{"meta":{"key":"s_id--pass-13","task":"S_ID","title":"SID bounded P9 noncash-proceeds correction and symbolic-register additions","parent_title":"Idaho debt and debt relief law","edition":"pass-13","path":"/research/s_id--pass-13/","kind":"split_pass","category":"state","role":"state","area_numbers":[66],"groups":["collections"],"date":"2026-10-28","tables":12,"claims":8,"sources":8,"review_status":"reviewed_bounded_correction_resolved_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","review_complete":true,"sha256":"4d05e6812d383d222196e6e6c17a5ff8ee28be1d80b6636ce365a0d8914a653c","headings":["1.1 Replacement for P9 § 4.5","1.2 Disposition and collection are separate clauses","Effective/application status","6.1 Definitions and relations","6.2 Conditions, burden, and exceptions","10.1 Fresh work","10.2 Preserved rather than re-created","10.3 PDF and visual status"],"generation_provenance":{"actual_route":"regular_chat_adaptive_models","actual_model":"GPT-6","actual_mode":"Pro","provenance_limit":"Actual documented capture labels only; missing labels remain unknown. No preferred setting is inferred as actual execution."},"public_id":"S_ID/pass-13","facets":{"geography":["us","us-id"],"debt_type":[],"stage":[],"subject":[]},"scope":"Bounded reviewedP9noncash615narrative/newclaim and omitted626symbolicregister correction; no wholereportrerun orP12dependency.","pending_corrections":0},"markdown":"# S_ID PASS-13 — bounded P9 noncash-proceeds correction and symbolic-register additions\n\n**Fresh public-source access date:** **October 28, 2026, America/Los_Angeles.**\n\n**Disposition:** The identified P9 § 4.5 sentence is corrected below. A distinct noncash-proceeds claim is added. The omitted symbolic-register rows are supplied with their conditions and verification status.\n\nA materially different source made § 28-9-626 readable: **FindLaw’s reproduction labeled “Current as of January 01, 2024.”** That is fresh, dated secondary evidence—not authentication of the previously reported 2025 reproduction or current official 2026 law. The supplied coordinator failures remain separate historical observations.\n\nNo other P9 finding is replaced. In particular, **S_ID-P9-C030 remains cash-only**, and S_ID-P9-C043 and C044 are not overwritten. P12 supplies no substantive foundation. All existing source, classification, application, and other-component holds remain.\n\n# 1. Exact noncash-proceeds correction\n\n## 1.1 Replacement for P9 § 4.5\n\n**Sentence to replace:**\n\n“Noncash proceeds require application only under the stated agreement/commercial-reasonableness conditions.”\n\n**Replacement text:**\n\n**For noncash proceeds of a disposition under § 28-9-610, § 28-9-615(c) does not make an agreement a prerequisite. Application or payment over is required when withholding it would be commercially unreasonable. Any application or payment over that occurs must itself be commercially reasonable.**\n\n**New claim:** **S_ID-P13-C001.**\n\nThe complete reproduced subsection supports this correction. The finding remains a reading of **Justia’s 2025 Idaho Code reproduction**, not authenticated current official law. [Justia Law](https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-615/)\n\n## 1.2 Disposition and collection are separate clauses\n\n| Issue | Disposition proceeds | Collection/enforcement proceeds |\n| --- | --- | --- |\n| Correct pinpoint | **§ 28-9-615(c)** | **§ 28-9-608(a)(3)** |\n| Referenced activity | Disposition under § 28-9-610 | Collection or enforcement under § 28-9-607 |\n| Relevant structure | Commercial reasonableness governs withholding application and the manner of application | The same two-part structure appears, within § 608(a)’s obligation-secured scope |\n| Agreement prerequisite in the noncash clause | None stated | None stated |\n| Supplied reference qualification | The § 615(c) reference is correct | The readable § 608 reproduction has **no subsection (c)**; its noncash clause is **(a)(3)** |\n\nThe agreement wording in the adjacent expense provisions concerns specified attorney fees and legal expenses. It must not be moved into either noncash clause. This is a textual distinction, not a ruling about any agreement or proceeds. **[C002–C003.]** [Justia Law+1](https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-615/)\n\nThe full neighboring provisions were inspected to preserve their different scope and surplus/deficiency qualifications. No new noncash valuation, application date, recipient entitlement, or actual commercial-reasonableness conclusion is supplied.\n\n# 2. Section 28-9-626: new reading, limited effect\n\nThe coordinator-supplied history reports failed deliveries of the official § 626 route and the identified Justia 2025 page. Those routes were **not repeatedly reopened**.\n\nThe newly read FindLaw page contains the complete introductory clause and subsections **(a)–(e)**. Its displayed date is **January 1, 2024**, and it warns that its codes may not reflect the latest law. The relevant symbolic relation and presumption appear in **(c)–(d)**; their procedural conditions appear in **(a)–(b)**. [FindLaw](https://codes.findlaw.com/id/title-28-commercial-transactions/id-st-sect-28-9-626/)\n\nAccordingly:\n\n| Evidence proposition | P13 result |\n| --- | --- |\n| P9 reported the definitions TTT, AAA, and HHH, and the two symbolic relations | Preserved as supplied prior research |\n| Coordinator freshly authenticated the reported 2025 § 626 body | **Not claimed**; supplied history says that delivery failed |\n| P13 found a materially different readable body | **Yes: FindLaw, January 1, 2024 reproduction** |\n| The supplied symbolic relations have additional textual support | **Yes, provisionally, from that dated reproduction** |\n| Current official § 626 or its complete amendment chain is authenticated | **No** |\n| P9 C044’s consumer-carveout observation is reopened or newly certified | **No; outside this correction’s merits scope** |\n| A deficiency, surplus, exception, or enforcement outcome is established | **No** |\n\nSection 28-9-628 was read only because § 626(c) expressly makes its rule subject to that section. The relevant qualifications are retained in the register below; no actual knowledge, reliance, or transaction category is decided.\n\n# 3. Source and usage register\n\nAll fresh accesses below occurred **October 28, 2026, Pacific time**. P13 IDs are usage identifiers. They do not turn another delivery format or repeated use into an independent authority.\n\n| Source/usage ID | Issuer, document, and literal HTTPS URL | Actual read bounds | Edition/status, credits, and limits |\n| --- | --- | --- | --- |\n| **S_ID-P13-S001** | Idaho Legislature, intended § 28-9-615 body: https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title28/T28CH9/SECT28-9-615/ | **One fresh ordinary-route attempt failed.** No operative text read. | Official route; tool reported inaccessible/internal error. No version, amendment, or effective clause recovered. |\n| **S_ID-P13-S002** | Idaho Secretary of State, search-discovered UCC publication route: https://sos.idaho.gov/ucc/Pubs/RA9.pdf | **One materially different official publication route attempted; 404.** | Search title suggested a UCC publication, but title, edition, contents, and currency were not authenticated from a readable document. No PDF text or pixels read. The alternate capitalization appearing in search was not used for repeated variant attempts. |\n| **S_ID-P13-S003** | Justia, *2025 Idaho Code, § 28-9-615—Application of Proceeds of Disposition; Liability for Deficiency and Right to Surplus*: https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-615/ | Complete **(a)–(g)**, displayed history, and disclaimer. Material correction: **(c)**. Adjacent scope: **(a)(1), (d)–(e)**; **(f)** inspected only for the separate § 626(e) boundary. | **Secondary 2025 reproduction.** Displayed credit: added 2001, ch. 208, § 2, p. 788. Original enactment and current amendment chain not recovered. Same underlying section identified in **P9 S_ID-P9-S004**. [Justia Law](https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-615/) |\n| **S_ID-P13-S004** | Justia, *2025 Idaho Code, § 28-9-608—Application of Proceeds of Collection or Enforcement; Liability for Deficiency and Right to Surplus*: https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-608/ | Complete **(a)(1)–(4), (b)**, history, and disclaimer. Material comparison: **(a) introductory clause and (a)(3)**. | **Secondary 2025 reproduction.** Displayed credit: added 2001, ch. 208, § 2, p. 783. No subsection (c) appears. Same underlying section identified in **P9 S_ID-P9-S004**. [Justia Law](https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-608/) |\n| **S_ID-P13-S005** | FindLaw, *Idaho Statutes Title 28, § 28-9-626—Action in Which Deficiency or Surplus Is in Issue*: https://codes.findlaw.com/id/title-28-commercial-transactions/id-st-sect-28-9-626/ | Complete introduction and **(a)–(e)**; date and currentness warning. Substantive use limited to register conditions and relations in **(a)–(d)**, with **(e)** identified as a separate branch. | **Secondary, labeled current as of January 1, 2024.** No enactment-history paragraph appears in this newly read page. P9’s supplied 2001/2002 credits remain attributed prior research, not freshly authenticated history. This is a new readable publication route for the same underlying section—not official current law. [FindLaw](https://codes.findlaw.com/id/title-28-commercial-transactions/id-st-sect-28-9-626/) |\n| **S_ID-P13-S006** | Justia, *2025 Idaho Code, § 28-9-628—Nonliability and Limitation on Liability of Secured Party; Liability of Secondary Obligor*: https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-628/ | Complete **(a)–(e)**, history, and disclaimer. Material exception use: **(a)–(c)**. Paragraphs **(d)–(e)** read but not developed into a new damages analysis. | **Secondary 2025 reproduction.