapter-II/subchapter-A/part-212/section-212.2
  2. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-31/subtitle-B/chapter-II/subchapter-A/part-212/section-212.3
  3. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-31/subtitle-B/chapter-II/subchapter-A/part-212/section-212.4
  4. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-31/subtitle-B/chapter-II/subchapter-A/part-212/section-212.5
  5. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-31/subtitle-B/chapter-II/subchapter-A/part-212/section-212.6
  6. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-31/subtitle-B/chapter-II/subchapter-A/part-212/section-212.7
  7. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-31/subtitle-B/chapter-II/subchapter-A/part-212/section-212.8
  8. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-31/subtitle-B/chapter-II/subchapter-A/part-212/section-212.9
  9. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-31/subtitle-B/chapter-II/subchapter-A/part-212/section-212.10
  10. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-31/subtitle-B/chapter-II/subchapter-A/part-212/section-212.11
  11. Appendix C https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-31/subtitle-B/chapter-II/subchapter-A/part-212/appendix-Appendix%20C%20to%20Part%20212

Fresh PASS-27 status: eCFR displayed the regulation as current through October 22, 2026, with Title 31 last amended October 15, 2026. HTML pages have no printed-page or PDF-index locator. eCFR+10

Precise operational qualifications

Original P22 claim Precise qualification
P22-C037 — initial check Section 212.4 requires the bank, no later than two business days after receipt of the order, and before other action, to determine whether the order contains the required Notice of Right to Garnish Federal Benefits.
P22-C039 — account review Section 212.5(a) generally requires review within two business days after the bank has received both the order and sufficient identifying information. Creditor-authorized batch processing can affect timing.
P22-C047/C048 — no-repeat and no-continuing rules Section 212.6’s operative protections—including no repeated action on the same order and no continuing garnishment of later deposits—apply when the account review shows that a benefit agency deposited a covered benefit during the lookback period.
P22-C046 — bank notice Section 212.7 notice is required only if all three predicates exist: a covered deposit during the lookback; a positive balance and protected amount; and funds above the protected amount.
P22-C052 — records Section 212.11 requires sufficient compliance records for at least two years from receipt of the garnishment order.

These are clause-precision corrections, not a new federal benefits report.

C. Replacement for PASS-22 S021 and form inventory

Official landing pages

Direct form URLs

  1. https://courts.mt.gov/external/library/forms/civil/city_jp/writ_exe.doc
  2. https://courts.mt.gov/external/library/forms/civil/district/writ_exec.doc
  3. https://courts.mt.gov/external/library/forms/civil/district/execution.doc
  4. https://courts.mt.gov/external/library/forms/civil/district/seizure.doc
  5. https://courts.mt.gov/external/library/forms/civil/city_jp/praecipe.doc
  6. https://courts.mt.gov/external/library/forms/civil/district/praecipe.pdf

Access qualification:

  • The two official landing pages were freshly read.
  • The five Word documents returned unsupported Word-document bodies; their text, revision dates, and every field remain not read.
  • The generic District Praecipe PDF was freshly read and visually inspected. It is two pages, marked 09/10/10, and addresses summons-service information. It is not a bank-garnishment packet or authority for bank duties, fees, answers, or federal-benefit review. Montana Courts+3

No current statewide form specifically titled “bank answer,” “bank interrogatories,” “federal benefit account review,” or “bank processing fee” was identified on those official pages.

D. Added Dorwart source and bounded later treatment

Historical due-process source

Dorwart v. Caraway, 1998 MT 191, Montana Supreme Court:

Material locations freshly verified:

  • ¶¶74–76: displayed PDF p.25 / zero-based PDF index 24;
  • ¶¶93–94: displayed PDF p.31 / index 30;
  • ¶¶95–98: displayed PDF p.32 / index 31;
  • ¶¶99–101: displayed PDF p.33 / index 32;
  • ¶¶102–103: displayed PDF p.34 / index 33.

The opinion recognized a protected property interest in statutory execution exemptions and held the former postjudgment procedure constitutionally inadequate because it lacked proper notice and a prompt hearing route. Current §§25-13-211 and 212 were enacted after the challenged procedure and now supply the operative statutory notice and hearing framework. Justia Law+4

Narrow later-treatment annotation

Trustees of Indiana University v. Buxbaum, 2003 MT 97, ¶46:

https://law.justia.com/cases/montana/supreme-court/2003/eff955bb-6f26-4929-9f2d-b920b9e3977c.html

Buxbaum overruled Dorwart only to the extent Dorwart was inconsistent with discretionary attorney-fee authority under the Uniform Declaratory Judgments Act, MCA §27-8-313. It did not overrule Dorwart’s execution-related due-process holdings. Printed-page and PDF-index locators were not separately authenticated because PASS-27 read the HTML opinion at ¶46. Justia Law

No complete citator claim is made.

E. Dean, Salminen, Philpott, and Porter source annotations

1. Dean v. Hoepfner

Material opinion pages were freshly inspected at printed PDF pp.7–10 / zero-based indices 6–9. The decision supports the historical proposition that traceable Social Security funds—including a spouse’s benefits—in a joint account could retain protection and that a reasonable FIFO tracing approach was permissible. The judgment was affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded. It does not make every unidentified joint-account balance exempt. Justia Law+3

2. Salminen v. Morrison & Frampton, PLLP

The filed caption controls: 2014 MT 323, filed December 2, 2014. The PDF’s legacy “PROPOSED OPINION” metadata does not change the filed status.

Read bounds:

  • ¶¶23–33: printed pp.10–15 / PDF indices 9–14;
  • ¶34: printed p.16 / index 15;
  • ¶36 disposition: printed p.17 / index 16.

The Court reversed in part, affirmed in part, and remanded. Its execution and private-property discussion arose at the pleading stage. It does not establish automatic bank liability, conversion damages, or relief for every delayed exemption determination. Paragraph 34 separately affirmed dismissal of the constitutional claim. Justia Law+7

3. Philpott v. Essex County Welfare Board

https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-409/pdf/USREPORTS-409-413.pdf

Majority read bounds: printed pp.415–417 / zero-based PDF indices 2–4. The Court held that deposited Social Security funds remained protected where they retained the quality of money and were readily withdrawable. The holding does not protect unrelated funds or eliminate source-tracing requirements. GovInfo

4. Porter v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.

https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-370/pdf/USREPORTS-370-159.pdf

Majority read bounds: printed pp.159–162 / zero-based PDF indices 0–3. The majority protected deposited veterans’ benefits while they remained readily available for support and maintenance and retained the qualities of money rather than becoming permanent investments.

Justice Douglas’s separate writing begins after the majority’s conclusion on printed p.162 / PDF index 3 and must not be attributed to the majority. The statutory provision concerning property purchased with VA benefits as to taxation is distinct from Porter’s creditor-process analysis of permanent investment. GovInfo

F. Federal benefit statute access annotation

The following are retained as coordinator-reported dated primary-source reuse, not new PASS-27 reads:

Also retained as dated reuse:

The reported OLRC headers were:

  • §§407 and 1383: laws through Public Law 119-124, October 15, 2026;
  • §§352, 8346, and 8470: laws through Public Law 119-120, October 7, 2026.

No GovInfo edition year, later-amendment completeness, or current VA OLRC header is inferred beyond those attributed checks.

G. Coverage-claim crosslink replacements

PASS-22 coverage row Original shorthand Replacement
Officer’s ten-day hold C12 S_MT-P22-C012, sourced to P22-S002, MCA §25-13-402(4)
Mailed debtor notice C14 S_MT-P22-C014, sourced to P22-S003, MCA §25-13-211(2)
Ordinary bank levy not continuing C10 S_MT-P22-C010, sourced to P22-S002, MCA §25-13-402(3), contrasted with wage/state-payment subsections
Justice/City execution route C001, S005 S_MT-P22-C001 plus S_MT-P27-C012, sourced to Justice/City Rule 23
Small Claims enforcement S005 S_MT-P27-C013, sourced to MCA §25-35-807
Six-month converted-property proceeds C028 S_MT-P27-C003 and C004, replacing P22-C028’s cumulative phrasing
HSA account protection C025 S_MT-P27-C005–C009, replacing the unqualified account label

Limited-court sources

Justice/City Rule 23:

https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0230/part_0010/section_0230/0250-0230-0010-0230.html

Small Claims enforcement:

https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0350/part_0080/section_0070/0250-0350-0080-0070.html

Rule 23 permits statewide execution after docketed judgment under the limited-court writ procedure. Section 25-35-807 sends Small Claims judgment enforcement to Justice Court execution law. These provisions do not resolve the still-held municipal and bank-specific form questions. Montana Code Annotated+1

H. Example 6 percentage-label correction

The original dollar inputs remain:

  • Debtor contribution: $2,000;
  • Nondebtor contribution: $4,000;
  • Total: $6,000.

Exact fractions:

$2,000$6,000=13\frac{$2,000}{$6,000}=\frac13$6,000$2,000​=31​$4,000$6,000=23\frac{$4,000}{$6,000}=\frac23$6,000$4,000​=32​Decimal displays:

13≈33.333%\frac13\approx 33.333%31​≈33.333%23≈66.667%\frac23\approx 66.667%32​≈66.667%The dollar shares remain exactly:

  • Debtor: $2,000;
  • Nondebtor: $4,000.

