{"meta":{"key":"s_ut--pass-02","task":"S_UT","title":"SUT bounded coordinator correction","parent_title":"Utah debt and debt relief law","edition":"pass-02","path":"/research/s_ut--pass-02/","kind":"split_pass","category":"state","role":"state","area_numbers":[66],"groups":["collections"],"date":"2026-10-25","tables":4,"claims":4,"sources":2,"review_status":"accepted_with_limits","review_complete":true,"sha256":"b465d9f4a383706dd819bfe749330fcc6961d984f8220eddca1cf1c9393b0d9a","headings":["1. Minimal replacement claim cells","2. Source and version usage check","3. Corrective PASS-02 claims","4. Focused PASS-01 coverage patch","5. Researcher self-check"],"generation_provenance":{"actual_route":"regular_chat_adaptive_models","actual_model":"GPT-5.6 Sol","actual_mode":"Pro","provenance_limit":"Actual documented capture labels only; missing labels remain unknown. No preferred setting is inferred as actual execution."},"public_id":"S_UT/pass-02","facets":{"geography":["us","us-ut"],"debt_type":[],"stage":[],"subject":[]},"scope":"OnlyP1C010/C016/C018signed-agreement/counseling/123(6)exceptionqualificationandaffectednarrative/coverage","pending_corrections":0},"markdown":"# S_UT PASS-02 — bounded coordinator correction\n\n**Fresh access:** October 24, 2026, Pacific\n**Scope:** Surgical correction of PASS-01 claims C010, C016, and C018 only. PASS-01’s calculations, examples, other findings, and unresolved holds remain unchanged. This is the same coordinator’s scoped correction, not an independent review.\n\n## 1. Minimal replacement claim cells\n\nFor traceability, the stable PASS-01 IDs are shown with the coordinator’s shortened aliases.\n\n| Stable PASS-01 claim ID | Full replacement wording | Replacement source and precise pinpoint | Confidence and limits |\n| --- | --- | --- | --- |\n| **S_UT-P1-C010** — coordinator alias **S_UT-C010** | **Section 13-42-123(2) states the general rule that a provider may not impose charges or receive payment for debt-management services until the provider and individual sign an agreement complying with §§13-42-119 and 13-42-128. That rule must not be restated as an absolute requirement that every statutorily permitted fee always follows a signed agreement: §13-42-123(4)(d) contains an express, bounded branch for educational and counseling services when the individual does not assent to an agreement. That branch remains subject to its own dollar, Division-approval, adjustment, and §13-42-128(4) conditions. It does not create general permission for other preagreement charges.** | **S_UT-P1-S001**, §13-42-123(1)–(2), (4)(a), and (4)(d)(i)–(ii), official PDF p.1. **S_UT-P2-S001**, §13-42-128(4), official PDF p.3 / PDF index 2. [Utah Legislature+1](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf) | **High** for the statutory text and correction of the universal phrasing. No conclusion is added regarding currently adjusted amounts, provider-specific Division permission, or compensation outside the express branches. |\n| **S_UT-P1-C016** — coordinator alias **S_UT-C016** | **Educational and counseling compensation is branch-specific. If an individual assents to an agreement, §13-42-123(3)(a) generally prohibits a fee for educational, counseling, or similar services except as otherwise provided in §123 and §13-42-128(4); §123(3)(b) separately permits the Division to authorize a fee based on the nature and extent of the services furnished. If the individual does not assent to an agreement, §123(4)(d) permits only the bounded educational-and-counseling fee described there: no more than the statutory $100 amount, subject to §13-42-132(6) adjustment, or a larger fee only with Division approval when the nature and extent of the services warrant it. Section 13-42-128(4) separately prohibits compensation for advising, arranging, or assisting an individual in obtaining an extension of credit or another service from a lender or service provider, subject to its exceptions for required government-sponsored counseling and compensation authorized under §123(4)(d). Those exceptions are not automatic authorization for every preagreement fee. A fee actually paid under §123(4)(d) is subject to the specific §123(5) refund rule if the individual assents to an agreement within the stated 90-day period; that refund rule is not a universal refund rule for every counseling-related charge.