** Displayed credit: added 2001, ch. 208, § 2, p. 796. No current official authentication. Read solely to avoid omitting § 626(c)’s express qualification. [Justia Law](https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-628/) |\n| **S_ID-P13-S007** | Justia § 28-9-626, the previously reported source: https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-626/ | **Search discovery only in P13; no fresh page-body open.** Prior P9 read and coordinator failure are supplied history. | Not counted as a freshly read 2025 body. Search-result text was not used to authenticate the formula or consumer observation. |\n| **S_ID-P13-S008** | Supplied P9 source/claim packet, including the § 608, § 615, and § 626 URLs above | Read as supplied conversation context only. | Supports identification of the sentence, original claims, symbols, and historical source assertions. It is not new legal authority or a fresh source-access event. |\n\n### Effective/application status\n\nNo new enacted, proposed, future-effective, repealed, or transitional rule was authenticated in this pass. The secondary publishers’ dates and displayed historical credits are **not effective dates**. Official-current text and material amendment/application verification remain held.\n\n# 4. Earlier-to-new patch map\n\n| P9 location or identity | Existing content/status | P13 patch or treatment |\n| --- | --- | --- |\n| **§ 4.5, exact noncash sentence** | “Noncash proceeds require application only under the stated agreement/commercial-reasonableness conditions.” | Replace only that sentence with the text in **§ 1.1 above**. Link **S_ID-P13-C001** and **S_ID-P13-S003 § 28-9-615(c)**. |\n| **S_ID-P9-C030** | “Cash-proceeds priority, lawful expenses, proof, and surplus/deficiency conditions govern.” | **Unchanged.** It is not renamed, expanded, or represented as already containing the noncash rule. |\n| **P9 source group S_ID-P9-S004, § 615 entry** | Existing § 615 document identity and supplied history | Retained. P13-S003 records a new read of that same reproduced section. |\n| **Collection comparison in this correction** | Request refers to possible “608(c)” comparison | Use **§ 28-9-608(a)(3)** for the actual noncash comparison. No unseen § 608(c) is invented. |\n| **P9 symbolic definitions** | TTT, AAA, and HHH as supplied | Preserve their wording as prior notation. Add the legal mapping, conditions, units, and status rows in Section 6. |\n| **P9 relation T−max⁡(A,H)T-\\max(A,H)T−max(A,H)** | Appears in narrative, omitted as a separate quantity-register entry | Add **Q05**, with **Q01–Q04 and Q07–Q11** qualifications. No numerical substitution. |\n| **P9 presumption H=TH=TH=T, unless less proved** | Appears in narrative, omitted as a separate quantity-register entry | Add **Q06**, explicitly confined to § 626(c)(2) through subsection (d). |\n| **S_ID-P9-C043** | Prior claim concerning the counterfactual relation and presumption | Not overwritten. P13 adds **dated 2024 secondary support** and an exception-qualified register. It does not retroactively change the coordinator’s failed-access record. |\n| **S_ID-P9-C044** | Prior consumer-carveout observation with official-current hold | **Unchanged and not newly adjudicated.** No expanded consumer-deficiency analysis is supplied. |\n| **P9’s existing 36-row quantity register** | Original entries | Add the rows below as an appendix to that register; do not regenerate or renumber its existing entries. |\n| **All other P9/P12 findings and C033/C035** | Existing findings and holds | No substantive replacement or closure. |\n\n# 5. New atomic claims\n\nAll new IDs are distinct from the P9 claim register.\n\n| Claim ID | Precise corrective or evidence assertion | Source/pinpoint | Scope and verification limit |\n| --- | --- | --- | --- |\n| **S_ID-P13-C001** | The noncash-disposition clause has no agreement prerequisite; its requirements turn on commercial reasonableness of nonapplication and of any application/payment over. | S003, **§ 28-9-615(c)** | Freshly read **2025 secondary text**; no actual duty or disposition determined. [Justia Law](https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-615/) |\n| **S_ID-P13-C002** | The adjacent agreement language concerning specified legal expenses must not be transferred into § 615(c). | S003, **§ 28-9-615(a)(1), (c)** | Textual separation only; no fee entitlement or agreement construed. [Justia Law](https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-615/) |\n| **S_ID-P13-C003** | The collection counterpart is § 28-9-608(a)(3), within subsection (a)’s scope, and likewise states commercial-reasonableness conditions rather than an agreement prerequisite. | S004, **§ 28-9-608(a), (a)(3), (b)** | Freshly read **2025 secondary text**; not a transfer of disposition rules to every collection. [Justia Law](https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-608/) |\n| **S_ID-P13-C004** | FindLaw’s dated reproduction supplies fresh provisional support for the supplied symbolic definitions and relations, under the conditions registered below. | S005, **§ 28-9-626 introductory clause, (a)–(d)** | **January 1, 2024** reproduction only; not fresh authentication of the reported 2025 source. [FindLaw](https://codes.findlaw.com/id/title-28-commercial-transactions/id-st-sect-28-9-626/) |\n| **S_ID-P13-C005** | The formula’s § 628 qualification must remain explicit, including the relevant knowledge and reasonable-reliance limitations. | S005 **§ 626(c)**; S006 **§ 628(a)–(c)** | No predicate, exception, or person’s liability is determined. [FindLaw+1](https://codes.findlaw.com/id/title-28-commercial-transactions/id-st-sect-28-9-626/) |\n| **S_ID-P13-C006** | The previously reported § 626 access failures and the newly successful FindLaw reading are different source events. | S005, S007–S008 | Source-status finding; no retroactive verification claim. |\n| **S_ID-P13-C007** | The symbolic relations are conditional legal shorthand, not a quantified entitlement, surplus calculation, or enforcement result. | S005 **§ 626(c)–(e)**; supplied P9 notation | No values, valuation method, fee authorization, rounding convention, or outcome added. [FindLaw](https://codes.findlaw.com/id/title-28-commercial-transactions/id-st-sect-28-9-626/) |\n| **S_ID-P13-C008** | Official-current statutory and amendment/application authentication remains unresolved after the bounded official-route attempts. | S001–S006 | Source gap only; no absence-of-law or no-amendment inference. |\n\n# 6. Complete symbolic quantity, trigger, exception, and status additions\n\nThe symbols are **report notation**, not characters used in the statute. Their supplied P9 wording is preserved. No amount, transaction, event, or value is inserted.\n\n## 6.1 Definitions and relations\n\n| Added row | Symbol or relation | Preserved meaning and legal mapping | Unit/base and limit | Verification status |\n| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |\n| **Q01** | **TTT** | P9: “the legally established secured obligation, expenses, and attorney fees included by the statute.” Maps to the aggregate stated in § 626(c)–(d). | Monetary aggregate. The notation does not itself establish any component’s amount or legal entitlement. | P9 attribution plus fresh **2024 secondary** support, S005. |\n| **Q02** | **AAA** | P9: “actual proceeds.” Maps to § 626(c)(1)’s proceeds from the relevant collection, enforcement, disposition, or acceptance. | Monetary proceeds measure for the relevant activity. Not restricted by the notation to a sale price. | Same limited status. |\n| **Q03** | **HHH** | P9: “proceeds of a complying collection, enforcement, disposition, or acceptance.” Maps to the counterfactual in § 626(c)(2). | Monetary counterfactual; not an assumed appraisal, liquidation value, or agreed value. | Same limited status. |\n| **Q04** | **max⁡(A,H)\\max(A,H)max(A,H)** | Represents the statutory comparison selecting the greater proceeds measure. | Comparison operator, not a new valuation rule. | Fresh provisional support from § 626(c)(1)–(2). |\n| **Q05** | **T−max⁡(A,H)T-\\max(A,H)T−max(A,H)** | Represents the excess described in § 626(c), when that provision applies. | A deficiency **limitation**, not automatic liability. No negative deficiency, surplus entitlement, or additional zero-floor equation is introduced. | Fresh provisional support from § 626(c); official-current status held. |\n| **Q06** | **H=TH=TH=T, unless the secured party proves a smaller HHH** | Represents subsection (d)’s rule **for purposes of subsection (c)(2)**. | A conditional presumption, not a factual finding that actual proceeds equal the obligation. | Fresh provisional support from § 626(d); no evidence or burden satisfied here. |\n\nThe six rows above are supported by the newly read FindLaw body, not by treating the coordinator’s failed deliveries as successful. [FindLaw](https://codes.findlaw.com/id/title-28-commercial-transactions/id-st-sect-28-9-626/)\n\n## 6.2 Conditions, burden, and exceptions\n\n| Added row | Required legal condition or boundary | Exact relation to the symbols | Pinpoint/status |\n| --- | --- | --- | --- |\n| **Q07 — proceeding scope** | An action arising from a transaction in which deficiency or surplus is in issue | The formulas are not a free-standing accounting mandate outside the section’s setting. | S005, § 626 introductory clause; 2024 secondary |\n| **Q08 — compliance issue** | Debtor or secondary obligor places compliance in issue | Subsections (a)–(b) determine when the secured party must establish compliance. | S005, § 626(a)–(b) |\n| **Q09 — operative trigger** | Secured party fails to prove the relevant compliance | The subsection (c) limitation is conditional on that failure, not merely on a demand for a deficiency. | S005, § 626(c) |\n| **Q10 — cross-reference exception** | Section 626(c) is expressly subject to § 28-9-628 | Neither symbolic relation may erase an applicable § 628 