The percentages must be labeled approximately because the exact decimals repeat. Montana’s ownership rule remains based on net contributions unless clear and convincing evidence shows a different intent. Montana Code Annotated

IV. PASS-27 source register

Source ID Authority, issuer, full literal URL, and pinpoint Version/status and access classification Read bounds and limits
S_MT-P27-S001 MCA §25-13-211, Montana Legislature. https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0130/part_0020/section_0110/0250-0130-0020-0110.html Fresh PASS-27 public read, October 26, 2026 Pacific/UTC; current MCA 2025 HTML Complete section. HTML: printed page/PDF index not applicable. Montana Code Annotated
S_MT-P27-S002 MCA §25-13-402, Montana Legislature. https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0130/part_0040/section_0020/0250-0130-0040-0020.html Fresh PASS-27 public read Complete material subsections, including snapshot levy, return exception, repeated levy, and wage/state-payment distinctions. Montana Code Annotated
S_MT-P27-S003 MCA §§25-13-603, 608, 609, 610, Montana Legislature. Full URLs reproduced in Group 3.A. Fresh PASS-27 public reads Complete material HSA, exemption, value-limited-property, and tracing clauses. HTML; no PDF locator. Montana Code Annotated+3
S_MT-P27-S004 In re John Charles Giacometto, 2017 MT 162, Montana Supreme Court. HTML: https://law.justia.com/cases/montana/supreme-court/2017/op-16-0709.html; PDF: https://cases.justia.com/montana/supreme-court/2017-op-16-0709.pdf?ts=1498777360 Fresh PASS-27 full opinion read and page inspection ¶14 printed p.7/PDF index 6; ¶15 p.8/index 7. Pre-amendment certified question; majority said 2017 legislation superseded the old route. Justia Law+2
S_MT-P27-S005 Justice/City Rule 23 and MCA §25-35-807, Montana Legislature. https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0230/part_0010/section_0230/0250-0230-0010-0230.html; https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0350/part_0080/section_0070/0250-0350-0080-0070.html Fresh PASS-27 public reads Limited route and Small Claims cross-reference only. No municipal or bank-answer form inferred. Montana Code Annotated+1
S_MT-P27-S006 MCA §72-6-211, Montana Legislature. https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0720/chapter_0060/part_0020/section_0110/0720-0060-0020-0110.html Fresh PASS-27 public read Complete lifetime beneficial-ownership provision. HTML; no PDF locator. Montana Code Annotated
S_MT-P27-S007 31 CFR Part 212 §§212.2–212.11 and Appendix C, eCFR. Full URLs reproduced in Group 3.B. Fresh PASS-27 public reads; eCFR current through October 22, 2026, last amended October 15, 2026 Complete material operational clauses. HTML; no printed page/PDF index. eCFR+9
S_MT-P27-S008 Montana Judicial Branch judgment/forms resources and six direct form URLs, full URLs in Group 3.C. Landing pages and generic PDF freshly read; five Word bodies failed/not read Generic Praecipe printed pp.1–2/PDF indices 0–1, dated 09/10/10; summons-service form, not bank packet. Montana Courts+3
S_MT-P27-S009 Dorwart v. Caraway, 1998 MT 191, full HTML/PDF URLs in Group 3.D. Fresh PASS-27 opinion and page-image read; historical currentness ¶¶74–76 displayed PDF p.25/index 24; ¶¶93–103 displayed pp.31–34/indices 30–33. Current §§211–212 postdate challenged regime. Justia Law+4
S_MT-P27-S010 Trustees of Indiana University v. Buxbaum, 2003 MT 97, https://law.justia.com/cases/montana/supreme-court/2003/eff955bb-6f26-4929-9f2d-b920b9e3977c.html Fresh PASS-27 HTML read ¶46; HTML only, printed page/PDF index not authenticated. Narrow fee-proposition overruling. Justia Law
S_MT-P27-S011 Dean v. Hoepfner, full HTML/PDF URLs in Group 3.E. Fresh PASS-27 full opinion/PDF-page read Printed PDF pp.7–10 / indices 6–9. Historical source/tracing facts. Justia Law+3
S_MT-P27-S012 Salminen v. Morrison & Frampton, PLLP, 2014 MT 323, full HTML/PDF URLs in Group 3.E. Fresh PASS-27 full opinion/page read ¶¶23–33 pp.10–15/indices 9–14; ¶34 p.16/index 15; ¶36 p.17/index 16. Filed Dec. 2, 2014. Justia Law+3
S_MT-P27-S013 Philpott v. Essex County Welfare Board, 409 U.S. 413 (1973), https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-409/pdf/USREPORTS-409-413.pdf Fresh PASS-27 official U.S. Reports read Majority printed pp.415–417/PDF indices 2–4. GovInfo
S_MT-P27-S014 Porter v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co., 370 U.S. 159 (1962), https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-370/pdf/USREPORTS-370-159.pdf Fresh PASS-27 official U.S. Reports read Majority printed pp.159–162/PDF indices 0–3; separate opinion begins at p.162/index 3. GovInfo
S_MT-P27-S015 Federal benefit statutes, exact GovInfo and OLRC URLs in Group 3.F. Coordinator-reported dated reuse, not fresh PASS-27 reads Pinpoints and header dates preserved exactly as attributed; no later-amendment completeness inferred.

V. PASS-27 claim register

Claim ID Affected original P22 location or claim Precise corrected claim Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
S_MT-P27-C001 Core 5; notice matrix; P22-C013/C014 context Officer notice must state case name, date of judgment, and creditor; seizure date is not a substitute. P27-S001, §25-13-211(1)(b). High.
S_MT-P27-C002 Workflow row 17 True excess is returned unless the judgment or court order directs otherwise. P27-S002, §25-13-402(2). High.
S_MT-P27-C003 Replaces P22-C028 in part Six-month tracing applies when qualifying exempt property has been sold, without adding indemnification as a sale predicate. P27-S003, §25-13-610(1). High.
S_MT-P27-C004 Replaces P22-C028 in part For property lost, damaged, or destroyed, six-month tracing requires that the debtor was indemnified. P27-S003, §25-13-610(1). High.
S_MT-P27-C005 Qualifies P22-C025 Section 603 broadly protects qualifying savings-account rights, assets, income, and funds, subject to the eligible-medical-expense recovery exception. P27-S003, §25-13-603. High.
S_MT-P27-C006 Qualifies P22-C025 Section 608(1)(l) expressly identifies pre-suit contributions and earnings on them, as provided in §603. P27-S003, §25-13-608(1)(l). High.
S_MT-P27-C007 Core 11; Example 14 Section 603 does not apply to the extent process seeks recovery of eligible medical expenses incurred from the account. P27-S003, §25-13-603(3). High.
S_MT-P27-C008 Example 14 and HSA coverage Exact protection for post-suit contributions under current §§603 and 608(1)(l) remains unresolved. Current texts plus bounded search. High as a gap statement.
S_MT-P27-C009 HSA currentness Giacometto construed pre-amendment §608(1)(f) and expressly said the 2017 amendment would supersede that route. P27-S004, ¶¶14–15. High.
S_MT-P27-C010 P22-C037/C039 §212.4’s initial check follows receipt of the order; §212.5 account review follows receipt plus sufficient identifying information. P27-S007, §§212.4–212.5. High.
S_MT-P27-C011 P22-C047/C048 Section 212.6’s same-order/no-continuing rules depend on the review finding a covered benefit deposit. P27-S007, §212.6 lead-in, (f)–(g). High.
S_MT-P27-C012 Replaces bare S005 in Justice/City coverage Justice/City execution proceeds under Rule 23 after docketed judgment and issuance of the limited-court writ. P27-S005, Rule 23. High; bank-specific form remains held.
S_MT-P27-C013 Replaces bare S005 in Small Claims coverage Small Claims judgment collection follows Justice Court execution law. P27-S005, §25-35-807. High.
S_MT-P27-C014 Adds missing Dorwart crosslink Dorwart historically recognized a protected interest in execution exemptions and the need for adequate notice and prompt hearing. P27-S009, ¶¶74–76, 93–103. High historical holding.
S_MT-P27-C015 Dorwart later treatment Buxbaum overruled only Dorwart’s inconsistent UDJA attorney-fee proposition, not its due-process holding. P27-S010, ¶46. High and bounded.
S_MT-P27-C016 P22-C058 Dean supports historical tracing of identifiable Social Security funds in a joint account and reasonable FIFO analysis. P27-S011, PDF pp.7–10/indices 6–9. High, fact-specific.
S_MT-P27-C017 P22-C061 Salminen was a filed opinion reversing in part, affirming in part, and remanding at the pleading stage; it does not establish automatic bank liability or damages. P27-S012, ¶¶23–36. High.
S_MT-P27-C018 P22-C054 Philpott protected deposited Social Security funds retaining the quality of money and ready withdrawal. P27-S013, pp.415–417/indices 2–4. High, source-specific.
S_MT-P27-C019 P22-C055 Porter protected deposited VA funds while readily available for support and not converted to permanent investment; separate-opinion language is not majority law. P27-S014, pp.159–162/indices 0–3. High, fact-specific.
S_MT-P27-C020 P22-C046/C052 Part 212 notice requires all three §212.7 predicates; compliance records run at least two years from receipt of the order. P27-S007, §§212.7, 212.11. High.
S_MT-P27-C021 Example 6 One-third and two-thirds are exact fractions; 33.333% and 66.667% are approximate decimal displays. Arithmetic plus P27-S006. Dollar results unchanged. High.
S_MT-P27-C022 P22 S021/forms Five official Word-form bodies and their revision dates remain unread; the 2010 generic District Praecipe is not a bank packet. P27-S008. High provenance qualification.