** | **S_UT-P1-S001**, §13-42-123(3)(a)–(b), (4)(a), (4)(d)(i)–(ii), and (5), official PDF pp.1–2. **S_UT-P2-S001**, §13-42-128(4)(a)–(b), official PDF p.3 / PDF index 2. [Utah Legislature+1](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf) | **High** for the operative text. The exact currently adjusted dollar amount, any particular Division authorization, and the treatment of a specific service or contract remain held. |\n| **S_UT-P1-C018** — coordinator alias **S_UT-C018** | **Except as otherwise provided in §13-42-123(3) and (4), when an agreement contemplates settlement for less than principal, compensation for settlement services must be reasonable and clearly disclosed in the agreement, and a settlement fee may be collected only as the debt is settled. Section 123(6) therefore does not displace or relax the more specific §123(4)(c) settlement-performance, consumer-payment, and fee-allocation conditions.** | **S_UT-P1-S001**, §13-42-123(4)(c)(i)–(iii) and (6)(a)–(b), official PDF pp.1–2. [Utah Legislature+1](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf) | **High.** Contract-specific reasonableness, provider authorization, and independently applicable federal timing remain unresolved. |\n\nThe controlling distinction is now explicit: **§123(2) supplies the general signed-agreement rule; §123(4)(d) supplies a limited no-agreement counseling branch; and neither §123 nor §128 converts that branch into blanket preagreement fee permission.** [Utah Legislature+1](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf)\n\n## 2. Source and version usage check\n\n| Source ID | Document, literal URL, and version | PASS-02 use and actual check |\n| --- | --- | --- |\n| **S_UT-P1-S001 — reused; no duplicate document ID created** | Utah Legislature, **Utah Code §13-42-123, “Fees and other charges.”** https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf Effective **May 6, 2026**; two pages; amended by Chapter 95, 2026 General Session. | Freshly reopened and read in full for PASS-02. Relied on §123(1)–(2), §123(3)(a)–(b), §123(4)(a), §123(4)(c)–(d), §123(5), and §123(6). Both pages were also visually inspected. [Utah Legislature+2](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf) |\n| **S_UT-P2-S001 — new document ID** | Utah Legislature, **Utah Code §13-42-128, “Prohibited acts and practices.”** https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S128_2026050620260506.pdf Effective **May 6, 2026**; three pages; amended by Chapter 95, 2026 General Session. | Freshly opened and reviewed. Corrective reliance is limited to §128(4)(a)–(b), Utah Code p.3 / PDF index 2: the compensation prohibition and its two stated exceptions. The relevant page was visually inspected. [Utah Legislature+1](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S128_2026050620260506.pdf) |\n\nNo historical §128 document or FAQ cache result is treated as read evidence in PASS-02.\n\n## 3. Corrective PASS-02 claims\n\n| Corrective claim ID | Corrective finding | Supporting authority |\n| --- | --- | --- |\n| **S_UT-P2-C001** | PASS-01 C010 was overbroad because §123(2)’s general agreement prerequisite must be read with the express no-agreement educational-and-counseling branch in §123(4)(d). The correction does not authorize any preagreement charge outside that bounded branch. | S_UT-P1-S001, §123(1)–(2), (4)(d); S_UT-P2-S001, §128(4). [Utah Legislature+1](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf) |\n| **S_UT-P2-C002** | The statute distinguishes: restrictions after assent under §123(3)(a); possible specific Division authorization under §123(3)(b); the no-agreement fee branch and larger-fee approval under §123(4)(d); and the separate subject-specific compensation prohibition and exceptions in §128(4). | S_UT-P1-S001, §123(3)(a)–(b), (4)(d); S_UT-P2-S001, §128(4)(a)–(b). [Utah Legislature+1](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf) |\n| **S_UT-P2-C003** | Section 123(5)’s 90-day refund applies specifically to a fee paid under §123(4)(d). It should not be described as applying to every educational, counseling, or similar fee under every branch. | S_UT-P1-S001, §123(5), official PDF p.2. [Utah Legislature+1](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf) |\n| **S_UT-P2-C004** | Section 123(6)’s reasonableness, disclosure, and “as the debt is settled” language is expressly qualified by §123(3) and (4), preserving §123(4)(c)’s specific settlement-fee conditions. | S_UT-P1-S001, §123(4)(c), (6), official PDF pp.1–2. [Utah Legislature+2](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf) |\n\n## 4. Focused PASS-01 coverage patch\n\n| Affected PASS-01 coverage row | Corrected status and claim mapping | What changes | Holds that remain unchanged |\n| --- | --- | --- | --- |\n| **Agreement, funds, bond, remedies** | **Agreement aspect: partial.