qualification. | S005–S006 |\n| **Q11 — knowledge qualification** | Section 628(a) addresses knowledge of debtor/obligor status, identity, and how to communicate; subsection (b) separately limits status-based liability | No knowledge or communication predicate is assumed. The relevant deficiency consequence in (a)(2) must be retained. | S006, § 628(a)–(b), 2025 secondary |\n| **Q12 — reasonable-purpose-reliance qualification** | Section 628(c) concerns an act or omission arising from the specified reasonable belief, based on reasonable reliance on a debtor’s collateral-purpose representation or obligor’s obligation-purpose representation | A label or assertion alone is not treated as satisfying the exception. | S006, § 628(c) |\n| **Q13 — separate subsection (e)** | Section 626(e) concerns a calculation under § 615(f) | Its separate allocation of proof is not replaced by the subsection (d) presumption. No new § 615(f) analysis is performed. | S005 § 626(e); S003 § 615(f) |\n| **Q14 — noncash distinction** | Noncash proceeds may arise in a disposition or collection/enforcement setting | The relevant clause is § 615(c) or § 608(a)(3), respectively; no agreement prerequisite is inserted. | S003–S004 |\n| **Q15 — unknown measurement** | Valuation, recognition, amount, permissible expenses, and admissible proof are unspecified | No numerical value, valuation date, expense rate, or rounding convention is supplied. | Explicit application hold |\n| **Q16 — no time computation** | None of these added relations supplies a numerical deadline | No calendar, receipt date, percentage, interest rate, or elapsed-period calculation is added. | Text-boundary finding |\n| **Q17 — source versions** | Justia 2025 for §§ 608, 615, 628; FindLaw January 1, 2024 for § 626 | These versions are not relabeled official/current 2026 or harmonized by assumption. | S003–S006 |\n| **Q18 — enactment/application** | Official current text and final amendment/application evidence were not recovered | Displayed old credits and publisher dates do not close the gap. | S001–S006 |\n\nThe relevant § 628 qualifications were freshly read, but not applied. Its separate § 625(c)(2) provisions in subsections (d)–(e) were inspected without reopening the P9 remedies report. [Justia Law](https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-628/)\n\n# 7. Conditional branches\n\n| Branch | Supported consequence | Missing predicate or authority | Adverse inference to avoid | Next precise generic inquiry |\n| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |\n| **B01 — noncash disposition** | C001 supplies the corrected textual rule. | Classification as noncash proceeds of a § 610 disposition; commercial-reasonableness construction. | An agreement is always required, or nonapplication is always permissible. | Readable official § 615 and necessary generic construction of its noncash standard. |\n| **B02 — collection/enforcement** | § 608(a)(3) is the distinct comparison clause. | Actual statutory collection/enforcement category and subsection (a) scope. | A nonexistent § 608(c), or automatic transfer of disposition rules. | Official § 608(a), with only necessary § 607 scope if later material. |\n| **B03 — agreement language** | The adjacent expense condition is not the noncash trigger. | Any separate lawful agreement term and governing limits, if ever relevant. | That deleting “agreement” establishes actual fee authority or decides contractual rights. | Exact generic agreement/expense provision only if separately required. |\n| **B04 — deficiency relation** | Q01–Q09 map the supplied notation to the dated reproduced text. | Applicable proceeding, compliance issue, failure of proof, and legally established components. | The equation alone creates a collectible deficiency. | Official § 626(a)–(d) and necessary application law. |\n| **B05 — presumption** | Q06 records the limited § 626(d) relation. | Whether the relevant proof changes the statutory counterfactual. | HHH is a factual market value or necessarily equals actual proceeds. | Generic proof/construction authority; no case inquiry performed here. |\n| **B06 — § 628 qualification** | Q10–Q12 retain express exceptions. | Knowledge, reasonable belief, reasonable reliance, and represented purpose. | An automatic defense from a label or lack of supplied facts. | Current official § 628 and necessary definitions only. |\n| **B07 — separate § 615(f) issue** | Q13 prevents merging two burden provisions. | Its related-transferee and significantly-low-proceeds predicates. | Subsection (d) silently controls every surplus or purchaser-value dispute. | Separate focused inquiry only if authorized; not rerun here. |\n| **B08 — source currency** | Fresh dated secondary support is identified accurately. | Current official bodies and amendment/application chain. | A new successful webpage means current official law, or erases prior failed reads. | Ordinary readable official publication; no repeated blocked-route attempts. |\n| **B09 — consumer observation** | P9 C044 remains unchanged. | Official authentication and any separately authorized consumer-law analysis. | This correction freshly validates or rejects the broader observation. | Retain existing hold; no new consumer-branch inquiry in P13. |\n\n# 8. Wholly blank worksheet\n\n| Field | Entry |\n| --- | --- |\n| Relevant statutory provision |  |\n| Source edition/status |  |\n| Official-current-text verification |  |\n| Proceeds category |  |\n| Referenced activity |  |\n| Nonapplication condition |  |\n| Application-manner condition |  |\n| Adjacent agreement-language boundary |  |\n| Symbol TTT definition |  |\n| Symbol AAA definition |  |\n| Symbol HHH definition |  |\n| Proceeding predicate |  |\n| Compliance-in-issue predicate |  |\n| Failure-of-proof predicate |  |\n| Applicable § 628 qualification |  |\n| Separate § 615(f) issue |  |\n| Measurement or construction gap |  |\n| Amendment/application gap |  |\n| Review status |  |\n\nNo entry is completed.\n\n# 9. Granular coverage of the requested correction\n\n| Request/subquestion | Disposition | Claims/rows/sources | Exact retained gap |\n| --- | --- | --- | --- |\n| **1 — complete § 615(c)** | Freshly read | C001; S003 | Official-current authentication |\n| Necessary adjacent qualifications | Complete § 615 body inspected; use confined to this correction | C002; S003 | No actual proceeds or agreement determination |\n| Collection comparison | Freshly read; pinpoint corrected to **§ 608(a)(3)** | C003; S004 | Actual § 607 activity not classified |\n| Ordinary official attempt | Completed once | S001 | Body inaccessible |\n| Materially different official route | Search-discovered SOS publication attempted once | S002 | 404; edition/content unread |\n| Dated secondary status | Preserved | S003–S006; Q17–Q18 | No 2026 certification |\n| Exact sentence correction | Supplied | Section 1.1; patch map | No other P9 narrative rewritten |\n| **2 — distinct new noncash claim** | Supplied | **S_ID-P13-C001** | No relabeling of P9 C030 |\n| Preserve C030 cash-only wording | Preserved in patch map | Section 4 | No expansion to noncash |\n| Locate P9 § 4.5 | Exact target and replacement identified | Sections 1 and 4 | No broader report regeneration |\n| Explain correction versus provisional status | Supplied | Sections 1–3 | Current law and actual duty held |\n| **3 — T/A/H definitions** | Added individually | Q01–Q03 | No values or valuation |\n| Counterfactual comparison and relation | Added individually | Q04–Q05 | Conditional limitation only |\n| Presumption | Added individually | Q06 | § 626(c)(2)-specific; no proof finding |\n| Trigger and burden | Added | Q07–Q09 | No proceeding or challenge facts |\n| Exceptions | Fresh relevant cross-reference read | Q10–Q13; S006 | No exception applied |\n| Earlier failed § 626 deliveries | Preserved as supplied history | S007–S008; C006 | Not relabeled as fresh success |\n| New ordinary readable § 626 source | Recovered | S005 | **2024 secondary**, not the reported 2025 body |\n| Consumer-carveout observation | Not reopened | Patch map; B09 | Original hold remains |\n| Full symbolic register status | Supplied | Q01–Q18 | Official-current and application gaps explicit |\n| No numerical or calendar scenario | Maintained | Worksheet/register | None supplied |\n| P9/P12/C033/C035 and other holds | Unchanged | Scope and patch map | No component acceptance |\n\n# 10. Read, search, and failure log\n\n## 10.1 Fresh work\n\n| Search/read action | Actual result |\n| --- | --- |\n| Generic official-focused searches for §§ 615 and 608, and a readable § 626 source | Located the relevant secondary bodies and a different FindLaw § 626 publication. |\n| Official § 615 route | One attempt failed. |\n| Justia §§ 615 and 608 | Complete bodies, displayed credits, and disclaimers read. |\n| FindLaw § 626 | Complete introduction and (a)–(e), date, and disclaimer read. |\n| Generic official-PDF search for the narrow provisions | Discovered the SOS UCC publication route; unrelated jurisdictional and case results were not used. |\n| SOS publication route | One attempt returned 404. |\n| Justia § 628 | Complete (a)–(e) read for the express § 626 qualification. |\n| Justia § 626 search listing | Discovery only; no fresh page-body open. |\n\n## 10.2 Preserved rather than re-created\n\n| Material | Treatment |\n| --- | --- |\n| P9 source and claim packet | Supplied attribution only |\n| Coordinator’s official/Justia § 626 failures | Historical supplied observations, not P13 failures |\n| P9 C030 | Cash-only claim unchanged |\n| P9 C043 | Original claim retained; additional dated secondary evidence identified separately |\n| P9 C044 | Not substantively rerun |\n| P12 and other sector findings | Not used as legal foundations |\n| Original Article 9 enactments and subsequent amendment chain | Not authenticated |\n| Cases, opinions, dockets, actual agreements or transactions | Not investigated |\n\n## 10.3 PDF and visual status\n\nNo PDF body was recovered or analyzed in this pass. The SOS PDF route returned 404. Therefore, no parsed-PDF or pixel-inspection claim is made.