VI. Coverage and residual-gap table

PASS-27 subissue Status Claims Exact missing evidence or next action
Required judgment date in debtor notice Corrected C001 Actual notice and judgment record
Five-day notice timing Preserved P22-C013 Actual execution date
Personal-versus-mail claim trigger Preserved P22-C014 and original §212 claim Actual service or mailing record
Same-day copies/hearing/late claim Preserved Original P22 claims Actual filing and receipt dates
Excess-return exception Corrected C002 Judgment, court order, priorities, and final accounting
Sale proceeds branch under §610 Corrected C003 Proof that exempt property was sold and proceeds remain traceable
Casualty/indemnity branch under §610 Corrected C004 Loss, damage, destruction, indemnification, and tracing
Six-month universal bank exemption Rejected/preserved as no C003–C004 Another specific exemption must apply
Forty-five-day deposited-wage tracing Unchanged P22-C026/C027 Source, receipt date, and transaction history
HSA §603 protection Answered textually C005, C007 Actual account and debt type
HSA §608(1)(l) timing Answered textually C006 Contribution and earnings records
Post-suit HSA contributions Unresolved C008 Post-2017 controlling construction or claim-specific order
Giacometto current reach Qualified C009 Its pre-amendment route is not current timing law
Part 212 initial check/review distinction Corrected C010 Order receipt and sufficient identifying information
Part 212 no-repeat/no-continuing predicate Corrected C011 Covered-benefit finding and whether order is same/new
Part 212 notice predicates Corrected C020 Actual review balance and protected/excess amounts
Part 212 records trigger Corrected C020 Actual receipt date
Full §212 URLs Corrected C010–C011, C020 None
Justice/City route claim link Corrected C012 Actual court and writ
Small Claims route claim link Corrected C013 Actual judgment
Municipal route Still unresolved — Current municipal-specific execution authority
Official form URLs Corrected C022 Readable current form bodies and revision dates
Dorwart missing source Corrected C014 No full subsequent-history audit
Buxbaum narrow later treatment Answered C015 No complete citator
Dean locator and scope Corrected C016 Actual account tracing remains private/fact-specific
Salminen status and posture Corrected C017 Merits and later proceedings not researched
Philpott read bounds Corrected C018 Actual Social Security source and tracing
Porter majority boundary Corrected C019 Actual VA source, availability, and investment status
Federal benefit statute provenance Qualified as dated reuse Original P22 benefit claims Complete later-amendment audit if required
Example 6 percentages Corrected as approximate C021 Dollar allocation unchanged
All other sixteen examples Preserved Original P22 claims No recomputation or new assumptions
Actual bank fee/account review/service/order Unresolved Original P22 holds Actual records prohibited/outside scope
Local/tribal/country/sector rules Excluded unchanged — Separate jurisdiction-specific work
Private Part 212 cause of action Unresolved unchanged Original P22 hold Controlling cause-of-action authority
Whole bank report acceptance Not supplied — Coordinator review remains pending

VII. Self-check

Freshly read in PASS-27

  • MCA §§25-13-211, 402, 603, 608, 609, 610, 72-6-211;
  • Justice/City Rule 23 and MCA §25-35-807;
  • 31 CFR §§212.2 through 212.11 and Appendix C;
  • Montana Judicial Branch judgment and civil-form pages;
  • The generic District Praecipe PDF;
  • In re Giacometto;
  • Dorwart;
  • Buxbaum;
  • Dean;
  • Salminen;
  • Philpott; and
  • Porter.

Coordinator-reported dated reuse, not fresh PASS-27 reads

  • 38 U.S.C. §5301;
  • 45 U.S.C. §§231m and 352(e);
  • 5 U.S.C. §§8346 and 8470;
  • OLRC currentness headers for §§407, 1383, 352, 8346, and 8470.

Failed or unread

  • Five official Word-form bodies and their internal revision dates;
  • A post-amendment Montana appellate decision squarely resolving current §§25-13-603 and 608(1)(l) for post-suit HSA contributions;
  • Any actual bank account, contribution ledger, ACH coding, benefit record, order, notice, fee, ownership record, or exemption filing.

Preserved unchanged

  • All sixteen P22 examples except the two stated textual qualifications;
  • All checked dollar results;
  • The state snapshot levy;
  • State-repeat versus Part 212 same-order distinction;
  • No-continuing-garnishment rule;
  • Actual-account, source, fee, service, order, title, contribution, currentness, local, tribal, country, and private-cause holds;
  • No adoption of PASS-22, PASS-23, PASS-24, or P26 as an accepted whole.

No filing, account movement, bank instruction, exemption claim, records request, provider or person lookup, local write, independent-review conclusion, component acceptance, Montana acceptance, parent-dossier acceptance, A066 acceptance, operational approval, or publication-readiness determination occurred.

END S_MT PASS-27.

Every captured table

Captured cells with original header handling and explicitly labeled bounded correction overlays. Downloaded JSON retains original cells. Tables may contain source limitations, historical examples and identified corrections; the complete reading supplies context.

Read the evidence with its boundaries. These are saved research components, including revisions. A scoped coordinator review checks selected evidence; it does not certify every claim, a complete jurisdiction, current law or individual applicability. Dates and access limits remain attached to the records.

How to read the research →

Captured table 01

Group and subissue · Affected PASS-22 location · Correction or qualification · 15 data rows

Group and subissueAffected PASS-22 locationCorrection or qualificationEffect on original
1(a) Debtor-notice contentsCore finding 5; notice matrix; debtor-notice coverageAdd the statutorily required date of judgment, together with case name and creditor.Timing and service rules remain unchanged.
1(b) Excess proceedsWorkflow row 17 and distribution languageAdd §25-13-402(2)’s exception: return excess unless the judgment or a court order directs otherwise.No universal debtor-return rule is created.
1(c) Converted exempt-property proceedsCore finding 13; P22-C028; proceeds matrix; coverageRestore §25-13-610(1)’s two disjunctive branches: sale; or loss/damage/destruction plus indemnification.Indemnification is not imposed on every voluntary sale.
2(a) HSA statutory interactionCore finding 11; exemption matrix; P22-C025; Example 14; coverageRead §25-13-603 together with §25-13-608(1)(l). Section 608 expressly identifies pre-suit contributions and earnings; §603 contains broader account language and its medical-expense-recovery exception.Exact treatment of post-suit contributions remains held.
2(b) HSA controlling opinionSame HSA locationsAdd In re Giacometto, 2017 MT 162. Its holding concerned the pre-amendment statute, and the Court expressly said the 2017 amendment would supersede that route.The old “used or will be used for care” route is not silently imported as the current contribution-timing rule.
3(a) P22 S007 URLsSource register S007Restore separate full literal URLs for §§25-13-603, 608, 609, and 610.Locator correction.
3(b) P22 S011 URLsSource register S011Restore separate full literal URLs for §§212.2 through 212.11 and Appendix C.Locator and clause-precision correction.
3(c) Part 212 timing and predicatesP22-C037, C039, C046–C048, C052Distinguish receipt-only initial Notice-of-Right check from account review after receipt plus sufficient identifying information; preserve §212.6’s covered-benefit predicate.No new federal framework is added.
3(d) Official formsP22 S021 and Part XIRestore two landing pages and six direct form URLs. Five Word bodies remain unread; the generic District Praecipe PDF is a 2010 summons-service form, not a bank packet.No form content or revision date is inferred.
3(e) Dorwart source omissionPart X decision table; no matching source-register rowAdd Dorwart as a historical due-process source and add the narrow Buxbaum later-treatment annotation.Current §§25-13-211 and 212 remain the operative procedure.
3(f) Dean provenanceP22 S019; P22-C058Confirm one-based PDF pp.7–10 / zero-based indices 6–9 and the historical joint-account/FIFO holding.Printed/PDF locator precision only.
3(g) Salminen provenanceP22 S020; P22-C061Treat the filed December 2, 2014 caption as controlling; preserve pleading-stage posture and partial reversal/remand.No automatic bank liability or damages conclusion.
3(h) Philpott and PorterP22 C054–C055 and source rowsCorrect majority read bounds and keep separate the statutory VA taxation clause, Porter’s creditor-process reasoning, and Justice Douglas’s separate opinion.Substantive bounded holdings preserved.
3(i) Coverage crosslinksRows using shortened C10/C12/C14 or bare S005Replace with full existing claim IDs and add only the missing limited-court route claims.No municipal or deposit-specific form rule is invented.
3(j) Example 6 percentagesJoint-account worked exampleState exact fractions as 1/3 and 2/3; label 33.333% and 66.667% as approximate.$2,000 and $4,000 results remain unchanged.