** Replace C010 with corrected **S_UT-P1-C010**; add **S_UT-P2-C001–C002**. The remaining funds, bond, and remedies scope stays excluded for later passes. | The general signed-agreement rule remains, but it is no longer expressed as universal across every permitted fee. The limited §123(4)(d) no-agreement counseling branch is expressly recognized. | Full agreement compliance under §§119 and 128; current exemption matrix; operative rules; provider-specific authority; contract interpretation; all non-agreement portions of the original row. |\n| **Counseling fee/refund** | **Partial.** Replace C016 with corrected **S_UT-P1-C016**; preserve P1 C017; add **S_UT-P2-C002–C003**. | Separates the assent branch, Division authorization under §123(3)(b), no-agreement branch, larger-fee approval, §128(4) prohibition/exceptions, and the fee-specific §123(5) refund. | Exact currently adjusted amount; §132(6) notices; standards, records, or terms of any Division approval; provider-specific authorization; contract facts; government-sponsored-program application; other refunds or cancellation rights. |\n| **Current settlement allocation / compensation timing** | **Answered only as current statutory text, with unresolved operational overlays.** Replace C018 with corrected **S_UT-P1-C018**; preserve C013–C015; add **S_UT-P2-C004**. | Preserves the opening qualification in §123(6): “except as otherwise provided” in subsections (3) and (4). Section 123(6) cannot be used to bypass §123(4)(c). | Federal TSR timing and coverage; CROA overlap; contract-specific reasonableness and disclosures; provider registration; actual settlement facts; cases and administrative interpretations. |\n| **Every other PASS-01 coverage row** | **Unchanged.** | No new finding or implied acceptance. | Current definitions and exemptions; remote-provider nexus; R152-42 and its adoption history; exact adjusted fees; actual provider status; registry verification; full contracts; federal law; cases; currentness beyond the two checked PDFs; local and tribal issues; and every other Utah or cross-state category remain open. |\n\n## 5. Researcher self-check\n\n**Freshly read for PASS-02**\n\n- The complete two-page current official §13-42-123 PDF, effective May 6, 2026, including the general agreement rule, both educational/counseling branches, specific Division authorization language, refund rule, and the express qualification in subsection (6). [Utah Legislature+2](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf)\n- The current three-page official §13-42-128 PDF, effective May 6, 2026. Corrective reliance is confined to §128(4), Utah Code page 3 / PDF index 2. [Utah Legislature+1](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S128_2026050620260506.pdf)\n\n**Reused**\n\n- Existing document ID **S_UT-P1-S001** for the same §123 PDF; no artificial new source ID was created.\n- PASS-01 C017’s fee-specific refund conclusion, now expressly tied to a fee paid under §123(4)(d).\n- All unaffected PASS-01 findings, quantities, tables, and examples without repetition.\n\n**Provided or referenced but not treated as read evidence**\n\n- The rejected historical §128 PDF request.\n- The FAQ-linked current HTML cache-miss route.\n- No claim relies on either route.\n\n**Not investigated in this bounded correction**\n\nNo search or conclusion was added concerning adjusted amounts or CPI calculations, §132(6) notices, current exemptions, R152-42, provider registration status, provider contracts, federal TSR or CROA permission, cases, local or tribal law, or other Utah dossier categories. All corresponding PASS-01 holds remain intact.\n\nNo independent-review claim, application, contact, account change, browser control, local write, publication action, or launch-readiness determination was made.