\n\nThe readable legal bodies were HTML. Publisher page dates, crawl dates, and copyright footers were not treated as enactment dates.\n\n# 11. Remaining gaps and researcher self-check\n\nThe bounded correction is established at the following level:\n\n- **Noncash sentence:** corrected against the freshly read 2025 reproduction of § 28-9-615(c).\n- **Collection comparison:** independently checked against § 28-9-608(a)(3), with the supplied subsection reference qualified.\n- **Symbolic omissions:** registered completely, with additional provisional support from a newly readable **January 1, 2024** § 626 reproduction.\n- **Exceptions:** the relevant § 628 text was read and retained without application.\n\nStill unresolved are current official statutory authentication, the relevant amendment/application chain, commercial-reasonableness construction, valuation and lawful-component questions, and every actual predicate needed to apply a rule or exception. The new secondary read does not cure those gaps.\n\nNo numeric substitution, collateral narrative, transaction, party, value, receipt, consent, fee, event, agreement, or case was supplied or invented. No actual duty, deficiency, surplus, contractual entitlement, collection right, or disposition permission is determined.\n\nThis is a **researcher self-check, not independent review**. Only the identified P9 sentence, the distinct corrective claims, and the omitted register entries are addressed. All other P9 findings and existing holds—including C033/C035 and unrelated P12/state/parent holds—remain preserved.\n\nEND S_ID PASS-13.\n\n","tables":[{"headers":["Issue","Disposition proceeds","Collection/enforcement proceeds"],"index":0,"links":[],"row_links":[[],[],[],[],[],[]],"rows":[["Issue","Disposition proceeds","Collection/enforcement proceeds"],["Correct pinpoint","§ 28-9-615(c)","§ 28-9-608(a)(3)"],["Referenced activity","Disposition under § 28-9-610","Collection or enforcement under § 28-9-607"],["Relevant structure","Commercial reasonableness governs withholding application and the manner of application","The same two-part structure appears, within § 608(a)’s obligation-secured scope"],["Agreement prerequisite in the noncash clause","None stated","None stated"],["Supplied reference qualification","The § 615(c) reference is correct","The readable § 608 reproduction has no subsection (c); its noncash clause is (a)(3)"]]},{"headers":["Evidence proposition","P13 result"],"index":1,"links":[],"row_links":[[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[]],"rows":[["Evidence proposition","P13 result"],["P9 reported the definitions \n𝑇\nT, \n𝐴\nA, and \n𝐻\nH, and the two symbolic relations","Preserved as supplied prior research"],["Coordinator freshly authenticated the reported 2025 § 626 body","Not claimed; supplied history says that delivery failed"],["P13 found a materially different readable body","Yes: FindLaw, January 1, 2024 reproduction"],["The supplied symbolic relations have additional textual support","Yes, provisionally, from that dated reproduction"],["Current official § 626 or its complete amendment chain is authenticated","No"],["P9 C044’s consumer-carveout observation is reopened or newly certified","No; outside this correction’s merits scope"],["A deficiency, surplus, exception, or enforcement outcome is established","No"]]},{"headers":["Source/usage ID","Issuer, document, and literal HTTPS URL","Actual read bounds","Edition/status, credits, and limits"],"index":2,"links":[{"href":"https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-615/","text":"Justia Law"},{"href":"https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-608/","text":"Justia Law"},{"href":"https://codes.findlaw.com/id/title-28-commercial-transactions/id-st-sect-28-9-626/","text":"FindLaw"},{"href":"https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-628/","text":"Justia Law"}],"row_links":[[],[],[],[{"href":"https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-615/","text":"Justia Law"}],[{"href":"https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-608/","text":"Justia Law"}],[{"href":"https://codes.findlaw.com/id/title-28-commercial-transactions/id-st-sect-28-9-626/","text":"FindLaw"}],[{"href":"https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-628/","text":"Justia Law"}],[],[]],"rows":[["Source/usage ID","Issuer, document, and literal HTTPS URL","Actual read bounds","Edition/status, credits, and limits"],["S_ID-P13-S001","Idaho Legislature, intended § 28-9-615 body: https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title28/T28CH9/SECT28-9-615/","One fresh ordinary-route attempt failed. No operative text read.","Official route; tool reported inaccessible/internal error. No version, amendment, or effective clause recovered."],["S_ID-P13-S002","Idaho Secretary of State, search-discovered UCC publication route: https://sos.idaho.gov/ucc/Pubs/RA9.pdf","One materially different official publication route attempted; 404.","Search title suggested a UCC publication, but title, edition, contents, and currency were not authenticated from a readable document. No PDF text or pixels read. The alternate capitalization appearing in search was not used for repeated variant attempts."],["S_ID-P13-S003","Justia, 2025 Idaho Code, § 28-9-615—Application of Proceeds of Disposition; Liability for Deficiency and Right to Surplus: https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-615/","Complete (a)–(g), displayed history, and disclaimer. Material correction: (c). Adjacent scope: (a)(1), (d)–(e); (f) inspected only for the separate § 626(e) boundary.","Secondary 2025 reproduction. Displayed credit: added 2001, ch. 208, § 2, p. 788. Original enactment and current amendment chain not recovered. Same underlying section identified in P9 S_ID-P9-S004. \nJustia Law"],["S_ID-P13-S004","Justia, 2025 Idaho Code, § 28-9-608—Application of Proceeds of Collection or Enforcement; Liability for Deficiency and Right to Surplus: https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-608/","Complete (a)(1)–(4), (b), history, and disclaimer. Material comparison: (a) introductory clause and (a)(3).","Secondary 2025 reproduction. Displayed credit: added 2001, ch. 208, § 2, p. 783. No subsection (c) appears. Same underlying section identified in P9 S_ID-P9-S004. \nJustia Law"],["S_ID-P13-S005","FindLaw, Idaho Statutes Title 28, § 28-9-626—Action in Which Deficiency or Surplus Is in Issue: https://codes.findlaw.com/id/title-28-commercial-transactions/id-st-sect-28-9-626/","Complete introduction and (a)–(e); date and currentness warning. Substantive use limited to register conditions and relations in (a)–(d), with (e) identified as a separate branch.","Secondary, labeled current as of January 1, 2024. No enactment-history paragraph appears in this newly read page. P9’s supplied 2001/2002 credits remain attributed prior research, not freshly authenticated history. This is a new readable publication route for the same underlying section—not official current law. \nFindLaw"],["S_ID-P13-S006","Justia, 2025 Idaho Code, § 28-9-628—Nonliability and Limitation on Liability of Secured Party; Liability of Secondary Obligor: https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-628/","Complete (a)–(e), history, and disclaimer. Material exception use: (a)–(c). Paragraphs (d)–(e) read but not developed into a new damages analysis.","Secondary 2025 reproduction. Displayed credit: added 2001, ch. 208, § 2, p. 796. No current official authentication. Read solely to avoid omitting § 626(c)’s express qualification. \nJustia Law"],["S_ID-P13-S007","Justia § 28-9-626, the previously reported source: https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-626/","Search discovery only in P13; no fresh page-body open. Prior P9 read and coordinator failure are supplied history.","Not counted as a freshly read 2025 body. Search-result text was not used to authenticate the formula or consumer observation."],["S_ID-P13-S008","Supplied P9 source/claim packet, including the § 608, § 615, and § 626 URLs above","Read as supplied conversation context only.","Supports identification of the sentence, original claims, symbols, and historical source assertions. It is not new legal authority or a fresh source-access event."]]},{"headers":["P9 location or identity","Existing content/status","P13 patch or treatment"],"index":3,"links":[],"row_links":[[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[]],"rows":[["P9 location or identity","Existing content/status","P13 patch or treatment"],["§ 4.5, exact noncash sentence","“Noncash proceeds require application only under the stated agreement/commercial-reasonableness conditions.”","Replace only that sentence with the text in § 1.1 above. Link S_ID-P13-C001 and S_ID-P13-S003 § 28-9-615(c)."],["S_ID-P9-C030","“Cash-proceeds priority, lawful expenses, proof, and surplus/deficiency conditions govern.”","Unchanged. It is not renamed, expanded, or represented as already containing the noncash rule."],["P9 source group S_ID-P9-S004, § 615 entry","Existing § 615 document identity and supplied history","Retained. P13-S003 records a new read of that same reproduced section."],["Collection comparison in this correction","Request refers to possible “608(c)” comparison","Use § 28-9-608(a)(3) for the actual noncash comparison. No unseen § 608(c) is invented."],["P9 symbolic definitions","𝑇\nT, \n𝐴\nA, and \n𝐻\nH as supplied","Preserve their wording as prior notation. Add the legal mapping, conditions, units, and status rows in Section 6."],["P9 relation \n𝑇\n−\nmax\n⁡\n(\n𝐴\n,\n𝐻\n)\nT−max(A,H)","Appears in narrative, omitted as a separate quantity-register entry","Add Q05, with Q01–Q04 and Q07–Q11 qualifications. No numerical substitution."],["P9 presumption \n𝐻\n=\n𝑇\nH=T, unless less proved","Appears in narrative, omitted as a separate quantity-register entry","Add Q06, explicitly confined to § 626(c)(2) through subsection (d)."],["S_ID-P9-C043","Prior claim concerning the counterfactual relation and presumption","Not overwritten. P13 adds dated 2024 secondary support and an exception-qualified register. It does not retroactively change the coordinator’s failed-access record."],["S_ID-P9-C044","Prior consumer-carveout observation with official-current hold","Unchanged and not newly adjudicated. No expanded consumer-deficiency analysis is supplied."],["P9’s existing 36-row quantity register","Original entries","Add the rows below as an appendix to that register; do not regenerate or renumber its existing entries."],["All other P9/P12 findings and C033/C035","Existing findings and holds","No substantive replacement or closure."]]