Captured table 02

Stage · Actor · Trigger · 1 data rows

StageActorTriggerRequired actionConsequence
17. DistributionSheriff or levying officerHold expires and no contrary order remainsApply lawful nonexempt proceeds as directed by statute, judgment, and court orderReturn true excess to the debtor unless the judgment or court order directs otherwise

Captured table 03

Source event · Additional statutory predicate · Duration · 3 data rows

Source eventAdditional statutory predicateDurationTracing
Exempt property soldSale proceeds remain identifiable as proceeds of the exempt property6 monthsFIFO, LIFO, or another reasonable method
Exempt property lost, damaged, or destroyedDebtor has been indemnified and the indemnity remains traceable6 monthsFIFO, LIFO, or another reasonable method
Exempt wages depositedPortion was exempt under the wage statute and remains traceable45 daysFIFO, LIFO, or another reasonable method

Captured table 04

Component · Status after PASS-27 · Claim IDs · 5 data rows

ComponentStatus after PASS-27Claim IDsExact remaining evidence or next action
Qualifying MCSA/HSA/MSA account protectionAnswered textuallyP27-C005, C006Actual account type and governing documents
Pre-suit contributions and earningsAnswered textuallyP27-C006Contribution and earnings ledger
Post-suit contributionsUnresolvedP27-C008Controlling post-2017 construction or claim-specific court ruling
Eligible-medical-expense recovery exceptionAnswered textuallyP27-C007Actual debt type and expense source
Pre-amendment Giacometto routeHistorical/currentness-qualifiedP27-C009Do not use as current contribution-timing rule

Captured table 05

Original P22 claim · Precise qualification · 5 data rows

Original P22 claimPrecise qualification
P22-C037 — initial checkSection 212.4 requires the bank, no later than two business days after receipt of the order, and before other action, to determine whether the order contains the required Notice of Right to Garnish Federal Benefits.
P22-C039 — account reviewSection 212.5(a) generally requires review within two business days after the bank has received both the order and sufficient identifying information. Creditor-authorized batch processing can affect timing.
P22-C047/C048 — no-repeat and no-continuing rulesSection 212.6’s operative protections—including no repeated action on the same order and no continuing garnishment of later deposits—apply when the account review shows that a benefit agency deposited a covered benefit during the lookback period.
P22-C046 — bank noticeSection 212.7 notice is required only if all three predicates exist: a covered deposit during the lookback; a positive balance and protected amount; and funds above the protected amount.
P22-C052 — recordsSection 212.11 requires sufficient compliance records for at least two years from receipt of the garnishment order.

Captured table 06

PASS-22 coverage row · Original shorthand · Replacement · 7 data rows

PASS-22 coverage rowOriginal shorthandReplacement
Officer’s ten-day holdC12S_MT-P22-C012, sourced to P22-S002, MCA §25-13-402(4)
Mailed debtor noticeC14S_MT-P22-C014, sourced to P22-S003, MCA §25-13-211(2)
Ordinary bank levy not continuingC10S_MT-P22-C010, sourced to P22-S002, MCA §25-13-402(3), contrasted with wage/state-payment subsections
Justice/City execution routeC001, S005S_MT-P22-C001 plus S_MT-P27-C012, sourced to Justice/City Rule 23
Small Claims enforcementS005S_MT-P27-C013, sourced to MCA §25-35-807
Six-month converted-property proceedsC028S_MT-P27-C003 and C004, replacing P22-C028’s cumulative phrasing
HSA account protectionC025S_MT-P27-C005–C009, replacing the unqualified account label

Captured table 07

Source ID · Authority, issuer, full literal URL, and pinpoint · Version/status and access classification · 15 data rows

Source IDAuthority, issuer, full literal URL, and pinpointVersion/status and access classificationRead bounds and limits
S_MT-P27-S001MCA §25-13-211, Montana Legislature. https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0130/part_0020/section_0110/0250-0130-0020-0110.htmlFresh PASS-27 public read, October 26, 2026 Pacific/UTC; current MCA 2025 HTMLComplete section. HTML: printed page/PDF index not applicable. Montana Code Annotated
S_MT-P27-S002MCA §25-13-402, Montana Legislature. https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0130/part_0040/section_0020/0250-0130-0040-0020.htmlFresh PASS-27 public readComplete material subsections, including snapshot levy, return exception, repeated levy, and wage/state-payment distinctions. Montana Code Annotated
S_MT-P27-S003MCA §§25-13-603, 608, 609, 610, Montana Legislature. Full URLs reproduced in Group 3.A.Fresh PASS-27 public readsComplete material HSA, exemption, value-limited-property, and tracing clauses. HTML; no PDF locator. Montana Code Annotated +3
S_MT-P27-S004In re John Charles Giacometto, 2017 MT 162, Montana Supreme Court. HTML: https://law.justia.com/cases/montana/supreme-court/2017/op-16-0709.html; PDF: https://cases.justia.com/montana/supreme-court/2017-op-16-0709.pdf?ts=1498777360Fresh PASS-27 full opinion read and page inspection¶14 printed p.7/PDF index 6; ¶15 p.8/index 7. Pre-amendment certified question; majority said 2017 legislation superseded the old route. Justia Law +2
S_MT-P27-S005Justice/City Rule 23 and MCA §25-35-807, Montana Legislature. https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0230/part_0010/section_0230/0250-0230-0010-0230.html; https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0350/part_0080/section_0070/0250-0350-0080-0070.htmlFresh PASS-27 public readsLimited route and Small Claims cross-reference only. No municipal or bank-answer form inferred. Montana Code Annotated +1
S_MT-P27-S006MCA §72-6-211, Montana Legislature. https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0720/chapter_0060/part_0020/section_0110/0720-0060-0020-0110.htmlFresh PASS-27 public readComplete lifetime beneficial-ownership provision. HTML; no PDF locator. Montana Code Annotated
S_MT-P27-S00731 CFR Part 212 §§212.2–212.11 and Appendix C, eCFR. Full URLs reproduced in Group 3.B.Fresh PASS-27 public reads; eCFR current through October 22, 2026, last amended October 15, 2026Complete material operational clauses. HTML; no printed page/PDF index. eCFR +9
S_MT-P27-S008Montana Judicial Branch judgment/forms resources and six direct form URLs, full URLs in Group 3.C.Landing pages and generic PDF freshly read; five Word bodies failed/not readGeneric Praecipe printed pp.1–2/PDF indices 0–1, dated 09/10/10; summons-service form, not bank packet. Montana Courts +3
S_MT-P27-S009Dorwart v. Caraway, 1998 MT 191, full HTML/PDF URLs in Group 3.D.Fresh PASS-27 opinion and page-image read; historical currentness¶¶74–76 displayed PDF p.25/index 24; ¶¶93–103 displayed pp.31–34/indices 30–33. Current §§211–212 postdate challenged regime. Justia Law +4
S_MT-P27-S010Trustees of Indiana University v. Buxbaum, 2003 MT 97, https://law.justia.com/cases/montana/supreme-court/2003/eff955bb-6f26-4929-9f2d-b920b9e3977c.htmlFresh PASS-27 HTML read¶46; HTML only, printed page/PDF index not authenticated. Narrow fee-proposition overruling. Justia Law
S_MT-P27-S011Dean v. Hoepfner, full HTML/PDF URLs in Group 3.E.Fresh PASS-27 full opinion/PDF-page readPrinted PDF pp.7–10 / indices 6–9. Historical source/tracing facts. Justia Law +3
S_MT-P27-S012Salminen v. Morrison & Frampton, PLLP, 2014 MT 323, full HTML/PDF URLs in Group 3.E.Fresh PASS-27 full opinion/page read¶¶23–33 pp.10–15/indices 9–14; ¶34 p.16/index 15; ¶36 p.17/index 16. Filed Dec. 2, 2014. Justia Law +3
S_MT-P27-S013Philpott v. Essex County Welfare Board, 409 U.S. 413 (1973), https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-409/pdf/USREPORTS-409-413.pdfFresh PASS-27 official U.S. Reports readMajority printed pp.415–417/PDF indices 2–4. GovInfo
S_MT-P27-S014Porter v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co., 370 U.S. 159 (1962), https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-370/pdf/USREPORTS-370-159.pdfFresh PASS-27 official U.S. Reports readMajority printed pp.159–162/PDF indices 0–3; separate opinion begins at p.162/index 3. GovInfo
S_MT-P27-S015Federal benefit statutes, exact GovInfo and OLRC URLs in Group 3.F.Coordinator-reported dated reuse, not fresh PASS-27 readsPinpoints and header dates preserved exactly as attributed; no later-amendment completeness inferred.
Source links captured in this table