\n\n**END S_UT PASS-02**\n\n","tables":[{"headers":["Stable PASS-01 claim ID","Full replacement wording","Replacement source and precise pinpoint","Confidence and limits"],"index":0,"links":[{"href":"https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf","text":"Utah Legislature\n+1"},{"href":"https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf","text":"Utah Legislature\n+1"},{"href":"https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf","text":"Utah Legislature\n+1"}],"row_links":[[],[{"href":"https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf","text":"Utah Legislature\n+1"}],[{"href":"https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf","text":"Utah Legislature\n+1"}],[{"href":"https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf","text":"Utah Legislature\n+1"}]],"rows":[["Stable PASS-01 claim ID","Full replacement wording","Replacement source and precise pinpoint","Confidence and limits"],["S_UT-P1-C010 — coordinator alias S_UT-C010","Section 13-42-123(2) states the general rule that a provider may not impose charges or receive payment for debt-management services until the provider and individual sign an agreement complying with §§13-42-119 and 13-42-128. That rule must not be restated as an absolute requirement that every statutorily permitted fee always follows a signed agreement: §13-42-123(4)(d) contains an express, bounded branch for educational and counseling services when the individual does not assent to an agreement. That branch remains subject to its own dollar, Division-approval, adjustment, and §13-42-128(4) conditions. It does not create general permission for other preagreement charges.","S_UT-P1-S001, §13-42-123(1)–(2), (4)(a), and (4)(d)(i)–(ii), official PDF p.1. S_UT-P2-S001, §13-42-128(4), official PDF p.3 / PDF index 2. \nUtah Legislature\n+1","High for the statutory text and correction of the universal phrasing. No conclusion is added regarding currently adjusted amounts, provider-specific Division permission, or compensation outside the express branches."],["S_UT-P1-C016 — coordinator alias S_UT-C016","Educational and counseling compensation is branch-specific. If an individual assents to an agreement, §13-42-123(3)(a) generally prohibits a fee for educational, counseling, or similar services except as otherwise provided in §123 and §13-42-128(4); §123(3)(b) separately permits the Division to authorize a fee based on the nature and extent of the services furnished. If the individual does not assent to an agreement, §123(4)(d) permits only the bounded educational-and-counseling fee described there: no more than the statutory $100 amount, subject to §13-42-132(6) adjustment, or a larger fee only with Division approval when the nature and extent of the services warrant it. Section 13-42-128(4) separately prohibits compensation for advising, arranging, or assisting an individual in obtaining an extension of credit or another service from a lender or service provider, subject to its exceptions for required government-sponsored counseling and compensation authorized under §123(4)(d). Those exceptions are not automatic authorization for every preagreement fee. A fee actually paid under §123(4)(d) is subject to the specific §123(5) refund rule if the individual assents to an agreement within the stated 90-day period; that refund rule is not a universal refund rule for every counseling-related charge.","S_UT-P1-S001, §13-42-123(3)(a)–(b), (4)(a), (4)(d)(i)–(ii), and (5), official PDF pp.1–2. S_UT-P2-S001, §13-42-128(4)(a)–(b), official PDF p.3 / PDF index 2. \nUtah Legislature\n+1","High for the operative text. The exact currently adjusted dollar amount, any particular Division authorization, and the treatment of a specific service or contract remain held."],["S_UT-P1-C018 — coordinator alias S_UT-C018","Except as otherwise provided in §13-42-123(3) and (4), when an agreement contemplates settlement for less than principal, compensation for settlement services must be reasonable and clearly disclosed in the agreement, and a settlement fee may be collected only as the debt is settled. Section 123(6) therefore does not displace or relax the more specific §123(4)(c) settlement-performance, consumer-payment, and fee-allocation conditions.","S_UT-P1-S001, §13-42-123(4)(c)(i)–(iii) and (6)(a)–(b), official PDF pp.1–2. \nUtah Legislature\n+1","High. Contract-specific reasonableness, provider authorization, and independently applicable federal timing remain unresolved."]]