},{"headers":["Claim ID","Precise corrective or evidence assertion","Source/pinpoint","Scope and verification limit"],"index":4,"links":[{"href":"https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-615/","text":"Justia Law"},{"href":"https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-615/","text":"Justia Law"},{"href":"https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-608/","text":"Justia Law"},{"href":"https://codes.findlaw.com/id/title-28-commercial-transactions/id-st-sect-28-9-626/","text":"FindLaw"},{"href":"https://codes.findlaw.com/id/title-28-commercial-transactions/id-st-sect-28-9-626/","text":"FindLaw\n+1"},{"href":"https://codes.findlaw.com/id/title-28-commercial-transactions/id-st-sect-28-9-626/","text":"FindLaw"}],"row_links":[[],[{"href":"https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-615/","text":"Justia Law"}],[{"href":"https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-615/","text":"Justia Law"}],[{"href":"https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-608/","text":"Justia Law"}],[{"href":"https://codes.findlaw.com/id/title-28-commercial-transactions/id-st-sect-28-9-626/","text":"FindLaw"}],[{"href":"https://codes.findlaw.com/id/title-28-commercial-transactions/id-st-sect-28-9-626/","text":"FindLaw\n+1"}],[],[{"href":"https://codes.findlaw.com/id/title-28-commercial-transactions/id-st-sect-28-9-626/","text":"FindLaw"}],[]],"rows":[["Claim ID","Precise corrective or evidence assertion","Source/pinpoint","Scope and verification limit"],["S_ID-P13-C001","The noncash-disposition clause has no agreement prerequisite; its requirements turn on commercial reasonableness of nonapplication and of any application/payment over.","S003, § 28-9-615(c)","Freshly read 2025 secondary text; no actual duty or disposition determined. \nJustia Law"],["S_ID-P13-C002","The adjacent agreement language concerning specified legal expenses must not be transferred into § 615(c).","S003, § 28-9-615(a)(1), (c)","Textual separation only; no fee entitlement or agreement construed. \nJustia Law"],["S_ID-P13-C003","The collection counterpart is § 28-9-608(a)(3), within subsection (a)’s scope, and likewise states commercial-reasonableness conditions rather than an agreement prerequisite.","S004, § 28-9-608(a), (a)(3), (b)","Freshly read 2025 secondary text; not a transfer of disposition rules to every collection. \nJustia Law"],["S_ID-P13-C004","FindLaw’s dated reproduction supplies fresh provisional support for the supplied symbolic definitions and relations, under the conditions registered below.","S005, § 28-9-626 introductory clause, (a)–(d)","January 1, 2024 reproduction only; not fresh authentication of the reported 2025 source. \nFindLaw"],["S_ID-P13-C005","The formula’s § 628 qualification must remain explicit, including the relevant knowledge and reasonable-reliance limitations.","S005 § 626(c); S006 § 628(a)–(c)","No predicate, exception, or person’s liability is determined. \nFindLaw\n+1"],["S_ID-P13-C006","The previously reported § 626 access failures and the newly successful FindLaw reading are different source events.","S005, S007–S008","Source-status finding; no retroactive verification claim."],["S_ID-P13-C007","The symbolic relations are conditional legal shorthand, not a quantified entitlement, surplus calculation, or enforcement result.","S005 § 626(c)–(e); supplied P9 notation","No values, valuation method, fee authorization, rounding convention, or outcome added. \nFindLaw"],["S_ID-P13-C008","Official-current statutory and amendment/application authentication remains unresolved after the bounded official-route attempts.","S001–S006","Source gap only; no absence-of-law or no-amendment inference."]]},{"headers":["Added row","Symbol or relation","Preserved meaning and legal mapping","Unit/base and limit","Verification status"],"index":5,"links":[],"row_links":[[],[],[],[],[],[],[]],"rows":[["Added row","Symbol or relation","Preserved meaning and legal mapping","Unit/base and limit","Verification status"],["Q01","𝑇\nT","P9: “the legally established secured obligation, expenses, and attorney fees included by the statute.” Maps to the aggregate stated in § 626(c)–(d).","Monetary aggregate. The notation does not itself establish any component’s amount or legal entitlement.","P9 attribution plus fresh 2024 secondary support, S005."],["Q02","𝐴\nA","P9: “actual proceeds.” Maps to § 626(c)(1)’s proceeds from the relevant collection, enforcement, disposition, or acceptance.","Monetary proceeds measure for the relevant activity. Not restricted by the notation to a sale price.","Same limited status."],["Q03","𝐻\nH","P9: “proceeds of a complying collection, enforcement, disposition, or acceptance.” Maps to the counterfactual in § 626(c)(2).","Monetary counterfactual; not an assumed appraisal, liquidation value, or agreed value.","Same limited status."],["Q04","max\n⁡\n(\n𝐴\n,\n𝐻\n)\nmax(A,H)","Represents the statutory comparison selecting the greater proceeds measure.","Comparison operator, not a new valuation rule.","Fresh provisional support from § 626(c)(1)–(2)."],["Q05","𝑇\n−\nmax\n⁡\n(\n𝐴\n,\n𝐻\n)\nT−max(A,H)","Represents the excess described in § 626(c), when that provision applies.","A deficiency limitation, not automatic liability. No negative deficiency, surplus entitlement, or additional zero-floor equation is introduced.","Fresh provisional support from § 626(c); official-current status held."],["Q06","𝐻\n=\n𝑇\nH=T, unless the secured party proves a smaller \n𝐻\nH","Represents subsection (d)’s rule for purposes of subsection (c)(2).","A conditional presumption, not a factual finding that actual proceeds equal the obligation.","Fresh provisional support from § 626(d); no evidence or burden satisfied here."]]},{"headers":["Added row","Required legal condition or boundary","Exact relation to the symbols","Pinpoint/status"],"index":6,"links":[],"row_links":[[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[]],"rows":[["Added row","Required legal condition or boundary","Exact relation to the symbols","Pinpoint/status"],["Q07 — proceeding scope","An action arising from a transaction in which deficiency or surplus is in issue","The formulas are not a free-standing accounting mandate outside the section’s setting.","S005, § 626 introductory clause; 2024 secondary"],["Q08 — compliance issue","Debtor or secondary obligor places compliance in issue","Subsections (a)–(b) determine when the secured party must establish compliance.","S005, § 626(a)–(b)"],["Q09 — operative trigger","Secured party fails to prove the relevant compliance","The subsection (c) limitation is conditional on that failure, not merely on a demand for a deficiency.","S005, § 626(c)"],["Q10 — cross-reference exception","Section 626(c) is expressly subject to § 28-9-628","Neither symbolic relation may erase an applicable § 628 qualification.","S005–S006"],["Q11 — knowledge qualification","Section 628(a) addresses knowledge of debtor/obligor status, identity, and how to communicate; subsection (b) separately limits status-based liability","No knowledge or communication predicate is assumed. The relevant deficiency consequence in (a)(2) must be retained.","S006, § 628(a)–(b), 2025 secondary"],["Q12 — reasonable-purpose-reliance qualification","Section 628(c) concerns an act or omission arising from the specified reasonable belief, based on reasonable reliance on a debtor’s collateral-purpose representation or obligor’s obligation-purpose representation","A label or assertion alone is not treated as satisfying the exception.","S006, § 628(c)"],["Q13 — separate subsection (e)","Section 626(e) concerns a calculation under § 615(f)","Its separate allocation of proof is not replaced by the subsection (d) presumption. No new § 615(f) analysis is performed.","S005 § 626(e); S003 § 615(f)"],["Q14 — noncash distinction","Noncash proceeds may arise in a disposition or collection/enforcement setting","The relevant clause is § 615(c) or § 608(a)(3), respectively; no agreement prerequisite is inserted.","S003–S004"],["Q15 — unknown measurement","Valuation, recognition, amount, permissible expenses, and admissible proof are unspecified","No numerical value, valuation date, expense rate, or rounding convention is supplied.","Explicit application hold"],["Q16 — no time computation","None of these added relations supplies a numerical deadline","No calendar, receipt date, percentage, interest rate, or elapsed-period calculation is added.","Text-boundary finding"],["Q17 — source versions","Justia 2025 for §§ 608, 615, 628; FindLaw January 1, 2024 for § 626","These versions are not relabeled official/current 2026 or harmonized by assumption.","S003–S006"],["Q18 — enactment/application","Official current text and final amendment/application evidence were not recovered","Displayed old credits and publisher dates do not close the gap.","S001–S006"]]},{"headers":["Branch","Supported consequence","Missing predicate or authority","Adverse inference to avoid","Next precise generic inquiry"],"index":7,"links":[],"row_links":[[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[]],"rows":[["Branch","Supported