Captured table 08

Claim ID · Affected original P22 location or claim · Precise corrected claim · 22 data rows

Claim IDAffected original P22 location or claimPrecise corrected claimSource/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
S_MT-P27-C001Core 5; notice matrix; P22-C013/C014 contextOfficer notice must state case name, date of judgment, and creditor; seizure date is not a substitute.P27-S001, §25-13-211(1)(b). High.
S_MT-P27-C002Workflow row 17True excess is returned unless the judgment or court order directs otherwise.P27-S002, §25-13-402(2). High.
S_MT-P27-C003Replaces P22-C028 in partSix-month tracing applies when qualifying exempt property has been sold, without adding indemnification as a sale predicate.P27-S003, §25-13-610(1). High.
S_MT-P27-C004Replaces P22-C028 in partFor property lost, damaged, or destroyed, six-month tracing requires that the debtor was indemnified.P27-S003, §25-13-610(1). High.
S_MT-P27-C005Qualifies P22-C025Section 603 broadly protects qualifying savings-account rights, assets, income, and funds, subject to the eligible-medical-expense recovery exception.P27-S003, §25-13-603. High.
S_MT-P27-C006Qualifies P22-C025Section 608(1)(l) expressly identifies pre-suit contributions and earnings on them, as provided in §603.P27-S003, §25-13-608(1)(l). High.
S_MT-P27-C007Core 11; Example 14Section 603 does not apply to the extent process seeks recovery of eligible medical expenses incurred from the account.P27-S003, §25-13-603(3). High.
S_MT-P27-C008Example 14 and HSA coverageExact protection for post-suit contributions under current §§603 and 608(1)(l) remains unresolved.Current texts plus bounded search. High as a gap statement.
S_MT-P27-C009HSA currentnessGiacometto construed pre-amendment §608(1)(f) and expressly said the 2017 amendment would supersede that route.P27-S004, ¶¶14–15. High.
S_MT-P27-C010P22-C037/C039§212.4’s initial check follows receipt of the order; §212.5 account review follows receipt plus sufficient identifying information.P27-S007, §§212.4–212.5. High.
S_MT-P27-C011P22-C047/C048Section 212.6’s same-order/no-continuing rules depend on the review finding a covered benefit deposit.P27-S007, §212.6 lead-in, (f)–(g). High.
S_MT-P27-C012Replaces bare S005 in Justice/City coverageJustice/City execution proceeds under Rule 23 after docketed judgment and issuance of the limited-court writ.P27-S005, Rule 23. High; bank-specific form remains held.
S_MT-P27-C013Replaces bare S005 in Small Claims coverageSmall Claims judgment collection follows Justice Court execution law.P27-S005, §25-35-807. High.
S_MT-P27-C014Adds missing Dorwart crosslinkDorwart historically recognized a protected interest in execution exemptions and the need for adequate notice and prompt hearing.P27-S009, ¶¶74–76, 93–103. High historical holding.
S_MT-P27-C015Dorwart later treatmentBuxbaum overruled only Dorwart’s inconsistent UDJA attorney-fee proposition, not its due-process holding.P27-S010, ¶46. High and bounded.
S_MT-P27-C016P22-C058Dean supports historical tracing of identifiable Social Security funds in a joint account and reasonable FIFO analysis.P27-S011, PDF pp.7–10/indices 6–9. High, fact-specific.
S_MT-P27-C017P22-C061Salminen was a filed opinion reversing in part, affirming in part, and remanding at the pleading stage; it does not establish automatic bank liability or damages.P27-S012, ¶¶23–36. High.
S_MT-P27-C018P22-C054Philpott protected deposited Social Security funds retaining the quality of money and ready withdrawal.P27-S013, pp.415–417/indices 2–4. High, source-specific.
S_MT-P27-C019P22-C055Porter protected deposited VA funds while readily available for support and not converted to permanent investment; separate-opinion language is not majority law.P27-S014, pp.159–162/indices 0–3. High, fact-specific.
S_MT-P27-C020P22-C046/C052Part 212 notice requires all three §212.7 predicates; compliance records run at least two years from receipt of the order.P27-S007, §§212.7, 212.11. High.
S_MT-P27-C021Example 6One-third and two-thirds are exact fractions; 33.333% and 66.667% are approximate decimal displays.Arithmetic plus P27-S006. Dollar results unchanged. High.
S_MT-P27-C022P22 S021/formsFive official Word-form bodies and their revision dates remain unread; the 2010 generic District Praecipe is not a bank packet.P27-S008. High provenance qualification.

Captured table 09

PASS-27 subissue · Status · Claims · 35 data rows

PASS-27 subissueStatusClaimsExact missing evidence or next action
Required judgment date in debtor noticeCorrectedC001Actual notice and judgment record
Five-day notice timingPreservedP22-C013Actual execution date
Personal-versus-mail claim triggerPreservedP22-C014 and original §212 claimActual service or mailing record
Same-day copies/hearing/late claimPreservedOriginal P22 claimsActual filing and receipt dates
Excess-return exceptionCorrectedC002Judgment, court order, priorities, and final accounting
Sale proceeds branch under §610CorrectedC003Proof that exempt property was sold and proceeds remain traceable
Casualty/indemnity branch under §610CorrectedC004Loss, damage, destruction, indemnification, and tracing
Six-month universal bank exemptionRejected/preserved as noC003–C004Another specific exemption must apply
Forty-five-day deposited-wage tracingUnchangedP22-C026/C027Source, receipt date, and transaction history
HSA §603 protectionAnswered textuallyC005, C007Actual account and debt type
HSA §608(1)(l) timingAnswered textuallyC006Contribution and earnings records
Post-suit HSA contributionsUnresolvedC008Post-2017 controlling construction or claim-specific order
Giacometto current reachQualifiedC009Its pre-amendment route is not current timing law
Part 212 initial check/review distinctionCorrectedC010Order receipt and sufficient identifying information
Part 212 no-repeat/no-continuing predicateCorrectedC011Covered-benefit finding and whether order is same/new
Part 212 notice predicatesCorrectedC020Actual review balance and protected/excess amounts
Part 212 records triggerCorrectedC020Actual receipt date
Full §212 URLsCorrectedC010–C011, C020None
Justice/City route claim linkCorrectedC012Actual court and writ
Small Claims route claim linkCorrectedC013Actual judgment
Municipal routeStill unresolved—Current municipal-specific execution authority
Official form URLsCorrectedC022Readable current form bodies and revision dates
Dorwart missing sourceCorrectedC014No full subsequent-history audit
Buxbaum narrow later treatmentAnsweredC015No complete citator
Dean locator and scopeCorrectedC016Actual account tracing remains private/fact-specific
Salminen status and postureCorrectedC017Merits and later proceedings not researched
Philpott read boundsCorrectedC018Actual Social Security source and tracing
Porter majority boundaryCorrectedC019Actual VA source, availability, and investment status
Federal benefit statute provenanceQualified as dated reuseOriginal P22 benefit claimsComplete later-amendment audit if required
Example 6 percentagesCorrected as approximateC021Dollar allocation unchanged
All other sixteen examplesPreservedOriginal P22 claimsNo recomputation or new assumptions
Actual bank fee/account review/service/orderUnresolvedOriginal P22 holdsActual records prohibited/outside scope
Local/tribal/country/sector rulesExcluded unchanged—Separate jurisdiction-specific work
Private Part 212 cause of actionUnresolved unchangedOriginal P22 holdControlling cause-of-action authority
Whole bank report acceptanceNot supplied—Coordinator review remains pending

Find the assertion and its boundaries

Read the evidence with its boundaries. These are saved research components, including revisions. A scoped coordinator review checks selected evidence; it does not certify every claim, a complete jurisdiction, current law or individual applicability. Dates and access limits remain attached to the records.

How to read the research →

S_MT-P27-C001 Saved research record

Core 5; notice matrix; P22-C013/C014 context

Recorded check status: supported with express application or dated access limits

Precise corrected claim
Officer notice must state case name, date of judgment, and creditor; seizure date is not a substitute.
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
P27-S001, §25-13-211(1)(b). High.
S_MT-P27-C002 Saved research record

True excess is returned unless the judgment or court order directs otherwise.

Recorded check status: supported with express application or dated access limits

Affected original P22 location or claim
Workflow row 17
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
P27-S002, §25-13-402(2). High.
S_MT-P27-C003 Saved research record

Six-month tracing applies when qualifying exempt property has been sold, without adding indemnification as a sale predicate.

Recorded check status: supported with express application or dated access limits

Affected original P22 location or claim
Replaces P22-C028 in part
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
P27-S003, §25-13-610(1). High.
S_MT-P27-C004 Saved research record

For property lost, damaged, or destroyed, six-month tracing requires that the debtor was indemnified.

Recorded check status: supported with express application or dated access limits

Affected original P22 location or claim
Replaces P22-C028 in part
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
P27-S003, §25-13-610(1). High.
S_MT-P27-C005 Saved research record

Section 603 broadly protects qualifying savings-account rights, assets, income, and funds, subject to the eligible-medical-expense recovery exception.