},{"headers":["Source ID","Document, literal URL, and version","PASS-02 use and actual check"],"index":1,"links":[{"href":"https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf","text":"Utah Legislature\n+2"},{"href":"https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S128_2026050620260506.pdf","text":"Utah Legislature\n+1"}],"row_links":[[],[{"href":"https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf","text":"Utah Legislature\n+2"}],[{"href":"https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S128_2026050620260506.pdf","text":"Utah Legislature\n+1"}]],"rows":[["Source ID","Document, literal URL, and version","PASS-02 use and actual check"],["S_UT-P1-S001 — reused; no duplicate document ID created","Utah Legislature, Utah Code §13-42-123, “Fees and other charges.” https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf Effective May 6, 2026; two pages; amended by Chapter 95, 2026 General Session.","Freshly reopened and read in full for PASS-02. Relied on §123(1)–(2), §123(3)(a)–(b), §123(4)(a), §123(4)(c)–(d), §123(5), and §123(6). Both pages were also visually inspected. \nUtah Legislature\n+2"],["S_UT-P2-S001 — new document ID","Utah Legislature, Utah Code §13-42-128, “Prohibited acts and practices.” https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S128_2026050620260506.pdf Effective May 6, 2026; three pages; amended by Chapter 95, 2026 General Session.","Freshly opened and reviewed. Corrective reliance is limited to §128(4)(a)–(b), Utah Code p.3 / PDF index 2: the compensation prohibition and its two stated exceptions. The relevant page was visually inspected. \nUtah Legislature\n+1"]]},{"headers":["Corrective claim ID","Corrective finding","Supporting authority"],"index":2,"links":[{"href":"https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf","text":"Utah Legislature\n+1"},{"href":"https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf","text":"Utah Legislature\n+1"},{"href":"https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf","text":"Utah Legislature\n+1"},{"href":"https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf","text":"Utah Legislature\n+2"}],"row_links":[[],[{"href":"https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf","text":"Utah Legislature\n+1"}],[{"href":"https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf","text":"Utah Legislature\n+1"}],[{"href":"https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf","text":"Utah Legislature\n+1"}],[{"href":"https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf","text":"Utah Legislature\n+2"}]],"rows":[["Corrective claim ID","Corrective finding","Supporting authority"],["S_UT-P2-C001","PASS-01 C010 was overbroad because §123(2)’s general agreement prerequisite must be read with the express no-agreement educational-and-counseling branch in §123(4)(d). The correction does not authorize any preagreement charge outside that bounded branch.","S_UT-P1-S001, §123(1)–(2), (4)(d); S_UT-P2-S001, §128(4). \nUtah Legislature\n+1"],["S_UT-P2-C002","The statute distinguishes: restrictions after assent under §123(3)(a); possible specific Division authorization under §123(3)(b); the no-agreement fee branch and larger-fee approval under §123(4)(d); and the separate subject-specific compensation prohibition and exceptions in §128(4).","S_UT-P1-S001, §123(3)(a)–(b), (4)(d); S_UT-P2-S001, §128(4)(a)–(b). \nUtah Legislature\n+1"],["S_UT-P2-C003","Section 123(5)’s 90-day refund applies specifically to a fee paid under §123(4)(d). It should not be described as applying to every educational, counseling, or similar fee under every branch.","S_UT-P1-S001, §123(5), official PDF p.2. \nUtah Legislature\n+1"],["S_UT-P2-C004","Section 123(6)’s reasonableness, disclosure, and “as the debt is settled” language is expressly qualified by §123(3) and (4), preserving §123(4)(c)’s specific settlement-fee conditions.","S_UT-P1-S001, §123(4)(c), (6), official PDF pp.1–2. \nUtah Legislature\n+2"]]},{"headers":["Affected PASS-01 coverage row","Corrected status and claim mapping","What changes","Holds that remain unchanged"],"index":3,"links":[],"row_links":[[],[],[],[],[]],"rows":[["Affected PASS-01 coverage row","Corrected status and claim mapping","What changes","Holds that remain unchanged"],["Agreement, funds, bond, remedies","Agreement aspect: partial. Replace C010 with corrected S_UT-P1-C010; add S_UT-P2-C001–C002. The remaining funds, bond, and remedies scope stays excluded for later passes.","The general signed-agreement rule remains, but it is no longer expressed as universal across every permitted fee. The limited §123(4)(d) no-agreement counseling branch is expressly recognized.","Full agreement compliance under §§119 and 128; current exemption matrix; operative rules; provider-specific authority; contract