consequence","Missing predicate or authority","Adverse inference to avoid","Next precise generic inquiry"],["B01 — noncash disposition","C001 supplies the corrected textual rule.","Classification as noncash proceeds of a § 610 disposition; commercial-reasonableness construction.","An agreement is always required, or nonapplication is always permissible.","Readable official § 615 and necessary generic construction of its noncash standard."],["B02 — collection/enforcement","§ 608(a)(3) is the distinct comparison clause.","Actual statutory collection/enforcement category and subsection (a) scope.","A nonexistent § 608(c), or automatic transfer of disposition rules.","Official § 608(a), with only necessary § 607 scope if later material."],["B03 — agreement language","The adjacent expense condition is not the noncash trigger.","Any separate lawful agreement term and governing limits, if ever relevant.","That deleting “agreement” establishes actual fee authority or decides contractual rights.","Exact generic agreement/expense provision only if separately required."],["B04 — deficiency relation","Q01–Q09 map the supplied notation to the dated reproduced text.","Applicable proceeding, compliance issue, failure of proof, and legally established components.","The equation alone creates a collectible deficiency.","Official § 626(a)–(d) and necessary application law."],["B05 — presumption","Q06 records the limited § 626(d) relation.","Whether the relevant proof changes the statutory counterfactual.","𝐻\nH is a factual market value or necessarily equals actual proceeds.","Generic proof/construction authority; no case inquiry performed here."],["B06 — § 628 qualification","Q10–Q12 retain express exceptions.","Knowledge, reasonable belief, reasonable reliance, and represented purpose.","An automatic defense from a label or lack of supplied facts.","Current official § 628 and necessary definitions only."],["B07 — separate § 615(f) issue","Q13 prevents merging two burden provisions.","Its related-transferee and significantly-low-proceeds predicates.","Subsection (d) silently controls every surplus or purchaser-value dispute.","Separate focused inquiry only if authorized; not rerun here."],["B08 — source currency","Fresh dated secondary support is identified accurately.","Current official bodies and amendment/application chain.","A new successful webpage means current official law, or erases prior failed reads.","Ordinary readable official publication; no repeated blocked-route attempts."],["B09 — consumer observation","P9 C044 remains unchanged.","Official authentication and any separately authorized consumer-law analysis.","This correction freshly validates or rejects the broader observation.","Retain existing hold; no new consumer-branch inquiry in P13."]]},{"headers":["Field","Entry"],"index":8,"links":[],"row_links":[[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[]],"rows":[["Field","Entry"],["Relevant statutory provision",""],["Source edition/status",""],["Official-current-text verification",""],["Proceeds category",""],["Referenced activity",""],["Nonapplication condition",""],["Application-manner condition",""],["Adjacent agreement-language boundary",""],["Symbol \n𝑇\nT definition",""],["Symbol \n𝐴\nA definition",""],["Symbol \n𝐻\nH definition",""],["Proceeding predicate",""],["Compliance-in-issue predicate",""],["Failure-of-proof predicate",""],["Applicable § 628 qualification",""],["Separate § 615(f) issue",""],["Measurement or construction gap",""],["Amendment/application gap",""],["Review status",""]]},{"headers":["Request/subquestion","Disposition","Claims/rows/sources","Exact retained gap"],"index":9,"links":[],"row_links":[[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[]],"rows":[["Request/subquestion","Disposition","Claims/rows/sources","Exact retained gap"],["1 — complete § 615(c)","Freshly read","C001; S003","Official-current authentication"],["Necessary adjacent qualifications","Complete § 615 body inspected; use confined to this correction","C002; S003","No actual proceeds or agreement determination"],["Collection comparison","Freshly read; pinpoint corrected to § 608(a)(3)","C003; S004","Actual § 607 activity not classified"],["Ordinary official attempt","Completed once","S001","Body inaccessible"],["Materially different official route","Search-discovered SOS publication attempted once","S002","404; edition/content unread"],["Dated secondary status","Preserved","S003–S006; Q17–Q18","No 2026 certification"],["Exact sentence correction","Supplied","Section 1.1; patch map","No other P9 narrative rewritten"],["2 — distinct new noncash claim","Supplied","S_ID-P13-C001","No relabeling of P9 C030"],["Preserve C030 cash-only wording","Preserved in patch map","Section 4","No expansion to noncash"],["Locate P9 § 4.5","Exact target and replacement identified","Sections 1 and 4","No broader report regeneration"],["Explain correction versus provisional status","Supplied","Sections 1–3","Current law and actual duty held"],["3 — T/A/H definitions","Added individually","Q01–Q03","No values or valuation"],["Counterfactual comparison and relation","Added individually","Q04–Q05","Conditional limitation only"],["Presumption","Added individually","Q06","§ 626(c)(2)-specific; no proof finding"],["Trigger and burden","Added","Q07–Q09","No proceeding or challenge facts"],["Exceptions","Fresh relevant cross-reference read","Q10–Q13; S006","No exception applied"],["Earlier failed § 626 deliveries","Preserved as supplied history","S007–S008; C006","Not relabeled as fresh success"],["New ordinary readable § 626 source","Recovered","S005","2024 secondary, not the reported 2025 body"],["Consumer-carveout observation","Not reopened","Patch map; B09","Original hold remains"],["Full symbolic register status","Supplied","Q01–Q18","Official-current and application gaps explicit"],["No numerical or calendar scenario","Maintained","Worksheet/register","None supplied"],["P9/P12/C033/C035 and other holds","Unchanged","Scope and patch map","No component acceptance"]]},{"headers":["Search/read action","Actual result"],"index":10,"links":[],"row_links":[[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[]],"rows":[["Search/read action","Actual result"],["Generic official-focused searches for §§ 615 and 608, and a readable § 626 source","Located the relevant secondary bodies and a different FindLaw § 626 publication."],["Official § 615 route","One attempt failed."],["Justia §§ 615 and 608","Complete bodies, displayed credits, and disclaimers read."],["FindLaw § 626","Complete introduction and (a)–(e), date, and disclaimer read."],["Generic official-PDF search for the narrow provisions","Discovered the SOS UCC publication route; unrelated jurisdictional and case results were not used."],["SOS publication route","One attempt returned 404."],["Justia § 628","Complete (a)–(e) read for the express § 626 qualification."],["Justia § 626 search listing","Discovery only; no fresh page-body open."]]},{"headers":["Material","Treatment"],"index":11,"links":[],"row_links":[[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[],[]],"rows":[["Material","Treatment"],["P9 source and claim packet","Supplied attribution only"],["Coordinator’s official/Justia § 626 failures","Historical supplied observations, not P13 failures"],["P9 C030","Cash-only claim unchanged"],["P9 C043","Original claim retained; additional dated secondary evidence identified separately"],["P9 C044","Not substantively rerun"],["P12 and other sector findings","Not used as legal foundations"],["Original Article 9 enactments and subsequent amendment chain","Not authenticated"],["Cases, opinions, dockets, actual agreements or transactions","Not investigated"]]}],"claims":[{"claim_id":"S_ID-P13-C001","area_numbers":[66],"area_assignment_method":"task_scope_fallback","researcher_record":{"Claim ID":"S_ID-P13-C001","Precise corrective or evidence assertion":"The noncash-disposition clause has no agreement prerequisite; its requirements turn on commercial reasonableness of nonapplication and of any application/payment over.","Source/pinpoint":"S003, § 28-9-615(c)","Scope and verification limit":"Freshly read 2025 secondary text; no actual duty or disposition determined. \nJustia Law"},"coordinator_verification_status":"whole_scoped_correction_reviewed_selected_secondary_text_and_provenance_limits_preserved","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]","coordinator_full_primary_acceptance":false},{"claim_id":"S_ID-P13-C002","area_numbers":[66],"area_assignment_method":"task_scope_fallback","researcher_record":{"Claim ID":"S_ID-P13-C002","Precise corrective or evidence assertion":"The adjacent agreement language concerning specified legal expenses must not be transferred into § 615(c).","Source/pinpoint":"S003, § 28-9-615(a)(1), (c)","Scope and verification limit":"Textual separation only; no fee entitlement or agreement construed. \nJustia Law"},"coordinator_verification_status":"whole_scoped_correction_reviewed_selected_secondary_text_and_provenance_limits_preserved","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]","coordinator_full_primary_acceptance":false},{"claim_id":"S_ID-P13-C003","area_numbers":[66],"area_assignment_method":"task_scope_fallback","researcher_record":{"Claim ID":"S_ID-P13-C003","Precise corrective or evidence assertion":"The collection counterpart is § 28-9-608(a)(3), within subsection (a)’s scope, and likewise states commercial-reasonableness conditions rather than an agreement prerequisite.","Source/pinpoint":"S004, § 28-9-608(a), (a)(3), (b)","Scope and verification limit":"Freshly read 2025 secondary text; not a transfer of disposition rules to every collection. \nJustia Law"},"coordinator_verification_status":"whole_scoped_correction_reviewed_selected_secondary_text_and_provenance_limits_preserved","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]","coordinator_full_primary_acceptance":false},{"claim_id":"S_ID-P13-C004","area_numbers":[66],"area_assignment_method":"task_scope_fallback","researcher_record":{"Claim