Recorded check status: supported with express application or dated access limits

Affected original P22 location or claim
Qualifies P22-C025
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
P27-S003, §25-13-603. High.
S_MT-P27-C006 Saved research record

Section 608(1)(l) expressly identifies pre-suit contributions and earnings on them, as provided in §603.

Recorded check status: supported with express application or dated access limits

Affected original P22 location or claim
Qualifies P22-C025
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
P27-S003, §25-13-608(1)(l). High.
S_MT-P27-C007 Saved research record

Section 603 does not apply to the extent process seeks recovery of eligible medical expenses incurred from the account.

Recorded check status: supported with express application or dated access limits

Affected original P22 location or claim
Core 11; Example 14
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
P27-S003, §25-13-603(3). High.
S_MT-P27-C008 Saved research record

Exact protection for post-suit contributions under current §§603 and 608(1)(l) remains unresolved.

Recorded check status: explicit gap or access hold retained

Affected original P22 location or claim
Example 14 and HSA coverage
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
Current texts plus bounded search. High as a gap statement.
S_MT-P27-C009 Saved research record

Giacometto construed pre-amendment §608(1)(f) and expressly said the 2017 amendment would supersede that route.

Recorded check status: supported with express application or dated access limits

Affected original P22 location or claim
HSA currentness
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
P27-S004, ¶¶14–15. High.
S_MT-P27-C010 Saved research record

§212.4’s initial check follows receipt of the order; §212.5 account review follows receipt plus sufficient identifying information.

Recorded check status: supported with express application or dated access limits

Affected original P22 location or claim
P22-C037/C039
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
P27-S007, §§212.4–212.5. High.
S_MT-P27-C011 Saved research record

Section 212.6’s same-order/no-continuing rules depend on the review finding a covered benefit deposit.

Recorded check status: supported with express application or dated access limits

Affected original P22 location or claim
P22-C047/C048
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
P27-S007, §212.6 lead-in, (f)–(g). High.
S_MT-P27-C012 Saved research record

Replaces bare S005 in Justice/City coverage

Recorded check status: supported with express application or dated access limits

Precise corrected claim
Justice/City execution proceeds under Rule 23 after docketed judgment and issuance of the limited-court writ.
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
P27-S005, Rule 23. High; bank-specific form remains held.
S_MT-P27-C013 Saved research record

Replaces bare S005 in Small Claims coverage

Recorded check status: supported with express application or dated access limits

Precise corrected claim
Small Claims judgment collection follows Justice Court execution law.
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
P27-S005, §25-35-807. High.
S_MT-P27-C014 Saved research record

Dorwart historically recognized a protected interest in execution exemptions and the need for adequate notice and prompt hearing.

Recorded check status: supported with express application or dated access limits

Affected original P22 location or claim
Adds missing Dorwart crosslink
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
P27-S009, ¶¶74–76, 93–103. High historical holding.
S_MT-P27-C015 Saved research record

Buxbaum overruled only Dorwart’s inconsistent UDJA attorney-fee proposition, not its due-process holding.

Recorded check status: supported with express application or dated access limits

Affected original P22 location or claim
Dorwart later treatment
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
P27-S010, ¶46. High and bounded.
S_MT-P27-C016 Saved research record

Dean supports historical tracing of identifiable Social Security funds in a joint account and reasonable FIFO analysis.

Recorded check status: supported with express application or dated access limits

Affected original P22 location or claim
P22-C058
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
P27-S011, PDF pp.7–10/indices 6–9. High, fact-specific.
S_MT-P27-C017 Saved research record

Salminen was a filed opinion reversing in part, affirming in part, and remanding at the pleading stage; it does not establish automatic bank liability or damages.

Recorded check status: supported with express application or dated access limits

Affected original P22 location or claim
P22-C061
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
P27-S012, ¶¶23–36. High.
S_MT-P27-C018 Saved research record

Philpott protected deposited Social Security funds retaining the quality of money and ready withdrawal.

Recorded check status: supported with express application or dated access limits

Affected original P22 location or claim
P22-C054
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
P27-S013, pp.415–417/indices 2–4. High, source-specific.
S_MT-P27-C019 Saved research record

Porter protected deposited VA funds while readily available for support and not converted to permanent investment; separate-opinion language is not majority law.

Recorded check status: supported with express application or dated access limits

Affected original P22 location or claim
P22-C055
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
P27-S014, pp.159–162/indices 0–3. High, fact-specific.
S_MT-P27-C020 Saved research record

Part 212 notice requires all three §212.7 predicates; compliance records run at least two years from receipt of the order.

Recorded check status: supported with express application or dated access limits

Affected original P22 location or claim
P22-C046/C052
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
P27-S007, §§212.7, 212.11. High.
S_MT-P27-C021 Saved research record

One-third and two-thirds are exact fractions; 33.333% and 66.667% are approximate decimal displays.

Recorded check status: supported with express application or dated access limits

Affected original P22 location or claim
Example 6
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
Arithmetic plus P27-S006. Dollar results unchanged. High.
S_MT-P27-C022 Saved research record

Five official Word-form bodies and their revision dates remain unread; the 2010 generic District Praecipe is not a bank packet.

Recorded check status: explicit gap or access hold retained

Affected original P22 location or claim
P22 S021/forms
Source/pinpoint, consequence, confidence
P27-S008. High provenance qualification.

Sources, pinpoints and access limits

Keep the source version, actual read extent and jurisdiction with the proposition. A link or researcher access claim is not a substitute for an operative primary passage.

S_MT-P27-S001 Saved research record

MCA §25-13-211, Montana Legislature. https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0130/part_0020/section_0110/0250-0130-0020-0110.html

Recorded check status: scoped review complete substantive groups resolved with limits residual provenance mapping patch required

Version/status and access classification
Fresh PASS-27 public read, October 26, 2026 Pacific/UTC; current MCA 2025 HTML
Read bounds and limits
Complete section. HTML: printed page/PDF index not applicable. Montana Code Annotated
Direct source URLs
https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0130/part_0020/section_0110/0250-0130-0020-0110.html
https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0130/part_0020/section_0110/0250-0130-0020-0110.html?utm_source=chatgpt.com
S_MT-P27-S002 Saved research record

MCA §25-13-402, Montana Legislature. https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0130/part_0040/section_0020/0250-0130-0040-0020.html

Recorded check status: scoped review complete substantive groups resolved with limits residual provenance mapping patch required

Version/status and access classification
Fresh PASS-27 public read
Read bounds and limits
Complete material subsections, including snapshot levy, return exception, repeated levy, and wage/state-payment distinctions. Montana Code Annotated
Direct source URLs
https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0130/part_0040/section_0020/0250-0130-0040-0020.html
S_MT-P27-S003 Saved research record

MCA §§25-13-603, 608, 609, 610, Montana Legislature. Full URLs reproduced in Group 3.A.

Recorded check status: scoped review complete substantive groups resolved with limits residual provenance mapping patch required

Version/status and access classification
Fresh PASS-27 public reads
Read bounds and limits
Complete material HSA, exemption, value-limited-property, and tracing clauses. HTML; no PDF locator. Montana Code Annotated +3
Direct source URLs
https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0130/part_0060/section_0100/0250-0130-0060-0100.html
S_MT-P27-S004 Saved research record

In re John Charles Giacometto, 2017 MT 162, Montana Supreme Court. HTML: https://law.justia.com/cases/montana/supreme-court/2017/op-16-0709.html; PDF: https://cases.justia.com/montana/supreme-court/2017-op-16-0709.pdf?ts=1498777360

Recorded check status: scoped review complete substantive groups resolved with limits residual provenance mapping patch required

Version/status and access classification
Fresh PASS-27 full opinion read and page inspection
Read bounds and limits
¶14 printed p.7/PDF index 6; ¶15 p.8/index 7. Pre-amendment certified question; majority said 2017 legislation superseded the old route. Justia Law +2
Direct source URLs
https://law.justia.com/cases/montana/supreme-court/2017/op-16-0709.html
https://cases.justia.com/montana/supreme-court/2017-op-16-0709.pdf?ts=1498777360
S_MT-P27-S005 Saved research record

Justice/City Rule 23 and MCA §25-35-807, Montana Legislature. https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0230/part_0010/section_0230/0250-0230-0010-0230.html; https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0350/part_0080/section_0070/0250-0350-0080-0070.html

Recorded check status: scoped review complete substantive groups resolved with limits residual provenance mapping patch required

Version/status and access classification
Fresh PASS-27 public reads
Read bounds and limits
Limited route and Small Claims cross-reference only. No municipal or bank-answer form inferred. Montana Code Annotated +1
Direct source URLs
https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0230/part_0010/section_0230/0250-0230-0010-0230.html
https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0250/chapter_0350/part_0080/section_0070/0250-0350-0080-0070.html
S_MT-P27-S006 Saved research record

MCA §72-6-211, Montana Legislature. https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0720/chapter_0060/part_0020/section_0110/0720-0060-0020-0110.html

Recorded check status: scoped review complete substantive groups resolved with limits residual provenance mapping patch required

Version/status and access classification
Fresh PASS-27 public read
Read bounds and limits
Complete lifetime beneficial-ownership provision. HTML; no PDF locator. Montana Code Annotated
Direct source URLs
https://mca.legmt.gov/bills/mca/title_0720/chapter_0060/part_0020/section_0110/0720-0060-0020-0110.html
S_MT-P27-S007 Saved research record

31 CFR Part 212 §§212.2–212.11 and Appendix C, eCFR. Full URLs reproduced in Group 3.B.

Recorded check status: scoped review complete substantive groups resolved with limits residual provenance mapping patch required

Version/status and access classification
Fresh PASS-27 public reads; eCFR current through October 22, 2026, last amended October 15, 2026
Read bounds and limits
Complete material operational clauses. HTML; no printed page/PDF index. eCFR +9
Direct source URLs
https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-31/subtitle-B/chapter-II/subchapter-A/part-212/section-212.2
S_MT-P27-S008 Saved research record

Montana Judicial Branch judgment/forms resources and six direct form URLs, full URLs in Group 3.C.