interpretation; all non-agreement portions of the original row."],["Counseling fee/refund","Partial. Replace C016 with corrected S_UT-P1-C016; preserve P1 C017; add S_UT-P2-C002–C003.","Separates the assent branch, Division authorization under §123(3)(b), no-agreement branch, larger-fee approval, §128(4) prohibition/exceptions, and the fee-specific §123(5) refund.","Exact currently adjusted amount; §132(6) notices; standards, records, or terms of any Division approval; provider-specific authorization; contract facts; government-sponsored-program application; other refunds or cancellation rights."],["Current settlement allocation / compensation timing","Answered only as current statutory text, with unresolved operational overlays. Replace C018 with corrected S_UT-P1-C018; preserve C013–C015; add S_UT-P2-C004.","Preserves the opening qualification in §123(6): “except as otherwise provided” in subsections (3) and (4). Section 123(6) cannot be used to bypass §123(4)(c).","Federal TSR timing and coverage; CROA overlap; contract-specific reasonableness and disclosures; provider registration; actual settlement facts; cases and administrative interpretations."],["Every other PASS-01 coverage row","Unchanged.","No new finding or implied acceptance.","Current definitions and exemptions; remote-provider nexus; R152-42 and its adoption history; exact adjusted fees; actual provider status; registry verification; full contracts; federal law; cases; currentness beyond the two checked PDFs; local and tribal issues; and every other Utah or cross-state category remain open."]]}],"claims":[{"claim_id":"S_UT-P2-C001","area_numbers":[66],"area_assignment_method":"task_scope_fallback","researcher_record":{"Corrective claim ID":"S_UT-P2-C001","Corrective finding":"PASS-01 C010 was overbroad because §123(2)’s general agreement prerequisite must be read with the express no-agreement educational-and-counseling branch in §123(4)(d). The correction does not authorize any preagreement charge outside that bounded branch.","Supporting authority":"S_UT-P1-S001, §123(1)–(2), (4)(d); S_UT-P2-S001, §128(4). \nUtah Legislature\n+1"},"coordinator_verification_status":"checked_with_limits_in_separate_scoped_review"},{"claim_id":"S_UT-P2-C002","area_numbers":[66],"area_assignment_method":"task_scope_fallback","researcher_record":{"Corrective claim ID":"S_UT-P2-C002","Corrective finding":"The statute distinguishes: restrictions after assent under §123(3)(a); possible specific Division authorization under §123(3)(b); the no-agreement fee branch and larger-fee approval under §123(4)(d); and the separate subject-specific compensation prohibition and exceptions in §128(4).","Supporting authority":"S_UT-P1-S001, §123(3)(a)–(b), (4)(d); S_UT-P2-S001, §128(4)(a)–(b). \nUtah Legislature\n+1"},"coordinator_verification_status":"checked_with_limits_in_separate_scoped_review"},{"claim_id":"S_UT-P2-C003","area_numbers":[66],"area_assignment_method":"task_scope_fallback","researcher_record":{"Corrective claim ID":"S_UT-P2-C003","Corrective finding":"Section 123(5)’s 90-day refund applies specifically to a fee paid under §123(4)(d). It should not be described as applying to every educational, counseling, or similar fee under every branch.","Supporting authority":"S_UT-P1-S001, §123(5), official PDF p.2. \nUtah Legislature\n+1"},"coordinator_verification_status":"checked_with_limits_in_separate_scoped_review"},{"claim_id":"S_UT-P2-C004","area_numbers":[66],"area_assignment_method":"task_scope_fallback","researcher_record":{"Corrective claim ID":"S_UT-P2-C004","Corrective finding":"Section 123(6)’s reasonableness, disclosure, and “as the debt is settled” language is expressly qualified by §123(3) and (4), preserving §123(4)(c)’s specific settlement-fee conditions.","Supporting authority":"S_UT-P1-S001, §123(4)(c), (6), official PDF pp.1–2. \nUtah Legislature\n+2"},"coordinator_verification_status":"checked_with_limits_in_separate_scoped_review"}],"sources":[{"source_id":"S_UT-P1-S001","urls":["https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf"],"researcher_record":{"Source ID":"S_UT-P1-S001 — reused; no duplicate document ID created","Document, literal URL, and version":"Utah Legislature, Utah Code §13-42-123, “Fees and other charges.” https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S123_2026050620260506.pdf Effective May 6, 2026; two pages; amended by Chapter 95, 2026 General Session.","PASS-02 use and actual check":"Freshly reopened and read in full for PASS-02. Relied on §123(1)–(2), §123(3)(a)–(b), §123(4)(a), §123(4)(c)–(d), §123(5), and §123(6). Both pages were also visually inspected. \nUtah Legislature\n+2"},"coordinator_verification_status":"prior_recent_primary_parsedtext_reused_with_limits;see scopedreview","id_normalization":"Scopedaliasfromdecoratedsourceusagecell;originalresearcher_record unchanged."