ID":"S_ID-P13-C004","Precise corrective or evidence assertion":"FindLaw’s dated reproduction supplies fresh provisional support for the supplied symbolic definitions and relations, under the conditions registered below.","Source/pinpoint":"S005, § 28-9-626 introductory clause, (a)–(d)","Scope and verification limit":"January 1, 2024 reproduction only; not fresh authentication of the reported 2025 source. \nFindLaw"},"coordinator_verification_status":"whole_scoped_correction_reviewed_selected_secondary_text_and_provenance_limits_preserved","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]","coordinator_full_primary_acceptance":false},{"claim_id":"S_ID-P13-C005","area_numbers":[66],"area_assignment_method":"task_scope_fallback","researcher_record":{"Claim ID":"S_ID-P13-C005","Precise corrective or evidence assertion":"The formula’s § 628 qualification must remain explicit, including the relevant knowledge and reasonable-reliance limitations.","Source/pinpoint":"S005 § 626(c); S006 § 628(a)–(c)","Scope and verification limit":"No predicate, exception, or person’s liability is determined. \nFindLaw\n+1"},"coordinator_verification_status":"whole_scoped_correction_reviewed_selected_secondary_text_and_provenance_limits_preserved","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]","coordinator_full_primary_acceptance":false},{"claim_id":"S_ID-P13-C006","area_numbers":[66],"area_assignment_method":"task_scope_fallback","researcher_record":{"Claim ID":"S_ID-P13-C006","Precise corrective or evidence assertion":"The previously reported § 626 access failures and the newly successful FindLaw reading are different source events.","Source/pinpoint":"S005, S007–S008","Scope and verification limit":"Source-status finding; no retroactive verification claim."},"coordinator_verification_status":"whole_scoped_correction_reviewed_selected_secondary_text_and_provenance_limits_preserved","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]","coordinator_full_primary_acceptance":false},{"claim_id":"S_ID-P13-C007","area_numbers":[66],"area_assignment_method":"task_scope_fallback","researcher_record":{"Claim ID":"S_ID-P13-C007","Precise corrective or evidence assertion":"The symbolic relations are conditional legal shorthand, not a quantified entitlement, surplus calculation, or enforcement result.","Source/pinpoint":"S005 § 626(c)–(e); supplied P9 notation","Scope and verification limit":"No values, valuation method, fee authorization, rounding convention, or outcome added. \nFindLaw"},"coordinator_verification_status":"whole_scoped_correction_reviewed_selected_secondary_text_and_provenance_limits_preserved","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]","coordinator_full_primary_acceptance":false},{"claim_id":"S_ID-P13-C008","area_numbers":[66],"area_assignment_method":"task_scope_fallback","researcher_record":{"Claim ID":"S_ID-P13-C008","Precise corrective or evidence assertion":"Official-current statutory and amendment/application authentication remains unresolved after the bounded official-route attempts.","Source/pinpoint":"S001–S006","Scope and verification limit":"Source gap only; no absence-of-law or no-amendment inference."},"coordinator_verification_status":"whole_scoped_correction_reviewed_selected_secondary_text_and_provenance_limits_preserved","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]","coordinator_full_primary_acceptance":false}],"sources":[{"source_id":"S_ID-P13-S001","urls":["https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title28/T28CH9/SECT28-9-615/"],"researcher_record":{"Source/usage ID":"S_ID-P13-S001","Issuer, document, and literal HTTPS URL":"Idaho Legislature, intended § 28-9-615 body: https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title28/T28CH9/SECT28-9-615/","Actual read bounds":"One fresh ordinary-route attempt failed. No operative text read.","Edition/status, credits, and limits":"Official route; tool reported inaccessible/internal error. No version, amendment, or effective clause recovered."},"coordinator_verification_status":"researcher_failure_or_discovery_record_not_freshly_reopened","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]","coordinator_check_evidence":{"at":"2026-10-28T16:09:30.260993+00:00","raw_packet":"[internal evidence reference]","note":"WholeP13recordreviewed;failure/discoveryhistorypreserved,notrepeatedorretrospectivelyverified. Officialcurrentnessheld."}},{"source_id":"S_ID-P13-S002","urls":["https://sos.idaho.gov/ucc/Pubs/RA9.pdf"],"researcher_record":{"Source/usage ID":"S_ID-P13-S002","Issuer, document, and literal HTTPS URL":"Idaho Secretary of State, search-discovered UCC publication route: https://sos.idaho.gov/ucc/Pubs/RA9.pdf","Actual read bounds":"One materially different official publication route attempted; 404.","Edition/status, credits, and limits":"Search title suggested a UCC publication, but title, edition, contents, and currency were not authenticated from a readable document. No PDF text or pixels read. The alternate capitalization appearing in search was not used for repeated variant attempts."},"coordinator_verification_status":"researcher_failure_or_discovery_record_not_freshly_reopened","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]","coordinator_check_evidence":{"at":"2026-10-28T16:09:30.260993+00:00","raw_packet":"[internal evidence reference]","note":"WholeP13recordreviewed;failure/discoveryhistorypreserved,notrepeatedorretrospectivelyverified. Officialcurrentnessheld."}},{"source_id":"S_ID-P13-S003","urls":["https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-615/"],"researcher_record":{"Source/usage ID":"S_ID-P13-S003","Issuer, document, and literal HTTPS URL":"Justia, 2025 Idaho Code, § 28-9-615—Application of Proceeds of Disposition; Liability for Deficiency and Right to Surplus: https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-615/","Actual read bounds":"Complete (a)–(g), displayed history, and disclaimer. Material correction: (c). Adjacent scope: (a)(1), (d)–(e); (f) inspected only for the separate § 626(e) boundary.","Edition/status, credits, and limits":"Secondary 2025 reproduction. Displayed credit: added 2001, ch. 208, § 2, p. 788. Original enactment and current amendment chain not recovered. Same underlying section identified in P9 S_ID-P9-S004. \nJustia Law"},"coordinator_verification_status":"selected_secondary_text_compared_official_currentness_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]","coordinator_check_evidence":{"at":"2026-10-28T16:09:30.260993+00:00","raw_packet":"[internal evidence reference]","note":"Complete2025secondary615(a)–(g), historicalcreditandpublishercurrentnesswarning; exact(c)andadjacentagreementlanguage(a)(1)compared."}},{"source_id":"S_ID-P13-S004","urls":["https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-608/"],"researcher_record":{"Source/usage ID":"S_ID-P13-S004","Issuer, document, and literal HTTPS URL":"Justia, 2025 Idaho Code, § 28-9-608—Application of Proceeds of Collection or Enforcement; Liability for Deficiency and Right to Surplus: https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-608/","Actual read bounds":"Complete (a)(1)–(4), (b), history, and disclaimer. Material comparison: (a) introductory clause and (a)(3).","Edition/status, credits, and limits":"Secondary 2025 reproduction. Displayed credit: added 2001, ch. 208, § 2, p. 783. No subsection (c) appears. Same underlying section identified in P9 S_ID-P9-S004. \nJustia Law"},"coordinator_verification_status":"selected_secondary_text_compared_official_currentness_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]","coordinator_check_evidence":{"at":"2026-10-28T16:09:30.260993+00:00","raw_packet":"[internal evidence reference]","note":"Complete2025secondary608(a)(1)–(4),(b),historyanddisclaimer. Actualnoncashpinpoint(a)(3); nosubsection(c). Obligation-securedscopeandseparatesale-of-receivablesbranchpreserved."}},{"source_id":"S_ID-P13-S005","urls":["https://codes.findlaw.com/id/title-28-commercial-transactions/id-st-sect-28-9-626/"],"researcher_record":{"Source/usage ID":"S_ID-P13-S005","Issuer, document, and literal HTTPS URL":"FindLaw, Idaho Statutes Title 28, § 28-9-626—Action in Which Deficiency or Surplus Is in Issue: https://codes.findlaw.com/id/title-28-commercial-transactions/id-st-sect-28-9-626/","Actual read bounds":"Complete introduction and (a)–(e); date and currentness warning. Substantive use limited to register conditions and relations in (a)–(d), with (e) identified as a separate branch.","Edition/status, credits, and limits":"Secondary, labeled current as of January 1, 2024. No enactment-history paragraph appears in this newly read page. P9’s supplied 2001/2002 credits remain attributed prior research, not freshly authenticated history. This is a new readable publication route for the same underlying section—not official current law. \nFindLaw"},"coordinator_verification_status":"selected_secondary_text_compared_official_currentness_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]","coordinator_check_evidence":{"at":"2026-10-28T16:09:30.260993+00:00","raw_packet":"[internal evidence reference]","note":"CompleteFindLaw626introductionand(a)–(e), displayedJan1,2024date/currentnesswarning. Thisisnewdatedsecondarysupport, notofficial2026orthefailed2025delivery. Burden,greater-ofrelationand(c)(2)-specificpresumptioncompared;consumerC044notnewlyadjudicated."