Recorded check status: scoped review complete substantive groups resolved with limits residual provenance mapping patch required

Version/status and access classification
Landing pages and generic PDF freshly read; five Word bodies failed/not read
Read bounds and limits
Generic Praecipe printed pp.1–2/PDF indices 0–1, dated 09/10/10; summons-service form, not bank packet. Montana Courts +3
Direct source URLs
https://courts.mt.gov/forms/judgement
S_MT-P27-S009 Saved research record

Dorwart v. Caraway, 1998 MT 191, full HTML/PDF URLs in Group 3.D.

Recorded check status: scoped review complete substantive groups resolved with limits residual provenance mapping patch required

Version/status and access classification
Fresh PASS-27 opinion and page-image read; historical currentness
Read bounds and limits
¶¶74–76 displayed PDF p.25/index 24; ¶¶93–103 displayed pp.31–34/indices 30–33. Current §§211–212 postdate challenged regime. Justia Law +4
Direct source URLs
https://cases.justia.com/montana/supreme-court/1998-08-04-3D8B9983-6BAE-41CF-9DE6-2350CBF0CD89.pdf?ts=1462388683
S_MT-P27-S010 Saved research record

Trustees of Indiana University v. Buxbaum, 2003 MT 97, https://law.justia.com/cases/montana/supreme-court/2003/eff955bb-6f26-4929-9f2d-b920b9e3977c.html

Recorded check status: scoped review complete substantive groups resolved with limits residual provenance mapping patch required

Version/status and access classification
Fresh PASS-27 HTML read
Read bounds and limits
¶46; HTML only, printed page/PDF index not authenticated. Narrow fee-proposition overruling. Justia Law
Direct source URLs
https://law.justia.com/cases/montana/supreme-court/2003/eff955bb-6f26-4929-9f2d-b920b9e3977c.html
S_MT-P27-S011 Saved research record

Dean v. Hoepfner, full HTML/PDF URLs in Group 3.E.

Recorded check status: scoped review complete substantive groups resolved with limits residual provenance mapping patch required

Version/status and access classification
Fresh PASS-27 full opinion/PDF-page read
Read bounds and limits
Printed PDF pp.7–10 / indices 6–9. Historical source/tracing facts. Justia Law +3
Direct source URLs
https://cases.justia.com/montana/supreme-court/1990-11-26-880C834C-CF0A-48B3-ACB0-C37B3979DA4A.pdf?ts=1462387647
S_MT-P27-S012 Saved research record

Salminen v. Morrison & Frampton, PLLP, 2014 MT 323, full HTML/PDF URLs in Group 3.E.

Recorded check status: scoped review complete substantive groups resolved with limits residual provenance mapping patch required

Version/status and access classification
Fresh PASS-27 full opinion/page read
Read bounds and limits
¶¶23–33 pp.10–15/indices 9–14; ¶34 p.16/index 15; ¶36 p.17/index 16. Filed Dec. 2, 2014. Justia Law +3
Direct source URLs
https://cases.justia.com/montana/supreme-court/2014-da-14-0179.pdf?ts=1417564946
S_MT-P27-S013 Saved research record

Philpott v. Essex County Welfare Board, 409 U.S. 413 (1973), https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-409/pdf/USREPORTS-409-413.pdf

Recorded check status: scoped review complete substantive groups resolved with limits residual provenance mapping patch required

Version/status and access classification
Fresh PASS-27 official U.S. Reports read
Read bounds and limits
Majority printed pp.415–417/PDF indices 2–4. GovInfo
Direct source URLs
https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-409/pdf/USREPORTS-409-413.pdf
S_MT-P27-S014 Saved research record

Porter v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co., 370 U.S. 159 (1962), https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-370/pdf/USREPORTS-370-159.pdf

Recorded check status: scoped review complete substantive groups resolved with limits residual provenance mapping patch required

Version/status and access classification
Fresh PASS-27 official U.S. Reports read
Read bounds and limits
Majority printed pp.159–162/PDF indices 0–3; separate opinion begins at p.162/index 3. GovInfo
Direct source URLs
https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-370/pdf/USREPORTS-370-159.pdf
S_MT-P27-S015 Saved research record

Federal benefit statutes, exact GovInfo and OLRC URLs in Group 3.F.

Recorded check status: scoped review complete substantive groups resolved with limits residual provenance mapping patch required

Version/status and access classification
Coordinator-reported dated reuse, not fresh PASS-27 reads
Read bounds and limits
Pinpoints and header dates preserved exactly as attributed; no later-amendment completeness inferred.

What was examined—and what is still missing

The saved component-level coverage record keeps answered, partial, blank and unresolved branches distinct. A coverage label is not acceptance of a whole subject or jurisdiction.

coverage-1 Saved research record

Required judgment date in debtor notice

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Corrected
Claims
C001
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual notice and judgment record

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-2 Saved research record

Five-day notice timing

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Preserved
Claims
P22-C013
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual execution date

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-3 Saved research record

Personal-versus-mail claim trigger

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Preserved
Claims
P22-C014 and original §212 claim
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual service or mailing record

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-4 Saved research record

Same-day copies/hearing/late claim

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Preserved
Claims
Original P22 claims
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual filing and receipt dates

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-5 Saved research record

Excess-return exception

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Corrected
Claims
C002
Exact missing evidence or next action
Judgment, court order, priorities, and final accounting

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-6 Saved research record

Sale proceeds branch under §610

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Corrected
Claims
C003
Exact missing evidence or next action
Proof that exempt property was sold and proceeds remain traceable

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-7 Saved research record

Casualty/indemnity branch under §610

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Corrected
Claims
C004
Exact missing evidence or next action
Loss, damage, destruction, indemnification, and tracing

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-8 Saved research record

Six-month universal bank exemption

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Rejected/preserved as no
Claims
C003–C004
Exact missing evidence or next action
Another specific exemption must apply

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-9 Saved research record

Forty-five-day deposited-wage tracing

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Unchanged
Claims
P22-C026/C027
Exact missing evidence or next action
Source, receipt date, and transaction history

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-10 Saved research record

HSA §603 protection

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered textually
Claims
C005, C007
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual account and debt type

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-11 Saved research record

HSA §608(1)(l) timing

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered textually
Claims
C006
Exact missing evidence or next action
Contribution and earnings records

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-12 Saved research record

Post-suit HSA contributions

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Unresolved
Claims
C008
Exact missing evidence or next action
Post-2017 controlling construction or claim-specific order

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-13 Saved research record

Giacometto current reach

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Qualified
Claims
C009
Exact missing evidence or next action
Its pre-amendment route is not current timing law

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-14 Saved research record

Part 212 initial check/review distinction

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Corrected
Claims
C010
Exact missing evidence or next action
Order receipt and sufficient identifying information

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-15 Saved research record

Part 212 no-repeat/no-continuing predicate

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Corrected
Claims
C011
Exact missing evidence or next action
Covered-benefit finding and whether order is same/new

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-16 Saved research record

Part 212 notice predicates

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Corrected
Claims
C020
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual review balance and protected/excess amounts

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-17 Saved research record

Part 212 records trigger

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Corrected
Claims
C020
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual receipt date

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-18 Saved research record

Full §212 URLs

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Corrected
Claims
C010–C011, C020
Exact missing evidence or next action
None

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-19 Saved research record

Justice/City route claim link

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Corrected
Claims
C012
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual court and writ

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-20 Saved research record

Small Claims route claim link

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Corrected
Claims
C013
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual judgment

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-21 Saved research record

Municipal route

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Still unresolved
Claims
—
Exact missing evidence or next action
Current municipal-specific execution authority

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-22 Saved research record

Official form URLs

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Corrected
Claims
C022
Exact missing evidence or next action
Readable current form bodies and revision dates

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-23 Saved research record

Dorwart missing source

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Corrected
Claims
C014
Exact missing evidence or next action
No full subsequent-history audit

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-24 Saved research record

Buxbaum narrow later treatment

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Answered
Claims
C015
Exact missing evidence or next action
No complete citator

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-25 Saved research record

Dean locator and scope

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Corrected
Claims
C016
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual account tracing remains private/fact-specific