},{"source_id":"S_UT-P2-S001","urls":["https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S128_2026050620260506.pdf"],"researcher_record":{"Source ID":"S_UT-P2-S001 — new document ID","Document, literal URL, and version":"Utah Legislature, Utah Code §13-42-128, “Prohibited acts and practices.” https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title13/Chapter42/C13-42-S128_2026050620260506.pdf Effective May 6, 2026; three pages; amended by Chapter 95, 2026 General Session.","PASS-02 use and actual check":"Freshly opened and reviewed. Corrective reliance is limited to §128(4)(a)–(b), Utah Code p.3 / PDF index 2: the compensation prohibition and its two stated exceptions. The relevant page was visually inspected. \nUtah Legislature\n+1"},"coordinator_verification_status":"prior_recent_primary_parsedtext_reused_with_limits;see scopedreview","id_normalization":"Scopedaliasfromdecoratedsourceusagecell;originalresearcher_record unchanged."}],"coverage":[{"topic":"Agreement, funds, bond, remedies","researcher_record":{"Affected PASS-01 coverage row":"Agreement, funds, bond, remedies","Corrected status and claim mapping":"Agreement aspect: partial. Replace C010 with corrected S_UT-P1-C010; add S_UT-P2-C001–C002. The remaining funds, bond, and remedies scope stays excluded for later passes.","What changes":"The general signed-agreement rule remains, but it is no longer expressed as universal across every permitted fee. The limited §123(4)(d) no-agreement counseling branch is expressly recognized.","Holds that remain unchanged":"Full agreement compliance under §§119 and 128; current exemption matrix; operative rules; provider-specific authority; contract interpretation; all non-agreement portions of the original row."},"coordinator_acceptance":"not_yet_reviewed"},{"topic":"Counseling fee/refund","researcher_record":{"Affected PASS-01 coverage row":"Counseling fee/refund","Corrected status and claim mapping":"Partial. Replace C016 with corrected S_UT-P1-C016; preserve P1 C017; add S_UT-P2-C002–C003.","What changes":"Separates the assent branch, Division authorization under §123(3)(b), no-agreement branch, larger-fee approval, §128(4) prohibition/exceptions, and the fee-specific §123(5) refund.","Holds that remain unchanged":"Exact currently adjusted amount; §132(6) notices; standards, records, or terms of any Division approval; provider-specific authorization; contract facts; government-sponsored-program application; other refunds or cancellation rights."},"coordinator_acceptance":"not_yet_reviewed"},{"topic":"Current settlement allocation / compensation timing","researcher_record":{"Affected PASS-01 coverage row":"Current settlement allocation / compensation timing","Corrected status and claim mapping":"Answered only as current statutory text, with unresolved operational overlays. Replace C018 with corrected S_UT-P1-C018; preserve C013–C015; add S_UT-P2-C004.","What changes":"Preserves the opening qualification in §123(6): “except as otherwise provided” in subsections (3) and (4). Section 123(6) cannot be used to bypass §123(4)(c).","Holds that remain unchanged":"Federal TSR timing and coverage; CROA overlap; contract-specific reasonableness and disclosures; provider registration; actual settlement facts; cases and administrative interpretations."},"coordinator_acceptance":"not_yet_reviewed"},{"topic":"Every other PASS-01 coverage row","researcher_record":{"Affected PASS-01 coverage row":"Every other PASS-01 coverage row","Corrected status and claim mapping":"Unchanged.","What changes":"No new finding or implied acceptance.","Holds that remain unchanged":"Current definitions and exemptions; remote-provider nexus; R152-42 and its adoption history; exact adjusted fees; actual provider status; registry verification; full contracts; federal law; cases; currentness beyond the two checked PDFs; local and tribal issues; and every other Utah or cross-state category remain open."},"coordinator_acceptance":"not_yet_reviewed"}],"annotations":{},"corrections":[],"resolved_corrections":[],"review_history":[]}