}},{"source_id":"S_ID-P13-S006","urls":["https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-628/"],"researcher_record":{"Source/usage ID":"S_ID-P13-S006","Issuer, document, and literal HTTPS URL":"Justia, 2025 Idaho Code, § 28-9-628—Nonliability and Limitation on Liability of Secured Party; Liability of Secondary Obligor: https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-628/","Actual read bounds":"Complete (a)–(e), history, and disclaimer. Material exception use: (a)–(c). Paragraphs (d)–(e) read but not developed into a new damages analysis.","Edition/status, credits, and limits":"Secondary 2025 reproduction. Displayed credit: added 2001, ch. 208, § 2, p. 796. No current official authentication. Read solely to avoid omitting § 626(c)’s express qualification. \nJustia Law"},"coordinator_verification_status":"selected_secondary_text_compared_official_currentness_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]","coordinator_check_evidence":{"at":"2026-10-28T16:09:30.260993+00:00","raw_packet":"[internal evidence reference]","note":"Complete2025secondary628(a)–(e),historyanddisclaimer; material(a)knowledge/communicationand(c)reasonablebelief/reliancepurposeconditionsand(b)statuslimitationcompared. Noexceptionapplied;separate625(c)(2)limitsnotnewdamagesanalysis."}},{"source_id":"S_ID-P13-S007","urls":["https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-626/"],"researcher_record":{"Source/usage ID":"S_ID-P13-S007","Issuer, document, and literal HTTPS URL":"Justia § 28-9-626, the previously reported source: https://law.justia.com/codes/idaho/title-28/chapter-9/part-6/section-28-9-626/","Actual read bounds":"Search discovery only in P13; no fresh page-body open. Prior P9 read and coordinator failure are supplied history.","Edition/status, credits, and limits":"Not counted as a freshly read 2025 body. Search-result text was not used to authenticate the formula or consumer observation."},"coordinator_verification_status":"researcher_failure_or_discovery_record_not_freshly_reopened","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]","coordinator_check_evidence":{"at":"2026-10-28T16:09:30.260993+00:00","raw_packet":"[internal evidence reference]","note":"WholeP13recordreviewed;failure/discoveryhistorypreserved,notrepeatedorretrospectivelyverified. Officialcurrentnessheld."}},{"source_id":"S_ID-P13-S008","urls":[],"researcher_record":{"Source/usage ID":"S_ID-P13-S008","Issuer, document, and literal HTTPS URL":"Supplied P9 source/claim packet, including the § 608, § 615, and § 626 URLs above","Actual read bounds":"Read as supplied conversation context only.","Edition/status, credits, and limits":"Supports identification of the sentence, original claims, symbols, and historical source assertions. It is not new legal authority or a fresh source-access event."},"coordinator_verification_status":"supplied_context_compared_not_external_authority","source_access_status":"supplied_context_not_external_source","url_extraction_hold":null,"coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]","coordinator_check_evidence":{"at":"2026-10-28T16:09:30.260993+00:00","raw_packet":"[internal evidence reference]","note":"ExactsuppliedP9packet/targetscomparedwithactualP9immutableanswerandclaims;notnewsourceaccess."}}],"coverage":[{"topic":"1 — complete § 615(c)","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"1 — complete § 615(c)","Disposition":"Freshly read","Claims/rows/sources":"C001; S003","Exact retained gap":"Official-current authentication"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"},{"topic":"Necessary adjacent qualifications","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"Necessary adjacent qualifications","Disposition":"Complete § 615 body inspected; use confined to this correction","Claims/rows/sources":"C002; S003","Exact retained gap":"No actual proceeds or agreement determination"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"},{"topic":"Collection comparison","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"Collection comparison","Disposition":"Freshly read; pinpoint corrected to § 608(a)(3)","Claims/rows/sources":"C003; S004","Exact retained gap":"Actual § 607 activity not classified"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"},{"topic":"Ordinary official attempt","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"Ordinary official attempt","Disposition":"Completed once","Claims/rows/sources":"S001","Exact retained gap":"Body inaccessible"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"},{"topic":"Materially different official route","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"Materially different official route","Disposition":"Search-discovered SOS publication attempted once","Claims/rows/sources":"S002","Exact retained gap":"404; edition/content unread"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"},{"topic":"Dated secondary status","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"Dated secondary status","Disposition":"Preserved","Claims/rows/sources":"S003–S006; Q17–Q18","Exact retained gap":"No 2026 certification"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"},{"topic":"Exact sentence correction","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"Exact sentence correction","Disposition":"Supplied","Claims/rows/sources":"Section 1.1; patch map","Exact retained gap":"No other P9 narrative rewritten"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"},{"topic":"2 — distinct new noncash claim","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"2 — distinct new noncash claim","Disposition":"Supplied","Claims/rows/sources":"S_ID-P13-C001","Exact retained gap":"No relabeling of P9 C030"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"},{"topic":"Preserve C030 cash-only wording","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"Preserve C030 cash-only wording","Disposition":"Preserved in patch map","Claims/rows/sources":"Section 4","Exact retained gap":"No expansion to noncash"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"},{"topic":"Locate P9 § 4.5","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"Locate P9 § 4.5","Disposition":"Exact target and replacement identified","Claims/rows/sources":"Sections 1 and 4","Exact retained gap":"No broader report regeneration"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"},{"topic":"Explain correction versus provisional status","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"Explain correction versus provisional status","Disposition":"Supplied","Claims/rows/sources":"Sections 1–3","Exact retained gap":"Current law and actual duty held"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"},{"topic":"3 — T/A/H definitions","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"3 — T/A/H definitions","Disposition":"Added individually","Claims/rows/sources":"Q01–Q03","Exact retained gap":"No values or valuation"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"},{"topic":"Counterfactual comparison and relation","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"Counterfactual comparison and relation","Disposition":"Added individually","Claims/rows/sources":"Q04–Q05","Exact retained gap":"Conditional limitation only"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"},{"topic":"Presumption","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"Presumption","Disposition":"Added individually","Claims/rows/sources":"Q06","Exact retained gap":"§ 626(c)(2)-specific; no proof finding"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"},{"topic":"Trigger and burden","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"Trigger and burden","Disposition":"Added","Claims/rows/sources":"Q07–Q09","Exact retained gap":"No proceeding or challenge facts"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"},{"topic":"Exceptions","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"Exceptions","Disposition":"Fresh relevant cross-reference read","Claims/rows/sources":"Q10–Q13; S006","Exact retained gap":"No exception applied"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"},{"topic":"Earlier failed § 626 deliveries","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"Earlier failed § 626 deliveries","Disposition":"Preserved as supplied history","Claims/rows/sources":"S007–S008; C006","Exact retained gap":"Not relabeled as fresh success"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"},{"topic":"New ordinary readable § 626 source","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"New ordinary readable § 626 source","Disposition":"Recovered","Claims/rows/sources":"S005","Exact retained gap":"2024 secondary, not the reported 2025 body"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"},{"topic":"Consumer-carveout observation","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"Consumer-carveout observation","Disposition":"Not reopened","Claims/rows/sources":"Patch map; B09","Exact retained gap":"Original hold remains"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"},{"topic":"Full symbolic register status","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"Full symbolic register status","Disposition":"Supplied","Claims/rows/sources":"Q01–Q18","Exact retained gap":"Official-current and application gaps explicit"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"},{"topic":"No numerical or calendar scenario","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"No numerical or calendar scenario","Disposition":"Maintained","Claims/rows/sources":"Worksheet/register","Exact retained gap":"None supplied"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"},{"topic":"P9/P12/C033/C035 and other holds","researcher_record":{"Request/subquestion":"P9/P12/C033/C035 and other holds","Disposition":"Unchanged","Claims/rows/sources":"Scope and patch map","Exact retained gap":"No component acceptance"},"raw_table_index":9,"coordinator_acceptance":"bounded_correction_scope_review_complete_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","coordinator_review":"[internal evidence reference]"}],"annotations":{},"corrections":[],"resolved_corrections":[],"review_history":[{"id":"S_ID-P13-P9-F001-corrected-secondary-support-20261028","status":"reviewed_bounded_correction_resolved_official_currentness_construction_and_application_held","at":"2026-10-28T16:09:30.260993+00:00"}]}