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-26 Saved research record

Salminen status and posture

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Corrected
Claims
C017
Exact missing evidence or next action
Merits and later proceedings not researched

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-27 Saved research record

Philpott read bounds

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Corrected
Claims
C018
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual Social Security source and tracing

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-28 Saved research record

Porter majority boundary

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Corrected
Claims
C019
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual VA source, availability, and investment status

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-29 Saved research record

Federal benefit statute provenance

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Qualified as dated reuse
Claims
Original P22 benefit claims
Exact missing evidence or next action
Complete later-amendment audit if required

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-30 Saved research record

Example 6 percentages

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Corrected as approximate
Claims
C021
Exact missing evidence or next action
Dollar allocation unchanged

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-31 Saved research record

All other sixteen examples

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Preserved
Claims
Original P22 claims
Exact missing evidence or next action
No recomputation or new assumptions

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-32 Saved research record

Actual bank fee/account review/service/order

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Unresolved
Claims
Original P22 holds
Exact missing evidence or next action
Actual records prohibited/outside scope

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-33 Saved research record

Local/tribal/country/sector rules

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Excluded unchanged
Claims
—
Exact missing evidence or next action
Separate jurisdiction-specific work

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-34 Saved research record

Private Part 212 cause of action

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Unresolved unchanged
Claims
Original P22 hold
Exact missing evidence or next action
Controlling cause-of-action authority

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required
coverage-35 Saved research record

Whole bank report acceptance

Recorded check status: recorded; no individual primary acceptance inferred

Status
Not supplied
Claims
—
Exact missing evidence or next action
Coordinator review remains pending

Recorded coordinator check boundaries

coordinator acceptance
substantive_corrections_supported_with_limits_residual_mapping_provenance_required

Corrections, review and scope

Read the evidence with its boundaries. These are saved research components, including revisions. A scoped coordinator review checks selected evidence; it does not certify every claim, a complete jurisdiction, current law or individual applicability. Dates and access limits remain attached to the records.

How to read the research →

No currently queued material correction is mapped to this component. This does not remove its currentness, access, jurisdiction or application limits.

Recorded review disposition

P27P30 requested correction groups resolved with explicit limits not component acceptance

Other components in this research series

S_MTpass-01

SMT Montana provider market access and consumer fees

Inside: A. Substantive findings · 1. Classification and market access · 2. Consumer fees

6 tables30 claim records16 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-25
S_MTpass-02

SMT Focused precision correction and current-rule/scope addendum

Inside: A. Exact federal replacements and corrected source labels · 1. Replacement for PASS-01 paragraph 5 and claim C025 · 2. Replacement qualification for C026 — dedicated accounts

4 tables13 claim records15 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-03

SMT Minimal provenance correction

Inside:

1 tables0 claim records0 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-04

SMT Montana consumer-money custody, trust-account, and refund architecture

Inside: Core determination · 1. Custody entry point and hybrid arrangements · Part 20 custody

6 tables31 claim records7 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-05

SMT Montana bond, insurance, and alternative-security component

Inside: Executive findings · 1. Covered models and security triggers · Part 20 — debt management and covered credit counseling

5 tables30 claim records12 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-06

SMT Montana mandatory agreement, disclosure, and execution component

Inside: Core conclusions · Part 20 custodial DMP · Part 21 noncustodial settlement

6 tables36 claim records11 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-07

SMT Montana Part 20/Part 21 provider enforcement, private remedies, voidness, fee return, and remedy-specific limitations

Inside: Executive conclusions · Administrative licensing discipline · A2. Part 21 remains the noncustodial settlement branch

7 tables45 claim records21 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-08

SMT Montana collection-agency/debt-buyer licensing, original-creditor coverage, and state-specific collection conduct

Inside: I. Executive determination · 1. No general standalone Montana “collection agency” license was identified · 2. The central Montana licensing trigger is the debt’s legal origin and the collector’s activity

5 tables54 claim records26 source recordsCorrections to readCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-09

SMT Montana prelitigation debt validation, disputes, and consumer access to account documentation

Inside: 1. Montana does not present one universal debt-validation regime · 2. Montana Consumer Loan Act records and consumer-facing information · A. Payment receipts

6 tables52 claim records23 source recordsCorrections to readCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-10

SMT Montana ordinary consumer-debt credit reporting, furnishing, and dispute overlays

Inside: I. Bottom-line findings · 2. Montana CRA accuracy and compliance duties · 3. Montana file access

8 tables53 claim records23 source recordsCorrections to readCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-11

SMT Montana ordinary unsecured consumer-debt limitation, accrual, choice-of-law, tolling, and revival

Inside: I. Executive conclusions · Classification rule · 1. General accrual

7 tables54 claim records25 source recordsCorrections to readCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-12

SMT Bounded Example 3 correction

Inside: Correction summary · Exact replacement text for PASS-04 Example 3 · Example 3 — Receipt before a valid signed DMP

4 tables1 claim records0 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-13

SMT Montana ordinary consumer-debt civil case entry, venue, service, response, default, and bounded vacatur

Inside: I. Executive findings · A. Small Claims assignment restriction · B. Real party and entity representation

8 tables62 claim records20 source recordsCorrections to readCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-14

SMT Two bounded agreement qualifications

Inside: A. Correction summary · Exact replacement for the PASS-06 E-SIGN paragraph · Conditional E-SIGN and Montana-UETA relationship

6 tables4 claim records5 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-15

SMT Montana ordinary consumer-debt lawsuit standing, assignment chain, debt proof, account/instrument records, and evidence

Inside: I. Executive findings · A. Real party versus subject-matter jurisdiction · B. Cure, ratification, joinder, and substitution

11 tables54 claim records21 source recordsCorrections to readCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-16

SMT Montana ordinary consumer-debt arbitration, delegation, judicial gateway, and related waiver

Inside: I. Executive findings · A. Actor matrix · B. Assignment boundary

11 tables62 claim records32 source recordsCorrections to readCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-17

SMT Montana ordinary consumer-debt arbitration award-to-judgment confirmation, vacatur, modification/correction, appeal, and stay boundaries

Inside: I. Core determinations · A. Montana statutory award requirements · B. Current AAA Consumer Rules—conditional only

15 tables60 claim records20 source recordsCorrections to readCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-18

SMT Montana ordinary consumer-debt court-judgment interest, duration, renewal, satisfaction, and judgment-lien release

Inside: I. Core conclusions · A. Prejudgment versus postjudgment interest · B. Montana default postjudgment formula

10 tables56 claim records18 source recordsCorrections to readCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-19

SMT Bounded corrections and qualifications to

Inside: Correction determination · Exact replacement for PASS-07 Example 1 · Exact replacement for PASS-07 Example 2

11 tables17 claim records11 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-20

SMT Bounded public-enforcement procedure, attorney-fee, and crosslink corrections

Inside: Correction summary · Civil investigative demand and challenge procedure · Conditional CID workflow

9 tables14 claim records12 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-21

SMT Montana ordinary unsecured consumer-debt wage garnishment and earnings exemptions/procedure

Inside: I. Core determinations · A. Statutory definitions · B. Required versus voluntary payroll deductions

15 tables61 claim records21 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-22

SMT Montana ordinary unsecured consumer-debt bank-account garnishment, deposit/benefit exemptions, and tracing

Inside: I. Core determinations · II. Court, actor, and account-route matrix · III. Montana ordinary bank-levy workflow

13 tables65 claim records22 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-23

SMT Montana ordinary unsecured consumer-money-judgment nonwage, nonbank personal-property execution, exemptions, and debtor procedure

Inside: I. Core determinations · A. Current amount and category matrix · B. Exemption stacking rules

12 tables58 claim records18 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-24

SMT Montana ordinary unsecured consumer-money-judgment real-estate execution and homestead

Inside: I. Core determinations · A. General seizure/exemption notice · B. General exemption request

6 tables68 claim records20 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-26

SMT Bounded precision and source corrections to

Inside: Effect on the original PASS-21 · 1(a). Replacement for P21 VI.A notice-content paragraph · Statutory officer notice

5 tables16 claim records17 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-28

SMT Bounded precision and completeness corrections to

Inside: Replacement for PASS-23 VI.A · Debtor notice after execution · Notice claim-cell effect

12 tables18 claim records20 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-29

SMT Bounded procedure, redemption, and source/render corrections to

Inside: A. Replacement for PASS-24 core finding 23, Matrix V step 5, VII.C, C038, and Example 7 · Service of the homestead appraisal petition · Service-method hold

10 tables16 claim records21 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
S_MTpass-30

SMT Bounded provenance, mail-method, claim-mapping, and display corrections to

Inside: I. Effect on original PASS-27 · Montana notification of seizure — §25-13-211 · Unchanged §25-13-212 conditions

7 tables8 claim records7 source recordsScoped review · limits applyCaptured 2026-10-26
Record integrity

Original saved Markdown SHA-256: 15bebc67e48a4b0d3d313fbc9133c89e7c2282d079f02cb11f62dbd297a2c8df. Public formatting, private-reference removal and correction annotations are separate from that immutable original.

Get debt settlement help